Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
AlisonDonut · 03/07/2022 13:31

I was actually agreeing with you, and just pointing out that the reason it's at play is because as of our end of term, it's being put in schools as a word we have to use.

Don't tell me you are a teacher?

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 13:13

maddening · 03/07/2022 13:01

"I certainly don't think my identity is based on me having a vagina, as you clearly do!"

I don't think that woman is an identity though, I am a woman, my identity is my personality, likes, interests. Why on earth is a movement basing itself on identifying as a sex and sex sterotypes? Your sex is certainly part of you and it may impact your identity as also your sexuality and race may do, but to hang your entire being off identity as a sex is not rational imo. It makes a person very flat and one dimensional. And the fact that we are pandering to sex stereotypes is very repressive, we have worked hard to remove these barriers and are back at point zero but with added attacks to women's rights being cheered on.

Exactly. that's my point, maddening.

Take the TRA's out. People don't want to change gender because they want to have a certain anatomy. For whatever reason, reasons I don't necessarily understand, they want to live as the opposite gender.Now we might not understand that, we might argue amongst ourselves about why, and why its wrong, or why it should change, but here's the thing - it isn't going to. The power of discussion alone is not going to stop it.

Remember when you were younger and you'd make stupid decisions and your parent or whoever looked after you would tell you that and out of sheer stubborness you'd dig your heels in deeper? That is the equivalent.

We have to listen. We have to try and understand, even if we don't agree. And we have to work TOGETHER to stop the safe spaces, prisons etc being infiltrated. Most trans people don't want that. The nutters are not the voice. Labelling it as "nonsense" and "flat earth" and all the rest of it is not goign to make trans people listen, it's going to push them away, and into the hands of the TRA's. Now you can say that we shouldnt have to be kind, and we say no, etc etc, but that doesn't actually fix anything. All it does is create two sides shouting a lot and as pointed out above, women are not winning.

I'm not trans but I've paid more attention to your posts than most of them on MN because of the respectful way you write (and before anyone points it out, yes I have not been brilliant at times on here, but that's what happens, it all gets silly.)

PS - If I did, as PP said, offend you with the cis comment, I genuinely didn't mean to. I was actually agreeing with you, and just pointing out that the reason it's at play is because as of our end of term, it's being put in schools as a word we have to use. I'm sorry if itoffends you, we enjoyed a respectful discussion so I wouldn't want that.

maddening · 03/07/2022 13:01

"I certainly don't think my identity is based on me having a vagina, as you clearly do!"

I don't think that woman is an identity though, I am a woman, my identity is my personality, likes, interests. Why on earth is a movement basing itself on identifying as a sex and sex sterotypes? Your sex is certainly part of you and it may impact your identity as also your sexuality and race may do, but to hang your entire being off identity as a sex is not rational imo. It makes a person very flat and one dimensional. And the fact that we are pandering to sex stereotypes is very repressive, we have worked hard to remove these barriers and are back at point zero but with added attacks to women's rights being cheered on.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 12:43

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 09:50

This is all a bit wide eyed and disingenuous. You are doing what TRAs do- women who say no are evil and uncaring (how unwomanly).

You seem new to this. Perhaps go and have a look at the Forstater case or Alison Bailley’s current case to see just how far the enforcement of speech has already gone.

While you weren’t paying attention the law has been changed on Scotland so that anyone who self declares themselves as a women had unrestricted access to ALL women’s space. No exceptions. Is that right?

No.

And most trans people would agree with you. So why are they copping for your anger?

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 12:42

TheKeatingFive · 02/07/2022 22:27

So you and I are pretty much in the same boat.

Cool.

So what was so ignorant, disrespectful, alienating of transpeople about my posts again? That necessitated all the shouty capitals?

I didnt use the word alienation.

I stand by all the things I said.

These are real people you are talking about.

I really object to this notion that you mist be rude about it, because if you're nice or kind to real people you're part of tbe problem.

In the last five years it has got completely out of hand, so how is being 'factual' and saying no' going for you? When was anything in life solved by doing things that way?

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 10:32

Howcoldloveis · 03/07/2022 10:15

perhaps they do not believe that a transwoman is a woman (for example) so consider the pronouns to be untrue Some people believe TWAW but like the flat earthers - this is a belief, like religion not based on fact. A transwoman is not a woman - there is no belief, it's a fact.

100% this. I believe that people should be free to believe whatever they like. I’ll defend their right to choose a belief system. That is enshrined in human rights law.

But almost all the problems in history have been cause by one set of people trying to enforce their beliefs on whole populations. The zeal of new genderism feel very cult like.

And just like I have had colleagues who were Scientologist or JLS believers and have worked supportively and politely with them, while also managing to not believe what they believe, I would do the same to trans colleagues. Because it is not my business how other people lead their lives. It only becomes my business if they are demanding that I think the same way too.

I don’t believe that sex= gender and I never will.

LovinglifeAF · 03/07/2022 10:31

babyjellyfish · 03/07/2022 09:31

@Popcorn77 But I don't think we naturally lack empathy for people. I think what you are seeing here is a hardening of attitudes caused by the unreasonable demands of trans activists, whose agenda is being promoted by people in positions of power.

I am sick of empathy being demanded from women for this one group - which in my view includes some people who don't need or deserve it - and not afforded to women, many of whom do need and deserve it.

If I had to work with a trans person, I would probably try and avoid talking about them in the third person as much as possible, and if I had to, I would try to use their name rather than pronouns. Obviously when talking to them I would just use "you".

I would find it easier to use the preferred pronouns of someone who seemed genuinely dysphoric, and in particular a trans man. I would struggle a bit with some people because I know that for some trans women the reason for it is autogynephilia. There are such people who openly admit on social media to feeling turned on when people use their pronouns. I don't want to be coerced into participating in someone's paraphilia.

I won't use the preferred pronouns of people like Lia Thomas. I will never meet Lia Thomas in real life, and the only thing I'm ever likely to say about Lia is to criticise Lia for Lia's behaviour. Being forced to pretend that Lia is a woman has directly harmed female athletes, and indirectly harmed women's sport as a whole. In that context, it would be hypocritical to use Lia's referred pronouns. I feel zero obligation to pretend that Lia is a woman, and neither should anyone else.

Totally agree

LovinglifeAF · 03/07/2022 10:28

In terms of using someone’s chosen pronouns- - I would endeavour to do so. I wouldn’t deliberately use the “wrong” ones just to piss them off.

however if it was pronouns clearly at odds with the evidence of my own ears and eyes as to their actual sex it would only be out of manners/politeness, not because I accept their notion of gender identity or that they are that gender.

Also, like most people I have a lot going on in my head. It may just slip my mind that Jane who looks and sounds like a man uses she/her pronouns. I would not find it very “kind” to be torn a strip off for a genuine mistake.

I can see though why people might refuse to use them and use the sex based pronouns they see as appropriate. It’s not what I would necessarily do (I make exceptions for criminals, people like Lia Thomas and Eddie Izzard) but I can totally see the compelled speech point and that people shouldn’t be obliged to partake in others’ delusions:adherence to an ideology if they don’t want to.

Howcoldloveis · 03/07/2022 10:15

perhaps they do not believe that a transwoman is a woman (for example) so consider the pronouns to be untrue Some people believe TWAW but like the flat earthers - this is a belief, like religion not based on fact. A transwoman is not a woman - there is no belief, it's a fact.

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 09:50

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 09:12

I don’t want to declare my pro nouns, and don’t. I am not criticising the challenge to the issues at all.

I just see real people who are feeling real challenges irl and in these comments there is intolerance. Not wanting to declare is fine, refusing to accept someone else’s choice makes me very uncomfortable (as does calling someone else's choice nonsense) and jumping from pro nouns & I don't want to identify as male/female to the more dramatic issues seems to only be harming. I agree there are many many challenges in the way that society is dealing with this and it is conflicting with woman's rights in a way that seems illogical to me. I was not suggesting for one min anyone should just accept. I just think the anger and lack of empathy is polarising and wont solve the issue. It genuinely surprised me - i am new on here and have not seen views expressed with such anger - i have only seen tolerance and some confusion how to best manage irl. I was commenting on my shock.

The problem (as I see it) is the societal construct of gender & societies management of this issue. The problem is not the individuals struggling through (albeit some people will be problematic as will some in every grouping of people)

This is all a bit wide eyed and disingenuous. You are doing what TRAs do- women who say no are evil and uncaring (how unwomanly).

You seem new to this. Perhaps go and have a look at the Forstater case or Alison Bailley’s current case to see just how far the enforcement of speech has already gone.

While you weren’t paying attention the law has been changed on Scotland so that anyone who self declares themselves as a women had unrestricted access to ALL women’s space. No exceptions. Is that right?

babyjellyfish · 03/07/2022 09:31

@Popcorn77 But I don't think we naturally lack empathy for people. I think what you are seeing here is a hardening of attitudes caused by the unreasonable demands of trans activists, whose agenda is being promoted by people in positions of power.

I am sick of empathy being demanded from women for this one group - which in my view includes some people who don't need or deserve it - and not afforded to women, many of whom do need and deserve it.

If I had to work with a trans person, I would probably try and avoid talking about them in the third person as much as possible, and if I had to, I would try to use their name rather than pronouns. Obviously when talking to them I would just use "you".

I would find it easier to use the preferred pronouns of someone who seemed genuinely dysphoric, and in particular a trans man. I would struggle a bit with some people because I know that for some trans women the reason for it is autogynephilia. There are such people who openly admit on social media to feeling turned on when people use their pronouns. I don't want to be coerced into participating in someone's paraphilia.

I won't use the preferred pronouns of people like Lia Thomas. I will never meet Lia Thomas in real life, and the only thing I'm ever likely to say about Lia is to criticise Lia for Lia's behaviour. Being forced to pretend that Lia is a woman has directly harmed female athletes, and indirectly harmed women's sport as a whole. In that context, it would be hypocritical to use Lia's referred pronouns. I feel zero obligation to pretend that Lia is a woman, and neither should anyone else.

TheKeatingFive · 03/07/2022 09:21

refusing to accept someone else’s choice makes me very uncomfortable

I don't think anyone is doing that however

The problem (as I see it) is the societal construct of gender & societies management of this issue. The problem is not the individuals struggling through (albeit some people will be problematic as will some in every grouping of people)

And again, I don't think anyone disagrees with this.

You seem to be misunderstanding the target of people's anger. It isnt individuals struggling, but the extreme TRA movement that have pushed this agenda in this first place.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 09:18

The problem (as I see it) is the societal construct of gender & societies management of this issue. The problem is not the individuals struggling through (albeit some people will be problematic as will some in every grouping of people)

The problem for female people is that those struggling individuals are being used as justification to redefine womanhood as a mental attribute not a physical one, which if accepted by society means all single sex provisions created to support female people are open to any male who claims to have a woman's mind.

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 09:12

babyjellyfish · 03/07/2022 08:45

@Popcorn77 Many of us now feel that using opposite sexed pronouns for someone sends out a message that we believe in this gender stuff and that humans can change sex or that gender is more important than sex, or whatever.

Rightly or wrongly, complying with the pronoun nonsense is interpreted as a sign of support for this ideology, which is something many of us no longer feel comfortable with.

I don’t want to declare my pro nouns, and don’t. I am not criticising the challenge to the issues at all.

I just see real people who are feeling real challenges irl and in these comments there is intolerance. Not wanting to declare is fine, refusing to accept someone else’s choice makes me very uncomfortable (as does calling someone else's choice nonsense) and jumping from pro nouns & I don't want to identify as male/female to the more dramatic issues seems to only be harming. I agree there are many many challenges in the way that society is dealing with this and it is conflicting with woman's rights in a way that seems illogical to me. I was not suggesting for one min anyone should just accept. I just think the anger and lack of empathy is polarising and wont solve the issue. It genuinely surprised me - i am new on here and have not seen views expressed with such anger - i have only seen tolerance and some confusion how to best manage irl. I was commenting on my shock.

The problem (as I see it) is the societal construct of gender & societies management of this issue. The problem is not the individuals struggling through (albeit some people will be problematic as will some in every grouping of people)

Cantanka · 03/07/2022 09:07

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:41

None of that is helped by refusing to call someone the pronouns they choose

we are all individuals and judging people as a group, assigning characteristics and addressing anger at a group is the foundation of these issues?

Yes, I would absolutely always use someone’s preferred pronouns and would call out anyone I knew who didn’t.

However the problem is that the stating of pronouns in a signature isn’t about telling someone your preferred pronouns. As it said upthread, it’s a political statement signifying you agree with the approach to things sophielegrand has outlined in her post. It is incredibly naive to think stating pronouns has anything to do with actually conveying that information in the majority of cases.

TheKeatingFive · 03/07/2022 08:59

I wouldn't refuse to use someone's preferred pronouns either. It's the expectation we all do it is the problem.

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 08:57

@Popcorn77 Where did I say that I refused to use someone’s pronouns? People change their names all the time for various reasons. It would be agressive and impolite not to respect that.

What I am objecting to is forcing everyone to declare their pronouns as an act of apparent solidarity. It is the most ridiculous form of armchair activism- it achieves actually nothing except to start arguments and create hostility. And it just serves to prioritise one group of people over another for no good reason.

And I really do object to the pressure to comply with random social rules created by others or be declared an outcast- which is so often to consequence. Especially when we know that women are still paid less and treated differently at work across the board. It is great that you haven’t experienced this. But it is still happening to a lot of us. It’s one of the reasons I don’t put my marital status or working hours on my email signature. Because I know people treat me differently once they know I am married, with a small child and work part time. This is why I’m definitely not adding pronouns.

babyjellyfish · 03/07/2022 08:45

@Popcorn77 Many of us now feel that using opposite sexed pronouns for someone sends out a message that we believe in this gender stuff and that humans can change sex or that gender is more important than sex, or whatever.

Rightly or wrongly, complying with the pronoun nonsense is interpreted as a sign of support for this ideology, which is something many of us no longer feel comfortable with.

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:41

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 08:25

And @Popcorn77 I’m not the intolerant one. I don’t not care how people dress or who they fall in love with or what they do with consenting partners. That is not for me to dictate. Because everyone should be free to make those choices for themselves. That’s where I thought all this was going years ago.

But it has since become apparent that this is not enough for some people. Now it is about coerced enforcement- telling us who we are, what to call ourselves, how to behave and who we must love/have sex with/ allow in our spaces. This feels like the complete opposite of Love is Love and Be Kind. It feels like Behave or we’ll hunt you down. Not exactly designed to make women comfortable.

I would like to know why it is that it is always women who have to give up something to be kind but our feelings and wishes are never, ever taken into account. Why is it that teenage girls have to allow middles aged men into their sports teams? Why is it that rape victims have push down their trauma to allow a transwomen the affirming experience of counselling them? Why is it that elderly women have to set aside their worries and discomfort to allow transwomen to give them initiate personal care? Yet we are allowed to say nothing in return.

Remember what Paris Lees told Jess Philips: questions are fine but ALL concerns are transphobic. What a great way to shut women up and ignore our feelings.

None of that is helped by refusing to call someone the pronouns they choose

we are all individuals and judging people as a group, assigning characteristics and addressing anger at a group is the foundation of these issues?

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 08:32

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:19

But is your anger helpful? Or will the consequences of it will just cause more pain. If you are angry be a constructive part of the solution. I don’t pretend to fully understand all, if any of the issues in full - but anger seems unhelpful. This society is created by every one of us as we are all responsible for how it is impacting people.

This is so condescending.

Women’s groups (the ones not ideologically captured) have begged for the last ten years to be listened to. And have been ignored. They written to MPs and tried to hold meetings with Stonewall and Mermaids and been told to go away. Then pilloried as bigots and had their finding pulled. It has taken years for women to become this furious.

Every women who has stuck her head above the parapet to try to talk about this has been harassed and threatened. Just go along to any of the Women’s Place meetings and see the black masked figures staring outside ready to harass survivors of FGM as they try to speak about their experiences. Look at the recent threats made to JKR on Twitter- someone released her address and a set of instructions on how to make a pipe bomb with encourage for someone to bomb her house.

Then look at the trans pride parades- are there any GC protesters? No.

Because being GC is about supporting women’s right and NOT about being anti-trans. While it seems that being a transactivists is about hating and harassing any women who says no. That is the difference. I don’t see anyone asking the black clad figures who scream at women to ‘die in a grease fire’ to be kinder.

babyjellyfish · 03/07/2022 08:27

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:04

I am genuinely shocked at the replies on this thread. I assumed the world to be much more tolerant and kind. I know people who live their lives as a gender they were not assigned at birth, and the impact of them doing so on me is nil. I know teenagers going through an identity crisis and it feels like a high number young people hitting puberty feel uncomfortable with the associations of the societal construct of the gender they are assigned to. That is a big issue which is really affecting the next generation and one that needs a lot of empathy and support not anger.

I feel no attachment to my pro nouns - they are words that help us navigate the
english language. This is a tricky topic - i do not want to declare my pro nouns and it’s interesting to explore why. But the anger and prejudice and intolerance is not what our society should be about.

I would hazard a guess that most of us have gone through the "pronouns, yes, fine, no problem, let's be kind" stage and come out the other side once we realised how damaging it actually is.

Let's be clear: nothing is assigned at birth.

Sex is irrevocably fixed at the moment of conception, and no pronouns, hormones or surgeries will ever change it. It is observed at or before birth and recorded on the birth certificate.

Gender is a set of regressive stereotypes which promote an incredibly old fashioned and conservative view of what it means to be a man or a woman. It is not binary - it is not even real - and no one is assigned one, at birth or at any other time.

But for some reason we are all being forced to pretend that it is real and important, and that most of us have gender identities which match our biological sex, whereas trans people have gender identities which are at odds with their biological sex, which is why they need hormones and surgeries and access to spaces and sports designated for the opposite sex.

It's harmful to women and children. It deprives us of single sex support for rape survivors and the chance to compete fairly in sport. It pushes non conforming children down a path which leads to infertility, loss of sexual function and other disabling complications. It makes it easier for sexual predators to access potential victims, because they know that if they say they identify as a woman, no one can challenge them.

It has nothing to do with being kind or tolerant, and it isn't the least bit progressive.

That's why so many of us don't even want to do the pronouns anymore.

Legrandsophie · 03/07/2022 08:25

And @Popcorn77 I’m not the intolerant one. I don’t not care how people dress or who they fall in love with or what they do with consenting partners. That is not for me to dictate. Because everyone should be free to make those choices for themselves. That’s where I thought all this was going years ago.

But it has since become apparent that this is not enough for some people. Now it is about coerced enforcement- telling us who we are, what to call ourselves, how to behave and who we must love/have sex with/ allow in our spaces. This feels like the complete opposite of Love is Love and Be Kind. It feels like Behave or we’ll hunt you down. Not exactly designed to make women comfortable.

I would like to know why it is that it is always women who have to give up something to be kind but our feelings and wishes are never, ever taken into account. Why is it that teenage girls have to allow middles aged men into their sports teams? Why is it that rape victims have push down their trauma to allow a transwomen the affirming experience of counselling them? Why is it that elderly women have to set aside their worries and discomfort to allow transwomen to give them initiate personal care? Yet we are allowed to say nothing in return.

Remember what Paris Lees told Jess Philips: questions are fine but ALL concerns are transphobic. What a great way to shut women up and ignore our feelings.

Cantanka · 03/07/2022 08:24

I know people who live their lives as a gender they were not assigned at birth, and the impact of them doing so on me is nil

OK but are you saying the impact on everyone of replacing sex with gender is nil?

Are you saying the impact on women who have been bullied, abused and doxxed for sticking up for the relevance of sex in their lives experience is nil?

This isn’t about just letting people transition and live as their acquired gender, no one sensible is saying that shouldn’t happen. It’s about a much bigger issue of the interplay between sex and gender.

TheKeatingFive · 03/07/2022 08:22

If you are angry be a constructive part of the solution

I am thanks.

I presume you on the other hand are nodding along, despite your reservations, because you're being 'kind'. In this way you're part of the problem for this generation who are seeing this normalised and no one speaking out.

Anger can be much more constructive than yapping on about everyone being nice to each other. In situations where 'niceness' is weaponised for a particular agenda.

Popcorn77 · 03/07/2022 08:19

But is your anger helpful? Or will the consequences of it will just cause more pain. If you are angry be a constructive part of the solution. I don’t pretend to fully understand all, if any of the issues in full - but anger seems unhelpful. This society is created by every one of us as we are all responsible for how it is impacting people.