Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:36

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 20:29

Except that is exactly what they did.

Are you able to account then how the majority of young trans people are FTM?

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:36

Clymene · 01/07/2022 20:29

Identity isn't real. Ask Rachel Dolezal.

tick tick tick goes the bingo card of trans on MN - throw in straw arguments, detract from the main issue.

Clymene · 01/07/2022 20:35

Happy to explain. If we respect pronouns in emails, we have to respect them everywhere. So in Canada, when respecting pronouns is ubiquitous, we have a clearly male person being searched for by the police who is referred to as she.

It's a lie. This person is clearly a he, not a she. This is a person with a penis. A man.

If I call him he, what's going to happen? He's going to feel a bit hurt and sad? So what, frankly.

Because he says he's a she, he's going to feel entitled to use female facilities because he is demanding everyone treats him as a woman. Even though everyone can see he isn't.

As for the fact that there are more and more girls thinking they can identify out of being female, I've got news for them. Men don't care. They're still going to rape you and grope you and pay you 30% less for the same job. Your pronouns mean jackshit.

Clymene · 01/07/2022 20:29

Identity isn't real. Ask Rachel Dolezal.

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 20:29

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:09

It's not all about you.

Anyone who believes that trans people looked at women and thought oooooooh let's steal their terms is immature, deluded and arrogant.

Except that is exactly what they did.

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:29

Clymene · 01/07/2022 20:24

The Toronto Police Service requests the public's assistance locating a missing woman.* Isobella Degrace, 27, was last seen on Saturday, June 25, 2022, at 3 a.m., in the Ryerson Avenue and Bathurst Streetet_ area.* She is described as 5’10", with a thin build, shaggy blonde hair, and a full goatee. She was last seen wearing a black t-shirt and grey pants.*

Do you see the problem now?

Could you explain how that relates into pronouns in emails? Or the fact that the overwhelming majority of people using pronouns in email in Britain will be FTM?

Is it the case that women have rights but only until they make choices that dont suit you?

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:28

FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/07/2022 20:21

It's not all about you.

No, but it is also about me, and the many many other people like me. Why are trans people's desire for honest acceptance more important than ours?

Anyone who believes that trans people looked at women and thought oooooooh let's steal their terms is immature, deluded and arrogant.

But that is literally what happened. In order to become Women, with an automatic right to everything that women have a right to, rather than just Live as Women, with limits on what that entitles them to, trans women (or rather the TRAs that speak for them) had to redefine Woman not just for trans women but for every woman.

Perhaps you are too young to know this but I have seen it happen in my lifetime. The language has changed in line with the demands that are being made.

Anyone who doesn't see that is naive, deluded and arrogant, and anyone who sees it but doesn't care is a misogynist and arrogant .

ALSO like you. Nobody is any less or more important - we are all equal. So where's your compromise, given that you literally deny their identity?

I don't disagree re your second point. I don't disagree about many of the barriers it poses. But I do disagree with outright denial.

MIsogynist gets bandied about like candy. I see you didn't address my question on the existence of transmen (and the fact that young trans people in this country are overwhelmingly FTM). Without using the misogny card, can you explain how that relates to your post?

Clymene · 01/07/2022 20:24

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:14

I understand the overall fears about womens' rights and agree with most of them - safe spaces, prisons, etc.

But I think the problem is the argument has now been taken too far and it makes it something hard to get behind

There are tranmen too, btw. Far more common in young people than transwomen.

The Toronto Police Service requests the public's assistance locating a missing woman.* Isobella Degrace, 27, was last seen on Saturday, June 25, 2022, at 3 a.m., in the Ryerson Avenue and Bathurst Streetet_ area.* She is described as 5’10", with a thin build, shaggy blonde hair, and a full goatee. She was last seen wearing a black t-shirt and grey pants.*

Do you see the problem now?

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails
FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/07/2022 20:21

It's not all about you.

No, but it is also about me, and the many many other people like me. Why are trans people's desire for honest acceptance more important than ours?

Anyone who believes that trans people looked at women and thought oooooooh let's steal their terms is immature, deluded and arrogant.

But that is literally what happened. In order to become Women, with an automatic right to everything that women have a right to, rather than just Live as Women, with limits on what that entitles them to, trans women (or rather the TRAs that speak for them) had to redefine Woman not just for trans women but for every woman.

Perhaps you are too young to know this but I have seen it happen in my lifetime. The language has changed in line with the demands that are being made.

Anyone who doesn't see that is naive, deluded and arrogant, and anyone who sees it but doesn't care is a misogynist and arrogant .

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:14

I understand the overall fears about womens' rights and agree with most of them - safe spaces, prisons, etc.

But I think the problem is the argument has now been taken too far and it makes it something hard to get behind

There are tranmen too, btw. Far more common in young people than transwomen.

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 20:09

FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/07/2022 20:04

I think it's pretty arrogant to take the only word that exists for members of the opposite sex to yourself and claim it for your "identity".

Your identity has nothing to do with them, but now you are forcing them to pretend they share it, or else relinquish the word for what they actually are.

👏exactly.

The issue is not, and never has been, that trans- and cis- women (meaning here only women who do self identify as cis, not female people who others assume are cis) want a name and set of pronouns for the inner gender identity they share.

The issue is that they want to use the exact ones that were already being used for people of the female sex and even worse, don't even allow those people of the female sex who don't share that inner gender a new name and pronoun to use instead. Why is it not enough for trans- and cis- women to be recognised for who they are? Why is it so important to deny that female people who are not gender dysphoric but also don't fit in with the trans- and cis- version of womanhood exist as a group in their own right as well?

It's not all about you.

Anyone who believes that trans people looked at women and thought oooooooh let's steal their terms is immature, deluded and arrogant.

1nsertusername · 01/07/2022 20:06

Its ridiculous

We are debating what email signatures pronouns to use when the Rich are getting richer,we are on the brink of WW3, and the environment is collapsing a

If all people have to worry about is their pronoun their life if fucking good!

This is a trivial issue whipped up to distract us from the true issues in the world.

I wish people would get as angry and vocal about the disparity between the rich and the poor as they do about being "misgendered"

The world is in freefall. Wake the hell up people!! We need to campaign the real issues not pronouns!

FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/07/2022 20:04

I think it's pretty arrogant to take the only word that exists for members of the opposite sex to yourself and claim it for your "identity".

Your identity has nothing to do with them, but now you are forcing them to pretend they share it, or else relinquish the word for what they actually are.

👏exactly.

The issue is not, and never has been, that trans- and cis- women (meaning here only women who do self identify as cis, not female people who others assume are cis) want a name and set of pronouns for the inner gender identity they share.

The issue is that they want to use the exact ones that were already being used for people of the female sex and even worse, don't even allow those people of the female sex who don't share that inner gender a new name and pronoun to use instead. Why is it not enough for trans- and cis- women to be recognised for who they are? Why is it so important to deny that female people who are not gender dysphoric but also don't fit in with the trans- and cis- version of womanhood exist as a group in their own right as well?

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 19:59

I don't agree with pronouns being forced on emails, and I think as PP said it singles people out who might not want to.

However, I have zero time or respect for anyone who refuses to acknowledge other peoples' pronouns and seems to think they are oh so terribly clever.

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 19:58

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 19:20

If only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans. If we all do it as standard it takes away the stigma. It’s a simple thing we can do to make peoples lives easier.

Really not my problem.

It would make everyone else's lives a lot easier if trans people realised that no one actually has a gender identity which matches their genitals.

You should be in charge of the UN, you'd solve it all in a day with those mind blowing views.

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 19:58

Marynotsocontrary · 01/07/2022 18:57

If only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans. If we all do it as standard it takes away the stigma. It’s a simple thing we can do to make peoples lives easier.

But don't many trans people change their name to match their chosen gender? When Bruce Jenner became Caitlyn it was obvious she wanted to use female pronouns too. Isn't the name alone enough?

And what about people who are trans but don't want to announce it?

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 19:20

If only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans. If we all do it as standard it takes away the stigma. It’s a simple thing we can do to make peoples lives easier.

Really not my problem.

It would make everyone else's lives a lot easier if trans people realised that no one actually has a gender identity which matches their genitals.

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 19:17

Dress it up anyway you like. You think people's identity is based on your opinion and what you think. And that is arrogant, through and through.

I think it's pretty arrogant to take the only word that exists for members of the opposite sex to yourself and claim it for your "identity".

Your identity has nothing to do with them, but now you are forcing them to pretend they share it, or else relinquish the word for what they actually are.

Marynotsocontrary · 01/07/2022 18:57

If only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans. If we all do it as standard it takes away the stigma. It’s a simple thing we can do to make peoples lives easier.

But don't many trans people change their name to match their chosen gender? When Bruce Jenner became Caitlyn it was obvious she wanted to use female pronouns too. Isn't the name alone enough?

Jourdain11 · 01/07/2022 18:48

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:45

Because I recall reading something about it a while ago and forming an opinion that I would not be adding mine, but I can't remember the detail.

There is also the argument that you could force a trans person to out themselves before they feel ready; or to misgender themselves because they do not.

On a personal level, I just think it's virtue-signalling and I don't want to! Plus, my name is very female and my profile photo is also quite obviously of a woman. So I don't feel the pronouns really are needed!

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 18:43

HeadOnShoulders · 01/07/2022 00:49

No, you're the one gaslighting and pretending something is rude and nasty when it isn't.

I never said I don't approve of trans people, because I neither approve or disapprove of them. Frankly I couldn't give a shit if a man wants to wear lipstick or a woman wants to grow an beard and burp. I absolutely have no truck, doesn't affect me in any way, and of that floats their boat so be it.

What I won't do though, is buy into their delusion. If a man wears a dress he's still a man. If a man perceives himself as a woman he's still a man. If a man wears makeup, takes hrt and thpeakth with an affected lisp, he's still a man.

I wouldn't just walk over to him and tell him that, because obviously he doesn't like being a man, and I have no reason to rub his face in it. Same as I wouldnt tell a fat person they're fat. That's just gratuitously being hurtful.

But pronouns aren't about that. They're about me doing mental gymnastics and buying in to the other person's delusion. A preferred pronoun expects me to modify my own speech and police my own thought processes when even thinking about someone else. And I refuse to do that.

Pronouns are a natural part of speech, as is using male pronouns for men. So when I talk about a man I refuse to be dictated to about having to use specific words when mentioning them. Even if he thinks he's a she.

Matt Walsh said it best. Can you have preferred adjectives? That when you say my name you have to preface it with handsome?

If a man sees himself ad a woman, that's his perception. And in his mind he can do whatever he wants. But if I see him as a man, I'm not going to change that just to please him.

No, you're going to do what you want, just to please you.

So you're the entitled one.

Dress it up anyway you like. You think people's identity is based on your opinion and what you think. And that is arrogant, through and through.

Babdoc · 01/07/2022 17:00

FlippetyFlappety, you haven’t defined what you mean by gender identity, as opposed to simply knowledge of one’s sex. You say you don’t mean stereotypes - ok, so what do you mean instead? I may add, I don’t have any gender identity, I am simply an adult human female, because that’s what my body is. It doesn’t predict anything about my behaviour, predilections, clothes, etc, etc.

babyjellyfish · 01/07/2022 14:59

FlippityFlapperty · 01/07/2022 14:40

@babyjellyfish and @Babdoc I’m talking specifically about the she / he ‘gender identity’ associated with the pronouns, as per the original post. Our understanding of whether people should refer to us as him or her.

Almost 100% of people are accurately sexed at birth and therefore are clearly identified as a he or a she. This stat is taken from evolutionary biologist Colin Wright. Almost 100% of us are then referred to, accurately, using these sex-related pronouns for our whole lives. Now, all of a sudden, this accurate sexing of babies and associated use of pronouns is meaningless. You can be a male, but say you are a female / they on your email signature and everyone else must accept that. It is not me that is conflating biological sex with gender identity: it is the ideology.

I still don’t know if I’ve made myself clearer. Part of the problem with discussing gender ideology / gender identity is that it is utterly loaded with semantics. I’m not referring to ‘gender identity’ as ‘a person who accepts outdated stereotypes about their sex.’

I agree with most of what you have posted, but not that 99% - or even a significant number - of people have a gender identity which aligns with their sex. As far as I can tell, trans people are the only ones who really seem to believe in it. Even if you ask an "ally" about their gender identity, the reality is that anyone who is referred to as "cis" - not a label I use - believes they are a man because they have a penis or a woman because they have a vagina. That's not an identity and it has nothing to do with gender. It's just awareness and acceptance of human biology.

Like most people, I use third person pronouns according to someone's sex. "He" when the person is male. "She" when the person is female. "They" when I am talking about several people, or about a person whose sex I don't know.

FlippityFlapperty · 01/07/2022 14:40

@babyjellyfish and @Babdoc I’m talking specifically about the she / he ‘gender identity’ associated with the pronouns, as per the original post. Our understanding of whether people should refer to us as him or her.

Almost 100% of people are accurately sexed at birth and therefore are clearly identified as a he or a she. This stat is taken from evolutionary biologist Colin Wright. Almost 100% of us are then referred to, accurately, using these sex-related pronouns for our whole lives. Now, all of a sudden, this accurate sexing of babies and associated use of pronouns is meaningless. You can be a male, but say you are a female / they on your email signature and everyone else must accept that. It is not me that is conflating biological sex with gender identity: it is the ideology.

I still don’t know if I’ve made myself clearer. Part of the problem with discussing gender ideology / gender identity is that it is utterly loaded with semantics. I’m not referring to ‘gender identity’ as ‘a person who accepts outdated stereotypes about their sex.’

onlyhalfagreenegg · 01/07/2022 14:25

CataTonic58 · 30/06/2022 15:39

Just be careful with the typos. He/she/tit.

😂😂