Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely hurt - mother birthday drama

212 replies

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 14:15

Have posted on here a few times over the years under different usernames for family advice, and you guys have always been fantastic. Long story short, my older brother is the golden child. My mother always puts him and his family first. My brother and I are not speaking (this is his fault, please trust me on that) and my mother had chosen to take his side and consequently we (husband, Children and I) are always left out of stuff. Ironically brother treats her like shit she is never included in his life and I include her always (invite her on holidays and heavily involve her in stuff as she is lonely and loves to be involved with grandchildren as brother shuts her out).

my son turns 5 next week. His actual birthday is a weekday, DM asks what we are doing. We are doing cake and presents after school. She asks if she can come. We say of course. DS is excited and has mentioned the plan several times. Today DM says she now has other plans, tickets to an event at 3pm so maybe she can “pop” at his bedtime. Maybe. Guess who other plans are with? That’s right.

is it too much to expect her to keep my son’s birthday free as fucking agreed and not treat him like an afterthought she can “pop” and see when she’s finished with her preferred plan with golden child, which she made AFTER saying she would come.

OP posts:
Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:51

*I wonder if you let others down if your mother wants to make an appearance or change plans because your mother wants to see you all?

You haven’t addressed this when others have asked - why not? Look at yourself and your behaviour and see if anything clicks*

when has someone else asked that? I have addressed it I have said it’s a very good point and food for thought. I have never, ever let someone down because my mother has changed plans etc. I wouldn’t do that - it’s rude.

OP posts:
Rainbowdrops2021 · 30/06/2022 19:50

Also it’s so easy to do what pp have suggested like saying something sarcastic or angry and taking a swipe but I did this numerous times and it never worked. I think being heartfelt and saying honestly how much it hurt me my whole life before walking away was what made her realise I wasn’t just causing drama.

Wouldliketobehappy · 30/06/2022 19:48

I agree with some of the other comments about not accommodating her so much. I have heard this issue many times before i.e parents favouring the kids who give nothing and treating the children who support their parents with less regard.
I would step back a bit, let your brother get on and organise things for you mum. She treats you as second best so put your children first and don't bother inviting her to everything.

Rinatinabina · 30/06/2022 19:48

Are you sure your brother didn’t actually cancel her and she’s back to her back up plan (you).

Honestly stop doing this to yourself. She doesn’t actually care how she makes you feel or your son. If she did she wouldn’t drop you like a stone every time your brother called. Stop making plans with her, it’s not your problem if she ends up alone at xmas because she was angling for an invite from your brother, she probably enjoys you fussing over it.

Sometimes our parents are not who we would have liked them to be. It’s not your fault (you really need to understand that it does not matter what you do, you can be wonderful and kind and welcoming and she will always prefer your brother) but you are under no obligation to be doormat.

Threetulips · 30/06/2022 19:47

She was shifty as fuck when she told me she must KNOW it’s cunty what she’s done, but as a PP says she needs the crumbs she’s offered

But you’re doing the same - taking the crumbs from her -

I wonder if you let others down if your mother wants to make an appearance or change plans because your mother wants to see you all?

You haven’t addressed this when others have asked - why not? Look at yourself and your behaviour and see if anything clicks.

laurenlodge · 30/06/2022 19:45

I think if it were me I would say she was no longer invited, unless you can be absolutely sure she won't say or do anything to sour the atmosphere on the day. Your son deserves someone who genuinely wants to be there....

goldfinchonthelawn · 30/06/2022 19:45

I really sympathise. I asked my mother once - once - to babysit for a massive charity fundraising event I was organising that meant DH and I would be out until very late. I booked them months in advance and told them how important it was. The day before, after I'd cleaned the spare room and bought an easy supper for them all, my mum rang up and said, 'Oh we've just been invited to supper by our neighbours so can't babysit anymore.'

I was so upset I just said, 'Fine' and hung up. It made me realise how utterly low priority me and my children were to her and always had been. She is a very sweet woman - everyone who meets her adores her. And all the rest of the family think she's a saint. But we are not important in her life.

billy1966 · 30/06/2022 19:44

@RandomMess has nailed it as usual.

You have accepted poor treatment in adulthood and are now allowing it to be a part of your childrens lives.

Your children will see the upset, hurt and mistreatment that you accept from your mother and it will become their norm too.

Your mother behaves badly because she thinks she can.

You accept her treating you and your family badly because you too believe you don't deserve any better.

Her behaviour is awful, but you accept it.

If you wanted your children to learn a healthy message you would model it yourself.

But you don't.

You deserve better OP.
So do your children.

I mean this very kindly but mothers with healthy boundaries would never accept this treatment of their children.

Stop looking at your mothers behaviour and look at your own.

Your children deserve better than this treatment.

Pixiedust1234 · 30/06/2022 19:41

As so often happens on mn, you have a dm problem and not a db problem in this dynamic. Separate the two problems.

Only involve your mother with the children when it isn't so important, ie not to come on actual birthday but at the weekend or if you hold a birthday party with friends etc as then there will be others around to help dilute the disappointment if she bails. Dont tell the children she is coming, wait until she arrives....its the same scenarios that divorced women have to do all the time with deadbeat dads. That is what she is so do the same protections for your children. Good luck, I know its hard.

WhatsInAMolatovMocktail · 30/06/2022 19:40

I like what @KittyKittyKat said. Don’t let her see she is getting to you. And don’t let her write the narrative

A light reply along the lines “well I’m glad you finally realised how disappointing it is for DC not to see you for his birthday tea after you asked and promised to come. However because you said you weren’t coming, I already let him down gently and explained you couldn’t come any more. I didn’t tell him you had a better offer from DB of course as there is no way to explain that to a 5 year old. I made up another excuse. So it really would be better if you came a different day, which leaves you free to do the important event with DB that day. Another time, we won’t make plans for you to see DC on his actual birthday, we can just pick a weekend nearby, and then we won’t end up in this pickle again where you findyou have something you absolutely can’t say no to when to DB asks, and end up disappointing DC. I can’t stand to see him disappointed, especially on his birthday.”

Rainbowdrops2021 · 30/06/2022 19:37

My mum was like this, she always put my sister first. I knew she loved me but it could be really hurtful the things she would say and do without realising. I became kind of obsessed with it and realised I needed to tell her how I felt and step away, stop trying to please her and be the “favourite” because it was exhausting. When she had some time to reflect and miss me her attitude completely changed and so did my relationship with my sister. I realised that the way we were treated and my jealousy over it was what caused tension between us and it wasn’t her fault. We all have a much better relationship now in fact my mum and sister are my best friends and my mum has apologised for her past actions. It turns out my sister wasn’t really the golden child but my mum had held on to guilt from suffering with pnd after having her and had fallen into this cycle of trying to make it up to her from a young age and I guess it just never stopped.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 30/06/2022 19:35

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:27

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps

spot on post.

if my mother only knew some of the shocking and entitled shit DB said about her….I mean she wouldn’t do anything about it but Christ it’s depressing.

Important not to repeat the cycle!

Flowers
Pallisers · 30/06/2022 19:34

I don't think you need to go no contact but you need to understand what low contact should entail. So when she says she'll pop by, you say "sure that would be nice" and don't bother telling your son. Don't have him expect her, don't build anything around it. If she cancels, then whatever. If she shows up, no big deal. If you invite her for christmas and she says she isn't sure yet say "no problem we'll plan without you. maybe next year". and stick to it. IF she comes back to you and says "oh I don't have plans as it happens, say oh what a pity, we already made our plans". Don't invite her for holidays. Meals together can be very rare. if she dumps you or fails you your response is "I didn't expect you anyway" not anything emotional because your emotions need to be low contact too - just don't bother too much about her. don't try to change her. don't have conversations about your brother. cut off the source of her enjoyment.

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:29

The problem is that even though she has now done the right thing and cancelled the ticketed event to come, the damage has been done because she thought it was ok to do that in the first place!

OP posts:
Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:29

If you are nc with your brother - it is probably better not to talk to her about him at all

this is how it’s supposed to be, but she can’t help herself. She makes it very clear when she is seeing him by being very over the top “I’m going to X with SOMEONE” “oh I just have to run off now I have to see….I have to go”
but in a way where it’s clear she wants me to know who she means but doesn’t want to be accused of speaking about him. I think she enjoys it

OP posts:
SettingsO · 30/06/2022 19:28

Actually we’ve decided now to have a fun afternoon of celebration with x, so we’ll be swimming or movies and then eating out. Not sure what time we’ll be home and don’t want to make firm plans around that, so we’ll see you some time later that week

this is a good message

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:27

@WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps

spot on post.

if my mother only knew some of the shocking and entitled shit DB said about her….I mean she wouldn’t do anything about it but Christ it’s depressing.

Important not to repeat the cycle!

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 30/06/2022 19:26

She ' thinks it's 'safer' to upset you than your brother. When I stopped this dynamic she altered her ways. Not only did I get more appreciation from my mother when I refused to be messed about, I gained a lot more self respect'

This is a good point.
Don't go no contact - but don't run around to pick up the pieces.
If you are nc with your brother - it is probably better not to talk to her about him at all.

WhileMyGuitarGentlyWeeps · 30/06/2022 19:25

I am really sorry for you @Herewegoagainffs and agree with PPs that you should go no-contact or very low contact. Stop giving into her and taking the crumbs she throws out.

Sadly, it's not uncommon for women (particularly women born before 1960 I find,) to favour the boys in the family. My brother was OK as a kid (he's 7 years younger than me,) but from about 16-18 turned into a total arse. Became this way (I believe) because of being worshipped by the women in the family - particularly my mother and grandmother.

He is very selfish and self centred and grabby and has had 1000s and 1000s of £££ dished out to him, that he has never given back. I went low contact some 12-13 years ago when our parents died, but in the eyes of my mother he could do no wrong, and also in the eyes of my aunts and my grandmother. Similarly, my mother's mother favoured my mother's brother too. So you'd think she'd know what it's like!!!

I know SO many women whose mothers, grandmothers and aunts favoured the boys/men in the family, even though they were/are mostly useless selfish lumps who do fuck-all for them. The girls/women give their all, fetch and carry, take them out (shopping/to appointments/day trips etc,) and act like the dutiful daughters, whilst the men in the family do shag-all, and yet the men are adored and worshipped.

Got on my tits SO much (and that of my 3 female cousins who had the same thing happening.) Doesn't seem to happen as much with the newer generations of mothers (born post 1960,) but it still does a bit.

sundaydriver · 30/06/2022 19:25

Vivi0 · 30/06/2022 15:30

This.

The situation is not your brother’s fault.

This dynamic has been set by one person and one person only: your mum.

I'm not certain the DB isn't stirring the pot here, though.

Very interesting timing that he suddenly wants to invite her to a ticketed event on the exact time and exact date of your son's birthday celebration.

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:24

@NotMyDust

shes on her own, yes. There are other siblings actually but they aren’t relevant to this specific dynamic. Another one is NC with her due to golden child. Another one is entranced by golden child. It’s very unhealthy tbh. I would say she definitely delights in the chasm and enjoys the power of the gatekeeper and speaking to golden child when 2 of us aren’t (because she sees that as a punishment for us I think). However golden child is also a total wanker, and she’s not manipulating him.

OP posts:
NotMyDust · 30/06/2022 19:21

agree she's possibly 'trying' - or just caught up in acting out- to play you both off each other to get her emotional kicks. is her life a bit empty? you don't mention your dad at all, am guessing she's on her own?

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 19:20

She was in the wrong by changing her plans and letting your DC down. That was bad manners

I said exactly this to her.

OP posts:
LiesDoNotBecomeUs · 30/06/2022 19:20

Take the whole brother thing out of this. It is being used to make you feel you need to fight your side. You really don't.

She was in the wrong by changing her plans and letting your DC down. That was bad manners.

No drama - it was just rudeness.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 30/06/2022 19:11

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 18:54

@CrikeyAlmightyOk

quite possibly

Will be good if she is on mumsnet. She might see this and hopefully, but doubtfully, see sense that she has created a brat out of her son and yet praises him for it and ignores her daughter. Stupid woman.