Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 21:08

Howcoldloveis · 06/07/2022 19:13

Do teachers lose their jobs for saying Santa isn't real?

Well, I work in secondary, so that would be strange, but I wouldn't say it to primary school kids who I work with in summer, cause I'm not a twat.

No, but I'd be pulled up for saying i was an atheist or that I vote for Nicola Sturgeon. That's directly against my terms of service/registration.

But comparing Santa to transgender is AGAIN, transphobic!

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 21:07

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 19:11

Mate, if she gets a pay out it will be compensation for her lost earnings.

The toll this has taken on her has been huge.

Struggling to rake up sympathy. She didn't look very "toll beaten" in her smug article today.

People lose their jobs for various reasons all the time, yet she is being celebrated when it is due to her making her own choices.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 21:06

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 19:10

Because it should not ever be considered bigoted to state that biological sex is real and important.

A relative in my family is an 'old generation' man who grew up in a country where homosexuality is still pretty much illegal.

He really struggles to understand that a man can be attracted to a man. Genuinely.

Would you say he was homophobic or bigoted?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 21:05

onlywhenidream · 06/07/2022 19:01

Have I lost the plot here ? Is you suggesting that Maya is exploiting trans people ?

Maya - the woman forced out of her job because vulnerable transpeople objected to her none offensive statements ?

No.

Well, yes.

Not directly.

Her article about a win for women etc etc and everyone applauding her - what that actually is doing is hurting transpeople. I really don't understand why people can't see that.

Helleofabore · 06/07/2022 21:02

Yes alison.

The same with military pack carrying, banks and coin bags, landscaping, store stacking and deliveries, warehouse work. A whole raft of work roles.

All because accommodations based on biological facts.

‘Equality’ doesn’t mean equal everything. The dropping off of the word ‘opportunity’ has had consequences in creating this false perception. Females should have equal opportunity, and be treated ‘equally’ wherever possible.

The distinction is very important.

Females are not like super heroes with equal strength to males . No female is a match for the very strongest male and it is foolish to believe that the average male is not stronger and a has huge number of other bodily differences that deliver advantages over average females.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 20:47

Instead accommodations can be made for most roles such as having a weight limit set for females that is different to males. So they can do the role just with more lifts when lifts is needed.

An example. When I started working on construction sites I was told I couldn't do x and y. Because things were too heavy. My solution, I ordered smaller bags. So our soil samples could simply be put into smaller bags, same overall weight [15-20kg rather than 30-40kg], and absolutely no barrier to the job. Which was to go out and take soil samples from construction sites.

Upshot, many of the younger men, many of who were still late teens/early 20s, thanked me as they hated the whole 'Carry heavy bags for the job' thing as well. As they were getting backaches from carrying very heavy bags around.

Solution for carrying concrete cubes, rather than lift 3 or 4 at a time, lift 1 or 2 and put a sack barrow on each van. Result, even women could go out collecting cubes.

It doesn't take much working out in the overall scheme of things.

Helleofabore · 06/07/2022 20:09

Not only are you denying women the opportunity to be trans (because we're only shouting about the transwomen, despite the fact transmen have caused little to no harm and they are the majority of the transitioners) you're denying them their rights based on the fact that they're a woman, and basing it on the men.

Could you please link up the evidence to your claim that the majority of transitioners are female.

Because I think you have taken a demographic from the under 18 transitioners over the past year and applied it generally. Or maybe you have seen statistics that we have not seen.

I don’t believe that there are any statistics available for even how many ‘trans’ people there are in the world. And are you forgetting trans people include non-binary people?

Maybe you are using ‘transition’ to specifically mean medically transition which would be incorrect.

Either way, I am keen to see the evidence that the majority of transitioners are female.

Helleofabore · 06/07/2022 20:01

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:54

No, but people would think I was a right arsehole.
So why does Maya get away and is practically cheered?

I really think it would be worth your while putting aside your prejudice here and reading the judgement.

Maya is not advocating standing at a person’s funeral declaring someone’s belief is an ‘ideology’ and someone is not going to heaven.

She is saying that where appropriate, and a think tank where people discussed wide ranging beliefs and opinions is appropriate, people should be able to express their views that people cannot change sex, and that females have need of single sex spaces for their safety and their dignity. And that males should not be competing in female sports categories.

The comparison between a funeral and her think tank work environment is a false comparison.

One is a specific event and the other is an where general opinions, not targeted at specific people should be explored.

Helleofabore · 06/07/2022 19:41

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:04

Lots of people would consider that sexist.

No.

It would be sexist discrimination to expect a female to lift weights that are too heavy for their body which would cause them injury (either immediately or later through repetition). Weights that a male body can easily lift with no ramifications.

The fact that some people believe that females are ‘equal’ and that means they should lift equal weights in their employment is an issue of using the word ‘equality’ in this way.

Females should not be ‘not considered’ for a role where lifting is involved. Just as a person with an injury or a disability should not be ‘not considered’.

Instead accommodations can be made for most roles such as having a weight limit set for females that is different to males. So they can do the role just with more lifts when lifts is needed.

It is NOT sexist to say females have different bodies and limits than males where it matters.

And ‘where it matters’ is key here.

AlisonDonut · 06/07/2022 19:31

I've known trans people since the late 80s.

They knew they were not the 'sex' they wanted to be and we knew it and if a mishap happened, there were no tantrums and wailing and sackings. Why must we behave as if trans people are toddlers that need to be pandered to as if they are all delicate vases that raised voices might crack? If they truly do not know what sex they are then how can they be trans in the first place?

This is why teaching kids they can change sex is so dangerous.

It is so insulting to trans people's intelligence to pretend things that are not true. And it puts people in danger. As we've seen with the predators who use it to their advantage.

I think for me the difference is, that as a female who worked in construction, I've had all sorts said to me over the years and so I'd expect grown men to be able to cope when people know they are not women. But apparently not.

Howcoldloveis · 06/07/2022 19:30

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 19:14

I'll stand at a funeral at the weekend and when they say about someone going to heaven il say "no she isn't, thats an ideology and heavens not real". that will be OK, wont it?

Well you're not going to lose your job over it, no.

No, but people would think I was a right arsehole.
So why does Maya get away and is practically cheered?

But if you made those comments about heaven and were dismissed from your employment as a result...it wouldn't be fair, would it? You're entitled to your own beliefs.
(Your dismissal would probably have happened once, but we've moved on from when the Church wielded such power thankfully).
If it had happened and if you sued as a result and if you won, people would cheer for you too.

It really seems like the zealots are in charge again these days. We're told what to think. And it all started out with the best of intentions, for the main part, but it's gone too far and it's causing harm. Things need to change to be as fair as possible to everyone.

You just can't imagine someone phoning an employer and saying your employee said God does not exist and there is no heaven at my relative's funeral. I can't imagine you'd get more than a sorry for your troubles. The fact is that the TRA are menacing and threaten commercial harm - we need keep doing the very thing they would like us to not do - we need to keep talking about this issue, we need to debate it and keep debating it again and again, we need to not stop, so every man and woman is fully aware of what is going on. There is a reason why the TRA do not want this discussed - it does not stand up to scrutiny.

Helleofabore · 06/07/2022 19:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 17:38

You'd have been much quicker at saying "he's a man".

Re the second one, she is being a dick in this article
"https://www.msn.com/en-gb/entertainment/music/maya-forstater-wins-two-claims-in-fresh-employment-tribunal-following-appeal/ar-AAZfX9k"

Doubling down on the hurt already caused.

You call it gender critical she's transphobic.

I think anyone who expresses transphobic, racist, sexist, misogynistic, misandrist, ableist or any other kind of hurtful view should be subjected to disciplinary and losing her job.

Under teaching registration I'm not allowed to give my political or religious affilliation in case it influences/offends anyone. I can be disciplined and struck off for that.

So why should it be OK for people like Maya?

You really do know nothing about this case. The organisation that she worked for was one who encouraged and fostered wide ranging political discussion.

It is a think tank. It is supposed to foster alternative viewpoints.

That was what made this specific case so stark. Because this organisation allowed freedom of thought and expression yet not about the view that people cannot change sex. And that males should not be in female prisons, or in female single sex spaces such as refuges.

The facts of the case is there for everyone to read.

You dismissal of it, without having any understanding of it, completely undermines your arguments.

AppleCharlottie · 06/07/2022 19:14

I'll stand at a funeral at the weekend and when they say about someone going to heaven il say "no she isn't, thats an ideology and heavens not real". that will be OK, wont it?

Well you're not going to lose your job over it, no.

No, but people would think I was a right arsehole.
So why does Maya get away and is practically cheered?

But if you made those comments about heaven and were dismissed from your employment as a result...it wouldn't be fair, would it? You're entitled to your own beliefs.
(Your dismissal would probably have happened once, but we've moved on from when the Church wielded such power thankfully).
If it had happened and if you sued as a result and if you won, people would cheer for you too.

It really seems like the zealots are in charge again these days. We're told what to think. And it all started out with the best of intentions, for the main part, but it's gone too far and it's causing harm. Things need to change to be as fair as possible to everyone.

Howcoldloveis · 06/07/2022 19:13

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 19:10

Because it should not ever be considered bigoted to state that biological sex is real and important.

Do teachers lose their jobs for saying Santa isn't real?

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 19:11

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:56

Thoughtful post Cantanka, cheers.

Will think about it.

and thanks! One of those have to go but would really rather sit on my backside and chill.

@babyjellyfish shes being cheered all over social media and will no doubt get a pay out and/or some exposure off the back of it so i think shes done just fine. Shame about the vulnerable trans people who shes exploiting to get that though, as if they don't already face enough criticisim.

Mate, if she gets a pay out it will be compensation for her lost earnings.

The toll this has taken on her has been huge.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 19:10

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:54

No, but people would think I was a right arsehole.
So why does Maya get away and is practically cheered?

Because it should not ever be considered bigoted to state that biological sex is real and important.

onlywhenidream · 06/07/2022 19:01

Have I lost the plot here ? Is you suggesting that Maya is exploiting trans people ?

Maya - the woman forced out of her job because vulnerable transpeople objected to her none offensive statements ?

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:56

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:44

It’s so much more nuanced and complicated than this.

Discrimination law has never been totally about perception. It’s not irrelevant - even aspect of the test for harassment is the effect it has on the complainant - but generally the reason for the treatment is what’s important.

“I didn’t mean x” - agreed, but you can see a situation where something isn’t intended to be racist but somebody eg acts out of either ignorance or subconscious bias. It’s racist, notwithstanding it wasn’t intentional. There are also cases where someone thinks something is racist but in fact the actions of the person doing the act was not tainted by racism at all. See David Lammy and the papal smoke.

Can you see that calling women cis and telling them they have a gender identity when their lived experience is that gender reinforces their oppression hurts people? Why is that ok? It does feel as though trans people are entitled not to have their feelings hurt but non-trans women aren’t.

You have to differentiate between the mere fact of holding the belief, and the way someone expresses that belief. Maya Forstater would not have won if it had been found she had been treated in the way she was for eg misgendering. The tribunal has found she was treated that way because she held those beliefs per se. So Katie Hopkins the issue would be the way she expressed her belief about Jesy Nelson’s size, not the mere fact she held that belief.

I know you think the tribunal are wrong to conclude Maya Forstater was not a dick to anyone at work but (I still haven’t read it) I am extremely confident they concluded these allegations against her were not true, NOT that the allegations were true but that this is perfectly fine.

have you read the judgment? I really do not think it says it’s fine to hurt peoples feelings Willy nilly. I think it says merely holding gender critical beliefs should not get women fired.

Thoughtful post Cantanka, cheers.

Will think about it.

and thanks! One of those have to go but would really rather sit on my backside and chill.

@babyjellyfish shes being cheered all over social media and will no doubt get a pay out and/or some exposure off the back of it so i think shes done just fine. Shame about the vulnerable trans people who shes exploiting to get that though, as if they don't already face enough criticisim.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:54

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:39

I expect in time you'l see that this was a big mistake, when men can say what they like to women in the workplace because its a "scientific fact".

They already do

I'll stand at a funeral at the weekend and when they say about someone going to heaven il say "no she isn't, thats an ideology and heavens not real". that will be OK, wont it?

Well you're not going to lose your job over it, no.

No, but people would think I was a right arsehole.
So why does Maya get away and is practically cheered?

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:48

@beautyisthefaceisee have a lovely dinner 😊

Cantanka · 06/07/2022 18:44

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:30

My parent was a policeman. We were brought up regularly reminded of incidents of that , where "I didnt mean x" meant nada.

I mean, I could be totally making it up for shits and giggles, but thats what we were always told. Presumably they had seen enough that made them feel strongly about that.

We've digressed. My point is, a world where people can be hurtful and offensive to others, why is that to be celebrated? I dont care if you agree with her, her view hurts people.

Jesy Nelson was bigger than the other girls. Katie Hopkins was factually correct. didn't hurt her any less. Why would we celebrate that?

It’s so much more nuanced and complicated than this.

Discrimination law has never been totally about perception. It’s not irrelevant - even aspect of the test for harassment is the effect it has on the complainant - but generally the reason for the treatment is what’s important.

“I didn’t mean x” - agreed, but you can see a situation where something isn’t intended to be racist but somebody eg acts out of either ignorance or subconscious bias. It’s racist, notwithstanding it wasn’t intentional. There are also cases where someone thinks something is racist but in fact the actions of the person doing the act was not tainted by racism at all. See David Lammy and the papal smoke.

Can you see that calling women cis and telling them they have a gender identity when their lived experience is that gender reinforces their oppression hurts people? Why is that ok? It does feel as though trans people are entitled not to have their feelings hurt but non-trans women aren’t.

You have to differentiate between the mere fact of holding the belief, and the way someone expresses that belief. Maya Forstater would not have won if it had been found she had been treated in the way she was for eg misgendering. The tribunal has found she was treated that way because she held those beliefs per se. So Katie Hopkins the issue would be the way she expressed her belief about Jesy Nelson’s size, not the mere fact she held that belief.

I know you think the tribunal are wrong to conclude Maya Forstater was not a dick to anyone at work but (I still haven’t read it) I am extremely confident they concluded these allegations against her were not true, NOT that the allegations were true but that this is perfectly fine.

have you read the judgment? I really do not think it says it’s fine to hurt peoples feelings Willy nilly. I think it says merely holding gender critical beliefs should not get women fired.

babyjellyfish · 06/07/2022 18:42

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:04

I don't think it's transphobic to think that.

I think it's transphobic to say it publicly in the way she has done and profit from hurting people.

She hasn't profited from it, she lost employment as a direct result of stating her entirely reasonable views.

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:40

My point is, you have to behave professionally, regardless of what you think behind closed doors. She didn't.

Whats unprofessional about stating basic scientific facts?

TheKeatingFive · 06/07/2022 18:39

I expect in time you'l see that this was a big mistake, when men can say what they like to women in the workplace because its a "scientific fact".

They already do

I'll stand at a funeral at the weekend and when they say about someone going to heaven il say "no she isn't, thats an ideology and heavens not real". that will be OK, wont it?

Well you're not going to lose your job over it, no.

beautyisthefaceisee · 06/07/2022 18:39

Heading out for the evening (for the inevitable post dinner discussion where I@ll be accused of ignoring questions).

I know we don't agree ladies, but i do appreciate the discussion. I agree on nothing, but it's things to think about. Thanks.

Swipe left for the next trending thread