Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
queenmeadhbh · 02/07/2022 13:22

Cantanka · 30/06/2022 15:39

To me, it isn’t a simple step to making trans people feel more included. It’s a political statement of allegiance to a movement which is hostile to women who do not subscribe to gender ideology.

First reply nails it. I won’t do it because putting ”my pronouns” after my name does not just signify “I am a woman” or “I identify as a woman” or whatever, it signifies “I believe in transgenderism”. It’s like a “Jesus take the wheel” bumper sticker.

tigger1001 · 02/07/2022 13:16

"That’s just their view. It is not fact. Same as Stonewall’s views are not fact. It is their belief. Which they are perfectly entitled to hold and use when describing themselves and people who follow their beliefs.

they are not entitled to impose it on others. I do not and never will consent to being referred to as “cis”. I find it grossly offensive and also inaccurate as I do not have a gender identity. That is my view which I am also entitled to hold and ask be respected."

I agree. I would find being referred to as "cis" offensive.

And I agree that I don't identify as female- I just am female.

I am very grateful that my work hasn't considered asking staff to include pronouns in email signatures- and I would be refusing to do so.

Womens rights are under threat as it is. I am not engaging with anything that will make that worse.

babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 13:00

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:39

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use - it's not designed to be offensive. I completed my LGBTQI Youth Scotland training the other week and it was given as the word.

It simply means identifying as the same sex you were born into.

I don't identify with being female, I just am. It's not an identity.

LovinglifeAF · 02/07/2022 12:59

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:39

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use - it's not designed to be offensive. I completed my LGBTQI Youth Scotland training the other week and it was given as the word.

It simply means identifying as the same sex you were born into.

That’s just their view. It is not fact. Same as Stonewall’s views are not fact. It is their belief. Which they are perfectly entitled to hold and use when describing themselves and people who follow their beliefs.

they are not entitled to impose it on others. I do not and never will consent to being referred to as “cis”. I find it grossly offensive and also inaccurate as I do not have a gender identity. That is my view which I am also entitled to hold and ask be respected.

Turnthatoff · 02/07/2022 12:56

Sorry, my first sentence should read ‘what is the difference between me identifying as a female, and actually being one.’

Turnthatoff · 02/07/2022 12:55

What is the difference between identifying as a female, and actually being one?

I think I’d reject being referred to as ‘cis’, just as much as being asked to put my pronouns in my email sig. it’s the same thing…. Essentially being asked to state publicly that i buy into gender ideology. And I don’t.

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 12:52

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:39

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use - it's not designed to be offensive. I completed my LGBTQI Youth Scotland training the other week and it was given as the word.

It simply means identifying as the same sex you were born into.

Identify - establish or indicate who or what (someone or something) is.

What you are saying is that people that identify as trans are identifying as the opposite. As they are 'self' identifying as something they are not. I don't identify as a female, I just am. Anyone who says they 'identify' as something usually means they are not that thing, otherwise they'd just 'be'.

You went on training to indoctrinate you into an ideology. And you've swallowed it hook line and sinker.

Congratulations, you are now one of the Borg.

Clymene · 02/07/2022 12:44

I find it offensive @beautyisthefaceisee. Respect goes both ways.

Its an attempt to give me a gender identity which I reject. It's also an attempt to put women into a subcategory. I've already seen some TRAs referring to women and cis women. Women being transwomen ie male people.

We have a word. Women is just fine. We don't need a prefix.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:41

maddening · 02/07/2022 12:35

Probably use their name, and I would probably go as far as use their pronouns, but should not be condemned for a slip up or not remembering. But I would not say a man is a woman, happy to use trans woman.

I do get that it seems to be such a little allowance, but this now goes beyond that, it is an ideology that is doing great harm to vulnerable people and requires mental gymnastics and is also detriments others eg disabilities that make it hard to do those mental gymnastics, impacts people with language barriers.and people are having their lives impacted for stating a fact of reality. So then you come to drawing a battle line. But this is the fault of the TRA movement imo. It has gone too far, a lot of what is happening is an utter disgrace, tradegy, scandal and there are real victims being created every day, so to fight that you have to draw a line and for many that includes pronouns, so to demand pronouns becomes compelled speech.

You can't call someone a trans woman. I mean you can in discussions like this, but for example in a work place, I'm not sure that would fly. Re the slip up - Not many in IRl get upset by accidental misgendering. That's been made up by feminists on here.

I don't agree with your views, but that is a very thoughtful post and I would certainly be interesting in reading them. And there's the key, and as much as MNers play the card of "I don't have to be kind", ultimately IRL, you listen to people if you find them respectful, intelligent and are interested in what they have to say - ie yourself.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:39

maddening · 02/07/2022 12:37

Oh and I reject cis - that is a slur imo and imposing an ideology that I do not subscribe to.

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use - it's not designed to be offensive. I completed my LGBTQI Youth Scotland training the other week and it was given as the word.

It simply means identifying as the same sex you were born into.

maddening · 02/07/2022 12:37

Oh and I reject cis - that is a slur imo and imposing an ideology that I do not subscribe to.

maddening · 02/07/2022 12:35

Probably use their name, and I would probably go as far as use their pronouns, but should not be condemned for a slip up or not remembering. But I would not say a man is a woman, happy to use trans woman.

I do get that it seems to be such a little allowance, but this now goes beyond that, it is an ideology that is doing great harm to vulnerable people and requires mental gymnastics and is also detriments others eg disabilities that make it hard to do those mental gymnastics, impacts people with language barriers.and people are having their lives impacted for stating a fact of reality. So then you come to drawing a battle line. But this is the fault of the TRA movement imo. It has gone too far, a lot of what is happening is an utter disgrace, tradegy, scandal and there are real victims being created every day, so to fight that you have to draw a line and for many that includes pronouns, so to demand pronouns becomes compelled speech.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 11:45

maddening · 02/07/2022 11:41

@beautyisthefaceisee

"maddening , that is not the case. There are a number of people on this thread alone who refuse to respect and use other peoples pronouns "

Firstly my post is in relation to requiring others to use pronouns in their email signatures which was the point of the OP, I don't see anyone saying you can't do what you want in YOUR email signature, it is being compelled to use it in their own signatures that is the issue.

As for using pronouns, again compelled speech is the issue. But in a conversation with you I would use "you" or "your" which is not gendered or sexed in any case, or your name. I would be polite.

But I don't believe in gender ideology, so just like any religion I would not support blasphemy laws or compelled speech for any religion. No issue with people living as they want, apart from where it encroaches in existing rights such as same sex spaces, sports and then medicalisation and radicalisation of children and young or mentally vulnerable people, but if you want to present any way you want that is obviously no issue. I would fight for your right for a third space or sport.

Yes, PP have said they refuse to accept other people's identity.

I'm with you on the rest.

However, what would you use when speaking about them?

maddening · 02/07/2022 11:41

@beautyisthefaceisee

"maddening , that is not the case. There are a number of people on this thread alone who refuse to respect and use other peoples pronouns "

Firstly my post is in relation to requiring others to use pronouns in their email signatures which was the point of the OP, I don't see anyone saying you can't do what you want in YOUR email signature, it is being compelled to use it in their own signatures that is the issue.

As for using pronouns, again compelled speech is the issue. But in a conversation with you I would use "you" or "your" which is not gendered or sexed in any case, or your name. I would be polite.

But I don't believe in gender ideology, so just like any religion I would not support blasphemy laws or compelled speech for any religion. No issue with people living as they want, apart from where it encroaches in existing rights such as same sex spaces, sports and then medicalisation and radicalisation of children and young or mentally vulnerable people, but if you want to present any way you want that is obviously no issue. I would fight for your right for a third space or sport.

LovinglifeAF · 02/07/2022 10:41

I’ve got no issue with trans people and their rights at all but that doesn’t extend to me having to partake in their beliefs about themselves, do something I’m uncomfortable with and that conflicts with my own beliefs, or being expected to forego my own sex based rights to privacy, dignity and safety

SolasAnla · 02/07/2022 10:33

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 21:58

Well firstly, it isnt. I've said repeatedly I don't agree with mixed spaces, mixed prisons and I haven't said this yet, but mixed races.

So that's not the case.

It's also not the case about the surgery - I'm surprised you didn't know that over 90 percent dont physically transition, because that is usually the trump card of "see , they just want to steal our rights).

The problem is that people who support trans people and their rights cannot win. We just can't. Everything we say is twisted, reworded, and countered. Your post is actually a thoughtful one, and I find myself agreeing with certain parts, but the sides are so divided now there will never be a compromise.

But it isn't the TRA's asking you to use pronouns in an email, is it? I don't use batshit feminists in arguments so why do you always jump to TRA's?

Why is a human being in an office who wants to be referred to as she rather than he copping for all of this?

Why is male asking me to deny what I see and hear?

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 09:54

brookstar · 02/07/2022 09:27

But no one wants to stop a person in an office including pronouns in the email, it is not wanting to be compelled to use it.

Do whatever you like with you email, but do not vilify or threaten or impede the career of someone that does not want to. In doing so you become the monster.

Absolutely.
Lots of my colleagues have their pronouns in their email .... fair play to them. I have no issue with it.
I don't want to though, and that should be fine too.

I'm with you.

@maddening , that is not the case. There are a number of people on this thread alone who refuse to respect and use other peoples pronouns.

Weirdwonders · 02/07/2022 09:45

Because I swear we’d just agreed that having to add our marital status to documents was irrelevant and reductive and now we’re being asked to do this instead.

brookstar · 02/07/2022 09:27

But no one wants to stop a person in an office including pronouns in the email, it is not wanting to be compelled to use it.

Do whatever you like with you email, but do not vilify or threaten or impede the career of someone that does not want to. In doing so you become the monster.

Absolutely.
Lots of my colleagues have their pronouns in their email .... fair play to them. I have no issue with it.
I don't want to though, and that should be fine too.

maddening · 02/07/2022 08:11

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 21:58

Well firstly, it isnt. I've said repeatedly I don't agree with mixed spaces, mixed prisons and I haven't said this yet, but mixed races.

So that's not the case.

It's also not the case about the surgery - I'm surprised you didn't know that over 90 percent dont physically transition, because that is usually the trump card of "see , they just want to steal our rights).

The problem is that people who support trans people and their rights cannot win. We just can't. Everything we say is twisted, reworded, and countered. Your post is actually a thoughtful one, and I find myself agreeing with certain parts, but the sides are so divided now there will never be a compromise.

But it isn't the TRA's asking you to use pronouns in an email, is it? I don't use batshit feminists in arguments so why do you always jump to TRA's?

Why is a human being in an office who wants to be referred to as she rather than he copping for all of this?

But no one wants to stop a person in an office including pronouns in the email, it is not wanting to be compelled to use it.

Do whatever you like with you email, but do not vilify or threaten or impede the career of someone that does not want to. In doing so you become the monster.

JustDanceAddict · 02/07/2022 08:06

It’s not for me.
my name is obviously female so therefore I am a woman. That’s it.
if others want to state pronouns that’s up to them but it reminds me of how my mum used to sign off - with a (Mrs) after her full name. Makes me feel it’s ‘old fashioned’ in that way, just use the person’s given name in response.,

TomPinch · 02/07/2022 07:56

Because my email sig isn't a place for making political statements.

If supporting the LGBTQIA+ community isn't a matter of politics but is more fundamental then why an I being asked to show support for this particular minority and not other minorities with protected characteristics?

Oceanus · 01/07/2022 22:58

CataTonic58 · 30/06/2022 15:39

Just be careful with the typos. He/she/tit.

Hahahah! That was funny! Though I'm not sure I'm allowed to say that outloud anymore!

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 22:40

I do think it's something we have to start accepting though.

I don't agree with forcing everyone to do it, but if someone chooses it, I think you need to respect that - if only on a professional front. Is that really that controversial?

beautyisthefaceisee · 01/07/2022 22:39

FlirtsWithRhinos · 01/07/2022 22:35

It's also not the case about the surgery - I'm surprised you didn't know that over 90 percent dont physically transition, because that is usually the trump card of "see , they just want to steal our rights).

I do know the % of trans people who have surgery is low. I still think it's something to be avoided where possible especially when young. I really don't like the current media trend to celebrate TM mastectomy scars as an edgy and progressive shorthand for LBGT inclusion because it glamourises what is actually significant and radical surgery. (Like most older women I have friends and relations who have had masectomies).

The problem is that people who support trans people and their rights cannot win. We just can't. Everything we say is twisted, reworded, and countered. Your post is actually a thoughtful one, and I find myself agreeing with certain parts, but the sides are so divided now there will never be a compromise.

There can, but the compromise has to involve recognising that there are limits to how far transition can bring one into the realm of the opposite sex and to go beyond those limits, especially for MTF, even if done by a nice and respectful person, is to pass from inclusion and tolerance into appropriation and dominance.

I genuinely think the right answer is separate words for the separate things. Both are real, or at least feelings real enough to be worth naming, and they are clearly not the same thing so why not name both separately and start exploring gender identity in its own right rather than a sort-of-but-isnt cousin to sex?

But it isn't the TRA's asking you to use pronouns in an email, is it? I don't use batshit feminists in arguments so why do you always jump to TRA's?

Actually I do it out of respect for trans people, because I don't want to accuse them en masse of the TRA batshit. However, unfortunately as long as the dominant voices telling society what trans people must have are those of TRAs, that's the arguments we who push back need to engage with.

Why is a human being in an office who wants to be referred to as she rather than he copping for all of this?

Sadly, because she wants to use a word that has significant meaning to other people. I'm sure she means no harm but she is causing harm because she is not an island and whether she admits it to herself or not she is taking part in a social change that hurts women.

In real life yes, I'll probably smile and be polite but I can tell you that smile will be exactly the same one I need when I have to listen to a sexist comment or joke, or get talked over by a man saying what I just said.

You know the smile I am sure. It's the one that says "I do not do this by choice but because society has taken away my right to say no. I know this not fair and but if I say anything about it or even look unhappy about it it will be turned into my problem and it will be painted as my unreasonable reaction to a tiny little thing, because women's right to be angry about men's treatment of them is less than men's right to not be made uncomfortable by women".

I actual took in your post and found it quite thought provoking. thank you.