Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be extremely hurt - mother birthday drama

212 replies

Herewegoagainffs · 30/06/2022 14:15

Have posted on here a few times over the years under different usernames for family advice, and you guys have always been fantastic. Long story short, my older brother is the golden child. My mother always puts him and his family first. My brother and I are not speaking (this is his fault, please trust me on that) and my mother had chosen to take his side and consequently we (husband, Children and I) are always left out of stuff. Ironically brother treats her like shit she is never included in his life and I include her always (invite her on holidays and heavily involve her in stuff as she is lonely and loves to be involved with grandchildren as brother shuts her out).

my son turns 5 next week. His actual birthday is a weekday, DM asks what we are doing. We are doing cake and presents after school. She asks if she can come. We say of course. DS is excited and has mentioned the plan several times. Today DM says she now has other plans, tickets to an event at 3pm so maybe she can “pop” at his bedtime. Maybe. Guess who other plans are with? That’s right.

is it too much to expect her to keep my son’s birthday free as fucking agreed and not treat him like an afterthought she can “pop” and see when she’s finished with her preferred plan with golden child, which she made AFTER saying she would come.

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
rainydaysandtuesday · 04/06/2023 19:32

This reply has been withdrawn

This message has been withdrawn at the poster's request

NumberTheory · 09/07/2022 03:36

@Herewegoagainffs

How did it go?

Do you feel you have more control and less vulnerability?

wentworthinmate · 03/07/2022 10:02

She’s downright sexist and thinks the son is more valuable than the daughter. I’d go NC but to be honest OP would she even care???

Merryweather80 · 02/07/2022 20:40

Pallisers · 30/06/2022 19:34

I don't think you need to go no contact but you need to understand what low contact should entail. So when she says she'll pop by, you say "sure that would be nice" and don't bother telling your son. Don't have him expect her, don't build anything around it. If she cancels, then whatever. If she shows up, no big deal. If you invite her for christmas and she says she isn't sure yet say "no problem we'll plan without you. maybe next year". and stick to it. IF she comes back to you and says "oh I don't have plans as it happens, say oh what a pity, we already made our plans". Don't invite her for holidays. Meals together can be very rare. if she dumps you or fails you your response is "I didn't expect you anyway" not anything emotional because your emotions need to be low contact too - just don't bother too much about her. don't try to change her. don't have conversations about your brother. cut off the source of her enjoyment.

I think this approach is absolutely the best. It’s not a game. It’s clear boundary setting. Making it clear she has a choice and that you aren’t playing her game by giving an emotional response but rising above it all.
she will soon realise- when she’s left out of things where her games have got her. The one you are no longer playing.

Madamum18 · 02/07/2022 17:55

EnterACloud · 30/06/2022 15:57

Hi mum, this is nothing to do with [brother], this is about you making the choice to let down your grandson on his birthday. You know how excited little kids get about their birthdays and he is fully aware you are coming and is looking forward to it very much. If you choose to change your plans and miss (son's) birthday tea, that is your decision. Just so you know, the tea is from x-x times and unfortunately we can't have visitors after that as he'll be in bed.

^ this would be my reply, clear and accurate and avoiding her bullshit. If she takes the time and doesn't come up with a reversal of her current plans, that's the time to tell her that you need to rethink the relationship esp between her and her grandchild. As others have said, having beloved relatives waltz in and out and let him down isn't nice for him.

Perfect reply. I would send it word for word if I were you

Ohthatsexciting · 02/07/2022 17:37

If she pops in several times a week
what time does she usually pop in?

ellyeth · 02/07/2022 17:27

I was so sorry to read your post. Your Mum is really being very unkind. I agree with what Paper Tyger suggests. If it were me I would drastically cool the relationship with my Mum. You appear to include your Mum in a lot of things - I think you said including holidays. I would not be so amenable in future. Unkindness should have consequences, especially when it involves letting down a child. She has continued to put your brother first so let him pick up the slack. If he does not, in the circumstances you describe your have already done more than enough - it is not your problem.

diddl · 02/07/2022 12:15

I carry on with bedtime routine regardless, especially on a school night. I know this makes me sound like an absolute bitch

Well no of course it doesn't-if she could come at a more convenient time but chooses not to that is entirely on her.

Your husband could perhaps pull back on the helping out especially if it affects the family at all.

cherish123 · 02/07/2022 11:57

YANBU

SoHereBesMe · 02/07/2022 11:32

Similar to my MIL. biL is the golden child and she will bend over backwards to help him. My DH bends over backwards to help her and she is always "too busy" to come near our house, or help we really need it (for doctors appts or when someone is rushed to hospital)

The only time she does come is on children's birthdays, and coincidentally, close to bedtime. I carry on with bedtime routine regardless, especially on a school night. I know this makes me sound like an absolute bitch 😒

You're absolutely right to say not to come at bedtime. It's not the time of day to call to see a child. Unfortunately (for her) this is the type of thing your son will remember about her.

PaulineBrady · 02/07/2022 10:12

I think you need to avoid giving her the opportunity to behave this way and make your son a pawn in the family power games. Move on from this without comment but leave her out of any plans involving DS in future. Manipulative behaviour thrives on attention.

Pr1mr0se · 02/07/2022 09:35

I have a parent like this. They actually travelled 120 miles for a birthday party for their very young grand-child and then missed it as they found a shop to go to on the way. I have a recording of my child saying 'where's grand-dad' which i sent to him as I am passive-aggressive like that. I then had a word when he finally did turn up with no excuse whatsoever other than 'oh;. Some people have no idea about other people and their impact and are totally self-obsessed. He has not been invited to any other birthday on the actual day since as I can't stand the tension.

Rosehugger · 02/07/2022 05:13

People often feel.sorry for lonely old neighbours, family never come to see them, etc. Always worth remembering there may be more to it.

bluesapphire48 · 02/07/2022 05:00

Tell her not to bother coming over after she’s been to your brother’s, and that she will NOT be welcome to “pop in” to see your son from now on.

On his birthday or at any other time.

Period.

In many cultures, the son is more important than a daughter. But this is Europe, in the twenty-first century. Not medieval China, for crying out loud.

S0upertrooper · 02/07/2022 01:58

You say your brother is a wanker, I believe you, I have 3 brothers who are all wankers and I have been NC with them for decades. Why is your brother your son's godfather if he is so awful? Do you also pander to him in the same way your mother does? I'm not criticising as I understand family dynamics can be really fucked up.

My DH had a similar dynamic to you with his DM and DS. His DM created a divide between him and DS, playing them off against eachother. He just stopped playing, stopped engaging in the drama, stopped requesting anything and it was so much easier for him.

If you can, try not to have any expectations of your mother. She probably enjoys the drama of your reaction, she's playing you because it makes her feel important and wanted. Stop taking her on holiday, stop inviting her, stop including her.

Redshell1976 · 01/07/2022 23:55

I would tell her not to bother, who does that to their grandchild

Ortega888 · 01/07/2022 21:38

I am so sorry to hear what’s happening. I had this with my mum and my youngest sister who could do no wrong so I know how you feel. It’s sad and it’s very damaging for you and your son being treated this way. I would step back and avoid all contact or have very little contact with your mum for the sake of your own mental health. Your mum is just so desperate to have a bond with your brother and his family she’s blinded to see how this is effecting you and your son and it’s just very sad for all involved. Have no expectations of your mum and if she calls round just be your friendly self you normally are. I know this must be very upsetting for you and your son but sometimes we have to accept that people cannot change and give us what we want. I would sit her down and talk to her and explain how you feel but I think she will get just defensive as deep down she knows what she is doing is wrong but is blinded by her feelings for your brother. The brother sounds a real piece of S…. I am just so sorry that this is how things are for you. I hope you have a lovely day with your son on his birthday. Let us know how it all goes.

Freegal · 01/07/2022 21:37

You've said some things that are really relatable to me. Your comment about your brother, something along the lines of if you do something he doesn't like he cuts you out forever.

With my situation it's generational trauma. My mother was cut out by her mother for a ridiculous reason, I make a choice my mother didn't agree with and told my dad how I felt my decisions as an adult weren't respected and met with silent treatment & hostility. The result?
She cut me out and told everyone I stopped her seeing her grandkids.
I have never had my mother's support if it was something she wouldn't choose herself. She never had my back.
And that's why I went NC and am going to try my absolute damned hardest to make sure my children NEVER feel the way that I felt and still do.
I'm just waiting on my therapy appointment to come through.

ComfyChairPose · 01/07/2022 21:30

Yupp. My brother sympathises so much with my mother when she is awful to me and I have a reaction to that.

What they want from me is that I never have any visible reaction to anything, but yet show a whole load of concern for their feelings.

BellaVida101 · 01/07/2022 21:30

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

TequilaStories · 01/07/2022 21:21

This is interesting what you said about her and your brother talking about your texts and her suddenly saying she’s available because she’s probably playing you off against each other, anticipating a response to her actions.

People like this get a fix off playing the victim and she’s able to use your responses to strengthen the bond she desires between her and your brother;

her - “look at these cruel texts she sent me!”
him - “yes I’ve told you before what she’s like.
her “gosh your right I just don’t know what to do.
him - comes in as saviour - bond strengthened.

You can never ever win with people like this as they will continually manipulate everything you say in order to take it back to the person they want to feel special with. Very LC is pretty effective if you don’t want to go NC. Just make the relationship as neutral and superficial as possible so there’s nothing for her to use as a trigger.

LaughandGiggle · 01/07/2022 21:00

Stop trying to seek her approval, you'll never get it.

It's something that you'll have to accept that she's never going to be the kind of mum you want.

Get some counselling to get over it.

LaughandGiggle · 01/07/2022 20:58

Yes, there's one person that's damaged your relationship with your brother and it's her. Probably from when you were both small.

@It's called divide and rule.

My Mum tried this with my brother and I when we were kids, favouring one over the other. We stuck together and went NC with her instead as young adults. My brother is one of my closest friends now and we don't have all the drama that she caused.

She's probably slagging you off to your brother in the same way that she slags him off to you.

I would go cold shoulder on her (as you don't want NC). Don't make that much effort, back off and avoid the drama llama.

IamMostlyUnreasonable · 01/07/2022 19:57

My Mum was a totally toxic person in my life. I went NC with her a few times, and gave her many "second" chances. I just sat there one day and realised that I only ever tried with her because people told me it was wrong to cut family out of my life. What was wrong was the way she had treated me all my life.
I took the plunge, and here I am 20+ years later still without her toxicity and cruelty in my life.

Putting a line through my relationship with her has been a healing time for me. I've had to concentrate on knowing that I did not deserve her behaviours ever. When I think about her now I don't really feel anything, except maybe sadness that it ended that way.
No matter what anyone tells you, just because you were in her womb does not make her allowed to treat you less than you deserve. Anyone who continually hurts you and let's you down is not a healthy addition to your life.
Live your life on your terms, decide your rules and stick to them. You don't owe her anything. Let her know your decisions, without justification. She knows how she's behaved.
I wish you health and happiness and a toxic free life ❤️

noirchatsdeux · 01/07/2022 19:48

Can I just ask...is it the Southport Flower Show?

Swipe left for the next trending thread