Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 18:46

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:44

You know fine rightly what I mean. The wide eyed faux "but you cant change sex" is beyond boring.

No, I don't know what you mean.

I have literally no idea what the fuck they are identifying with.

And I don't believe you do either.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:44

babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 18:43

What does that mean?

How can you identify with having body parts you do not have?

You know fine rightly what I mean. The wide eyed faux "but you cant change sex" is beyond boring.

babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 18:43

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 16:35

I'm going to take this as a genuine question.

Identifying as female while being born in the male sex.

What does that mean?

How can you identify with having body parts you do not have?

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:27

taking you at your word though, @Clymene , the only point of 'conflict', more differeing opinions, between maddening and I was the use of the word cisgender.

I never said people had to like it or use it or that I supercede their opinion, as some rambling PP said. What I said was, it's in the current training. Because it is. So therefore someone using it in a workplace is not necessarily being offensive, are they? Surely how it's the word is used?

I find it far more offensive to be called a TRA and compared to nutters on twitter, but that word is trotted out like candy on MN to anyone who dares to slightly disagree with anones beliefs (despite the fact if anyone bothers to read back, I actually am on board with other posters opinions re trans a lot of the time).

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:19

Clymene · 02/07/2022 16:39

I didn't say you were a TRA @beautyisthefaceisee but you certainly don't seem to have very good listening skills

Strange that, as if you bother to read the thread you will see me having a pretty respectful discussion.

"not listening" doesn't mean the same as having a different opinion, its just that some posters are more arrogant than others.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:18

@AlisonDonut Reported for calling me a TRA.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:18

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 16:41

You are deliberately stirring up trouble on what was a respectful discussion and I am not remotely interested in your goading

You telling people that your training supercedes their opinion, is not respectful.

TRAs are not indicative of the rest of us though.

If you are telling women that they are not allowed to consider cis a slur, because it puts them into a subclass of their own sex...then you ARE a TRA.

Could you quote me where I said that?

YouSetTheTone · 02/07/2022 18:16

Tigofigo but if I speak to someone who is religious I’m not compelled to believe in their religion.

If someone ‘identifies as non-binary’ (I.e how most people realistically feel) they can crack on. But I’m not going to refer to them any differently - no one gets to dictate to me that I should do anything other than correctly sex individuals. Don’t talk to me about ‘being kind’ because there’s NOTHING kind about this ideology as far as women are concerned. So I say no.

Tigofigo · 02/07/2022 16:50

What other personal characteristics will be asked to be declared in an email signature to show allyship - ethnicity, religion, disability?

Well this is a bit of a disingenuous comparison because you don't refer to people differently based on their ethnicity, religion, or disability.

I feel like it's most helpful to people who identify as non binary and want to use they / them pronouns, I can see that by everyone listing their pronouns it may make them feel more able to list theirs, equally I see the issue with people not wanting to reveal their pronouns (yet) feeling pushed into a corner.

It's an imperfect, over simplistic solution.

Spanielservant · 02/07/2022 16:50

I hope they bring this into my industry. Will use he him, luckily at the moment am inan Arabic country who don't care as long as you are good

ObjectionHearsay · 02/07/2022 16:45

I just find it pointless. I have a clear feminine name. I'm happy for people to assume I am female from my name.

When people meet me I am happy for them to assume I use she/her.

Even if someone did by some bizzare reason call me him I wouldn't be offended.

I'm clearly a woman, I'm a attractive 30 something year old feminine woman.

Writing shit at the bottom of my e-mail signature is not needed. I simply don't do it. Others in my company have, I don't do it in mine, I've never been questioned or asked to include it either.

I've also never been questioned on my sexuality/religion/race which is also forms part of my "identity" so the day someone demand I put a pronoun on my signature to identify me I'm also going to demand I'm able to write "Bisexual White Christian She/Her". Because if "identity" is that important I'm in for a penny in for a pound. 😂

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 16:41

You are deliberately stirring up trouble on what was a respectful discussion and I am not remotely interested in your goading

You telling people that your training supercedes their opinion, is not respectful.

TRAs are not indicative of the rest of us though.

If you are telling women that they are not allowed to consider cis a slur, because it puts them into a subclass of their own sex...then you ARE a TRA.

Clymene · 02/07/2022 16:39

I didn't say you were a TRA @beautyisthefaceisee but you certainly don't seem to have very good listening skills

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 16:36

Clymene · 02/07/2022 12:44

I find it offensive @beautyisthefaceisee. Respect goes both ways.

Its an attempt to give me a gender identity which I reject. It's also an attempt to put women into a subcategory. I've already seen some TRAs referring to women and cis women. Women being transwomen ie male people.

We have a word. Women is just fine. We don't need a prefix.

TRAs are not indicative of the rest of us though.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 16:35

Turnthatoff · 02/07/2022 12:55

What is the difference between identifying as a female, and actually being one?

I think I’d reject being referred to as ‘cis’, just as much as being asked to put my pronouns in my email sig. it’s the same thing…. Essentially being asked to state publicly that i buy into gender ideology. And I don’t.

I'm going to take this as a genuine question.

Identifying as female while being born in the male sex.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 16:34

IcedPurple · 02/07/2022 16:09

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use

I don't accept it.

You dont have to.

My point was the reason it's used (in schools, which is where mu knowledge of it comes from) is that it isnt intended as a slur.

I do however accept your right to nor use it or be offended by it, same as maddening.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 16:33

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 15:51

It's an internet forum. Anyone can post.

I can't see how someone saying that they think cis is a slur and you telling them that it is 'the word' is respectful in any way. Or does your disrespect now identify as respect?

It's not my problem if you aren't able to rationalise what you have been taught on your training, and just take it as read that the people indoctrinating you are right.

Who ran this training that you seem to have taken as 'the way' from here on in?

You are deliberately stirring up trouble on what was a respectful discussion and I am not remotely interested in your goading.

IcedPurple · 02/07/2022 16:09

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use

I don't accept it.

tillytown · 02/07/2022 16:06

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 12:39

Cisgender, despite how its twisted, is an accepted word of use - it's not designed to be offensive. I completed my LGBTQI Youth Scotland training the other week and it was given as the word.

It simply means identifying as the same sex you were born into.

  1. No woman identifies into lower pay, sexual harassment, femicide, or domestic violence. Call yourself whatever you want, but stop pretending you aren't being offensive when you clearly are.
  1. By using cis you are acknowledging there is a difference between women and trans women, which makes trans women are women invalid and you transphobic. Scotland needs to update their training.
IcedPurple · 02/07/2022 16:00

I dont identify as a woman. I just am one.

To me, this is the core of it.

I'm a woman. That's just a fact. Always have been and always will, whether I like it or not, or however I 'identify'.

Sex isn't an "identity". It's a biological fact.

YouSetTheTone · 02/07/2022 15:53

I would not put my pronouns in an email signature or on a badge because doing so indicates I agree with an ideology that sees men allowed into women’s single sex spaces, men into women’s prisons, male athletes taking away female athletes’ prizes, men taking women’s spots on bursaries, awards and other schemes designed to level the playing field.

It indicates that I agree with an ideology that is homophobic as it denies same sex attraction.

It indicates I agree with an ideology that encourages children down a pathway to debilitating health outcomes - telling them they need to change their bodies to fit in with stereotypes.

It indicates I agree with an ideology that’s a misappropriation of privilege- taking ‘queer theory’ from American academia and imposing on it the lives of people who be negatively impacted by it- usually the most marginalised people in societies. De-sexing language is an example of this misappropriation of privilege - when you remove the word ‘woman’ from medical literature designed to inform women about critical health checks this impacts on women with lower literacy levels, women with special educational needs, women whose first language isn’t English. Etc.

In short I reject everything about this fundamentally misogynist, homophobic, ‘luxury beliefs’ ideology and that includes ‘announcing’ pronouns.

Squiff70 · 02/07/2022 15:52

I've just received an official email. It was signed "Claire (Surname), she/her".

Why do they feel the need to - or be made to - put their pronouns after their name which is already identifiable as female? How many men are called Claire? If the person who sent this email was transitioning, they possibly wouldn't name themselves "Claire". If the person was identifying as female and wanted to be known as 'Claire', then just their name would suffice.

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 15:51

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 15:34

I'm not sure why you've waded into a respectful and interesting conversation from two people on opposite sides with this rude, ignorant and patronising post.

It's an internet forum. Anyone can post.

I can't see how someone saying that they think cis is a slur and you telling them that it is 'the word' is respectful in any way. Or does your disrespect now identify as respect?

It's not my problem if you aren't able to rationalise what you have been taught on your training, and just take it as read that the people indoctrinating you are right.

Who ran this training that you seem to have taken as 'the way' from here on in?

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 15:34

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 12:52

Identify - establish or indicate who or what (someone or something) is.

What you are saying is that people that identify as trans are identifying as the opposite. As they are 'self' identifying as something they are not. I don't identify as a female, I just am. Anyone who says they 'identify' as something usually means they are not that thing, otherwise they'd just 'be'.

You went on training to indoctrinate you into an ideology. And you've swallowed it hook line and sinker.

Congratulations, you are now one of the Borg.

I'm not sure why you've waded into a respectful and interesting conversation from two people on opposite sides with this rude, ignorant and patronising post.

WeAllHaveWings · 02/07/2022 13:30

Thankfully, while our workplace suggests it in yammer posts they don't put any pressure on to do it. The only people I have seen actually do it are in our local HR and one member of the board when they do online global comms (large multinational)..