Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 08:18

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:04

I am genuinely shocked at the replies on this thread. I assumed the world to be much more tolerant and kind. I know people who live their lives as a gender they were not assigned at birth, and the impact of them doing so on me is nil. I know teenagers going through an identity crisis and it feels like a high number young people hitting puberty feel uncomfortable with the associations of the societal construct of the gender they are assigned to. That is a big issue which is really affecting the next generation and one that needs a lot of empathy and support not anger.

I feel no attachment to my pro nouns - they are words that help us navigate the
english language. This is a tricky topic - i do not want to declare my pro nouns and it’s interesting to explore why. But the anger and prejudice and intolerance is not what our society should be about.

Why should we be tolerant to a group that disdain and hate us? The pronoun on email push is just another way to try to flush out gender critical women to target and harass them.

The #bekind thing is only a veneer with trans orgs. The level of coercion and control is frightening once you start disagreeing with anything they have to say. The violence, doxxing and harassment is on the same scale as right wing hate groups. Yet people are cheering it on and telling women to shut up and be kind. It is actually unbelievable.

TheKeatingFive · 03/07/2022 08:11

That is a big issue which is really affecting the next generation and one that needs a lot of empathy and support not anger.

Im pretty angry this generation have been led to believe that their discomfort with their gender is anything to do with their body being 'wrong' rather than a problem with societal stereotypes about gender.

I think anger is a perfectly justified response to this situation. They deserve so much better than this.

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:04

I am genuinely shocked at the replies on this thread. I assumed the world to be much more tolerant and kind. I know people who live their lives as a gender they were not assigned at birth, and the impact of them doing so on me is nil. I know teenagers going through an identity crisis and it feels like a high number young people hitting puberty feel uncomfortable with the associations of the societal construct of the gender they are assigned to. That is a big issue which is really affecting the next generation and one that needs a lot of empathy and support not anger.

I feel no attachment to my pro nouns - they are words that help us navigate the
english language. This is a tricky topic - i do not want to declare my pro nouns and it’s interesting to explore why. But the anger and prejudice and intolerance is not what our society should be about.

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 07:54

RosesAndHellebores · 03/07/2022 00:12

I am almost 62.
I have enjoyed every minute of being a woman and have never felt discriminated against. I have worked for all but 7 of the last 42 years. I have worked in male dominated and female dominated organisations. Whilst I have come across the occasional sexist, misogynistic git, they have never bothered me unduly, they have felt a hard stare and have never stood in my way.

I don't give two hoots what anyone else thinks. I don't mind gender neutral bogs, providing a hospital ward were clean, the staff polite and others generally well behaved I don't care whether the patients are women or not (obviously not gynae wards) and have never felt the need to have 100% female spaces just as I don't think men should have 100% male spaces. It's sexist.

That is great for you. But do you want to take away that choice for other women.

Like the woman recently that was told that there were no female only rape crisis meetings in her area and that she had no right to complain about someone very obviously male turning up to her meetings.

Now that is sexist.

This is not about the Freemasons or the bar at the golf club. It’s about female inmates being raped in prison and becoming pregnant by transwomen (has already happened in the US). It’s about rape victims being told to get over their prejudice if they refuse a transwomen as a rape counsellor (from the lips of the head of Edinburgh rape crisis). It’s about teenage girls losing scholarships to middle aged transwomen (Laurel Hubbard, Veronica Ivy, Hannah Mouncey).

It’s about men having a huge tantrum because women have boundaries and are trying to enforce them. You only have to look at the way groups of transwomen talk about women online to see that. They don’t seem that keen to be kind to us. In fact, they seem to hate us.

Passtheduchyonthelefthandside · 03/07/2022 03:20

I really don't get this... I couldn't give a toss what people call me when I'm not there, as long as I'm called by my name when being spoken to in person.

RosesAndHellebores · 03/07/2022 02:57

Well yes indeed @Marynotsocontrary. I'm not acquainted with either so didn't think of them. You are quite right of course.

Marynotsocontrary · 03/07/2022 02:53

"and have never felt the need to have 100% female spaces just as I don't think men should have 100% male spaces. It's sexist."

What about prisons or DV refuges @RosesAndHellebores?

RosesAndHellebores · 03/07/2022 00:12

I am almost 62.
I have enjoyed every minute of being a woman and have never felt discriminated against. I have worked for all but 7 of the last 42 years. I have worked in male dominated and female dominated organisations. Whilst I have come across the occasional sexist, misogynistic git, they have never bothered me unduly, they have felt a hard stare and have never stood in my way.

I don't give two hoots what anyone else thinks. I don't mind gender neutral bogs, providing a hospital ward were clean, the staff polite and others generally well behaved I don't care whether the patients are women or not (obviously not gynae wards) and have never felt the need to have 100% female spaces just as I don't think men should have 100% male spaces. It's sexist.

YouSetTheTone · 02/07/2022 22:59

Tigofigo · 02/07/2022 20:55

Well you do you...

I think many if not most people would be fine with using their chosen pronouns though as they don't see it a such a big deal to do so - hence still worth including them?

Sadly I agree with you - lots of people are fine with being homophobic misogynists and going along with ideology promoted by an aggressive lobby group, and signalling that by displaying pronouns.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 02/07/2022 22:57

when it comes to things like spaces, sports, prisons etc I'm sure we (and my trans friend) would bloody agree

Telling us you and your friend would bloody agree with us on things like spaces, sports, prisons etc is sadly not going to make any difference, because we are not the people who are trying to take them away. You need to tell them.

Are you and your friend out there on the TRA online spaces telling them?

Because until people like you, who agree with pronouns and #BeKind but not the wholesale replacement of sex by gender, actually step up to say so, TRAs are going to portray the public's support for pronouns and politely pretending sex can be changed as public support for their whole kit and kaboodle.

LastTrainEast · 02/07/2022 22:56

Also we don't ask everyone to wear a fat suit to make overweight people (like me) stand out less or make everyone typo a lot to protect dyslexic people.

Legrandsophie · 02/07/2022 22:53

It is ridiculous for all the reasons stated above.

And it should be optional- just like Mrs/Miss/Ms is these days. I don’t sign off my emails with my marital status- why would I? But those who want to can go right ahead. I also do using off telling people my religion, disability status or anything else. Because it is irrelevant to my job.

Nothing like this should be mandated. Some people just get the greatest thrill in telling everyone else how to love their lives (hint: it’s not the feminists reacting to this bullshit it’s the people dictating it and then having a tantrum when people say no- usually by screaming about literal violence and using suicide stats as a stick to beat people with).

LastTrainEast · 02/07/2022 22:53

"if only trans people use preferred pronouns in their signatures to avoid being misgendered, it singles them out as being trans"

That might work a bit in email, but they are used face to face too and in that case people are going to know anyway when their pronouns don't match their sex.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:29

Oh and 'cold'. Let's not forget that one.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:27

So you and I are pretty much in the same boat.

Cool.

So what was so ignorant, disrespectful, alienating of transpeople about my posts again? That necessitated all the shouty capitals?

hulahooper2 · 02/07/2022 22:27

I’m against it as I believe you are a he or a she , all this non binary nonsense is just folk who crave attention

AlisonDonut · 02/07/2022 22:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 22:16

Sorry, but I think the rules are suspended given that the poster has spent the last hour or so calling me a "borg".

Oh no, did someone call you something you find offensive?

And yet you can't work out why we don't like being told 'the word for you is CIS'.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 22:25

Signing out for the night.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:24

Is it possible to have a debate without mentioning them?

They are unfortunately (for your friend as much as anyone) shaping the narrative right now. That's the elephant in the room

And while you're quick to say you didn't say that, you don't appear to like others stating that you can't change sex either.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 22:24

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:22

Re your "undermining someone elses rights", my friend wanting to be known as he and a male name is not undermining your rights.

He may not be. The TRA movement certainly is. I'd like to see TG within that stand up to the stonewall narrative, but I'm not seeing a lot of that, in fairness. That's not in anyway a criticism of your friend, but a general observation.

Your friend staying preferred pronouns isn't a problem, but the expectation that everyone does it, is.

Oh, there goes TRA again.

I dont expect everyone to state pronouns and neither does he. So you and I are pretty much in the same boat.

If I mentioned the views of a batshit feminist, or as earlier the example of a woman who murdered her own child, then said "you must think that because you're a woman/feminist", that would be ridiculous.

So why the jump to TRA views?

Why should trans gender people stand up to the stonewall narrative when you spend your days writing about how much you dont accept them?! Why on earth would they?

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:22

Re your "undermining someone elses rights", my friend wanting to be known as he and a male name is not undermining your rights.

He may not be. The TRA movement certainly is. I'd like to see TG within that stand up to the stonewall narrative, but I'm not seeing a lot of that, in fairness. That's not in anyway a criticism of your friend, but a general observation.

Your friend staying preferred pronouns isn't a problem, but the expectation that everyone does it, is.

Livpool · 02/07/2022 22:21

Because I would feel the same if we were asked to apply our religious viewpoints. I would be asked be a 'heathen' even though I am not religious personally so don't apply it to myself.

Do it if you want but I couldn't care less.

Plus the only people I have seen do it are men with obviously male names
who 'identify' as "he/him". And women with obviously female names with identity as "she/her". Virtue-signalling at its finest

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 22:20

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:18

You weren't respectful in that you responded to my post about a RL situation with "But you cant change sex".

Look we have to get past this position that stating the truth is hurtful or disrespectful. In a world where the TRA narrative is TWAW and respect for sex spaces is shot, it needs to be said. It does no one any favours to suggest that anyone can change sex. Honest debate starts with this point.

But I didn't say that, and neither did my friend.

TRA's did.

Is it possible to have a debate without mentioning them? or do we need them because they are a "gotcha" card.

beautyisthefaceisee · 02/07/2022 22:20

Wouldloveanother · 02/07/2022 22:18

But stating men can be women and vice versa isn’t a harmless indulgence like reassuring somebody their deceased loved one is in heaven. It has serious consequences for women, in terms of their safety; for children, in terms of confusion over ‘gender identity’; and for truth, because if you say a man can be a woman, you’re stating something that we know to be impossible (in all fairness there’s more chance of heaven because we don’t know what happens after death).

you can’t just indulge it a little bit, either you sign up for the whole pseudo science nonsense or, like most of us, want to help people with their mental health issues but not pretend the earth is flat to keep them happy.

Of course you can.

It's not black and white, it's a whole umbrella, and the annoying thing is with the likes of @TheKeatingFive when it comes to things like spaces, sports, prisons etc I'm sure we (and my trans friend) would bloody agree, but the blinkers are on at the mention of the word trans.

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:18

You weren't respectful in that you responded to my post about a RL situation with "But you cant change sex".

Look we have to get past this position that stating the truth is hurtful or disrespectful. In a world where the TRA narrative is TWAW and respect for sex spaces is shot, it needs to be said. It does no one any favours to suggest that anyone can change sex. Honest debate starts with this point.