Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 16:54

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:49

Nope. Can you expand

Basically that the feelings of trans people have to be respected or it’s “transphobic” but women who’ve said they find “cis” a slur and misogynistic aren’t entitled to do so

thats basically what you’ve said isn’t it

if I am wrong I apologise, I may have missed something in the chat

LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 16:52

I think the problem is beauty is that you are taking the stuff you are fed on school training courses as fact. It is not. It is just the opinion of whoever is leading that training.

a belief in the binary nature of sex and that it is immutable is a protected philosophical belief in law. An expression of that belief is not in and of itself “transphobic”

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:49

LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 16:48

Do you not see your double standards @beautyisthefaceisee ?

Nope. Can you expand

LovinglifeAF · 04/07/2022 16:48

Do you not see your double standards @beautyisthefaceisee ?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:43

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 16:37

Great.

By the same logic, if I find the idea that trans women are women is misogynistic, it is.

And if I say the word "cis" is an offensive slur, it is.

Unfortunately not, because it's used in schools under policy, as I've said above.

Misogyny isn't legally a hate crime.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 16:37

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:31

The thing is though, there's such a tiny nuance between what you're saying and what you're worried about saying, that I honestly think you've lost track of what is acceptable to say on that one.

Btw, legally, transphobic uses the same logic as racism. If they find it transphobic, it is.

I don't think they were tainted. I've enjoyed our conversations throughout.

Great.

By the same logic, if I find the idea that trans women are women is misogynistic, it is.

And if I say the word "cis" is an offensive slur, it is.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 16:36

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:30

No, didn't say that.

Calling Elliot a woman is transphobic.

Elliot is an adult human of the female biological sex.

Which is what the word "woman" means.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:31

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 16:27

You actually said that if I don't stand up against the TRA's, it will look like I agree with them.

Ah, so you do understand. I didn't say you did support them, I said it's the same outcome. And only, of course, in the context of there being things that you genuinely do disagree with, not an expectation of blanket condemnation.

Basically it's the difference between thinking just about your own perspective and motivations, and thinking about how your actions might impact the wider world in ways you did not intend. Thank you for acknowledging that.

So how come people on here can either not address transphobia (ie the Elliot Page comment) or border on it themselves with their views and I can't say that?

You can say what you want (as long as it's within the board rules of course). If you think something is transphobic of course you can say so. What you cannot do is expect others to agree with you.

Nor can you force them to address a "transphobia" in your terms when they may not agree with those terms.

Some things will be agreed to be transphobic by almost everyone. Some things will not considered transphobic by almost anyone. Between the two will be disagreement where people explain why they have come to the conclusion they did. In that space between the two ends of certainty yes, people may challenge assertions you make and not agree with you. They may point out that your position is inconsistent but it's not a personal attack on you. If you make a good case, which means acknowledging and engaging with their perspective rather than just blocking it, you may well change someone's views. I know my views have evolved through conversations here, sometime in ways I would never have expected. And even if you now consider all our previous interactions tainted, I think they were worthwhile.

Of course, if you repeatedly misrepresent people they will repeatedly correct that, not necessarily for your benefit but to make sure their actual message isn't missed.

I'm not sure if you noticed I didn't discuss Elliot Page at all but FWIW I am enjoying UAS3.

The thing is though, there's such a tiny nuance between what you're saying and what you're worried about saying, that I honestly think you've lost track of what is acceptable to say on that one.

Btw, legally, transphobic uses the same logic as racism. If they find it transphobic, it is.

I don't think they were tainted. I've enjoyed our conversations throughout.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 16:30

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 16:29

You're basically saying it's transphobic to believe that "women" means "female people" and "men" means "male people".

You're saying it's transphobic not to believe someone's subjective identity trumps biological reality.

That's the problem here.

No, didn't say that.

Calling Elliot a woman is transphobic.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 16:29

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:24

"what about them". Well, yes, what about them. Because they don't matter, do they?

Elliot is not a woman. That is transphobic.

You're basically saying it's transphobic to believe that "women" means "female people" and "men" means "male people".

You're saying it's transphobic not to believe someone's subjective identity trumps biological reality.

That's the problem here.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 16:27

You actually said that if I don't stand up against the TRA's, it will look like I agree with them.

Ah, so you do understand. I didn't say you did support them, I said it's the same outcome. And only, of course, in the context of there being things that you genuinely do disagree with, not an expectation of blanket condemnation.

Basically it's the difference between thinking just about your own perspective and motivations, and thinking about how your actions might impact the wider world in ways you did not intend. Thank you for acknowledging that.

So how come people on here can either not address transphobia (ie the Elliot Page comment) or border on it themselves with their views and I can't say that?

You can say what you want (as long as it's within the board rules of course). If you think something is transphobic of course you can say so. What you cannot do is expect others to agree with you.

Nor can you force them to address a "transphobia" in your terms when they may not agree with those terms.

Some things will be agreed to be transphobic by almost everyone. Some things will not considered transphobic by almost anyone. Between the two will be disagreement where people explain why they have come to the conclusion they did. In that space between the two ends of certainty yes, people may challenge assertions you make and not agree with you. They may point out that your position is inconsistent but it's not a personal attack on you. If you make a good case, which means acknowledging and engaging with their perspective rather than just blocking it, you may well change someone's views. I know my views have evolved through conversations here, sometime in ways I would never have expected. And even if you now consider all our previous interactions tainted, I think they were worthwhile.

Of course, if you repeatedly misrepresent people they will repeatedly correct that, not necessarily for your benefit but to make sure their actual message isn't missed.

I'm not sure if you noticed I didn't discuss Elliot Page at all but FWIW I am enjoying UAS3.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:59

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 15:56

If I don't stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question, I'm supporting the TRAs. a PP said that.

Assuming I am the PP:

No I didn't. Please don't misrepresent me.

You have said many times that you do not agree with many parts of the TRA position and I fully accepted that right from the first time you said it.

I have never said you must "stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question". That is either lazy hyperbole or deliberate misrepresentation. I would never, and have never, told anyone to defend something they do not believe in.

I have said that if you do not speak up about the times you do not agree with TRAs - not "stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question" but simply based on the views you already have, then your acquiesce to the views you do agree with (Like politely complying with pronouns is entirely unconnected to female disempowerment, or that it is inescapably transphobic to question whether how trans people see themselves must supercede any other source of information, or that to poke fun at the huge holes in the genderist assertions is horrid abuse) will be taken as support for the whole TRA agenda whether you do support them or not.

And I also said that telling us we cannot refer to the impact of the wider TRA agenda when explaining why we may say or do things that you (not us) consider transphobic because TRAs are a small group of nutters and most trans people and allies don't agree either is missing the point that until those trans people and allies actually stand up and say they don't agree, the agenda will continue to be driven by the small group of nutters.

I have been polite and clear despite your ongoing misrepresentation of what I am saying. I will continue to do so. But this hyperbolic misrepresentation has to stop.

You can play your word games as much as you want. It is clear what you mean.

You actually said that if I don't stand up against the TRA's, it will look like I agree with them. It's the same bloody thing.

So how come people on here can either not address transphobia (ie the Elliot Page comment) or border on it themselves with their views and I can't say that?

FlirtsWithRhinos · 04/07/2022 15:56

If I don't stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question, I'm supporting the TRAs. a PP said that.

Assuming I am the PP:

No I didn't. Please don't misrepresent me.

You have said many times that you do not agree with many parts of the TRA position and I fully accepted that right from the first time you said it.

I have never said you must "stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question". That is either lazy hyperbole or deliberate misrepresentation. I would never, and have never, told anyone to defend something they do not believe in.

I have said that if you do not speak up about the times you do not agree with TRAs - not "stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question" but simply based on the views you already have, then your acquiesce to the views you do agree with (Like politely complying with pronouns is entirely unconnected to female disempowerment, or that it is inescapably transphobic to question whether how trans people see themselves must supercede any other source of information, or that to poke fun at the huge holes in the genderist assertions is horrid abuse) will be taken as support for the whole TRA agenda whether you do support them or not.

And I also said that telling us we cannot refer to the impact of the wider TRA agenda when explaining why we may say or do things that you (not us) consider transphobic because TRAs are a small group of nutters and most trans people and allies don't agree either is missing the point that until those trans people and allies actually stand up and say they don't agree, the agenda will continue to be driven by the small group of nutters.

I have been polite and clear despite your ongoing misrepresentation of what I am saying. I will continue to do so. But this hyperbolic misrepresentation has to stop.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:34

Theeyeballsinthesky · 04/07/2022 15:29

Page is a biological woman - they can’t change that, the best they can do is present as a facsimile of a man, they can’t ever actually be a man & they’ll never be treated like one either.

No, they won't, by transphobic people, but not everyone is. Thankfully.

Theeyeballsinthesky · 04/07/2022 15:29

Page is a biological woman - they can’t change that, the best they can do is present as a facsimile of a man, they can’t ever actually be a man & they’ll never be treated like one either.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:24

Howcoldloveis · 04/07/2022 08:26

I wanted to marry my dog when I was a kid.😬

They do indeed lose their minds, but not how you mean.

To be fair, I fancied Simba.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:24

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 08:37

Which proves that the whole thing isnt really about the precious belief of feminism about gender and something they hold so dear as they claim. Its about them.

No, @beautyisthefaceisee, it proves nothing of the kind.

Feminism exists, and is unfortunately necessary, because female people have been oppressed by male people throughout human history.

We can't accept or even pretend to accept people's beliefs about gender without accepting the redefinition of women not as female people, but as people who choose to identify as something.

That's incredibly insulting. There is no shared identity that all women have. And we don't experience sexism because of how we choose to identify.

What about the many many trans women who have no interest in being in your spaces?

What about them?

Eliot page , since you mention him , aas dead named on twitter by some arsehole with the justification that Ellen's films stil have her name (obviously). Therss a thread on it with people saying how wonderfully brave the arsehole is. If Eliot is no risk pt you, why cant he be left the fuck alone?

Elliot Page is no risk to me because I understand very clearly that Elliot is a woman.

I feel deeply uncomfortable with people like Elliot glamourising extreme body modification though, and the example that that sets to young women and girls.

"what about them". Well, yes, what about them. Because they don't matter, do they?

Elliot is not a woman. That is transphobic.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:23

ExitChasedByABee · 04/07/2022 09:26

But surely asking or questioning aspects of trans is not the same as transphobia?? It would then imply that you’re shutting down any debate or discussion by even suggesting that. And then express faux innocence when “all hell breaks loose”.

You're missing my point.

If I don't stand completely in defence of feminists, completely and utterly without question, I'm supporting the TRAs. a PP said that.

But you can question any aspect of trans and I can't suggest that is transphobic?

So is the rule if you're on the feminist side, you can say what you like but if you're not, you can't?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 15:22

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 01:07

How on earth are you still accepted as a teacher, of children, with you accepting women as being labelled "cis", a subdivision of our own sex class?

Because the word "cisgender" is in our bloody training, Knitting. We got our gold award in June and it's the training.

I assume you arent suggesting I openly defy our new policy and lose my job just to keep a random on MN happy?

Where did I say I personally accept cis?

AlisonDonut · 04/07/2022 11:51

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 09:31

We can eradicate the pay gap, female genital mutilation and obstetric violence just by all identifying as men!
Er, yeah, being trans doesn't really work like that does it.
I mean if that was true we'd all do it
I'm certainly not going to want to identify as a man just to get away from being a woman!
Because, what some people don't seem to understand, is that we're not all the same.
Whereas some of us say wouldn't mind if they were a man, as they wouldn't feel any different, some like myself would mind awfully.

So you agree that women who identify as men aren't treated as men and still experience the pay gap, female genital mutilation etc etc etc...because that's transphobic.

Another ally showing how transphobic they really are.

reop · 04/07/2022 11:12

I just completed a work form and it asked me to state my pronouns but there was only the male and female options.

It was a required option with no way to bypass and it stated they are working on a. Gender inclusive solution.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 10:47

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 09:31

We can eradicate the pay gap, female genital mutilation and obstetric violence just by all identifying as men!
Er, yeah, being trans doesn't really work like that does it.
I mean if that was true we'd all do it
I'm certainly not going to want to identify as a man just to get away from being a woman!
Because, what some people don't seem to understand, is that we're not all the same.
Whereas some of us say wouldn't mind if they were a man, as they wouldn't feel any different, some like myself would mind awfully.

No, it doesn't work like that at all.

Trans men still experience misogyny and trans women still experience male privilege.

Female people - even trans men - do not benefit from this redefinition of men and women in any way.

ExitChasedByABee · 04/07/2022 09:51

GoodJanetBadJanet · 03/07/2022 23:42

Nothing on this board comes anywhere close to the hatred and vitriol there, or in the comments I see myself in pro-trans twitter, Medium, Facebook etc.
So what if it doesn't?
You're really taking the argument well look what they're saying over there, we're not as bad as them so therefore it's all OK?!
It's not a competition. 😕

@GoodJanetBadJanet I’m confused by what you’re trying to say? I am sure you are ok with calling out any hate speech so I am sure you can also do it over there? Just as I’m sure you would on any other site that you’re on if someone is being transphobic? Besides, who said it was a competition?

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 09:31

We can eradicate the pay gap, female genital mutilation and obstetric violence just by all identifying as men!
Er, yeah, being trans doesn't really work like that does it.
I mean if that was true we'd all do it
I'm certainly not going to want to identify as a man just to get away from being a woman!
Because, what some people don't seem to understand, is that we're not all the same.
Whereas some of us say wouldn't mind if they were a man, as they wouldn't feel any different, some like myself would mind awfully.

ExitChasedByABee · 04/07/2022 09:26

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 00:38

This.

Yet when people question aspects of trans, all hell breaks loose if I suggest transohobia!

But surely asking or questioning aspects of trans is not the same as transphobia?? It would then imply that you’re shutting down any debate or discussion by even suggesting that. And then express faux innocence when “all hell breaks loose”.

Swipe left for the next trending thread