Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:04

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:56

How exactly is she "being a dick"?

What has she said in this article that you consider to be "transphobic"?

It seems to me that you think anyone who isn't willing to at least pretend to believe that humans can change sex is transphobic.

I don't think it's transphobic to think that.

I think it's transphobic to say it publicly in the way she has done and profit from hurting people.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 18:00

But that's the thing. The political belief aspect of trans is in question - who I vote for isn't. lots of people don't believe its an ideology, so thats the issue.

Yes, well Christians believe they are right about the whole God thing.

Well, because me saying I think GC views are often bigoted is not directly aimed at anyone. If I called my colleague a bigot I'd be in a lot of trouble

Maya is openly laughing at trans people and being celebrated for being hurtful.

No she isn't, and she certainly isn't directing it at an individual, which is where you seem to think the line should be drawn.

Lots and lots of homophobic, racist and sexist remarks are fact.

Can you give some examples?

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 17:59

What's wrong about saying women are physically less strong than men @beautyisthefaceisee ?

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:56

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:38

You'd have been much quicker at saying "he's a man".

Re the second one, she is being a dick in this article
"https://www.msn.com/en-gb/entertainment/music/maya-forstater-wins-two-claims-in-fresh-employment-tribunal-following-appeal/ar-AAZfX9k"

Doubling down on the hurt already caused.

You call it gender critical she's transphobic.

I think anyone who expresses transphobic, racist, sexist, misogynistic, misandrist, ableist or any other kind of hurtful view should be subjected to disciplinary and losing her job.

Under teaching registration I'm not allowed to give my political or religious affilliation in case it influences/offends anyone. I can be disciplined and struck off for that.

So why should it be OK for people like Maya?

How exactly is she "being a dick"?

What has she said in this article that you consider to be "transphobic"?

It seems to me that you think anyone who isn't willing to at least pretend to believe that humans can change sex is transphobic.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:54

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:48

Under teaching registration I'm not allowed to give my political or religious affilliation in case it influences/offends anyone. I can be disciplined and struck off for that. So why should it be OK for people like Maya?

this comment is interesting because my entire reason for objecting to pronouns in professional correspondence (as stated in the second thread on this post) is because it displays a political belief. If people can denote that they think trans women are women and gender critical beliefs are bigoted in a professional environment, why can’t people denote that they think sex is a material reality in the oppression of female people?

I thought we had been having a polite discussion up till now but your “he’s a man” comment was pretty patronising - I’m a lawyer who is actually pretty objective about court judgments and yes I find a 200 paragraph detailed assessment of contemporaneous evidence more persuasive than an unreasoned decision of a jury who were not sequestered and subjected to a massive social media campaign - yes campaign - against Amber Heard.

I will read your article now but as I say, I havent expressed a view on Forstater because I haven’t read it. But as a general rule, people who do not believe gender is more important than sex should not lose their jobs over it, (unless the belief manifests itself at work in a way which justifies it)

If anyone actually believes someone lost their job because they accidentally left a leaflet, the poor wee victim - well, more fool them.

I didn't mean you thought that, but others do (re Amber).

But that's the thing. The political belief aspect of trans is in question - who I vote for isn't. lots of people don't believe its an ideology, so thats the issue.

Well, because me saying I think GC views are often bigoted is not directly aimed at anyone. If I called my colleague a bigot I'd be in a lot of trouble

Maya is openly laughing at trans people and being celebrated for being hurtful.

If i made a comment about women, i dont know, being physically less strong than men, or an ableist comment, would that be OK, 'even though it's fact'? no. So how did Maya win on those grounds when actually it's disputed?

Lots and lots of homophobic, racist and sexist remarks are fact. i don't see anyone smugly seeing them in the workplace and then smiling in the papers about it.

But that's because transpeople are fair game.

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:52

Ok I’ve read the article and the quote from her (not sure what is hateful unless you think saying you can’t change sex is being a dick?) but that is a quote from today. It isn’t evidence before the tribunal on which they could have concluded that she was treated that way due to the way she expressed that belief rather than the fact of her holding it.

have you read the judgment?

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:48

Under teaching registration I'm not allowed to give my political or religious affilliation in case it influences/offends anyone. I can be disciplined and struck off for that. So why should it be OK for people like Maya?

this comment is interesting because my entire reason for objecting to pronouns in professional correspondence (as stated in the second thread on this post) is because it displays a political belief. If people can denote that they think trans women are women and gender critical beliefs are bigoted in a professional environment, why can’t people denote that they think sex is a material reality in the oppression of female people?

I thought we had been having a polite discussion up till now but your “he’s a man” comment was pretty patronising - I’m a lawyer who is actually pretty objective about court judgments and yes I find a 200 paragraph detailed assessment of contemporaneous evidence more persuasive than an unreasoned decision of a jury who were not sequestered and subjected to a massive social media campaign - yes campaign - against Amber Heard.

I will read your article now but as I say, I havent expressed a view on Forstater because I haven’t read it. But as a general rule, people who do not believe gender is more important than sex should not lose their jobs over it, (unless the belief manifests itself at work in a way which justifies it)

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:38

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:34

The Johnny Depp verdict directly contradicted the findings of the English High Court, that was my issue with that jury decision. I found the detailed high court judgment very persuasive. I’m not aware of any such conflicting decision here.

I haven’t read the Forstater judgment and pass no comment on it but perhaps you could point me to the paragraphs of it which contain the evidence she was acting like a dick to people?

as a general rule do you accept that people who hold gender critical beliefs should not be discriminated against in the workplace?

You'd have been much quicker at saying "he's a man".

Re the second one, she is being a dick in this article
"https://www.msn.com/en-gb/entertainment/music/maya-forstater-wins-two-claims-in-fresh-employment-tribunal-following-appeal/ar-AAZfX9k"

Doubling down on the hurt already caused.

You call it gender critical she's transphobic.

I think anyone who expresses transphobic, racist, sexist, misogynistic, misandrist, ableist or any other kind of hurtful view should be subjected to disciplinary and losing her job.

Under teaching registration I'm not allowed to give my political or religious affilliation in case it influences/offends anyone. I can be disciplined and struck off for that.

So why should it be OK for people like Maya?

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:34

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:27

It's interesting how the same people who were railing about the Johnny Depp verdict last week now accept a tribunal ruling without question.

It's almost as if women are bending the rules to suit themselves.

However, we have come a long way from pronouns in emails, ey?

The Johnny Depp verdict directly contradicted the findings of the English High Court, that was my issue with that jury decision. I found the detailed high court judgment very persuasive. I’m not aware of any such conflicting decision here.

I haven’t read the Forstater judgment and pass no comment on it but perhaps you could point me to the paragraphs of it which contain the evidence she was acting like a dick to people?

as a general rule do you accept that people who hold gender critical beliefs should not be discriminated against in the workplace?

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 17:32

However, we have come a long way from pronouns in emails, ey?

Not really in fact Maya's result actually gives women more pushback against them.

Which is a fantastic result.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:30

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:27

It's interesting how the same people who were railing about the Johnny Depp verdict last week now accept a tribunal ruling without question.

It's almost as if women are bending the rules to suit themselves.

However, we have come a long way from pronouns in emails, ey?

Almost as if they were two completely unrelated hearings, involving completely different parties, different facts and different areas of the law.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:28

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:22

Oh, is it not? Explain to me why you don't want males in shared spaces and counselling groups and prisons.

I don't want males in single sex spaces for women.

Because these single sex spaces exist for women's safety and dignity, and they were designated single sex spaces for women, long before anyone started suggesting that "women" meant anything other than "the female sex".

There is literally no reason for people to be in single sex spaces for the opposite sex.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:27

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:25

his “truth” would have to be a protected belief for the purposes of the Equality Act though so what this “truth” is would be highly relevant to whether he would win.

It's interesting how the same people who were railing about the Johnny Depp verdict last week now accept a tribunal ruling without question.

It's almost as if women are bending the rules to suit themselves.

However, we have come a long way from pronouns in emails, ey?

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:23

I would lose my job if I aired my political or religious views. As I should.

well done on the meltdown line and lie down. It was so clver the first time you had to repeat it. Well done donut.

No, I know nothing about the case. I have no interest in the opinions of transphobes, or their little happy clappy gang.

If you said "trans women are women" you would be expressing a political view and you would most certainly not lose your job for it.

You might lose your job for saying the opposite though.

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 17:25

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:14

It's more to do with the fact that she is in a professional environment.

The verdict is actually a loss for women.

How long until a man "states" truth, loses his job and wins? they've shot themselves in the foot.

his “truth” would have to be a protected belief for the purposes of the Equality Act though so what this “truth” is would be highly relevant to whether he would win.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:23

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 17:21

a) you really are naive
b) she'll get a payout, cause people like her always do.

I've no idea what you're on about re stilts.

Evidently you know nothing about this case as that's all she did. And again, you know nothing about this case as if you did you'd know about 'nonsense on stilts'. And nothing has been decided about payouts, I agree she is likely to do so but you don't make the rules, the tribunal does and unlike you, I stick to actual reality. And no judgement on awards has been made yet.

Perhaps instead of having a complete public meltdown, go do some research if you want to know, or just go have that little lie down. Nobody should lose their job for a leaflet. On whichever side you are. It is utterly ridiculous.

I would lose my job if I aired my political or religious views. As I should.

well done on the meltdown line and lie down. It was so clver the first time you had to repeat it. Well done donut.

No, I know nothing about the case. I have no interest in the opinions of transphobes, or their little happy clappy gang.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:22

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:15

Btw - you cant have it both ways. according to you, transmen are women. So do you not care about their feelings? Or do you lose your MN feminism badge if you make choices others dont like?

This is such an odd take.

This isn't about feelings.

Oh, is it not? Explain to me why you don't want males in shared spaces and counselling groups and prisons.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 17:21

a) you really are naive
b) she'll get a payout, cause people like her always do.

I've no idea what you're on about re stilts.

Evidently you know nothing about this case as that's all she did. And again, you know nothing about this case as if you did you'd know about 'nonsense on stilts'. And nothing has been decided about payouts, I agree she is likely to do so but you don't make the rules, the tribunal does and unlike you, I stick to actual reality. And no judgement on awards has been made yet.

Perhaps instead of having a complete public meltdown, go do some research if you want to know, or just go have that little lie down. Nobody should lose their job for a leaflet. On whichever side you are. It is utterly ridiculous.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:20

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:14

It's more to do with the fact that she is in a professional environment.

The verdict is actually a loss for women.

How long until a man "states" truth, loses his job and wins? they've shot themselves in the foot.

Yeah, people who deliver "diversity training" in which they mislabel people "cis" and use nonsense phrases such as "assigned at birth" and claim that everyone has a gender identity are also in a professional environment.

Why are they allowed - even encouraged and invited - to express their personal beliefs in a work environment and present them as facts, but Maya isn't allowed to express hers in a professional environment?

If you want people to keep their beliefs about sex and gender out of the professional working environment then that needs to apply to both sides, and I think gender critical feminists would be absolutely delighted with that outcome. Everyone can just bring their work selves to work and leave their gender identities at home.

This verdict is a victory for common sense, and for women who shouldn't be victimised for disagreeing with gender ideology. Yes I know you don't like that word, but I really don't know what else to call it. It is a belief system, for which there is basically no evidence.

Men state the truth all the time and aren't victimised for it.

People persecuted for having gender critical beliefs, and losing their livelihood over it, are almost all female. Maybe you should have a long hard think about why that is.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:15

Btw - you cant have it both ways. according to you, transmen are women. So do you not care about their feelings? Or do you lose your MN feminism badge if you make choices others dont like?

This is such an odd take.

This isn't about feelings.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:15

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 16:59

a - she wasn't an arsehole, she merely left a leaflet on her desk, relating to a government consultation.
b - No decision has been made on a payout. If she lost her job for a leaflet then that is discrimination, and she deserves a payout [that's how discrimination tribunals work].

The facts are all there, you might want to read up on them. Before spouting 'nonsense on stilts'.

a) you really are naive
b) she'll get a payout, cause people like her always do.

I've no idea what you're on about re stilts.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:14

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:01

Well yes, that person also cannot have what they want, which is to change sex. Something which is not scientifically possible and never will be.

I take reasonable care not to deliberately hurt people's feelings, but not to the point of lying or denying material reality. If reality hurts people's feelings, then there comes a point where I think we can reasonably consider that that is a "them problem" and we are not obliged to accommodate it.

Of course my feminism includes trans men and female non binary people. It includes all female people, and not male people. But feminism isn't about telling people what they want to hear. It's not about being kind or nice. It's about fighting for equal rights for female people, and an end to sex based oppression. Perhaps if we can accomplish that, fewer people will want to opt out of being female.

Maya Forstater has had a payout for being unlawfully discriminated against for her beliefs, which are considered "worthy of respect in a democratic society". Amazing that her "belief" that humans can't change sex, which is less of a belief than a statement of obvious and irrefutable fact, even needs to be defended in a court of law.

It's more to do with the fact that she is in a professional environment.

The verdict is actually a loss for women.

How long until a man "states" truth, loses his job and wins? they've shot themselves in the foot.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:13

SmashingEgg · 06/07/2022 16:56

@beautyisthefaceisee If it makes me a bigot, so be it. Your opinion of me is as irrelevant as the man pretending to be a woman.

Transphobic to boot. you're lovely.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:13

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 16:55

You don't care that you're hurting people with your views, you're invalidating their identity, you're dismissing their voices, shutting them down and then seem mightily surprised when people don't want to listen to you.

Males getting hurty feelings always does seem to result in death and rape threats towards women...weird huh. Almost like they keep their male pattern violent behaviour.

DO you have a MN textbook? "hurty feelings" indeed. And they say misandry doesn't exist on MN.

Btw - you cant have it both ways. according to you, transmen are women. So do you not care about their feelings? Or do you lose your MN feminism badge if you make choices others dont like?

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 17:02

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 16:52

But not everybody is asking you to do that, tho. its not black and white. can you really not get that?

It is black and white though.

Either trans women are women or they aren't. They aren't.

Either trans men are men or they aren't. They aren't.

Either being a woman is a feeling in someone's head or it is a biological reality. It is a biological reality.

Swipe left for the next trending thread