Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 23:02

How do you know what I do or don't say in public? or to my friends? or what they say?

Well, because you were quite adamant that it was ridiculous to expect you and your friends to go to the places (IRL or online) where woman are being castigated for saying the things you yourself believe in and say you agree with them.

I absolutely can castigate women who don't behave well towards trans people based on TRA batshit because they are two separate things!

To you they are. But can you really blame the women who are sick of the sort of shit on terfisaslur.com for being a little less than 100% polite at times? Nothing on this board comes anywhere close to the hatred and vitriol there, or in the comments I see myself in pro-trans twitter, Medium, Facebook etc. Can I assume you condemn those people just as roundly? (And I do mean condemn them there in those places where the abuse is said, not just inside your head).

Just in case of doubt, I'm not instructing you to condemn them, or say anything, or do anything at all. I'm just telling you what I would expect you to be doing based on the values you claim to have.

YouSetTheTone · 03/07/2022 22:51

www.nytimes.com/2022/07/03/opinion/the-far-right-and-far-left-agree-on-one-thing-women-dont-count.html

for the lurkers - this article might not remain accessible for long. It’s food for thought - and pronouns are one step on the road that diminishes women.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:46

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 22:44

But given your continued (disingenuous) insistence that if I don't DO what people wat me to do then I must be a TRA supporter. You are not giving me the respect I have given you - which further proves my point that the feminists are often the ones doing the damage.

Again, no. I'm not saying you actively support the TRA agenda. I'm saying to agree in public with the TRA elements you agree with (for example, pronouns), and disagree internally but not say so in public with the parts you disagree with has the same outcome as if you actually were a supporter. And what I want you to DO (if you were to do anything) is to be as open about the elements of TRA batshit you reject when you are with "your side" as you have been here. Because if you can be honest about your reservations with your enemies (rhetorical flourish, we are not really enemies), surely it must be safe to be honest about those reservations with your friends, right?

And I'm also saying that it's not fair to castigate women on FWR who are not behaving as well as you think they should when faced with the TRA batshit, then not allow them to bring that same batshit into the conversation because you personally don't support it.

But I do agree we probably would fundamentally agree on many things. I have enjoyed talking to you, especially being challenged to properly interrogate and structure my thoughts about trans men, and I hope I've given you some things that, while you may not agree with me, have caused you to think as well.

You did make me think and reflect, until you repeatedly suggested I condone TRA's.

How do you know what I do or don't say in public? or to my friends? or what they say? You are reaching, you really are. It's almost as if you can't accept that you can be pro and accepting of trans but also back women.

I absolutely can castigate women who don't behave well towards trans people based on TRA batshit because they are two separate things!

TharBeDragons · 03/07/2022 22:45

I have a (newly promoted) colleague who calls everyone "them". I constantly reminder her of my sex and others, especially when they have this pronoun madness in an email signature. Our joint LM believes in the eradication of gender from business/public life, even though she's a woman.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:45

Clymene · 03/07/2022 22:41

@beautyisthefaceisee I can only apologise for paraphrasing. Here's what you actually typed:

I would never dismiss a personal experience out of hand, so I sont know why you needed to precede that. I believe any person who talks about their child.

And I would also be sympathetic to an autistic child who physically cannot express the change, or for any other reason ie global development cannot handle it. That said, I do think parents who are anti trans can exaggerate.

And then you went on to talk about primary school children specifically.

The article mentions a child who is unwilling to use the correct gender. Assuming no ASN, i stand behind any sanction of this absolutely. Wilful misgendeeing is a totally different thing.

You are talking about primary school children. Wilful misgendering deserves sanctions? People who try and enforce their ideology belong nowhere near children.

I believe you.

I have no reason to believe an unnamed source in the paper.

Yes, wilful, deliberate misgendering does deserve sanctions. Absolutely.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 22:44

But given your continued (disingenuous) insistence that if I don't DO what people wat me to do then I must be a TRA supporter. You are not giving me the respect I have given you - which further proves my point that the feminists are often the ones doing the damage.

Again, no. I'm not saying you actively support the TRA agenda. I'm saying to agree in public with the TRA elements you agree with (for example, pronouns), and disagree internally but not say so in public with the parts you disagree with has the same outcome as if you actually were a supporter. And what I want you to DO (if you were to do anything) is to be as open about the elements of TRA batshit you reject when you are with "your side" as you have been here. Because if you can be honest about your reservations with your enemies (rhetorical flourish, we are not really enemies), surely it must be safe to be honest about those reservations with your friends, right?

And I'm also saying that it's not fair to castigate women on FWR who are not behaving as well as you think they should when faced with the TRA batshit, then not allow them to bring that same batshit into the conversation because you personally don't support it.

But I do agree we probably would fundamentally agree on many things. I have enjoyed talking to you, especially being challenged to properly interrogate and structure my thoughts about trans men, and I hope I've given you some things that, while you may not agree with me, have caused you to think as well.

Clymene · 03/07/2022 22:41

@beautyisthefaceisee I can only apologise for paraphrasing. Here's what you actually typed:

I would never dismiss a personal experience out of hand, so I sont know why you needed to precede that. I believe any person who talks about their child.

And I would also be sympathetic to an autistic child who physically cannot express the change, or for any other reason ie global development cannot handle it. That said, I do think parents who are anti trans can exaggerate.

And then you went on to talk about primary school children specifically.

The article mentions a child who is unwilling to use the correct gender. Assuming no ASN, i stand behind any sanction of this absolutely. Wilful misgendeeing is a totally different thing.

You are talking about primary school children. Wilful misgendering deserves sanctions? People who try and enforce their ideology belong nowhere near children.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:33

I'm intrigued to know what you think it is that I must do that I'm not.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:33

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 22:29

I am frankly somehwat disappointed that you are implying that i in any way condone TRA's. I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve here but it's certainly not working. I think your tactics are disingenous.

Again, I am not saying you ARE a TRA supporter. I know you are not. I'm saying that because TRA demands are currently the dominant ones that are forming the public debate, unless you explicitly condemn the parts you disagree with your voice as an ally will be seen to condone the full package whether you want it to or not.

I'm trying to get you to see, as I said a few posts ago, that you may think you are separate yourself from TRA batshit but unless you do something about that, unless you say "I am a trans ally but I don't agree with this", that distinction only matters in your head.

And no, I didn't say join our cause. I am not trying to bully you into anything. I just want you to realise that when you treat women not deploying appropriate levels of kindness while being attacked by TRA batshit as being as bad or worse than the batshit itself, you kind of lose the right to say the batshit can't get brought up.

That's fine, Rhino.

The sad thing is we'd probably fundamentally agree with many things in real life.

But given your continued (disingenuous) insistence that if I don't DO what people wat me to do then I must be a TRA supporter. You are not giving me the respect I have given you - which further proves my point that the feminists are often the ones doing the damage.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 22:29

I am frankly somehwat disappointed that you are implying that i in any way condone TRA's. I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve here but it's certainly not working. I think your tactics are disingenous.

Again, I am not saying you ARE a TRA supporter. I know you are not. I'm saying that because TRA demands are currently the dominant ones that are forming the public debate, unless you explicitly condemn the parts you disagree with your voice as an ally will be seen to condone the full package whether you want it to or not.

I'm trying to get you to see, as I said a few posts ago, that you may think you are separate yourself from TRA batshit but unless you do something about that, unless you say "I am a trans ally but I don't agree with this", that distinction only matters in your head.

And no, I didn't say join our cause. I am not trying to bully you into anything. I just want you to realise that when you treat women not deploying appropriate levels of kindness while being attacked by TRA batshit as being as bad or worse than the batshit itself, you kind of lose the right to say the batshit can't get brought up.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/07/2022 22:28

It was in direct response to my posts and you know it

bit of both

you saying there are threads full of people taking the piss and lola saying she hadn’t seen any

I think you are both right, in different ways

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:23

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/07/2022 22:03

There was one the other day where a number of posters claimed they were going to identify as carrots, horses etc and picking pronouns and taking the piss

I was talking to lola

if you think I’m saying things that are irrelevant its probably better to just ignore them

i obviously don’t think its irrelevant or I wouldn’t be talking to lola about it

It was in direct response to my posts and you know it.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:22

Clymene · 03/07/2022 22:12

Nope, I don't think so @beautyisthefaceisee. On the one hand, you said that it's absolutely offensive for me to suggest that you wouldn't take anything a parent said as honest and truthful; on the other, you said that people who are anti trans can exaggerate.

Given that you seem to have stuck me in the anti trans camp for sticking up for women's rights, I can't see how you can also believe me.

No I didn't say anything was absolutely offensive, actually. And I also haven't stuck you in any camp. You are grasping at straws and making things up.

Clymene · 03/07/2022 22:12

Nope, I don't think so @beautyisthefaceisee. On the one hand, you said that it's absolutely offensive for me to suggest that you wouldn't take anything a parent said as honest and truthful; on the other, you said that people who are anti trans can exaggerate.

Given that you seem to have stuck me in the anti trans camp for sticking up for women's rights, I can't see how you can also believe me.

LarryBlackmonsCodpiece · 03/07/2022 22:08

pronouns are for raging narcissists

GoodJanetBadJanet · 03/07/2022 22:04

The chat about ponies and whatever certainly is
Exactly, and that was referenced in what was quoted so personally thought it was perfectly clear where and what you meant.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/07/2022 22:03

There was one the other day where a number of posters claimed they were going to identify as carrots, horses etc and picking pronouns and taking the piss

I was talking to lola

if you think I’m saying things that are irrelevant its probably better to just ignore them

i obviously don’t think its irrelevant or I wouldn’t be talking to lola about it

onlywhenidream · 03/07/2022 22:02

Each woman who opts out is saying

Woman means something other than biology

Reinforcing the stereotypes that women are -beyond biology - somehow different

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 22:00

@FlirtsWithRhinos

Nothing i have said in the last two pages refers to you. I find you to be respectful, thought provoking, intelligent and I've enjoyed your posts.

What you're quoting is a more general discussion with Janet in regards to the mockery on the boards that other PP are claming doesn't happen.

I absolutely can deny it in good faith.

I am frankly somehwat disappointed that you are implying that i in any way condone TRA's. I'm not sure what you're trying to achieve here but it's certainly not working. I think your tactics are disingenous.

For what it's worth, I will defend innocent trans people before I defend women who try and bully me into their cause by suggesting that if I don't, I must be a supporter of TRA.

Not cool.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 21:54

My favourite argument is the outrage of why trans people don't speak up and join their cause.

If you are referring to me, it's not outrage.

I'm not asking you why.

I'm not demanding you join us or outraged that you don't. I'm just explaining to you that you the argument you were trying to make - that TRAs are nothing to do with you so we shouldn't bring them up - doesn't hold water.

Because your outrage at being told your position, whether you want it to or not, backs up the demands of TRAs is only justified if you are actually saying No to the TRAs.

Because while it may make you comfortable in your own head to know that the TRA batshit is not what you believe, until this mass of trans people and allies who you say do not agree with the TRAs actually stand up and say so, until you decide that the most important challenge is to the TRA batshit rather than to the women who do not deploy appropriate levels of kindness while being attacked by that batshit, you are implicitly condoning the TRA agenda.

You may not like that, but you can't in good faith deny it. Say "not in my name" but only quietly inside your own head, and you might as well not say it at all.

So be honest. Make your choice. You can't have it both ways. Decide to stand up against TRA batshit or stop pretending you are not a part of it.

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 21:51

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/07/2022 21:45

We were doing well in respectful debate, could you keep it that way?

I haven’t been disrespectful in the slightest

The chat about ponies and whatever certainly is. It's certainly irrelevant to what we are talking about.

RufustheFloralmissingreindeer · 03/07/2022 21:45

We were doing well in respectful debate, could you keep it that way?

I haven’t been disrespectful in the slightest

GoodJanetBadJanet · 03/07/2022 21:40

making your point without being mocking of, abusive to or generally denying the identity of trans people
As I said above, YOU might not do that, but a quick scour of even these boards will show you that lots and lots of people do.
And that's what I say no to.
Agree with this
fully expects these points raised to be completely ignored by some though and complains about tone policing instead

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 21:32

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 21:31

They dont give a toss about the transpeople who are collateral.

Please stop saying that. It is not true.

We have been put in an impossible position.

We didn't start this.

We didn't ask for womanhood to be redefined to exclude us unless we lie and say we experience a commonality of mind with trans women that in reality we simply do not feel.

We didn't ask that male people who feel something that they believe makes them "the same" be given the right to access our spaces, to take our opportunities, to speak for us politically, to silence our voices if we say "no, I'm sorry, the thing you think you recognise between us is not something we recognise in ourselves".

But it happened.

So we either perform the polite actions that you feel are necessary to avoid trans people being "collateral" and in doing so capitulate to the wider ideology, which you say most trans people do not share yet do not in public refute, or we protect ourselves.

And yes, the threat to female political voice is from trans women not trans men. But as I posted to you last night, unless the dominant voices driving the trans demand to redefine sex are prepared to separate TWAW and TMAM, we have to say no to both.

So rather than just telling us that we are bad, nasty women for considering our own reality and political existence to be as important as your trans friend's, tell us how you think we can protect trans people while also protecting our own truth as female people who exist in a way that male people do not (and vice versa). I'll happily do it. But for now, these small things you think will have no cost, to me seem to have a huge cost, that of capitulating to a movement that seeks to unpower and undefine me.

By doing pretty much what you've done rhino - making your point without being mocking of, abusive to or generally denying the identity of trans people.

As I said above, YOU might not do that, but a quick scour of even these boards will show you that lots and lots of people do.

And that's what I say no to.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 21:31

They dont give a toss about the transpeople who are collateral.

Please stop saying that. It is not true.

We have been put in an impossible position.

We didn't start this.

We didn't ask for womanhood to be redefined to exclude us unless we lie and say we experience a commonality of mind with trans women that in reality we simply do not feel.

We didn't ask that male people who feel something that they believe makes them "the same" be given the right to access our spaces, to take our opportunities, to speak for us politically, to silence our voices if we say "no, I'm sorry, the thing you think you recognise between us is not something we recognise in ourselves".

But it happened.

So we either perform the polite actions that you feel are necessary to avoid trans people being "collateral" and in doing so capitulate to the wider ideology, which you say most trans people do not share yet do not in public refute, or we protect ourselves.

And yes, the threat to female political voice is from trans women not trans men. But as I posted to you last night, unless the dominant voices driving the trans demand to redefine sex are prepared to separate TWAW and TMAM, we have to say no to both.

So rather than just telling us that we are bad, nasty women for considering our own reality and political existence to be as important as your trans friend's, tell us how you think we can protect trans people while also protecting our own truth as female people who exist in a way that male people do not (and vice versa). I'll happily do it. But for now, these small things you think will have no cost, to me seem to have a huge cost, that of capitulating to a movement that seeks to unpower and undefine me.