Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

to expect house sellers to have a moral compass? absolutely fuming

68 replies

Itsonthestairs · 30/06/2022 12:56

We sold our house earlier this year and bought another, our buyer are fabulous and we've had great communication with them throughout the process, the house we purchased fell through after spending around £2000 on solicitors fees and a survey, this was because the vendor didn't have the right planning permissions and refused to rectify it, therefore unmortgagable according to our solicitor (this was 3 months down the line). Obviously we were really upset at not getting the house but also the vendors attitude (its gone straight back onto the market and I suspect some other poor person is going to end up in the same position). Anyway onwards and upwards, our buyers are really understanding an said they will wait so we have been scouring the market.
We viewed one this morning - almost perfect, rang up to ask a couple of questions to be told the property has had an offer excepted already! ok why didn't they cancel our viewing then after me a DH arranged the morning off work to view it? their response was 'the vendors accepting viewing until the survey is done next week' this tells me that an offer must have been accepted weeks ago (its around a 3 week wait at the moment locally to get a survey). I'm fuming not only for us but for the person who has actually bought that house and is paying hundreds on a survey. I would never treat people or buyers of our property in such a shitty way. I know the market is hot right now but come on - AIBU expecting vendors to have some morals?

OP posts:
hatchyu · 01/07/2022 14:34

It's not unusual to have paid for surveys on two or more properties by the time you get around to completing on one.

Is it? I only book my survey once whoever I'm buying off has also had an offer accepted.

Is this because you offer on multiple properties?

hatchyu · 01/07/2022 14:32

But if I'm the Vendor I don't stop marketing the property, taking viewings, and considering offers until Exchange

When your buying do you offer on multiple properties then? I assume you assume anything your buying could fall through?

DogInATent · 01/07/2022 14:25

Annonnimoouse42 · 01/07/2022 14:14

I really don't understand why its not a priority for the house buying system to be changed. I presume the government are getting money out of it somewhere, but it don't understand where or why.

Most people don't buy/sell property frequently enough for it to be a significant issue at election time. It's a PITA whilst you're doing it, but not important to you until you do it again.

DomPerignon12 · 01/07/2022 14:23

DogInATent · 01/07/2022 14:12

I put YABU, on balance.

On the first property the vendor is being short-sight, presumably hoping for a cash-buyer that won't care. I took the vendor of one house right up to the line insisting they rectified the lack sign-off on a 9yo extension before we'd exchange. Survey costs are a house-hunting cost not a purchase cost. It's not unusual to have paid for surveys on two or more properties by the time you get around to completing on one.

On the second house, you should have been told the house was under offer. But if I'm the Vendor I don't stop marketing the property, taking viewings, and considering offers until Exchange. It's moral to inform people there's an offer, but given the broken conveyancing process in England and Wales it would be stupid to put up an Under Offer sign and turn away everyone else. Offers fall through all the time (as per your first example).

Eh?
Many people don’t have several hundreds of pounds spare to be paying for surveys on multiple houses. I’ve never heard of agents even allowing it until the offer has been accepted.

Similarly… house purchases take ages. Buyers will have spent money on surveys, solicitor deposits etc.
And you think it’s fair to let them, when the property might not be theirs?

I hope I never have to buy from someone like you

outofbedtime · 01/07/2022 14:23

Until estate agents develop morals or are subject to any real regulations that make the process safe and fair to buyers and sellers, people can and will do as they please.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 01/07/2022 14:20

@Annonnimoouse42 stamp duty, searches, (a portion of the charges will
go to councils) land registry fees, possibly the epc, tax on various insurances. The government and councils will do quite nicely out of the current system.

Annonnimoouse42 · 01/07/2022 14:14

I really don't understand why its not a priority for the house buying system to be changed. I presume the government are getting money out of it somewhere, but it don't understand where or why.

DogInATent · 01/07/2022 14:12

I put YABU, on balance.

On the first property the vendor is being short-sight, presumably hoping for a cash-buyer that won't care. I took the vendor of one house right up to the line insisting they rectified the lack sign-off on a 9yo extension before we'd exchange. Survey costs are a house-hunting cost not a purchase cost. It's not unusual to have paid for surveys on two or more properties by the time you get around to completing on one.

On the second house, you should have been told the house was under offer. But if I'm the Vendor I don't stop marketing the property, taking viewings, and considering offers until Exchange. It's moral to inform people there's an offer, but given the broken conveyancing process in England and Wales it would be stupid to put up an Under Offer sign and turn away everyone else. Offers fall through all the time (as per your first example).

Zeus44 · 01/07/2022 14:08

When we buy, the condition is always the property must be marked as sold and no further viewings allowed.

Clearly the seller believes the buyer is not genuine.

DomPerignon12 · 01/07/2022 13:51

Also to add it’s very location dependent.
I’ve seen houses with agents desperate to sell. Figured out why the moment I saw it.

The ones that I actually want? So does everyone else!

DomPerignon12 · 01/07/2022 13:50

LoobyDop · 01/07/2022 13:32

I’m house-hunting at the moment, for the third time. The previous two times were in a “buyer’s market”, and were so different. I remember from before that if you asked to view a house the agent would want to get you in asap. Now they book everything at least a week in advance, you get offered one slot, and if you can’t do that one, tough. It feels as though agents just can’t be bothered- they know buyers will be fighting over every house whether they lift a finger or not. The system is completely broken, and the lengths and amount of insecurity you’re expected to expose yourself to are ridiculous, and the urgency and intensity of it all pretty much forces buyers to behave unethically just to protect themselves.

Exactly!
This was point was well driven home yesterday… sitting at the dinner table.. all the family who had bought houses 20 years ago saying things like
Go for multiple viewings , see the house in all lightings, offer under and negotiate, etc.

I can’t even get ONE viewing let alone multiple?!???

They were also wittering on about not buying before a crash.

Yes darling but we need a place to stay, won’t have anywhere to rent with all the LL’s selling up and won’t get a mortgage during a crash so unless you want to offer us a rent free room at yours until it’s all over …

hatchyu · 01/07/2022 13:35

The system is so shit, why don't people want change?

2bazookas · 01/07/2022 13:34

I've been buying and selling houses for over 50 years . 5 different solicitors in two UK countries. Sometimes, a purchase or sale fell through (for reasons similar to your own).

NOT ONE of those solicitors ever charged me a bean for anything they had done during a failed conveyance.

LoobyDop · 01/07/2022 13:32

I’m house-hunting at the moment, for the third time. The previous two times were in a “buyer’s market”, and were so different. I remember from before that if you asked to view a house the agent would want to get you in asap. Now they book everything at least a week in advance, you get offered one slot, and if you can’t do that one, tough. It feels as though agents just can’t be bothered- they know buyers will be fighting over every house whether they lift a finger or not. The system is completely broken, and the lengths and amount of insecurity you’re expected to expose yourself to are ridiculous, and the urgency and intensity of it all pretty much forces buyers to behave unethically just to protect themselves.

Blowthemandown · 01/07/2022 13:15

Moved in 7 weeks from viewing last End July. We had a chain of ‘decent’ people with common sense. But it still only happened quickly because I kind of project managed it, in cahoots with a progress chaser from one of the agents. The solicitors were ok but did need pushing sometimes. I also made sure everyone knew what was expected, as previously got bitten (22 years ago) when, on day of exchange, the buyer of one property had got to that point without realising he had to handover deposit money up the chain 🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️🤦🏻‍♀️ He then did something crazy on completion day that meant completion was delayed so we didn’t get into the house until 6pm 😵‍💫😳. This time round was far less stressful, in part to our wonderful removals team who were so chilled, careful and downright lovely. Though next time (if there is one) I will pay the extra to have someone pack 🫣😂

CurlyTop1980 · 01/07/2022 12:45

The system in England is just awful. My best mate put in an offer and arranged surveys for a house and then the seller changed thier mind and the sale fell through. The next house they offered on the survey valued the property as lower then their offer and the bank refused the mortgage
.

My parents were just about the exchange contracts and the buyers have just pulled out. They've already laid conversing and survey fees, loacla authority checks. A skip and put a deposit on a removals. It's crazy that is allowed. I hope you get through this.

CaptainThe95thRifles · 01/07/2022 12:33

CheltenhamLady · 30/06/2022 15:12

Indeed. However, it is not always/usually the vendor doing 'something dodgy' it is often mislaid paperwork, timed-out planning issues, or the fact that the property is leasehold. All are easily solvable if the will is there.

We have often bought indemnity policies to get around such issues from sellers. Such is life, if you want the property badly enough(certainly in this market) then another £80 per policy is a price worth paying IMO, even if technically, it is the sellers' issue to resolve.

M

Lucky you to have encountered such easily solvable issues - that isn't my experience and it doesn't sound like the OP's either. Not mislaid paperwork or leasehold issues, but literally not having the right to use the land owned as advertised, no legal access, undisclosed overage charges, no PP for extensive work, or as the OP, work carried out in an area of natural beauty / SSSI etc. I doubt many sensible people would turn down a decent property for the sake of £80 - but these aren't those sorts of problems!

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/06/2022 16:20

@AmandaHoldensLips i think I’m
grateful he left the light bulbs…..the jury is still out on that.
today I think I may well be ‘moving in’ with an air bed, for a fortnight, so I can get things to a habitable state reasonably soon (at least upstairs) - as it’s a 3 hour drive from when we currently are.

BalloonsAndWhistles · 30/06/2022 15:55

Some people are just shits @Itsonthestairs sorry that happened to you. We’re now in a lovely house but we offered on another on previous to this one. However, when we got the survey back there were about 10 pages listing all the faults! They included the fact the extension wasn’t attached properly, faulty wiring, two walls needed replacing, honestly I could go on and on. It’s now been on the market for about two years. We spent about £1k on the survey and searches and the cheeky fucker estate agent asked us for the survey!! We told him to do one unless the seller paid for it.

AmandaHoldensLips · 30/06/2022 15:47

@Alphabet1spaghetti2 - snap! Absolute bastard vendor who left a scene of destruction and devastation. Too filthy to move into. Had to stay in a hotel. And there's water coming in through one of the bedroom ceilings.

We are just about over the "what the hell have we done" stage.

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/06/2022 15:38

@SBAM phew. And thank you. Fingers crossed this will be our final move, just need the electrician to sign off and then I can at least get upstairs decorated and start to move in. Skip filling, I’m sure will help with the ‘out with the old and in with new us’.

SBAM · 30/06/2022 15:14

@Alphabet1spaghetti2 yes, it’s been almost 3 years, but it really only took a couple of weeks to feel right. Repainting the bedrooms has really helped. The decor was fine before, not old fashioned or bad, just not our taste but now the colours look better with our furniture and things. And spending time gardening, seeing the things I planted come up and removing the ones I didn’t like makes it more mine too.

CheltenhamLady · 30/06/2022 15:12

CaptainThe95thRifles · 30/06/2022 14:12

Many solicitors/clients back off at the first sign of such an issue, when, if they had a little more tenacity the transaction might proceed.

Better yet, people could just get the right PP when doing work, or at least be upfront about it when asked at viewings. It's not the fault of the solicitor or buyer that the vendor has done something dodgy.

Indeed. However, it is not always/usually the vendor doing 'something dodgy' it is often mislaid paperwork, timed-out planning issues, or the fact that the property is leasehold. All are easily solvable if the will is there.

We have often bought indemnity policies to get around such issues from sellers. Such is life, if you want the property badly enough(certainly in this market) then another £80 per policy is a price worth paying IMO, even if technically, it is the sellers' issue to resolve.

M

Alphabet1spaghetti2 · 30/06/2022 15:05

@SBAM yep, I am at the ‘what the hell have we done buying this shit hole’. Desperately trying to keep in mind a picture of it looking clean and tidy….
do you love the place now? Does it feel like home?

HitsAndMrs · 30/06/2022 15:03

We made an offer on a house and the vendors accepted it before the house went to market. We informed the EA who marketed it anyway, forced the vendors to take viewings knowing full well it had an accepted offer in 'just in case'. It was unfair to all involved. Estate agents are horrendous and some have no moral compass.