Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Pronouns - Can someone remind me why we are against this in emails

916 replies

landantan · 30/06/2022 15:37

Hi

Can someone remind me why some people (likely myself included) does not agree with stated pronouns in email signatures?

It is being requested at work from the perspective of being a small step to being an ally to LGBTQ+ community.

I just think it is a bit pointless and whilst I have nothing against this or any other community I cannot see what knowing or sharing pronouns really does apart from make you look like a bit of a tit.

Can someone offer a more articulate explanation please?

OP posts:
Helleofabore · 05/07/2022 18:36

Good to see that we have the usual ‘you are mean’ and ‘you are rude’ on this thread. Nothing new.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 18:31

SmashingEgg · 05/07/2022 15:33

I have today received an email from my energy provider asking me if I want to add a pronoun to my name.
My reply wasn't quite what they expect I would imagine.
To say I was furious is an understatement.

Why on earth would you be "furious"? NO thanks will do. It's not about you.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 18:31

YouSetTheTone · 05/07/2022 18:09

Please do explain exactly what is offensive about this. The fact that it’s the truth?

Lots of offensive things are also true.

I honestly don't understand how human beings can't see that.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 18:30

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 15:23

I'd rather be woke than a rude person that hurts peoples feelings (I'm being polite)

Why are the feelings of this one group the only feelings that matter?

they're not.

But I'm not prioritising JUST women. Amazing, that.

YouSetTheTone · 05/07/2022 18:09

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 15:09

It is offensive, yes.

Please do explain exactly what is offensive about this. The fact that it’s the truth?

SmashingEgg · 05/07/2022 15:33

I have today received an email from my energy provider asking me if I want to add a pronoun to my name.
My reply wasn't quite what they expect I would imagine.
To say I was furious is an understatement.

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 15:23

I'd rather be woke than a rude person that hurts peoples feelings (I'm being polite)

Why are the feelings of this one group the only feelings that matter?

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 15:22

'Ridiculous state if handwringing'but trans people arent handwrjnging. Feminists are. It's rather mean of you to call people on your side hand wringing, really.

Why would they?

They're being given everything they want, at the expense of women.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 15:17

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 14:00

I know.

I'm not the one pushing it.

Just giving some context for the lurkers. And how we got to this ridiculous state of handwringing about what we dare to call ourselves.

'Ridiculous state if handwringing'but trans people arent handwrjnging. Feminists are. It's rather mean of you to call people on your side hand wringing, really.

I thought of you today. I saw a picture that said I am happy to be woke, I'd rather be woke than a rude person that hurts peoples feelings (I'm being polite)

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 15:14

She makes a good point though, @beautyisthefaceisee.

Absolutely nothing about a male person who has taken all the hormones and had all the surgery is female.

And the things they have done to achieve some sort of visual approximation of a female body are things no female person has ever done or will ever do or can ever relate to in any way.

And they have never done and will never do and can never relate to anything about being female.

beautyisthefaceisee · 05/07/2022 15:09

YouSetTheTone · 04/07/2022 22:47

@beautyisthefaceisee
you say that you consider a person who has ‘fully transitioned’ is actually a woman. You do understand don’t you that ‘fully transitioned’ means that the man has had radical cosmetic surgery to remove his genitals and fashion a neo-vagina out of his colon? It means feminising surgery to reduce the size of his Adam’s apple and various other cosmetic procedures to create a more ‘feminine’ appearance. It does not and can never mean they have changed sex.
So in what way do you consider them a woman? They will never go through any biological process that an adult human female does.

That all sounds harsh but I genuinely don’t understand how you consider that a woman = a man without a penis. This is offensive to both men and women.

If I have my male dog castrated it is still a male dog.

It is offensive, yes.

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 14:00

I know.

I'm not the one pushing it.

Just giving some context for the lurkers. And how we got to this ridiculous state of handwringing about what we dare to call ourselves.

IDidntKnowItWasAParty · 05/07/2022 13:56

Because humans cannot change sex

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 13:25

I don't disagree, but I don't think they even thought or cared about what the women included actually feel or identify as...it's just a way to say 'transwomen and CIS women' make up the category of women. The 'what this means' came long after they placed all non-trans people into the category 'cis'.

We don't need a word for that though.

I don't need to describe myself as "a biological woman who does not suffer from dysphoria", just like I don't need a word to describe myself as "not Chinese", "not a dog owner" or "not allergic to peanuts".

I certainly don't "identify as a woman", and even if "vagina + no dysphoria" were an identity, it wouldn't be the same identity as "penis + dysphoria".

EagleThrustSeven · 05/07/2022 12:38

The pronouns thing is a nonsense (like so much in the world of LGBT, imo).

Pronouns are actually specified by the rules of the language we speak - we don't get to select them ourselves.

If we all started selecting our own pronouns / other words, our system of language would collapse.

Like the nonsensical made-up genders, if campaigners can get reality (men & women, him/her etc) relegated from being reality to just one of many options, then it gives credence to their false claims that their are many genders and pronouns options.

There are not.

People should refuse to indulge in this nonsense, even though it if often pitched as being inclusive etc. Obviously inclusion is a good thing, but not at the expense of dignifying nonsense.

If employers try to force the matter, play them at their own game.

If I was forced to pick pronouns, mine would be:

jinga / jonga / bingabonga

And I would scream blue murder anytime someone forgot or got it wrong.

A full on, spittle-flecked, "LGBT special" meltdown about 'bigotry' etc. I would be on to HR and everything.

I would actually quite enjoy the humour in that, but Im fundamentally too sensible / busy for this kind of nonsense!

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 12:30

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 11:57

The core issue of all of this for me is, that if you 'believe' that a man saying words automatically becomes a member of the opposite sex, for whatever reason and you include him as such, then you need another word to describe the actual members of the opposite sex. And we've seen for years that they are now calling men 'women' and women 'cis women'. So sidelining us from our own sex category.

But even "cis women" doesn't mean adult humans of the female biological sex.

It means adult humans of the female biological sex who don't believe they identify as something other than a woman.

So it doesn't include female people who believe they identify as trans men or non binary, meaning it's not a word for all adult humans of the female biological sex. It's a word for adult humans of the female biological sex who call themselves women. It automatically reframes womanhood as something you can identify into.

I don't disagree, but I don't think they even thought or cared about what the women included actually feel or identify as...it's just a way to say 'transwomen and CIS women' make up the category of women. The 'what this means' came long after they placed all non-trans people into the category 'cis'.

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 11:57

The core issue of all of this for me is, that if you 'believe' that a man saying words automatically becomes a member of the opposite sex, for whatever reason and you include him as such, then you need another word to describe the actual members of the opposite sex. And we've seen for years that they are now calling men 'women' and women 'cis women'. So sidelining us from our own sex category.

But even "cis women" doesn't mean adult humans of the female biological sex.

It means adult humans of the female biological sex who don't believe they identify as something other than a woman.

So it doesn't include female people who believe they identify as trans men or non binary, meaning it's not a word for all adult humans of the female biological sex. It's a word for adult humans of the female biological sex who call themselves women. It automatically reframes womanhood as something you can identify into.

AlisonDonut · 05/07/2022 11:00

The core issue of all of this for me is, that if you 'believe' that a man saying words automatically becomes a member of the opposite sex, for whatever reason and you include him as such, then you need another word to describe the actual members of the opposite sex. And we've seen for years that they are now calling men 'women' and women 'cis women'. So sidelining us from our own sex category.

Many people are opposed to this as we know that many men will use this to gain access to women's spaces, some of us have known about this for decades.

They rarely do this to men, calling women 'men' and men 'cis men'. Because there are less 'be kind' men than there are women. 'Be kind' equates to 'gullible' or 'scared shitless that someone will attack me for knowing that sex exists'.

Pronouns, which this thread is all about, are just a methodology of reinforcing this ideology and have been used by Stonewall as an example of organisations 'committment' to 'inclusion' and hence HR departments who have to justify spending £ on Stonewall are pushing it to show how very good they are being.

xeyages · 05/07/2022 09:49

This reply has been deleted

This has been deleted by MNHQ for breaking our Talk Guidelines.

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 09:45

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 09:35

For me the core issue is that this movement demands to redefine Man and Woman as groups that can include either sex, but refuses to allow a backfill of sex into new words. It's not enough that we recognise gender, we have to unrecognise sex in any legal, social or physical arena other than medicine.

And that is because the meaning of women for these people, which some even admit, is "oh all the people who we already know are women, plus some male people who see themselves as the same". The role of those "people who we already know are women" is to just pretend nothing has changed and keep doing what they always did so the male people have the female world they identify into kept intact as the place they want it to be.

To this movement sex and gender are different when a male person identifies as a woman, but the same when female people ask for sex-specific provisions to backfill the support they lose when women's provisions become mixed sex.

Yep.

"Sex and gender are different" is the official explanation for why some male people are apparently women, but they insist on using the same words for sex and gender, and can't explain what gender is or why it is something we need to pay any attention to.

The way I see it is this: other than in situations where biological sex is relevant, you shouldn't be treating men and women differently.

FlirtsWithRhinos · 05/07/2022 09:35

For me the core issue is that this movement demands to redefine Man and Woman as groups that can include either sex, but refuses to allow a backfill of sex into new words. It's not enough that we recognise gender, we have to unrecognise sex in any legal, social or physical arena other than medicine.

And that is because the meaning of women for these people, which some even admit, is "oh all the people who we already know are women, plus some male people who see themselves as the same". The role of those "people who we already know are women" is to just pretend nothing has changed and keep doing what they always did so the male people have the female world they identify into kept intact as the place they want it to be.

To this movement sex and gender are different when a male person identifies as a woman, but the same when female people ask for sex-specific provisions to backfill the support they lose when women's provisions become mixed sex.

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 09:30

Or others have the right to believe that if they want but not to push it onto others and call them “transphobic” if they don’t agree.

They especially shouldn't be pushing it onto impressionable children, which is one of the reasons why the kind of "training"@beautyisthefaceisee talks about above is so very dangerous.

It's promoting gender ideology as though it is real, to people who are too young to see through it.

LovinglifeAF · 05/07/2022 09:20

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 08:55

Yes, for me this is one of the most disturbing things.

In previous generations, children grew up believing that a boy is a child with a willy and a girl is a child without a willy. Very occasionally, someone - usually male - would reach adulthood with long term, persistent dysphoria, and after researching the subject, would learn about transgenderism and the fact that some people take hormones and have surgery to ease their dysphoria.

Now children are being taught that they can choose whether to be a boy or a girl. God only knows what they believe boys and girls are, but they believe they can choose. In the same way that kids believe in Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy. So a little boy decides he's actually a little girl, and, encouraged by well meaning teachers and parents, changes his name and pronouns and starts wearing dresses. Children eventually realise that Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy aren't real. But boys and girls are real. So those children are never going to get to an age when they and all their friends realise this stuff isn't real. But they are going to get to an age where, despite having genuinely believed for the last five, six, seven years that they are the opposte sex, they learn that they are going to go through the "wrong" puberty.

What the hell do you do at this point? You either say, "Actually, we lied to you, you were a boy all along, and now you are going to go through male puberty and become a man, sorry about that!" or you say yes to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones, surgery and all the rest of it, meaning that that child has no hope of ever living a normal life, will never have children of their own or any kind of sexual function.

Is this really supposed to be the kind option? Kinder than saying, "No dear, you've got a willy, that means you're a boy"?

Or others have the right to believe that if they want but not to push it onto others and call them “transphobic” if they don’t agree.

babyjellyfish · 05/07/2022 08:55

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 23:57

People - humans, mammals - cannot ever change sex.
It's very cruel to push the lie on children and adults that "sex change" is possible, and even desirable; because it's not. It is particularly vicious to promote this lie among children, who tend to believe what they are told by adults.

That's it. Bare fact. People cannot change their sex.

Announcing pronouns, it just seeks to police people's speech and people's thoughts, and wrap it up in a fascist world view where only one view can ever be acceptable.

No.

Yes, for me this is one of the most disturbing things.

In previous generations, children grew up believing that a boy is a child with a willy and a girl is a child without a willy. Very occasionally, someone - usually male - would reach adulthood with long term, persistent dysphoria, and after researching the subject, would learn about transgenderism and the fact that some people take hormones and have surgery to ease their dysphoria.

Now children are being taught that they can choose whether to be a boy or a girl. God only knows what they believe boys and girls are, but they believe they can choose. In the same way that kids believe in Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy. So a little boy decides he's actually a little girl, and, encouraged by well meaning teachers and parents, changes his name and pronouns and starts wearing dresses. Children eventually realise that Father Christmas, the Easter Bunny and the Tooth Fairy aren't real. But boys and girls are real. So those children are never going to get to an age when they and all their friends realise this stuff isn't real. But they are going to get to an age where, despite having genuinely believed for the last five, six, seven years that they are the opposte sex, they learn that they are going to go through the "wrong" puberty.

What the hell do you do at this point? You either say, "Actually, we lied to you, you were a boy all along, and now you are going to go through male puberty and become a man, sorry about that!" or you say yes to puberty blockers, cross sex hormones, surgery and all the rest of it, meaning that that child has no hope of ever living a normal life, will never have children of their own or any kind of sexual function.

Is this really supposed to be the kind option? Kinder than saying, "No dear, you've got a willy, that means you're a boy"?

KnittingWords · 04/07/2022 23:57

People - humans, mammals - cannot ever change sex.
It's very cruel to push the lie on children and adults that "sex change" is possible, and even desirable; because it's not. It is particularly vicious to promote this lie among children, who tend to believe what they are told by adults.

That's it. Bare fact. People cannot change their sex.

Announcing pronouns, it just seeks to police people's speech and people's thoughts, and wrap it up in a fascist world view where only one view can ever be acceptable.

No.

Swipe left for the next trending thread