Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:47

I have a FTM friend who literally all his life all he wanted to do was change to M

They can't change sex. That's biologically impossible.

They can however live as they want to and should be supported in doing so, while respecting sex based rights.

Its the attempt to conflate these positions that's the problem.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:43

I was talking to my auntie about this tonight.

I have a FTM friend who literally all his life all he wanted to do was change to M. Now you can analyse that to within an inch of his life but ultimately since changing 10 years ago he is happy, healthy and nothing like the person he was before.

He is also angry at the wankers on twitter because they make people like him fade into the background while we all mock and sneer at it.

Another friend of mine is gay, came out at 28 because of prejudice in our home town.

I can't imagine or tell you what its like to be gay, because I'm not, nor would I pretend to. But I respect his right to love who he chooses.

In the same way I respect my friends right to live as he chooses.

We dont question anyone else within an inch of their life about they feel the way they do, be it politics, religion, or any other thing that involves identity and being - so why trans?

And if it's because you fear your spaces and safety - I stand with you on that. I don't agree with mixed spaces, prisons, sports, etc etc.

I just really strongly disagree with this constant questioning, mocking and faux wanting to understand when really whatever anyone says you will pick it apart.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:39

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:28

So only trans people can define male and female? Well this gets more bonkers by the minute

they can for themselves, surely?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/07/2022 21:37

Speaking personally, the reason I cannot in good conscience use other people's self-selected pronouns or accept the label "cis" for myself is because they are framed by the narrative that trans women are women and that that womanhood supersedes any consideration of body sex.

If the narrative was instead "trans women are gender dysphoric men who are more comfortable being seen and living as women", and alongside that was open, honest and over time evolving assessment about when it was fine to include trans women with women and when it was not appropriate, I'd be far more accommodating.

In that world a cis woman would be a woman without gender dysphoria, a trans man would be a woman with gender dysphoria, a trans women would be a man with gender dysphoria. Preferred pronouns would be exactly what they should be, not a statement that a male person IS a woman (which unavoidably redefines womenhood for all women) but simply a hint on how someone prefers to be addressed.

No drama, no negation, just acceptance and support.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:30

So only trans people can define male and female?

Not the first time I've heard this, has to be said.

We're back to 'being male/female is totally undefinable, except when transpeople tell us what they are.'

A right Orwellian nightmare we have on our hands here.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:28

No, people definitely do.

But based on what? What's their understanding of what's male/female coming from?

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:28

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:24

I can't, because I'm not bloody trans. Have you thought about asking/reading about people who are?

No, people definitely do.

See ridiculous responses upthread because i dared to point out that the most recent secondary schools training uses cisgender as a term, not a slur, as if I made the bloody training myself!

So only trans people can define male and female? Well this gets more bonkers by the minute

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:25

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:23

😂

no, it really doesn’t. My point is you can make a physical observation- women have vaginas, brunettes have dark hair- without it being reductionist. Which goes against what you’re saying.

It does.
But I'm not derailing, as you're missing the point.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:24

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:21

Me? (and to the other PPs who asked this) I judge my identity on my heart - my kindness, the way I make people feel, the way I dress, the colours I wear, the way I speak.

So give us examples of what of that criteria is male and what's female?

I just respect it and let them live their lives.

I don't think anyone has a problem
with letting people live their lives. It's recasting language norms and definitions because of a nebulous understand of gender that's the issue.

I can't, because I'm not bloody trans. Have you thought about asking/reading about people who are?

No, people definitely do.

See ridiculous responses upthread because i dared to point out that the most recent secondary schools training uses cisgender as a term, not a slur, as if I made the bloody training myself!

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:23

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:20

No - hence why I don't understand someone thinks that being trans is about wanting a certain sexual organ. Your metaphor backs up my argument, not PP's.

😂

no, it really doesn’t. My point is you can make a physical observation- women have vaginas, brunettes have dark hair- without it being reductionist. Which goes against what you’re saying.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:21

Me? (and to the other PPs who asked this) I judge my identity on my heart - my kindness, the way I make people feel, the way I dress, the colours I wear, the way I speak.

So give us examples of what of that criteria is male and what's female?

I just respect it and let them live their lives.

I don't think anyone has a problem
with letting people live their lives. It's recasting language norms and definitions because of a nebulous understand of gender that's the issue.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:21

@AlisonDonut your username is appropriate.

b being utterly ridiculous and transphobic and calling us "borgs", all you are actually doing is shutting down discussion. Do you regularly shut down the views of other women?

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:20

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:19

if I said a brunette is someone with dark hair, would you assume ‘all’ I think they are is dark hair?

No - hence why I don't understand someone thinks that being trans is about wanting a certain sexual organ. Your metaphor backs up my argument, not PP's.

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 21:19

if I said a brunette is someone with dark hair, would you assume ‘all’ I think they are is dark hair?

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:17

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 19:16

So what is your identity based on @beautyisthefaceisee ?
you say vagina like it’s a bad thing?

No, I pointed out that the PP's position that people being women means they want to have a vagina means that you think that's all women are.

Me? (and to the other PPs who asked this) I judge my identity on my heart - my kindness, the way I make people feel, the way I dress, the colours I wear, the way I speak.

But then I'm not trans, and I don't spend my days picking apart what other people think. I just respect it and let them live their lives. Mad eh.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:16

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 20:58

That's generally what TRAs do. Report people for not obeying the Borg.

You done good on that training, did Miss give you a pat on the head? Do you report back on how many women you reported on MN as a follow up?

And you were not being respectful to maddening when you told her that cis was 'the word'. After she said that she considered it a slur. Which it is.

PS, its "done well or did well" , not "done good".

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 21:15

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 20:58

That's generally what TRAs do. Report people for not obeying the Borg.

You done good on that training, did Miss give you a pat on the head? Do you report back on how many women you reported on MN as a follow up?

And you were not being respectful to maddening when you told her that cis was 'the word'. After she said that she considered it a slur. Which it is.

I didnt say that though, hun. I said its in official training. I didn't say it was OK to use , I explained why it is used.

Re the rest of your post, I cant be arsed. Well done on derailing what was a pretty good thread. Your input has been phenomenal.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 21:04

So what is your identity based on @beautyisthefaceisee ?

I'd like to know this too

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 20:58

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:18

@AlisonDonut Reported for calling me a TRA.

That's generally what TRAs do. Report people for not obeying the Borg.

You done good on that training, did Miss give you a pat on the head? Do you report back on how many women you reported on MN as a follow up?

And you were not being respectful to maddening when you told her that cis was 'the word'. After she said that she considered it a slur. Which it is.

Tigofigo · 02/07/2022 20:55

YouSetTheTone · 02/07/2022 18:16

Tigofigo but if I speak to someone who is religious I’m not compelled to believe in their religion.

If someone ‘identifies as non-binary’ (I.e how most people realistically feel) they can crack on. But I’m not going to refer to them any differently - no one gets to dictate to me that I should do anything other than correctly sex individuals. Don’t talk to me about ‘being kind’ because there’s NOTHING kind about this ideology as far as women are concerned. So I say no.

Well you do you...

I think many if not most people would be fine with using their chosen pronouns though as they don't see it a such a big deal to do so - hence still worth including them?

YouSetTheTone · 02/07/2022 20:32

If you’re not actually a woman surely ‘feeling like a woman’ is based on interpretations of stereotypes or assumptions about what some women might feel?

We don’t ‘feel’ the same like some kind of amorphous blob.

The things women share are based on growing up the same sex.

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 19:16

So what is your identity based on @beautyisthefaceisee ?
you say vagina like it’s a bad thing?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/07/2022 19:01

You know fine rightly what I mean. The wide eyed faux "but you cant change sex" is beyond boring.

But the thing is, we (or at least I) genuinely don't know what it means. As far as I can tell, it means different things to different people and, deliberately or otherwise, those arguing for trans people will pick the meaning that best supports their current demand even if it contradicts or undermines a meaning on which a different demand is being justified.

Is a trans woman someone who believes they would have been happier if they were born female and possibly takes steps to modify their body closer to female, or someone who has a mental quality that means they ARE female? And if the latter, what is that quality and why is it more socially, physically and legally significant than body sex?

TWAW, at least as used by TRAs and the dominant trans pressure groups, is not a polite fiction with practical limitations but a statement of underlying reality that means no distinction between those who are women by sex and those who are women by mind can ever be valid.

It seems a logic somewhat unique to gender ideology that really wanting something you don't have (the body of the opposite sex) is considered to be interchangeable with actually having it.

babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 18:57

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:51

No, you're not interested, you think it's a load of nonsense, and your question isn't in good faith. WHich is fine. Just don't pretend otherwise.

Don't lump me inw ith you - I certainly don't think my identity is based on me having a vagina, as you clearly do!

Well you're half right. I do think it's a load of nonsense.

But I am genuinely interested to know what they believe they are identifying with.

I get to "lump you in with me" because the category of people that we noth belong to is a thing that actually exists. Female people. And yes, it is about having a vagina and other female body parts. It's not an identity. I couldn't care less about any identity you may believe you have, and I'm not claiming that we share one.

But I don't believe that people like Lia Thomas get to lump me or you or any female people in with them. They are claiming that woman is an identity that they have, which entitles them to access women's single sex spaces and compete in women's sporting categories. It's offensive and dangerous and harmful to women.

So damn right, I want to know exactly what Lia Thomas believes Lia is identifying with, and why Lia thinks it has anything to do with being a woman, or swimming, or the female swimmers who are being disadvantaged by Lia's identity.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 18:51

babyjellyfish · 02/07/2022 18:46

No, I don't know what you mean.

I have literally no idea what the fuck they are identifying with.

And I don't believe you do either.

No, you're not interested, you think it's a load of nonsense, and your question isn't in good faith. WHich is fine. Just don't pretend otherwise.

Don't lump me inw ith you - I certainly don't think my identity is based on me having a vagina, as you clearly do!