Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:21

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:13

Almost no one "identifies as the sex they were born with".
How can you state that as fact?
I certainly do.
I'm not arrogant enough to presume I'm the only one who does, either.
So there must be more.

so do I.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:21

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2022 21:19

Oh come on, Keating,. I can't win here

Thats pretty much the point.

You cant 'treat trans women as women' and simultaneously safeguard same sex spaces for things like rape crisis centres.

Its not possible. Those positions contradict each other.

But you don't want to engage with that contradiction. You want to fudge it and then call anyone who points out the issues with unilaterally 'treating trans women as women' as transphobic.

Despite the fact that it's actually totally in line with your own position.

Well, if you want to push me, which you clearly do, you will push me towards being pro trans, come what may.

Because you wont let me support trans but support feminists in certain situations.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:20

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:19

Right, but no one is trying to make you pray to God or observe Ramadan.

That's the difference.

Of course you are.

At weddings, at funerals, at Easter, at Christmas, whenever anyone posts anything about the afterlife on social media which is most days.....

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2022 21:19

Oh come on, Keating,. I can't win here

Thats pretty much the point.

You cant 'treat trans women as women' and simultaneously safeguard same sex spaces for things like rape crisis centres.

Its not possible. Those positions contradict each other.

But you don't want to engage with that contradiction. You want to fudge it and then call anyone who points out the issues with unilaterally 'treating trans women as women' as transphobic.

Despite the fact that it's actually totally in line with your own position.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:19

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:18

So I'm an atheist. Massively so.

Can I then tell the people I know that granny isn't really "going to be with x" but she is going to be in her coffin?

Can I refute that anyone is "off to be a better place" or "in peace"?

Do my views count over what I think is a made up ideology?

NO?

Why not?

Right, but no one is trying to make you pray to God or observe Ramadan.

That's the difference.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:18

So I'm an atheist. Massively so.

Can I then tell the people I know that granny isn't really "going to be with x" but she is going to be in her coffin?

Can I refute that anyone is "off to be a better place" or "in peace"?

Do my views count over what I think is a made up ideology?

NO?

Why not?

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:18

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:17

I accept their belief, yes, absolutely. Nothing to do with being kind.

Why should i accept your belief that cisgender is offensive when logistically and legally it isn't when you won't accept my trans friends?

I accept my Christian friends' beliefs. I do not share them.

Do you genuinely believe that you "identify as" your sex?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:17

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:12

Almost no one "identifies as the sex they were born with".

Very few people think accepting the reality that you have a vagina and not a penis - or vice versa - is an identity.

In reality I think only trans people believe this is an identity, and a few people like you are willing to pretend you believe it is one in order to "be kind".

I accept their belief, yes, absolutely. Nothing to do with being kind.

Why should i accept your belief that cisgender is offensive when logistically and legally it isn't when you won't accept my trans friends?

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:15

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:13

Almost no one "identifies as the sex they were born with".
How can you state that as fact?
I certainly do.
I'm not arrogant enough to presume I'm the only one who does, either.
So there must be more.

Great, what does that mean to you?

What are you identifying with?

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:13

Almost no one "identifies as the sex they were born with".
How can you state that as fact?
I certainly do.
I'm not arrogant enough to presume I'm the only one who does, either.
So there must be more.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:13

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:11

Regressive and sexist? Maybe.

And transpeople have the right to their definition, despite the fact you think it's made up.

Yeah but what they don't have is the right to define me - as "cisgender" - or redefine me - by appropriating the word "woman".

They need to get their own vocabulary for their religion and leave the rest of us out of it.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:12

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:10

A person (not woman) identifying as the sex they were born with.

Almost no one "identifies as the sex they were born with".

Very few people think accepting the reality that you have a vagina and not a penis - or vice versa - is an identity.

In reality I think only trans people believe this is an identity, and a few people like you are willing to pretend you believe it is one in order to "be kind".

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:11

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:10

"Cis" is short for "cisgender".

Calling someone "cis" means you are defining them by reference to gender.

This is inherently offensive because gender is just regressive and sexist stereotypes.

We have the right not to be defined according to these things.

Regressive and sexist? Maybe.

And transpeople have the right to their definition, despite the fact you think it's made up.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 21:10

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 20:58

Can you define the word cisgender?

A person (not woman) identifying as the sex they were born with.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:10

"Cis" is short for "cisgender".

Calling someone "cis" means you are defining them by reference to gender.

This is inherently offensive because gender is just regressive and sexist stereotypes.

We have the right not to be defined according to these things.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:09

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:07

Can you define the word cisgender?
what has that got to do with us saying we don't find cisgender offensive?
posters saying they can say what they like that they don't believe the ideology - you've blatantly skipped the question asked (which was so we can say cis, no?) and trotted out "define"
why?
it's like you're trying to just set it back round in circles.
What about what beauty asked?

I don't think you should be calling people something you can't define.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:07

Can you define the word cisgender?
what has that got to do with us saying we don't find cisgender offensive?
posters saying they can say what they like that they don't believe the ideology - you've blatantly skipped the question asked (which was so we can say cis, no?) and trotted out "define"
why?
it's like you're trying to just set it back round in circles.
What about what beauty asked?

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 21:04

I think you may be confusing the right not to have other people's beliefs forced upon you - which is the right I am asserting, with the "right" to force your beliefs on others, which is what you appear to think you have.

Calling people "cis" is forcing your beliefs on others.

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 21:02

then I can use the word cis in my workplace since I don't find it offensive, no?
Exactly.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 20:58

Can you define the word cisgender?

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 20:53

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 20:48

I would in mine, yes.

But I don't work in the UK.

If I worked in the UK I would be afraid to, and I think that is fundamentally wrong.

I am allowed to say I don't believe in God, so why shouldn't I be allowed to say I don't believe in gender ideology? This is the only unprovable belief people are essentially forced to hold or pretend they hold. Why?

then I can use the word cis in my workplace since I don't find it offensive, no?

GoodJanetBadJanet · 04/07/2022 20:52

Their identity has nothing to do with me - or other people in general - which is why I believe they should use a different word for it
See that's where we differ - Whereas I agree other people's identity has nothing to do with me, that's why I don't have a problem with using their pronouns as that's up to them.
They're their own person, they're not me.

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 20:52

TheKeatingFive · 04/07/2022 20:18

Because it's not black and white.

well sex actually is, sorry to contradict you

Certain things, for me, have exceptions.

but you didn't allow the others you labelled transphobic to have these exceptions. They were just plain transphobic for doing exactly what you're doing now.

Is it just you that gets to have exceptions?

Oh come on, Keating,. I can't win here.

You must see that.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 20:51

Yet trans people have to listen to how they're either not trans, cause it's made up, or they are trans, to get into womens' bathrooms, or they are trans, because they want to escape being a woman (depending on who wants to pull them into politics first).

Someone being trans isn't inconsistent with it all being made up.

We can acknowledge that Christians exist even if we don't believe in God.

Ultimately their motivation for being trans is irrelevant. They aren't entitled to redefine what the words "man" and "woman" mean.

babyjellyfish · 04/07/2022 20:48

beautyisthefaceisee · 04/07/2022 18:59

@beautyisthefaceisee out of interest..

Would you Express in your workplace that you see trans as an ideology?

I would in mine, yes.

But I don't work in the UK.

If I worked in the UK I would be afraid to, and I think that is fundamentally wrong.

I am allowed to say I don't believe in God, so why shouldn't I be allowed to say I don't believe in gender ideology? This is the only unprovable belief people are essentially forced to hold or pretend they hold. Why?