Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 18:38

Well, not really. and it's an ideology, in your opinion.

What do you think an ideology is, and why do you think the belief that we have sexed souls and that this is more important than physical sex is not one?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:37

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:33

What was achieved by the Maya verdict?

that women cannot be discriminated against in the workplace merely because they hold an opinion about the role sex plays in their oppression.

Her case was fact specific. This decision doesn’t set any precedent - had she been found to have acted in a transphobic way, she would have lost, but the principle from the last hearing, that gender critical beliefs are protected, will protect the huge number of women that don’t want sex erased in favour of gender.

it doesn’t mean anyone can say what they want and get away with it. it literally doesn’t mean that at all

What about men? or do we only care about women?

It's hard to find her transphobic when as you point out we protect GC beliefs, a great deal of which are transphobic!

It does though, and it will. Anyone who thinks this will remain a stand alone.....fair play. But its a sad day.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:36

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:33

What was achieved by the Maya verdict?

People can state scientific facts without fear of losing their jobs because of ideologues. I expect in time you'll get why that's important. Do call back when the realisation dawns.

Well, not really. and it's an ideology, in your opinion.

Maya might like to think she's leading the revolution but it won't happen by practice. If anything, she's shot her own employment

I expect in time you'l see that this was a big mistake, when men can say what they like to women in the workplace because its a "scientific fact".

I'll stand at a funeral at the weekend and when they say about someone going to heaven il say "no she isn't, thats an ideology and heavens not real". that will be OK, wont it?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:34

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:31

If I went on a night out and made a scene and was reported, I'd be up in front of the GTCS for disrepute. So yes, I would.

Are you not capable of making like for like comparisons? The case in question is about tweeting beliefs. You can tweet that MN is full of ciswomen til the cows come home, you won't get any penalties of any description for that.

I thought it was about "Leaving a leaflet on a desk".

My point is, you have to behave professionally, regardless of what you think behind closed doors. She didn't.

I cant make like for like, because I dont think trans is an ideology. So I wouldn't say anything as bloody stupid as that in the first place, but my point was , we all have to watch how we behave in relation to our beliefs.

And its not a like for like comparison. You might find it offensive on MN but its a term agreed by policy and I could say it daily in work without any come back. The fact you think the two compare shows how far this has gone.

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:33

What was achieved by the Maya verdict?

that women cannot be discriminated against in the workplace merely because they hold an opinion about the role sex plays in their oppression.

Her case was fact specific. This decision doesn’t set any precedent - had she been found to have acted in a transphobic way, she would have lost, but the principle from the last hearing, that gender critical beliefs are protected, will protect the huge number of women that don’t want sex erased in favour of gender.

it doesn’t mean anyone can say what they want and get away with it. it literally doesn’t mean that at all

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:33

What was achieved by the Maya verdict?

People can state scientific facts without fear of losing their jobs because of ideologues. I expect in time you'll get why that's important. Do call back when the realisation dawns.

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:31

If I went on a night out and made a scene and was reported, I'd be up in front of the GTCS for disrepute. So yes, I would.

Are you not capable of making like for like comparisons? The case in question is about tweeting beliefs. You can tweet that MN is full of ciswomen til the cows come home, you won't get any penalties of any description for that.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:30

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:27

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was

was it? When?

My parent was a policeman. We were brought up regularly reminded of incidents of that , where "I didnt mean x" meant nada.

I mean, I could be totally making it up for shits and giggles, but thats what we were always told. Presumably they had seen enough that made them feel strongly about that.

We've digressed. My point is, a world where people can be hurtful and offensive to others, why is that to be celebrated? I dont care if you agree with her, her view hurts people.

Jesy Nelson was bigger than the other girls. Katie Hopkins was factually correct. didn't hurt her any less. Why would we celebrate that?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:28

Can I ask a serious question?

What was achieved by the Maya verdict?

That 'women wont be silenced and can say that trans is an ideology?'

We will see in 5 years where the "you can say what you want and wont lose your job" gets us.

Certainly not a society I want to be in.

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:27

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was

was it? When?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:25

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:22

So I can call MN women a ciswoman day and night then, desite the fact they've told me they find it offensive - because it's an accepted term in my workplace that we have been told to use to refer to women as (it hasn't come up yet, because I don't work 'with' adults).

You can tweet that as much as you like and it won't affect your employment, no.

Ciswomen wouldn't.

My political belief would, my registration would be affected.

Make of that what you will.

I had a pal a few years ago who was photographed in the same photo as a box which said Neil Lennon on it (not long after the letter box bomb threat).

Thrown out of university for bringing it into disrepute.

If I went on a night out and made a scene and was reported, I'd be up in front of the GTCS for disrepute. So yes, I would.

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:22

So I can call MN women a ciswoman day and night then, desite the fact they've told me they find it offensive - because it's an accepted term in my workplace that we have been told to use to refer to women as (it hasn't come up yet, because I don't work 'with' adults).

You can tweet that as much as you like and it won't affect your employment, no.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:21

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:14

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was.

What complete and utter nonsense
😂 😂 😂

So I can call MN women a ciswoman day and night then, desite the fact they've told me they find it offensive - because it's an accepted term in my workplace that we have been told to use to refer to women as (it hasn't come up yet, because I don't work 'with' adults).

Oh, it wouldnt be OK?

Thought it was down to the person doing the feeling?

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:21

In schools, if a pupil tells me they feel a comment was racist, it's logged as a racist incident.

And when investigated and found to be not even remotely racist, then it will be dropped.

Your relationship with factual discussion is something else 😆

onlywhenidream · 06/07/2022 18:21

It is possible however for that approach to be misused

But as a general question if one party feels something is transphobic and the other feels that misogyny was expressed do you record both equally ?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:20

So can I assume Katie Hopkins will be the next to be in the guardian with her payouts then? A lot of the things she says are based on fact.

Frankie Boyle will now avoid all criticism because his jokes are factual?

A pupil, years ago now, threatened to violate me in the worst way possible. The outcome was that it wasn't sexual violence because he "didn't actually do it" and he "didn't mean it". Back in my class the next day.

Cause truth is better than feelings, yeah?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:18

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 18:15

I don't think lots would, no. Certainly not if the question were better defined (ie. when talking about strength are we talking about upper body strength, or endurance, or ability to bear pain?)

Is saying women live longer than men sexist in your opinion?

No. and I know you think you're being clever with that, but statistically we do.

Doesn't change the fact my friend's wife was dead at 42 and my friend has a dad in his 90s, though, does it?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:17

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:14

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was.

What complete and utter nonsense
😂 😂 😂

The feeling of the victim is always taken into account

Who do you think decides? the perpetrator?

"Were you being racist"

"no"

case closed.

In schools, if a pupil tells me they feel a comment was racist, it's logged as a racist incident. But you'll know better than the policymakers.

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 18:15

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:04

Lots of people would consider that sexist.

I don't think lots would, no. Certainly not if the question were better defined (ie. when talking about strength are we talking about upper body strength, or endurance, or ability to bear pain?)

Is saying women live longer than men sexist in your opinion?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:15

onlywhenidream · 06/07/2022 18:12

But most people would accept that as a generalisation it is true and significant

Feminism isn't about denial about biology it's about understanding when it's relevant and when it's not

Feminism 'should be' about protecting all women.

Not only are you denying women the opportunity to be trans (because we're only shouting about the transwomen, despite the fact transmen have caused little to no harm and they are the majority of the transitioners) you're denying them their rights based on the fact that they're a woman, and basing it on the men.

I don't think most people would accept that it's an ideology or be naive enough to thtink that "humans cant change sex" is the issue at hand. We fucking know that, despite Maya thinking she's now some kind of world leader (brave, my eye).

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:14

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was.

What complete and utter nonsense
😂 😂 😂

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:13

Lots of people would consider that sexist.

Well people who have trouble with scientific facts might, I guess. You'd know about them

Back in reality, tweeting that women are generally less strong than men would not impact your employment status. HTH.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:13

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 18:00

But that's the thing. The political belief aspect of trans is in question - who I vote for isn't. lots of people don't believe its an ideology, so thats the issue.

Yes, well Christians believe they are right about the whole God thing.

Well, because me saying I think GC views are often bigoted is not directly aimed at anyone. If I called my colleague a bigot I'd be in a lot of trouble

Maya is openly laughing at trans people and being celebrated for being hurtful.

No she isn't, and she certainly isn't directing it at an individual, which is where you seem to think the line should be drawn.

Lots and lots of homophobic, racist and sexist remarks are fact.

Can you give some examples?

re your first point - I'm an atheist living in a society where I have to accept what to me is made up as fact, because the rules are different there.

No, I think the line should be drawn at saying it publicly, mockingly and celebrating it. She is literally celebrating hurting eople.

Well, when I was at school, there was a boy (who would later come out as gay, and was gay then) and people would call him X "gay boy" Y.

If you're getting your little dictionary out, technically speaking its not homophobic, because he is gay and he is a boy (now man). But if someone said that In my school I'd log it as a homophobic incident (deragatory use of terms).

Mind years ago in Big Brother when Jade was done for saying "fuck off back to where you came from" despite the fact she repeatedly said she meant Bollywood, celebrity background, not the country. Still hurt the same though, and still racist because Shilpa felt it was.

I work with men regularly. We have spent YEARS trying to be seen as equals to men int he workplace, and by bringing this truth thing in, it's an open playing field. We'd only just got to a point where males sitting around wiht page 3 making comments on womens' appearances wasn't OK, but now? why isn't it? Why isn't it OK for a man to say "oh look at her boobs/look at her hips/she looks sexy" etc etc.

I once worked with a man who was in his 60s who enjoyed telling me at length how erect his penis was when talking to me. How long until he says, well, it's a fact? I also met a guy who found it acceptable to call his girlfriend a "slut" because the term originally meant someone who lived in a messy house. That's OK , right?

I'm being OTT here but you see my point. When we prioritise "it's a fact" - its not a good move. There's a thread currently running about a teacher who called a pupil a "big girl" and that her eyebrows were "like slugs". Both of those things may well be facts. Now what?

Note it'll only work one way though. if I call my hideous colleage an arsehole, do you think you will see me standing in the guardian saying "the truth will out"?

Here's the thing though. Yes, all she said was humans can't change sex. They can't. But she knew exactly what she was doing with that remark, and she's done it. Allowing the transphobes to hide in plain sight, and it's a slippery slope.

It used to be that racism, sexism, homophobia was judged in a court of law on what the person at the receiving end felt it was.

Now, it's changing to the person behind the gun.

How long until Smug McSmugson is racist but factual and that has to now be accepted because the trans comment was?

onlywhenidream · 06/07/2022 18:12

But most people would accept that as a generalisation it is true and significant

Feminism isn't about denial about biology it's about understanding when it's relevant and when it's not

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:04

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 17:59

What's wrong about saying women are physically less strong than men @beautyisthefaceisee ?

Lots of people would consider that sexist.