Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 09:16

1984 obviously 😆

LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 09:16

Eliot page , since you mention him , aas dead named on twitter by some arsehole with the justification that Ellen's films stil have her name (obviously). Therss a thread on it with people saying how wonderfully brave the arsehole is. If Eliot is no risk pt you, why cant he be left the fuck alone?

see this is what I don’t get. Why it’s not enough for everyone to have to accept the person as having changed sex now, but that it somehow erases the past too. It’s like 1985 ministry of truth. EP might not like that EP is a biological female and had a female name but it is what it is. Why does stating reality and the past make someone an arsehole?

I’m not the biggest fan of Caitlyn Jenner but at least she doesn’t expect people to forget she was a bloke.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 08:41

beautyisthefaceisee · 03/07/2022 21:17

This. this this this this.

We care about women and we support their rights and we stand behind them and we value them...............until they want to be men.

Then we patronise them.

Interestingly enough, if PP do believe that that's what it is, where is the help and support for them?

I have a trans MAN friend (PP struggled with this earlier) and if you heard his story and what he had to put his body through to be able to live his life (which he now is doing, he's amazing) - how on earth anyone can think he did that cause he just didn't fancy being a woman is beyond me.

It doesn't matter how much they want to be men.

They aren't men and they never will be.

The only way we can accept them as men is if we accept that a man is something other than a male person, and a woman is something other than a female person.

And that's not something I will ever accept, because it is deeply harmful to women.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 08:39

GoodJanetBadJanet · 03/07/2022 21:12

The only issue with trans men is the idea that you can opt out of womanhood, which does us all a massive disservice
Why?
Why does it "do us all a massive disservice" what SOMEONE ELSE is?
How ridiculous.
I don't suddenly want to opt out of womanhood just because I know of the existence of trans men, it's like you're treating women as victims and it's ugh.
"Does us all" - you don't speak for all women so don't come across like you do by using the word all.
It's also seriously patronising, like they can't know their own mind and body and just want to "opt out of womanhood".

(Oh and I'm using the word Ugh because I can't articulate right now how disgusting your whole argument is.)

Why does it do us all a massive disservice?

Because if a woman is something you merely identify as, we don't need feminism.

We can eradicate the pay gap, female genital mutilation and obstetric violence just by all identifying as men!

Oh no wait, we can't do that, can we?

We aren't oppressed because we choose to be, because we "identify as women". We are oppressed because of our female bodies.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 08:37

Which proves that the whole thing isnt really about the precious belief of feminism about gender and something they hold so dear as they claim. Its about them.

No, @beautyisthefaceisee, it proves nothing of the kind.

Feminism exists, and is unfortunately necessary, because female people have been oppressed by male people throughout human history.

We can't accept or even pretend to accept people's beliefs about gender without accepting the redefinition of women not as female people, but as people who choose to identify as something.

That's incredibly insulting. There is no shared identity that all women have. And we don't experience sexism because of how we choose to identify.

What about the many many trans women who have no interest in being in your spaces?

What about them?

Eliot page , since you mention him , aas dead named on twitter by some arsehole with the justification that Ellen's films stil have her name (obviously). Therss a thread on it with people saying how wonderfully brave the arsehole is. If Eliot is no risk pt you, why cant he be left the fuck alone?

Elliot Page is no risk to me because I understand very clearly that Elliot is a woman.

I feel deeply uncomfortable with people like Elliot glamourising extreme body modification though, and the example that that sets to young women and girls.

Howcoldloveis · 04/07/2022 08:26

AlisonDonut · 04/07/2022 08:14

My stepdaughters best friend thought she was a cat for several years. We did not feed her cat food.

Kids have imaginative play but it isn't reality. What is going on with people that they lose their rational minds if someone says the word 'trans'.

I wanted to marry my dog when I was a kid.😬

AlisonDonut · 04/07/2022 08:14

My stepdaughters best friend thought she was a cat for several years. We did not feed her cat food.

Kids have imaginative play but it isn't reality. What is going on with people that they lose their rational minds if someone says the word 'trans'.

Deeplydippy74 · 04/07/2022 07:14

No I can't because I an not, against them.
I have children's friends who want identify as they for example and anything that makes life easier fir them is good imo.

AlisonDonut · 04/07/2022 07:09

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 01:07

How on earth are you still accepted as a teacher, of children, with you accepting women as being labelled "cis", a subdivision of our own sex class?

And that a 5 year old needs to be sanctioned if they 'misgender' someone.

These people are dangerous to the next generation.

We teach kids not to lie then force them to call a man 'she'.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 01:33

What was that comment in reference to?

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 01:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 01:24

Oh, and it's not scolding on here for goodness sake.
I'm not scolding you, what a bizarre take.
It's called hearing a different opinion, I'm sorry if you don't like that though.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 01:23

my question is why is it more important to you to condemn what is said here than what is said there?
I've already answered that, did you miss it or are you ignoring it?
Will give you the benefit of the doubt and answer again - why would we willingly go to hate sites to argue with extremists?
I do not want to do that.
Just because I can condemn what is said here, doesn't mean I can't condemn what is said there.
Of course I condemn threats or abuse wherever it is coming from.
Including over there and other places.

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 01:07

How on earth are you still accepted as a teacher, of children, with you accepting women as being labelled "cis", a subdivision of our own sex class?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 01:03

Don't feel you have to answer that BTW. It's more a question you could ask yourself.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 01:01

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:38

This.

Yet when people question aspects of trans, all hell breaks loose if I suggest transohobia!

The point is, to both you and BadJanet, that you say you condemn abuse and slurs in general but only actively scold the women who are reacting against the anti-woman aspects in the current construction of trans rights, leaving the worse abuse and slurs against those women in mainstream (not hate sites) pro-trans spaces unchallenged.

It's not a case of "they are worse, so we are OK", my question is why is it more important to you to condemn what is said here than what is said there?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:38

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 00:20

No, because I'm about as interested in hate sites as flying to the moon. I'm not interested in their opinion, I don't give a shit what they have to say, and I have no interest in entertaining them
Exactly, why on earth would I go to sites like that willingly?
The comment you're replying to makes no sense because if we're condemning things said here, it stands to reason we'd hate slurs and abuse elsewhere.
Just because people can be against any GC" abuse doesnt mean they automatically are fine with any TRA abuse, that's a daft take.

This.

Yet when people question aspects of trans, all hell breaks loose if I suggest transohobia!

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:36

Mummyofmaniacs · 04/07/2022 00:12

I really don't want to call people 'it'.. it seems incredibly rude, but equally to give them a multiple genders 'they' is surreal and actually quite difficult to do in a conversation

Get over yourself

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 00:20

No, because I'm about as interested in hate sites as flying to the moon. I'm not interested in their opinion, I don't give a shit what they have to say, and I have no interest in entertaining them
Exactly, why on earth would I go to sites like that willingly?
The comment you're replying to makes no sense because if we're condemning things said here, it stands to reason we'd hate slurs and abuse elsewhere.
Just because people can be against any GC" abuse doesnt mean they automatically are fine with any TRA abuse, that's a daft take.

Mummyofmaniacs · 04/07/2022 00:12

I really don't want to call people 'it'.. it seems incredibly rude, but equally to give them a multiple genders 'they' is surreal and actually quite difficult to do in a conversation

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:05

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 23:53

You're really taking the argument well look what they're saying over there, we're not as bad as them so therefore it's all OK?!

Not at all. I'm saying if you condem what's being said here but not what's being said there which IS far worse, then your problem is not in fact what is being said, but who is saying it to who.

But it goes without saying we condemn it. The fact I've got more in my life than to go over to those sites and argue with nutters doesn't mean anything.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:04

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 23:02

How do you know what I do or don't say in public? or to my friends? or what they say?

Well, because you were quite adamant that it was ridiculous to expect you and your friends to go to the places (IRL or online) where woman are being castigated for saying the things you yourself believe in and say you agree with them.

I absolutely can castigate women who don't behave well towards trans people based on TRA batshit because they are two separate things!

To you they are. But can you really blame the women who are sick of the sort of shit on terfisaslur.com for being a little less than 100% polite at times? Nothing on this board comes anywhere close to the hatred and vitriol there, or in the comments I see myself in pro-trans twitter, Medium, Facebook etc. Can I assume you condemn those people just as roundly? (And I do mean condemn them there in those places where the abuse is said, not just inside your head).

Just in case of doubt, I'm not instructing you to condemn them, or say anything, or do anything at all. I'm just telling you what I would expect you to be doing based on the values you claim to have.

No, because I'm about as interested in hate sites as flying to the moon. I'm not interested in their opinion, I don't give a shit what they have to say, and I have no interest in entertaining them.

Why on earth would I?

I've said I don't believe you're an extremist feminist, but I could ask the same question - why are you not over on the feminist boards addressing nasty threads about trans people? I wouldn't expect you to 'prove' you don't agree with them, that's not your repsonsiblity!

I understand the TRA is setting the agenda, and I understand where you're coming from (I think) but I fundamentally disagree that it's one camp or the other.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 23:53

You're really taking the argument well look what they're saying over there, we're not as bad as them so therefore it's all OK?!

Not at all. I'm saying if you condem what's being said here but not what's being said there which IS far worse, then your problem is not in fact what is being said, but who is saying it to who.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 03/07/2022 23:42

Nothing on this board comes anywhere close to the hatred and vitriol there, or in the comments I see myself in pro-trans twitter, Medium, Facebook etc.
So what if it doesn't?
You're really taking the argument well look what they're saying over there, we're not as bad as them so therefore it's all OK?!
It's not a competition. 😕

FlirtsWithRhinos · 03/07/2022 23:08

It's almost as if you can't accept that you can be pro and accepting of trans but also back women

And no, you are reading that based on your own projections. I've said numerous times that I think it's entirely possible. I gave a couple of examples I think.

But it is not possible as long as the TRA version of supporting trans people is the one that is setting the political agenda. And that's why getting to that place of genuine acceptance and support that works for both women and trans people has to start with trans people and their allies joining women and saying NO! Because until that happens, the TRA voice will continue to shape the terms of the debate and continue to drive us all to a place that cannot allow compromise.