Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abortion is fine but euthanasia isn't??

209 replies

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

OP posts:
Vikinga · 30/06/2022 11:21

Euthanasia should be legal but very strict guidelines.

SummerWinterSummerWinter · 30/06/2022 11:19

@pointythings That must have been so difficult for your Dad to realise he'd made the wrong decision for him, and really hard for you to watch your Dad go through it.

I think your points about mental health and enduring suffering are very interesting - food for thought.

123ROLO · 30/06/2022 11:13

I am pro choice, and I think euthanasia should be legal.

I think If anyone had ever witnessed someone dying, in distress, pain and scared without dignity, most with any empathy would also agree with euthanasia.

With the aging population and shortage of carers, I hope that euthanasia gets introduced. Many people suffer in their final months/years wishing for death, and without adequate carer support, providing that dignity and quality care is going to be hard.

I worked for 6 months on a catastrophic spinal/brain injury unit, some were catatonic, some only had movement of their eyes but had full brain function, there was one man who sat in his wheelchair all day every day for years screaming. I 100% believe they would all wish for death, and the staff and family if able, would facilitate that out of compassion.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 11:13

@CounsellorTroi

In the article, it says the following. This is exactly the reasons that I want to decide when I die as well.

Ms Pharaoh, from north London, said she did not want to become a burden to her children or be "blocking beds" and costing the NHS a "fortune".

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 11:03

@CounsellorTroi

But I want to die before I am ill. I am not suffering from a mental illness.

I have had the most wonderful life so far and I want to die on my terms, before I get dementia or another illness.

Thank you so much for the link. I really did not realise this was possible.

pointythings · 30/06/2022 10:59

@SummerWinterSummerWinter my grandmother had a terminal physical condition and she was 82, but there are no age limits in the Netherlands. Nor should there be! Having an assisted suicide for a non-physical condition is not easy, but it has happened in a few cases. One was a man with an alcohol addiction who had been fighting his addiction for decades. There have also been women with anorexia who have chosen assisted suicide, again after decades of failed treatment. These cases raise the questions around how much suffering we can expect people to endure before they say it is enough. I have seen some posts in here blithely dismissing suicidal feeling as 'something that will pass with treatment' - but that is simply not always true, and we should not force people to endure decades of misery so that we can feel comfortable. I am opposed to excluding mental health from grounds for assisted suicide on that basis.

WIth dementia it is much, much more difficult and there is still discussion on what the law should be. At present, a person with dementia has to be deemed to have capacity at the point where the decision to go ahead is taken. My father fell into this trap - he chose not to go ahead when the option was presented to him, but by the time his dementia worsened (but he still had lucid periods), he was deemed not to have capacity any more. He knew he had made a mistake and it caused him immense pain.

There have also been cases where a doctor has stepped in illegally - these people have been prosecuted and sentenced.

CounsellorTroi · 30/06/2022 10:59

@ILoveAllRainbowsx

She wasn’t actually Ill. She’d expressed a wish to die when she was 50 and then at 60. I’m just not sure she was not suffering from mental health problems. Seems to me she had a lot of life left in her. I felt sorry for her children and her partner of 25 years who supported her but weren’t happy about it at all.

Auntybusybody1 · 30/06/2022 10:58

If we can relieve dogs of their stress and distress at the end of life why can’t we do it for humans?

absolutely pro euthanasia and pro choice.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 10:52

@CounsellorTroi

Thank you so much for that link. I did not realise it was possible.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 10:51

@CounsellorTroi

That story gives me so much hope. It does not make me sad at all.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 10:50

CounsellorTroi · 30/06/2022 10:47

I am pro choice and cautiously pro voluntary euthanasia (my thoughts on that have changed over the years) but I did find the case of Gill Pharaoh sad and disturbing.

www.itv.com/news/2015-08-03/gill-paraoh-healthy-nurse-75-ends-life-at-swiss-suicide-clinic-because-she-did-not-want-to-become-hobbling-old-lady

@CounsellorTroi

Why do you find it sad? I would love to be able to decide when I die. I think it is a basic right.

She was very lucky and being a nurse, she knew exactly what she wanted to avoid in later life.

womaninatightspot · 30/06/2022 10:50

With the exception of the odd religious person pretty much everyone I've ever spoken too about the subject would be in favour of some sort of assisted dying/ euthanasia. So many people have watched loved ones die slow, lingering deaths where they are just shells of their former selves.

I couldn't allow my dog to suffer like that so why is it ok for a person?

I'm also pro-choice.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 10:47

GreatCrash · 30/06/2022 09:35

I'm pro-choice and pro-euthanasia. I'm a member of the dignity in dying movement linked to above. Join us OP!

www.dignityindying.org.uk/

I've just joined.

There is a current thread on MN:

www.mumsnet.com/talk/guest_posts/4575053-guest-post-im-terminally-ill-and-want-to-die-on-my-own-terms

CounsellorTroi · 30/06/2022 10:47

I am pro choice and cautiously pro voluntary euthanasia (my thoughts on that have changed over the years) but I did find the case of Gill Pharaoh sad and disturbing.

www.itv.com/news/2015-08-03/gill-paraoh-healthy-nurse-75-ends-life-at-swiss-suicide-clinic-because-she-did-not-want-to-become-hobbling-old-lady

SummerWinterSummerWinter · 30/06/2022 10:46

@pointythings that's really interesting to hear your experience/encouraging too.

If you don't mind me asking, how ill was your grandmother when she chose to go ahead with assisted suicide? Did she have a terminal condition or was it just one that made her life not very pleasant any more?

I think a really interesting and tricky line for regulators would be when to allow it to go ahead to make sure they didn't facilitate suicide of younger people that should be given mental health support instead.

Do you know much about what restrictions/rules are in the Netherlands? e.g. what age can you do it, do you have to have a terminal illness etc?

SummerWinterSummerWinter · 30/06/2022 10:43

From what I've read, it seems that one of the important reasons it's not yet is because it would leave the door open for people to take advantage/bump off relatives they no longer want to care for, or potentially for older people who don't actually want to die but feel like they're a nuisance to say yes to going ahead with it.

But if it can regulated properly absolutely we should allow it. I am 100% in favour of euthanasia. It baffles me that I could give my dog a respectful end and stop his suffering when he was completely miserable, and yet, god forbid, I won't be able to help my mum in the same way.

PearlclutchersInc · 30/06/2022 10:34

If you can't see the difference then you'e being obtuse.

pointythings · 30/06/2022 10:28

I am fully in favour of abortion on demand and of assisted suicide. I'm Dutch, my grandmother had an assisted suicide . She was fully able to advocate for herself, her condition was purely physical and she was in control of the process. She passed peacefully with her family around us.

She did leave a very small inheritance - about £600 for all her family members still living, with a request to spend it on 'something frivolous'. Nobody pressured her into anything.

The guidelines in the Netherlands work well.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 10:20

@CandyLeBonBon + @Allnostalgic i agree with both of you totally but let's treat that post with the contempt it deserves and not dignify it by responding.

It's heartening to see it's the only one of it's kind here and that the majority have just scrolled on by :)

Runnerduck34 · 30/06/2022 10:20

There's a big difference between abortion and euthanasia. Abortion is only permitted before the foetus is viable to survive by itself.
A living person is a completely different scenario.
I dont like the idea of anyone suffering, waiting to die.
However euthanasia is complicated and can be open to abuse.
I think doctors should make patients as comfortable as possible with medication, including letting them slip away, but there's a line between that and seeking an earlier death.
One case that stays with me was a girl in her early twenties with anorexia being allowed euthanasia, I can't remember the country now, possibly Scandinavia or Holland, My teenage daughter was seriously ill with anorexia at the time and would have definitely said she wanted to die but 4 years on , she is well and happy and is at university.
So it's a very complicated with lots of safeguarding issues.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 10:16

So the (massively oversimplified here obvs.) safeguarding checks other countries seem to have are:

  • euthanasia is not allowed if the person advocating for the patient stands to gain anything, such as an inheritance, from the person’s death.
  • If the patient is not terminally ill, then a one-month waiting period is required. For a child to be considered, he or she must have a terminal illness.
  • The physician involved must consult with at least one independent physician to ensure that the patient meets the criteria for euthanasia. Children as young as 12 can request euthanasia, but they must have parental permission.
  • A doctor cannot bring up the prospect of euthanasia; the patient must explicitly request it – three times
So it's doable. I wonder why it's taking us so long to catch up?
CandyLeBonBon · 30/06/2022 10:15

Allnostalgic · 30/06/2022 10:11

@CandyLeBonBon it's so fucking tedious isn't it? It's never the fault of a man though is it? It's those immoral women.

Yep. I honestly despair. These attitude are still so ingrained. Immoral women having sex and not taking responsibility for their actions. I'm so very very tired of it. Anyone who thinks feminism has done its job needs to read this shit coming from OTHER WOMEN to realise we've got such a long way to go.

FunDragon · 30/06/2022 10:12

Yeah, I think euthanasia should be allowed, particularly after watching a family member die slowly and painfully from cancer and attempting (and failing) to take their own life to end their suffering. And I support abortion too.

No ‘gotcha’ here I’m afraid.

Allnostalgic · 30/06/2022 10:11

@CandyLeBonBon it's so fucking tedious isn't it? It's never the fault of a man though is it? It's those immoral women.

CatSpeakForDummies · 30/06/2022 10:11

I am pro-choice and pro-euthanasia, I think there is a huge overlap with these beliefs (it pretty much divides down the religion line) but I do think the comparison is poor.

The most compelling argument I see for abortion is that nobody should be forced to use their body to keep another person/foetus alive. If somebody would die without your kidney, then you can give them one if you choose to, but you don't have to do so, legally. Abortion is the same in that respect. The only reason that abortion is more contentious is that we are quite happy using women's bodies and have a horribly history of blaming women for the consequences of sex and wanting them punished.

It's why we allow people to travel to low income countries for surrogacy but not for organ harvesting.