Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 16:07

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 16:04

Where on earth are you getting your info from? No such thing as a trans child and "turn out to be gay" both of those points are just utter bollocks.

Evidence shows that 80% of children who are ‘gender non-conforming’ - if carefully supported and allowed to go through puberty as our bodies are intended to - will turn out to either be gay/ lesbian (which is a healthy, normal thing obviously) or the non-conformity just desists.

As I understand it, what is termed a ‘trans child’ in the truest sense of the term, is a child who has body dysphoria. One way to alleviate this is to live as the opposite sex. It does not mean a child has a gender that doesn’t match their sex - there is no such thing as ‘born in the wrong body’! How on Earth do you describe or define a ‘trans child’?

Absolute and totao bollocks. 80 percent turn out gay and lesbian? I'd like to se your stats.

a trans child is just a trans person who is a child. Surely you can manage that.

And yes, there absolutely is such a thing (for them, not us) as born in the wrong body. Your ignorance is astounding (and this is part of the reason that trans people will not speak up for you - why would they, when you continue to deny the feelings and not take them seriouslY?0

Trans and body dysphoria is not the same thing, even the NHS would disagree wiht you on that one.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 16:05

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 16:03

Re your final part - whether you interpret me as full support is not my problem. It's not my fault that some feminists are so narrow minded they seem to think that stereotyping me will help.

Sorry, you miss my point again. It's not about whether I think you support TRAs or not. You say you don't and I believe you, always have.

It's about how your public actions are interpreted publicly. As long as the only public voice for trans people is the TRA voice, your use of pronouns will be taken by the people you interact with as support for the full TRA agenda. And those who genuinely do support it will be emboldened by that. And those who don't, trans or otherwise, will become more marginalised and more afraid.

www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674707580#:~:text=Preference%20falsification%2C%20according%20to%20the,we%20actually%20find%20it%20bland.

Thanks.

But as long as feminsts continue to speak the way they do about trans (I take the respect you give me as non TRA and I give you the same respect back as a thoughtful poster, despite our views) but a look across the feminist boards gives an idea of how much they have the piss taken out of them. And until that stops, they won't, and shouldn't be expected , to speak up for woman publicly.

It's interesting that the same posters and the same forums who claimed women shouldn't be speaking up for men with the #notallmen campaign and they could fight their own battles don't think that now that they are the ones in the firing line.

TRA's are nutters, we know this. But they haven't caused the divide. Feminists have. Surely the solution is that the non TRA's and the non batshit feminists and trans people work together?

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 16:04

Where on earth are you getting your info from? No such thing as a trans child and "turn out to be gay" both of those points are just utter bollocks.

Evidence shows that 80% of children who are ‘gender non-conforming’ - if carefully supported and allowed to go through puberty as our bodies are intended to - will turn out to either be gay/ lesbian (which is a healthy, normal thing obviously) or the non-conformity just desists.

As I understand it, what is termed a ‘trans child’ in the truest sense of the term, is a child who has body dysphoria. One way to alleviate this is to live as the opposite sex. It does not mean a child has a gender that doesn’t match their sex - there is no such thing as ‘born in the wrong body’! How on Earth do you describe or define a ‘trans child’?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 16:03

Re your final part - whether you interpret me as full support is not my problem. It's not my fault that some feminists are so narrow minded they seem to think that stereotyping me will help.

Sorry, you miss my point again. It's not about whether I think you support TRAs or not. You say you don't and I believe you, always have.

It's about how your public actions are interpreted publicly. As long as the only public voice for trans people is the TRA voice, your use of pronouns will be taken by the people you interact with as support for the full TRA agenda. And those who genuinely do support it will be emboldened by that. And those who don't, trans or otherwise, will become more marginalised and more afraid.

www.hup.harvard.edu/catalog.php?isbn=9780674707580#:~:text=Preference%20falsification%2C%20according%20to%20the,we%20actually%20find%20it%20bland.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:56

But it is. It's not my teenage trans pupil making the law, so why are they the ones being mocked and ridiculed on the internet?

They are not being mocked and ridiculed by me. My concern is not to ignore gender but to get it properly separated from sex instead of this current incoherent (some might say duplicitious) assertion that sex is not gender but nevertheless it's fine to just swap in gender for everything previously set up based on sex.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:53

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 15:51

@beautyisthefaceisee but we’re asking you - what does ‘genuine trans person’ mean? We’ve been told anyone who says they’re a different ‘gender’ to what they’re born with is a trans person. Regardless of whether they have transitioned at all or even if they don’t intend to. Jamie Wallace the newly declared ‘trans’ MP fully presents as a man and doesn’t have any intention thus far to change this (as far as I know).

A person who has suffered from body dysphoria from a young age isn’t even necessarily ‘trans’ in the same way that say, Jamie Wallace or Eddie Izzard are. People with body dysmorphia suffer from a recognised condition that may (or may not) be alleviated if they live as if they are the opposite sex. Many gender non-conforming children (who aren’t in this category of body dysmorphia) turn out to be gay and/ or the non-conformity desists naturally over time. They are not ‘trans’ - there is no such thing as a trans child. This is imposing adult attitudes about stereotypes and conformity onto young children.

Your ‘trans teenager’ is fully deserving of support - but social affirmation may not be the right way to go. It is part of puberty to feel uncertain of your identity and emotions and your body. It’s actually an integral part of puberty itself! Telling that teen that they should compound that uncertainty by saying that they’re ‘actually’ the opposite sex sounds pretty unhelpful to me. And worse - if they’re encouraged to cut off healthy body parts and take drugs that will damage them. It’s the feminists who are looking out for these children/ teens more than you realise.

Are you aware than many men who identify as women have fetishes? This is a fact. It’s called autogynephilia. They are aroused by the thought of being a woman or dressing as a woman. Are these men ‘genuine trans’? If not why not?

We keep asking you what is ‘genuine trans’ for a reason.

And so what if you have ‘trans’ (quotation marks as I’m still waiting for your definition) friends? I have friends who are women. So we both have friends affected by this debate. Your friends don’t trump mine.

I also have friends who are women.

They do, in this debate, because we are talking about pronouns.

If the debate was about your right to spaces, I'd back you. Because I don't believe it's a black and white issue.

Where on earth are you getting your info from? No such thing as a trans child and "turn out to be gay" both of those points are just utter bollocks.

You keep asking me what genuine trans is because you think it's a way to trip me up. You have proved my point.

We are talking about pronouns. Eddie Izzard and your fetish men and Lia whoever and all the same boring, tedious points that keep getting dragged out have hee haw to do with anything. I've seen it all before, and I'm not playing.

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 15:51

@beautyisthefaceisee but we’re asking you - what does ‘genuine trans person’ mean? We’ve been told anyone who says they’re a different ‘gender’ to what they’re born with is a trans person. Regardless of whether they have transitioned at all or even if they don’t intend to. Jamie Wallace the newly declared ‘trans’ MP fully presents as a man and doesn’t have any intention thus far to change this (as far as I know).

A person who has suffered from body dysphoria from a young age isn’t even necessarily ‘trans’ in the same way that say, Jamie Wallace or Eddie Izzard are. People with body dysmorphia suffer from a recognised condition that may (or may not) be alleviated if they live as if they are the opposite sex. Many gender non-conforming children (who aren’t in this category of body dysmorphia) turn out to be gay and/ or the non-conformity desists naturally over time. They are not ‘trans’ - there is no such thing as a trans child. This is imposing adult attitudes about stereotypes and conformity onto young children.

Your ‘trans teenager’ is fully deserving of support - but social affirmation may not be the right way to go. It is part of puberty to feel uncertain of your identity and emotions and your body. It’s actually an integral part of puberty itself! Telling that teen that they should compound that uncertainty by saying that they’re ‘actually’ the opposite sex sounds pretty unhelpful to me. And worse - if they’re encouraged to cut off healthy body parts and take drugs that will damage them. It’s the feminists who are looking out for these children/ teens more than you realise.

Are you aware than many men who identify as women have fetishes? This is a fact. It’s called autogynephilia. They are aroused by the thought of being a woman or dressing as a woman. Are these men ‘genuine trans’? If not why not?

We keep asking you what is ‘genuine trans’ for a reason.

And so what if you have ‘trans’ (quotation marks as I’m still waiting for your definition) friends? I have friends who are women. So we both have friends affected by this debate. Your friends don’t trump mine.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:48

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:42

Why on earth would they speak up on social media and in public places when they are spoken about the way that they are? I wouldn't!

You're expecting them to speak up when you publicly treat them as collateral and you yourself called them "irrelevant"

I said If the extremists are setting the agenda then we need to talk about the extremists. Nice, rational people hiding behind the sofa are sadly irrelevant until they act.

Not that moderate trans people are irrelevant themselves, but that the debate has to be about the extremists views because they are setting the political agenda. The fact that you and your friends have more moderate views is certainly relevant to not tarring everyone with the TRA brush, but as I told you last night I'm careful not to do that anyway. However it is irrelevant to the political debate because the TRA voice is the one that is influencing our politicians and institutions so that is the position that needs to be challenged. If you and your friends want to be relevant in that conversation you need to speak up.

So you want them to put their neck on the line so that they can be thrown to the wolf that is social media - will you be there to defend them when they get ripped to shreds? Course you won't.

Have they stepped up to defend the women whose views they supposedly share who have already been ripped to shreds? You rather prove my point.

Of course it's not an acceptance of the whole TRA project. How come it's acceptable to pretty much imply I'm on board with TRA - wasnt it originally that that was a strikable offence?

Again you're misunderstanding. I'm not saying pronouns mean you do accept the TRA agenda. My point is that even for people like you who do not, because this moderate view is not being given in public, your use of pronouns is going to be interpreted as full support for the TRA agenda whether you like it or not.

But hang on.

I'm told repeatedly on here that women don't have to do anything (for example, when I suggest that rather than mocking trans and taking the piss out of it, it might be more beneficial to have a respectful conversation, I'm told no, why should women be NICE, we say no) so why do I have to do anything to be relevant to your conversation?

No, you prove my point - why would a trans person speak up in support of feminists when a feminist wouldn't stand up in support of a trans person? Why should they?

Re your final part - whether you interpret me as full support is not my problem. It's not my fault that some feminists are so narrow minded they seem to think that stereotyping me will help. I don't assume every feminist is one of the batshit ones, so why not the same respect?

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:46

Clymene · 03/07/2022 15:36

Right so your argument @beautyisthefaceisee is:

Women complain about the fact that men are identifying as women and are breaching our privacy, dignity and safety.

In return we get doxxed, death threats and our livelihood threatened.

So we complain about that.

And we can't expect the genuine transpeople to stand up for us because ... we've what? Not put up and shut up? Haven't couched everything we've said in 'well of course most transpeople wouldn't dream of doing that'.

That's a bullshit argument and you know it. For a start, JKR was exceedingly clear that she has no issue with transpeople, she is just protecting women's rights to our spaces. Threats and doxxing and attempts at cancellation ensued. So it doesn't matter. Unless we go along with everything, pretend there is no conflict ever, it is never enough. And it is always women who are the target. The vitriol we receive is phenomenal compared to men. Anyone tried to dox Gervais? No.

Incidentally, I feel nothing but pity for children who think that identifying as a boy is going to let them escape the horrible pressures women face.

No, it isn't a bullshit argument.

You cannot mock, sneer, deny their identity, call it the most offensive things and that you don't believe in it and then when you find yourself in an argument with some nutters on twitter because you are so bloody stubborn, expect them to defend you!

JKR's an idiot, I'm not remotely interested in her opinion.

Well, good for you, but once again you are being patronising (I ask again why you think that trans people don't want to stand up for you, when you have ridiculous opinions like that).

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:42

Why on earth would they speak up on social media and in public places when they are spoken about the way that they are? I wouldn't!

You're expecting them to speak up when you publicly treat them as collateral and you yourself called them "irrelevant"

I said If the extremists are setting the agenda then we need to talk about the extremists. Nice, rational people hiding behind the sofa are sadly irrelevant until they act.

Not that moderate trans people are irrelevant themselves, but that the debate has to be about the extremists views because they are setting the political agenda. The fact that you and your friends have more moderate views is certainly relevant to not tarring everyone with the TRA brush, but as I told you last night I'm careful not to do that anyway. However it is irrelevant to the political debate because the TRA voice is the one that is influencing our politicians and institutions so that is the position that needs to be challenged. If you and your friends want to be relevant in that conversation you need to speak up.

So you want them to put their neck on the line so that they can be thrown to the wolf that is social media - will you be there to defend them when they get ripped to shreds? Course you won't.

Have they stepped up to defend the women whose views they supposedly share who have already been ripped to shreds? You rather prove my point.

Of course it's not an acceptance of the whole TRA project. How come it's acceptable to pretty much imply I'm on board with TRA - wasnt it originally that that was a strikable offence?

Again you're misunderstanding. I'm not saying pronouns mean you do accept the TRA agenda. My point is that even for people like you who do not, because this moderate view is not being given in public, your use of pronouns is going to be interpreted as full support for the TRA agenda whether you like it or not.

Clymene · 03/07/2022 15:36

Right so your argument @beautyisthefaceisee is:

Women complain about the fact that men are identifying as women and are breaching our privacy, dignity and safety.

In return we get doxxed, death threats and our livelihood threatened.

So we complain about that.

And we can't expect the genuine transpeople to stand up for us because ... we've what? Not put up and shut up? Haven't couched everything we've said in 'well of course most transpeople wouldn't dream of doing that'.

That's a bullshit argument and you know it. For a start, JKR was exceedingly clear that she has no issue with transpeople, she is just protecting women's rights to our spaces. Threats and doxxing and attempts at cancellation ensued. So it doesn't matter. Unless we go along with everything, pretend there is no conflict ever, it is never enough. And it is always women who are the target. The vitriol we receive is phenomenal compared to men. Anyone tried to dox Gervais? No.

Incidentally, I feel nothing but pity for children who think that identifying as a boy is going to let them escape the horrible pressures women face.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:32

LovinglifeAF · 03/07/2022 15:29

if people are who they say they are and that’s meant to be accepted without question, how do we even tell who are the “genuine trans people”?

Well, I would say everyone, but because of MN's obsession with TRA's, if I mention a trans person they say "OH BUT WHAT ABOUT LIA" or the one thats doing the rounds at the minute of the missing 'woman' who is facially a young man.

It's tedious

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:31

AlisonDonut · 03/07/2022 15:25

Isn't it transphobic to say 'genuine trans people'?

Not the first 'ally' to out themselves as a transphobe, not even the first this weekend.

the donut strikes again - as per, in the middle of a reasonable and respectful debate.

the reason I've had to put "genuine" is because idiots like you talk about TRA's at every given opportunity, so we have to actually separate them.

you done for the day? I do enjoy you plopping in every so often

LovinglifeAF · 03/07/2022 15:29

if people are who they say they are and that’s meant to be accepted without question, how do we even tell who are the “genuine trans people”?

cillacilla · 03/07/2022 15:25

If my brain was transported into a male's body in a Freaky Friday type scenario and people started calling me he because I looked like a he even though I was a "female inside" I would not care particularly. Calling a male person she seems like it would confuse people. We use language to communicate and it's better to be accurate in my opinion. Pronouns are used usually when the person being referred to isn't there anyway, in front of someone it might be "sir/lady/gentleman etc" or something and if its someone you know normally you use their name. Putting them in emails is ridiculous as when would you every use he/she when referring to someone in an email to them?

AlisonDonut · 03/07/2022 15:25

Isn't it transphobic to say 'genuine trans people'?

Not the first 'ally' to out themselves as a transphobe, not even the first this weekend.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:21

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:21

Fact is, the reason nobody can have a debate without referring to them is because they are used as a "gotcha" because you can't actually tell me what risk a genuine trans person is if they don't want to use your spaces other than the petulant "BUT THEYRE NOT A WOMAN, I AM".

I explained in depth last night. And no, it's not because "BUT THEYRE NOT A WOMAN, I AM". It's because female voices and needs exist separate to male and that needs to be recognised and respected.

But it is. It's not my teenage trans pupil making the law, so why are they the ones being mocked and ridiculed on the internet?

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:21

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:17

But I don't care what they're saying and doing.

Then you were wrong to claim "some of the poundings I've had on here have been equally as bad" when you actually had no idea whether that's true or not, and in doing so you very badly misrepresented us by implying posters on FWR would engage in doxxing and threats.

I care about genuine trans people, and women.

Of course you do. I do too. But I also care about women. And until these moderate voices speak up and make it clear that day to day courtesy like pronouns is not an endorsement for the damaging credo that gender must always come before sex, my support for trans people cannot include actions that also damage women.

I haven't been doxxed or had threats but I've had some pretty foul things said to me. These boards can be brutal and you know it.

I don't disagree with your second post. But I think feminists unforrtunately now cannot expect trans people to do anything for them. Why should they? I wouldn't.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:21

Fact is, the reason nobody can have a debate without referring to them is because they are used as a "gotcha" because you can't actually tell me what risk a genuine trans person is if they don't want to use your spaces other than the petulant "BUT THEYRE NOT A WOMAN, I AM".

I explained in depth last night. And no, it's not because "BUT THEYRE NOT A WOMAN, I AM". It's because female voices and needs exist separate to male and that needs to be recognised and respected.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:20

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 15:15

@beautyisthefaceisee you need to take up your complaints with Stonewall and TRA groups if you think ‘genuine trans people’ are suffering because feminists are saying NO. Women didn’t start this. Women have spent years trying to have discussions and solutions. Women are not backing down and playing nicely anymore. If you want solutions then you need to bring the other side to the table because women have been there for years, waiting.

But when we’ve got a point where a rape victim is being abused and pilloried for requesting ONE additional counselling group that is for women only, well then my alliegance is to women and ‘genuine trans people’ need to show some compassion about where this situation has placed women. Do you agree with what the author of the article below says? Think about her last line.

thecritic.co.uk/spaces-of-our-own/

I don't need to do shit. I'm not the one who has escalated the issue to the point that they are now an island and have nowhere to go with it. Women have done that. And they are now losing.

Is there a reason you've put "genuine" in speech marks? The only reason i need to say that is because the vast majority of people in these boards disagree with trans as a concept (and then have the bollocks to tell trans people what they should be doing!)

Why should genuine trans people show compassion for women when women show zero compassion for them? The sad thing is, they probably would. My friend certainly would. You're just not interested in their views because you can't separate trans and TRA's.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:17

But I don't care what they're saying and doing.

Then you were wrong to claim "some of the poundings I've had on here have been equally as bad" when you actually had no idea whether that's true or not, and in doing so you very badly misrepresented us by implying posters on FWR would engage in doxxing and threats.

I care about genuine trans people, and women.

Of course you do. I do too. But I also care about women. And until these moderate voices speak up and make it clear that day to day courtesy like pronouns is not an endorsement for the damaging credo that gender must always come before sex, my support for trans people cannot include actions that also damage women.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:17

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 15:10

Is there a reason not one of you is capable of having a debate without mentioning extremists on either side?

Firstly, it is not "either side". There are three main sides. Feminists are not aligned with the people who want to enforce traditional gender roles and those are the people the extremism against trans rights mostly comes from.

Secondly, you say the TRA view that sex is not socially significant and self-defined gender should take its place for all legal and social matters is extremist but as you yourself gave an example of, it is being taught in schools. It is being taught in professional training in public and private sectors. I have myself sat in it. It is the stated view of three of our four main political parties in England. It is being used by the police to define hate crimes.

If the extremists are setting the agenda then we need to talk about the extremists. Nice, rational people hiding behind the sofa are sadly irrelevant until they act.

Re where are they - hiding away from you guys because you spend your days writing about their beliefs being gender woo, nonsense, taking the piss and generally excluding them from your cause. Can't think why they wouldn't want to speak up.

I'm not asking why they are not here. Why would they be? We are not the ones they need to convince. I'm asking why they are not speaking up in public debate? Why they are not telling the politicians of those parties "no, you've got this wrong, you are listening to extremists"? Why when they see a social media pile on they are not saying "actually I am trans and I agree"?

Some are of course, but the TRA voices, the ones you claim are an extreme minority, are loudest. And as I said a few posts ago, until people like you say clearly that your kind choice to use pronouns is not an acceptance of the whole TRA project, I'm afraid that's what it's doing.

Why on earth would they speak up on social media and in public places when they are spoken about the way that they are? I wouldn't!

You're expecting them to speak up when you publicly treat them as collateral and you yourself called them "irrelevant"

So you want them to put their neck on the line so that they can be thrown to the wolf that is social media - will you be there to defend them when they get ripped to shreds? Course you won't.

Of course it's not an acceptance of the whole TRA project. How come it's acceptable to pretty much imply I'm on board with TRA - wasnt it originally that that was a strikable offence?

They are a bloody minority. The fact they are loudest is neither here nor there. I have to suffer far more of people like JKR than I do them - it is easy to ignore them. They are not sitting on MN or in the street.

Fact is, the reason nobody can have a debate without referring to them is because they are used as a "gotcha" because you can't actually tell me what risk a genuine trans person is if they don't want to use your spaces other than the petulant "BUT THEYRE NOT A WOMAN, I AM".

ExitChasedByABee · 03/07/2022 15:15

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 14:23

How is stomping your feet and saying NO going for you?

Slightly better than when we were accepting pronouns and being kind and agreeing TWAW because we thought they meant we should accept TW as if they were women socially, not that womanhood itself is a collection of mental traits found in either sex and therefore male people's experience of womanhood has no less authority than female people's. We didn't think saying TWAW to support vulnerable trans women being left alone to live their lives would turn into male bodied people in women's sport, or prisons, or taking women's officerships, or male rapists and sex offenders, crimes that are common in males and rare in females, being accepted as women, because that's not reasonable and most people are reasonable and know sex matters.

And yet, here we are. All those things are happening and anyone saying publicly this is not fair on female people is dismissed as a bigot because trans women ARE women, and if it turns out some women have the type of body that is better at sports or more likely to be physically or sexually violent or comes with 30 years of male privilege well so what? You are all women together and you should celebrate the achievements of the people who took them from you.

So now we say NO because every time we said "Yes, but...." they just took the Yes and gave us No Debate.

The only difference between us and you is we already tried the things you think will work and know they didn't.

You should look at the Hansard record from when the GRA was being debated. See things that were dismissed as fear-mongering and never-going-to-happen at the time are now framed as totally valid and transphobic to question.

You keep saying we should not base our arguments on the TRAs and that most trans people and their allies share many of our concerns. So why is it that TRAs are being left to do the lobbying and set the political and commercial agenda? Why are these moderate trans and trans-ally voices, the ones you say agree with us on many things, not speaking up? They are assuming rational voices will prevail but not taking the risk of being those rational voices. They leave it to us so they can denounce us and stay safe even when we say what they also think in private.

You say you don't want this debate to be a polarised screaming match between what you see as two equally bad sides, but your solution seems to be try to move one of the sides nearer the centre and hope the other takes the hint when it needs to be for the people already in the centre to find their voices and bloody well speak up!

(and let's be honest, we all know the reason you are trying to move us and not the TRA side us because it's safer to disagree with us than them)

This is in spades.

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 15:15

@beautyisthefaceisee you need to take up your complaints with Stonewall and TRA groups if you think ‘genuine trans people’ are suffering because feminists are saying NO. Women didn’t start this. Women have spent years trying to have discussions and solutions. Women are not backing down and playing nicely anymore. If you want solutions then you need to bring the other side to the table because women have been there for years, waiting.

But when we’ve got a point where a rape victim is being abused and pilloried for requesting ONE additional counselling group that is for women only, well then my alliegance is to women and ‘genuine trans people’ need to show some compassion about where this situation has placed women. Do you agree with what the author of the article below says? Think about her last line.

thecritic.co.uk/spaces-of-our-own/

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 15:13

Clymene · 03/07/2022 15:08

Where are the trans voices speaking up against the death threats omen are being subjected to @beautyisthefaceisee?

Again with the extremists.

I dare you to have a debate about trans, pronouns etc without mentioning TRA's. I manage it without talking about batshit feminists.

I dont know clymene, I can't think why genuine trans people wouldnt want to speak up on social media....

Swipe left for the next trending thread