Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:01

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:52

What about a woman that wants to be a man? By your logic, she's still a woman, so does your feminism extend to her?

I notice you completely ignored my post about hurting peoples' feelings.

There's a thread running about Maya Forstater, who has had a payout for being an arsehole to other people.

I'd rather live in a cardboard box on the street than be in that camp.

Well yes, that person also cannot have what they want, which is to change sex. Something which is not scientifically possible and never will be.

I take reasonable care not to deliberately hurt people's feelings, but not to the point of lying or denying material reality. If reality hurts people's feelings, then there comes a point where I think we can reasonably consider that that is a "them problem" and we are not obliged to accommodate it.

Of course my feminism includes trans men and female non binary people. It includes all female people, and not male people. But feminism isn't about telling people what they want to hear. It's not about being kind or nice. It's about fighting for equal rights for female people, and an end to sex based oppression. Perhaps if we can accomplish that, fewer people will want to opt out of being female.

Maya Forstater has had a payout for being unlawfully discriminated against for her beliefs, which are considered "worthy of respect in a democratic society". Amazing that her "belief" that humans can't change sex, which is less of a belief than a statement of obvious and irrefutable fact, even needs to be defended in a court of law.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 16:59

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:52

What about a woman that wants to be a man? By your logic, she's still a woman, so does your feminism extend to her?

I notice you completely ignored my post about hurting peoples' feelings.

There's a thread running about Maya Forstater, who has had a payout for being an arsehole to other people.

I'd rather live in a cardboard box on the street than be in that camp.

a - she wasn't an arsehole, she merely left a leaflet on her desk, relating to a government consultation.
b - No decision has been made on a payout. If she lost her job for a leaflet then that is discrimination, and she deserves a payout [that's how discrimination tribunals work].

The facts are all there, you might want to read up on them. Before spouting 'nonsense on stilts'.

SmashingEgg · 06/07/2022 16:56

@beautyisthefaceisee If it makes me a bigot, so be it. Your opinion of me is as irrelevant as the man pretending to be a woman.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 16:55

You don't care that you're hurting people with your views, you're invalidating their identity, you're dismissing their voices, shutting them down and then seem mightily surprised when people don't want to listen to you.

Males getting hurty feelings always does seem to result in death and rape threats towards women...weird huh. Almost like they keep their male pattern violent behaviour.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:52

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:50

To put it another way, if accepting trans women as women means we have to accept that all women are redefined, and that we no longer have a word for "adult humans of the female biological sex", I absolutely don't see why we should be under any obligation to do that.

But not everybody is asking you to do that, tho. its not black and white. can you really not get that?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:52

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:50

And maybe it really is just as simple as "you can't always have what you want", particularly if you are a male person who wants to be a woman.

What about a woman that wants to be a man? By your logic, she's still a woman, so does your feminism extend to her?

I notice you completely ignored my post about hurting peoples' feelings.

There's a thread running about Maya Forstater, who has had a payout for being an arsehole to other people.

I'd rather live in a cardboard box on the street than be in that camp.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:50

And maybe it really is just as simple as "you can't always have what you want", particularly if you are a male person who wants to be a woman.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:50

To put it another way, if accepting trans women as women means we have to accept that all women are redefined, and that we no longer have a word for "adult humans of the female biological sex", I absolutely don't see why we should be under any obligation to do that.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:47

Valid doesn't mean real.
Valid means accepted.
You have proved why this will never be solved. You don't care that you're hurting people with your views, you're invalidating their identity, you're dismissing their voices, shutting them down and then seem mightily surprised when people don't want to listen to you.

Well no. I can't accept male people as women, because in order to do so you have to change the definition of what a woman is.

If you redefine a woman as someone with a particular identity, I am excluded from that definition.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:21

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:20

Valid women is a ridiculous expression. What's the opposite? An invalid woman?Which is a what? And how does one "earn" their ronouns?

In this instance I think valid means real. And I think that in order to be a valid, or real, woman, you need to be an adult human of the female biological sex. Nothing more, nothing less.

Pronouns don't change reality.

I'd like to see a feminist backing the safe spaces, prison etc, rape counsellors (Believe it or not, I was HORRIFIED to hear about that) and speaking up for women without calling trans an ideology or hurting peoples' feelings. Why so difficult?

An ideology is essentially a belief system.

How is the belief that "woman" is an identity, or an indefinable feeling that some people have, NOT an ideology?

I don't think we can avoid hurting people's feelings if stating a few facts about biological reality hurts people's feelings.

Valid doesn't mean real.
Valid means accepted.

You have proved why this will never be solved. You don't care that you're hurting people with your views, you're invalidating their identity, you're dismissing their voices, shutting them down and then seem mightily surprised when people don't want to listen to you.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 16:20

Valid women is a ridiculous expression. What's the opposite? An invalid woman?Which is a what? And how does one "earn" their ronouns?

In this instance I think valid means real. And I think that in order to be a valid, or real, woman, you need to be an adult human of the female biological sex. Nothing more, nothing less.

Pronouns don't change reality.

I'd like to see a feminist backing the safe spaces, prison etc, rape counsellors (Believe it or not, I was HORRIFIED to hear about that) and speaking up for women without calling trans an ideology or hurting peoples' feelings. Why so difficult?

An ideology is essentially a belief system.

How is the belief that "woman" is an identity, or an indefinable feeling that some people have, NOT an ideology?

I don't think we can avoid hurting people's feelings if stating a few facts about biological reality hurts people's feelings.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:13

@FlirtsWithRhinos or, conversely, a trans person who will stand u for womans' rights.

But neither of these things will happen for as long as the"she started it" continues, and it's women who will cop for it, and genuine trans people, which is a shame.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:12

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/07/2022 00:03

No not reasonable to me
I don't thnk tw are "valid women"
nor do i agree with TM instantly being cast aside!

Ah, ok. That is a shame, it was an 100% genuine attempt.

To be clear, TM weren't cast aside. I've gone into my thinking around TM with you in some detail but for this post, in the interests of brevity I gave a partial example just around TW since that is the area where most differences seem to arise.

And I used "valid women" specifically because that is a phrase I see often used in statements from trans allies. I'm actually surprised you weren't ok with it.

BUT - it's just an example to get the conversation started. I was trying to work out what this Someone who has respect for both would say.

And ok, clearly I got it wrong but I'm sure you can do better.

What would you say?

Of course I can't do better. If I could, I'd be on the big bucks.

Valid women is a ridiculous expression. What's the opposite? An invalid woman?Which is a what? And how does one "earn" their ronouns?

I've just realised i gave you a very short sentence in retaliation to your reply and i apologise for that - we had the police round for door to door and I got distracted and forgot to come back to you.

I'd like to see a feminist backing the safe spaces, prison etc, rape counsellors (Believe it or not, I was HORRIFIED to hear about that) and speaking up for women without calling trans an ideology or hurting peoples' feelings. Why so difficult?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:09

@AlisonDonut so if theres no middle ground, whats the solution? refuse to budge in a childish game of he started it under the delusion you have a chance of winning this?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:09

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 11:47

This.

Not to mention the fact that half the Labour front bench have adopted positions @beautyisthefaceiseewould no doubt claim were extreme TRA, as do Stonewall who are responsible for providing training to both children and adults and doling out sought after diversity points to businesses.

Eh? What do Labour have to do with it?!

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:55

Marynotsocontrary · 06/07/2022 15:41

Firstly, I assure you I was confused.

Secondly - no, I don't think it's okay.
Your logic doesn't follow, I'm afraid.

I'll leave it at that. I'm sorry, but it's too difficult to have a proper discussion with you.

No, it isnt. You are being deliberately obtuse. And if you're not, it's far too much work if I have to make the same point for times and you are still arguing kt.

It's very, very simple.

I dont think what women do is as bad as rape and death, but in the conversation of causing the problem to go on and on, they're equal.

Whether you think I did or didnt sa that a few pages ago is irrelevant. We arent in court.

Marynotsocontrary · 06/07/2022 15:41

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:27

I don't think you've been confused by my lack of precision, you are just determined to trip me up when actually my points are quite reasonable.

Well, you seem so determined to defend womens' behaviour that you surely think it's relatively OK, otherwise you wouldn't have spent 3 pages arguing about a sentence.

Firstly, I assure you I was confused.

Secondly - no, I don't think it's okay.
Your logic doesn't follow, I'm afraid.

I'll leave it at that. I'm sorry, but it's too difficult to have a proper discussion with you.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:35

FlirtsWithRhinos · 06/07/2022 00:03

No not reasonable to me
I don't thnk tw are "valid women"
nor do i agree with TM instantly being cast aside!

Ah, ok. That is a shame, it was an 100% genuine attempt.

To be clear, TM weren't cast aside. I've gone into my thinking around TM with you in some detail but for this post, in the interests of brevity I gave a partial example just around TW since that is the area where most differences seem to arise.

And I used "valid women" specifically because that is a phrase I see often used in statements from trans allies. I'm actually surprised you weren't ok with it.

BUT - it's just an example to get the conversation started. I was trying to work out what this Someone who has respect for both would say.

And ok, clearly I got it wrong but I'm sure you can do better.

What would you say?

I've lost the thread here. Let me go back and read it again.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:29

Re whoever said about Stonewall in schools - that's a nonsense. They don't deliver the training, certainly not in ours.

You have to be Stonewall certified to be led by them (I worked in one where it wa granted and I met Ian McKellen). Most of the training was about homosexuality not trans.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:28

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 08:43

What does meeting trans people half way look like, @beautyisthefaceisee?

I don't think anyone minded pronouns a few years ago, but now pronouns are being used as evidence that we all agree that trans women are women and belong in women only spaces.

I can't respect a male person's identity as a woman because I do not believe a male person is a woman. And to agree that they can be one, just to be nice, would mean prioritising their belief that woman is an identity over my own belief that woman means female person, and my right not to share any kind of identity with them.

I'm not sure how we can meet people halfway when you either believe that trans women are women or you don't.

And before you mention trans men again, well no, I don't believe trans men are men either. The reason they don't feature so much in this debate is because they aren't taking sporting opportunities from male athletes or making men feel unsafe in their rape therapy groups. But you can't logically accept that trans men are men and not accept that trans women are women. The same logic has to apply to both.

It's not about believe that trans women are women.

It's about a world where @SmashingEgg and the ilk would not speak about trans people in the way they do, and idiots on twitter wouldn't speak about feminists the way they do. Then, we might have a fighting chance of a reasonable debate. @SmashingEgg re your point about chest feeders etc - do you think my 30 year old trans friend makes them rules? can you realy not see as per reindeer's point earlier that it affects him too?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:27

Marynotsocontrary · 06/07/2022 10:15

@beautyisthefaceisee
Thank you for your explanation posted earlier.

I think we agree on a lot of things as it happens.
Sometimes I've been confused by a lack of precision in your language.
Saying "x is no better than y", or "x is not any better than y" (as you did), will always imply "x is just as bad as y" to me. Lots of explanation and sidetracking later and I do understand that is not really what you meant.

Similarly, if you had said to the pp who was upset "it's not only about you" or "it's not just about you" instead of the exclusionary "it's not about you" I would have had no argument with that. Again, the problem was with language. What you said implied something different to what you actually meant, I think.

The fact we seem to think that anything under rape and death threats is Ok is chilling. It really is.
Just because I"m questioning what you're saying doesn't mean that I, for one, think anything of the sort. You keep making sweeping generalisations like this with no evidence of their truth.

I don't think you've been confused by my lack of precision, you are just determined to trip me up when actually my points are quite reasonable.

Well, you seem so determined to defend womens' behaviour that you surely think it's relatively OK, otherwise you wouldn't have spent 3 pages arguing about a sentence.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:25

GerryAtrick · 06/07/2022 11:38

@SmashingEgg

I'll second that until the end of time.

I'm not sure what's worse - being a bigot or blindly supporting one.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:25

SmashingEgg · 06/07/2022 09:15

@beautyisthefaceisee Yes furious and I'll continue to be furious.
Sick to death of men who think they're women, whether they've still got their balls attached or not, impinging on natural born females and demanding everything be their way.
You might bang your drum for them, but I won't.
You can sit bashing your keyboard all you like, but it won't change the fact that because of them, women are slowly but surely being eroded.
Chest feeders, womb carriers, people who menstruate? Pronouns to state my sex?
As I said, they can shove that shit up their arses!

"bashing your keyboard" Nice. Do you usually dismiss other womens' opinions?

Because of who? because of trans people? Who are these peole "demanding everything be their way"?

People regularly claim MN isn't nasty towards trans. No idea how they can when there are osts like that.

Women slowly but surely being eroded is down in part to atittudes like yours.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:24

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 08:43

What does meeting trans people half way look like, @beautyisthefaceisee?

I don't think anyone minded pronouns a few years ago, but now pronouns are being used as evidence that we all agree that trans women are women and belong in women only spaces.

I can't respect a male person's identity as a woman because I do not believe a male person is a woman. And to agree that they can be one, just to be nice, would mean prioritising their belief that woman is an identity over my own belief that woman means female person, and my right not to share any kind of identity with them.

I'm not sure how we can meet people halfway when you either believe that trans women are women or you don't.

And before you mention trans men again, well no, I don't believe trans men are men either. The reason they don't feature so much in this debate is because they aren't taking sporting opportunities from male athletes or making men feel unsafe in their rape therapy groups. But you can't logically accept that trans men are men and not accept that trans women are women. The same logic has to apply to both.

Well, I personally believe both are both, but I wuld be happy to compromise with the term trans man or trans woman. What I won't budge on is refusal to use pronouns and referring to it as an "ideology".

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 15:23

Howcoldloveis · 06/07/2022 08:36

Happy for trans people to do their thing, as long as it doesn't infringe on me - not happy to be lied to when I ask for a female health care professional and I get a transwoman. Not happy for transwomen to have access to female only spaces, not happy for transwomen to compete in women's sport. The pronouns thing is bullshit - no sane person believes transwomen are women. They may not feel like men - but they are not women - maybe like in sport they need a new category. I suspect I am therefore a trans bigot and weirdly I am ok with that.

But you're not hapy for them to do their thing, that's a lie. I agree with you on the spaces, the health care professional, and the sport. That doent make you a bigot

However -
"the pronouns thing is bullshit - no sane person believes transwomen are women" - in what way is that letting them 'do theri thing? that bit is bigoted, yes.

Swipe left for the next trending thread