Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abortion is fine but euthanasia isn't??

209 replies

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

OP posts:
rhowton · 30/06/2022 10:10

I have had an abortion (for a medical reason), and believe other women should be able to have an abortion for whatever reason they so wish.

I also being in euthanasia, and think it will be introduced in the next 10/15 years. We have an aging population that are living far too long and costing far too much money. If you are in a care home/ nursing home, with no memory, or quality of life, what's the point of living.

SleeplessInEngland · 30/06/2022 10:09

Most people do think euthanasia should be legal. This thread isn't a gotcha.

BigFatLiar · 30/06/2022 10:08

There used to be strict rules for Abortion but these lapse, there was a case not so long ago where doctors at the hospital left pre-signed forms with reception so anyone could have an abortion without seeing them.

If we allow euthanasia with controls we'll see the controls slip and over time it'll be easier and more acceptable.

Down the road...your daughter tried to commit suicide Mrs B we'll send a paramedic around to help make it successful.

Allnostalgic · 30/06/2022 10:08

@HelloAllll why do they? Without getting into all the ins and outs and various scenarios of why women become pregnant.

Why do you say that women need to start taking more responsibility? In what way does a woman having an abortion affect you?

Why is a genuine contraceptive failure more deserving than a careless mistake? Does the careless person deserve to be punished with a forced pregnancy regardless of the circumstances?

Do you apply that to other aspect of life? Are you fat, do you smoke, eat unhealthy food, drink alcohol, have you ever done something in your life that is less than 100% perfect that has resulted in you needing medicine or treatment?

CandyLeBonBon · 30/06/2022 10:07

HelloAllll · 30/06/2022 08:50

Completely agree with everything yoy have said OP. The only thing i will add is that it is sad just how accepted and normalised abortion seems to have become - women need to start taking more responsibility and not getting themselves in the sotuation of pregnancy if they do not want a child. Yes contraception isnt 100% effective but it is certainly more effective than abortion rates

Oh look. More regressive, sexist, internalised misogyny.

Bearing in mind a woman can only get pregnant once a year, and a man could impregnate a different woman every single day of that year, I'd say you need to have a think about why you're so focused on women 'shutting their legs' and not 'men need to keep it in their pants' (yes I know that's not what you said, but that was the implication).

Such a bloody tedious attitude.

CandyLeBonBon · 30/06/2022 10:03

I absolutely do not want to end my life with my kids having to wipe my arse and not knowing who my partner is. I don't want that for me, my partner or my children and I 100% support assisted dying. I agree though that safeguarding, checks and rigorous guidelines must be in place to stop unscrupulous practice.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 10:02

It would be interesting to know how those above countries have coped with the concerns we have here.

Allnostalgic · 30/06/2022 09:59

Abortion and euthanasia are two completely different things.

Suicide is a completely different matter again and should not be grouped in with euthanasia.

I'm neither for or against euthanasia, if it were to be legalised there would need to be stringent rules and checks.

It's nothing whatsoever like abortion. A woman should have the choice to end a pregnancy for any reason that she sees fit. You and I don't have to agree with her reasons and it's not up to us to decide whether she is deserving enough. She is the only one who is affected and it's her choice.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 09:59

I've c&p'd this from The World Population Review website just because i thought it was interesting. Personally i knew about Switzerland, but honestly didn't know about anywhere else's policies. Particularly i'm surprised about the USA tbh.

''In many countries, euthanasia is illegal and can result in a murder conviction. However, there are some countries in which it is legal under stringent conditions.

  • Switzerland has perhaps the least-regulated laws dealing with euthanasia, as a diagnosis is not required by the physician administering the lethal medication, and there is no age limit. Nevertheless, euthanasia is not allowed if the person advocating for doctor-assisted suicide stands to gain anything, such as an inheritance, from the person’s death.
  • Euthanasia is legal in Belgium for someone who is in unbearable suffering and will not recover. If that person is not terminally ill, then a one-month waiting period is required. There is no age regulation for those requesting euthanasia, but for a child to be considered, he or she must have a terminal illness.
  • In the Netherlands, someone who is in chronic pain and will not recover can request euthanasia, even if he or she is not terminally ill. However, the physician involved must consult with at least one independent physician to ensure that the patient meets the criteria for euthanasia. Children as young as 12 can request euthanasia, but they must have parental permission.
  • Luxembourg, Canada, Australia, and Colombia allow euthanasia for adults who are in unbearable suffering and who will die from their condition. In Australia, a doctor cannot bring up the prospect of euthanasia; the patient must explicitly request it – three times.
  • There are a few states in the United States in which euthanasia is now legal for patients who are terminally ill.
  • In France, euthanasia is not permitted, but patients can request to be heavily sedated until they die.''
SausageAndCash · 30/06/2022 09:58

They have one issue in common which is the ‘sanctity of life’ question. Those who believe in absolute sanctity of life from conception to death presumably share a common view of abortion and euthanasia in the same moral terms and any circumstances or qualifications to that are irrelevant.

For many / most people it is the nuances and pragmatics, and / or the ethics of bodily autonomy that count.

For me, bodily autonomy is absolute. A woman must have dominion over what or does not happen in her body. An adult with capacity has absolute autonomy over their wish to preserve their life or call it a day.

Many disabled people see euthanasia as a threat: thin end of the wedge towards euthanasia for disabled babies, and others making decisions about ‘quality of life’ where it is not perceived to match able bodied.

Lots if legal issues to consider.

And anticipating the next question: I am 100% against state execution / capital punishment. But would vote for life prisoners being able to choose to euthanase themselves.

snowsea · 30/06/2022 09:57

I'm pro euthanasia. Obviously with strict criteria in place.

brookstar · 30/06/2022 09:54

women need to start taking more responsibility and not getting themselves in the sotuation of pregnancy if they do not want a child.

SO it's just the woman's responsibility to ensure she doesn't get pregnant? How about more men taking more responsibility?

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 09:53

I just want to say, I completely get that they are different, but I think it's close enough to say if we can have 1, the other should also be an option.

I would want strict guidelines around it, and I'd personally have stricter rules on abortion, but as many have said, if we can offer a peaceful end to animals, why not humans?

I'm not currently a member of an organisation fighting for it to be legal but now I know there are some, I'll definitely be looking into joining one!

OP posts:
LindaEllen · 30/06/2022 09:43

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/06/2022 08:14

For me there is a massive difference between abortion and euthanasia. I'm not averse to euthanasia but I would want very strict guidelines around it.

This.

A lot of people who kill themselves do so because they have a treatable, mental illness. If euthanasia were made legal, there would have to be proper channels, and treatments to go through, and assessments to make sure the individual is of sound mind.

GreatCrash · 30/06/2022 09:35

I'm pro-choice and pro-euthanasia. I'm a member of the dignity in dying movement linked to above. Join us OP!

www.dignityindying.org.uk/

Mummyoflittledragon · 30/06/2022 09:31

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

Suicide and euthanasia are not the same and this argument is very upsetting to those, who wish for the latter. My slow demise, which started when I was about 40 has been excruciating. Maybe one day I will be in the position of wanting to end it. Yet there are people, who think they know better having never experienced such poor health and a distinctly reduced quality of life, who thin they have the right to tell me not to.

Forced pregnancy is equally devastating. There will be pregnant women with such poor mental health in the US attempting suicide now or in the near future. I am thinking they may end up being sent to prison if they don’t succeed. I have read in some states it is now illegal to cross county lines to have an abortion and the women could be tried for murder. For some, especially impoverished women, this will be the only way out.

Eatingchips · 30/06/2022 09:26

I think euthanasia should be legalised but I recognise the murkiness around pressure being exerted on vulnerable people and I’m not sure how to manage that aspect.

Meadowbreeze · 30/06/2022 09:26

@WindowsSmindows I don't particularly agree with your argument. Very very often suicidal people wish they could be helped. There's literally no options. That's not the same as most physical illness. Even at the end of life, there are hospices designed to keep people as comfortable as possible. There is no such thing for people suffering day in and day out. So many people are suicidal because of financial difficulty.
My brother killed himself at 19. He didn't have depression, he got himself into a really scary situation and felt there was no other way out. It was either that or someone kills him.
I would suggest you educate yourself on suicide before comparing it to euthanasia. For what it's worth, I completely support euthanasia if people want it. I think it's disgusting how we've managed to get medicine to the point where we keep people alive, not much beyond that.

IncompleteSenten · 30/06/2022 09:23

Absolutely I would. I want the right to choose my time to go. It is inhumane to force people to suffer in a way that if you did it to your pet, the rspca would take legal action.

And we force people to suffer because ... they are more important Hmm

if my cat has cancer and faces an agonising death - Put her to sleep.
if I have cancer and face an agonising death - make me live every second of it until my body finally shuts down.

I don't know about anyone else but that doesn't feel like humans are 'more important'

It has its roots in religion I believe which is even more infuriating. I don't want other people's religion to dictate MY life.

onelittlefrog · 30/06/2022 09:22

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/06/2022 08:14

For me there is a massive difference between abortion and euthanasia. I'm not averse to euthanasia but I would want very strict guidelines around it.

This. There are many complications with euthanasia that are not the same with abortion. You can't really compare these two things.

With euthanasia there need to be considerations around elderly/ very ill people who do not have capacity to consent potentially being taken advantage of by those who stand to benefit from their death (e.g. inheritance).

Pinklimey · 30/06/2022 09:18

no

grey12 · 30/06/2022 09:17

BaronessEllarawrosaurus · 30/06/2022 08:14

For me there is a massive difference between abortion and euthanasia. I'm not averse to euthanasia but I would want very strict guidelines around it.

This

Until about the 4th month the fetus doesn't even have a working brain! And also we're asking a person (the mother) to give her body to another person (the baby) possibly against her consent. This is illegal in any other situation, I think it's called body autonomy (you can't take my kidney even if it would save your life).

ReneBumsWombats · 30/06/2022 09:17

In theory, I do agree. In practise, I'm worried about exploitative, inheritance-ready families pushing people who don't really want to. I'm also worried that once assisted dying becomes a choice, so does the decision not to do it...and some people may think their families are better off with them dead. Inheritance and so on.

I'm open to being persuaded otherwise. If these situations weren't a risk, I'd be very much in favour.

LoveIsAFairyTale · 30/06/2022 09:15

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

I think it's the trauma for those that find them. Sometimes the lack of answers. If there was a process. And a place. That wouldn't leave a child to find their parent bled out in the bath or hanging somewhere.

And obviously, sometimes changes could be made to someone life which would mean they would then choose life.

NorthernLights5 · 30/06/2022 09:15

I support euthanasia. I work in care and people can have years and years not knowing who/where/when they are.

However I'd want really strict measures in place. The amount of vultures who descend when someone has passed away who I've cared for for years yet never seen this family member who has come with their hand stretched out is disgusting. One lady had had nothing to do with her sister for decades. As soon as she passed away said sister came to collect anything valuable and we had to let her. I will admit I didn't help and just let her struggle carrying the items out.