Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abortion is fine but euthanasia isn't??

209 replies

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

OP posts:
DyingForACuppa · 30/06/2022 12:54

I am pro abortion for any woman who wants or needs it. I do worry that sometimes (very few) women are pressured into abortions they don't want and that is something that care needs to be taken on.

I am pro euthanasia for anyone who is mentally sound enough to make that decision. I even think that in some extreme cases other people should be able to decide euthanasia is the best course of action for someone who doesn't have mental capacity. I worry a lot of vulnerable people would have pressure put on them (i.e. you need looking after now, and the grandkids could really do with the house) to undergo it. The stakes for getting it wrong are a lot higher than with abortion.

I am pro mental health support to save suicidal peoples lives in the same way I'm pro treating physical illnesses. Mentally ill people aren't making careful rational decisions about their lives. Sadly there's very little support in this country.

KevinTheKoala · 30/06/2022 12:53

In some countries you can be offered euthanasia on psychiatric grounds. As someone who has BPD that is terrifying. I have been suicidal many many times and will likely be suicidal many, many times in future, BPD carries the highest suicide risk, and yet I don't think I need to be euthanized (or at least not at the moment when I'm stable). I think I need better treatment and more accessible treatment. I agree with euthanasia in cases where the person is terminally ill, has no quality of life and no chance of a good quality of life but my fear is that if people can be killed for mental illness in other countries because their quality of life is lower, then where do they draw the line?

With abortions its generally done before the foetus is viable and anything later is for a specific medical reason. It isn't the same as euthanasia, that foetus has never lived, it is not a living person with conscious thought in the same way someone who's been born and lived is.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 12:53

pushingpoppies · 30/06/2022 12:43

Because suicide is linked more, usually, to mental health in otherwise young, healthy people who could have lived if they had help and treatment, completely out of the blue and resulting in trauma to their discovery by family or paramedics and just not ever knowing the reasons why or how much they could have helped. And euthanasia is linked more to physical health in older, unhealthy people who are in physical pain with every breath and in a way that isn't ever going to be treatable or have any dignity and could be done in a clinical setting with family knowledge. They are not the same at all and obviously it is more nuanced than that, but the broad brush strokes.

@pushingpoppies I disagree, I've been to many suicides as a paramedic and the reasons for suicide include mental health but also many are effectively self euthanasia.

For example of the 4 hangings I have been to

Elderly man who expressed in his note that he was 'short of breath and his legs had gone" and he didn't want to carry on any more.

John doe found hanging in woods - so no idea of reasons

Young female failed to escape abusive relation

Middle age man, suffered massive head injuries as a teenage driver recovered to discharge from hospital but very poor quality of life, unable to sustain work/relationships.

So from that small sample 50% would probably be considered reasonable grounds for medical euthanasia. So it's certainly not uncommon to come across.

HoneysuckleBeanstalk · 30/06/2022 12:50

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 30/06/2022 12:40

@HoneysuckleBeanstalk - I tested negative for the gene, yes, and it was an unspeakable relief as I already had young DC when we found out the disease was in my family.

My dad was barely existing towards the end. I honestly can't understand why people who weren't dying his death would fight so hard to keep him alive.

That's really good news, what an additional burden it would be the carry the gene. Hopefully in the future they will come up with a cure for others.

A family friends dad died of Huntington's a few years ago. I didn't witness the illness directly but I know his final years were difficult. He couldn't swallow so had to be artificially fed, often taken to hospital when he did eat because he was desperate for a taste. He aspirated his food into his lungs. A very long death, I wouldn't wish it on anyone.

I think it's easy to theoretically disagree with something when the reality of certain illnesses isn't directly impacting.

I suppose I've been lucky, in that I've not had to consider the idea in my own life or family.

Thelnebriati · 30/06/2022 12:48

I support the right to elective euthanasia, which would mean its my choice, and I can decide while I am still well.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 12:44

AryaStarkWolf · 30/06/2022 12:41

I agree in principal, the only worry I would have is that it might be abused, sick or elderly people pressured into to it for selfish or greedy reasons

There are some worrying stories coming out of Canada where they have legalised euthanasia within a private/insurance based health system, but this is not a reason not to legalise euthanasia in the UK, but a reason to fight hard to keep the NHS.

pushingpoppies · 30/06/2022 12:43

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

Because suicide is linked more, usually, to mental health in otherwise young, healthy people who could have lived if they had help and treatment, completely out of the blue and resulting in trauma to their discovery by family or paramedics and just not ever knowing the reasons why or how much they could have helped. And euthanasia is linked more to physical health in older, unhealthy people who are in physical pain with every breath and in a way that isn't ever going to be treatable or have any dignity and could be done in a clinical setting with family knowledge. They are not the same at all and obviously it is more nuanced than that, but the broad brush strokes.

AryaStarkWolf · 30/06/2022 12:41

I agree in principal, the only worry I would have is that it might be abused, sick or elderly people pressured into to it for selfish or greedy reasons

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 30/06/2022 12:40

@HoneysuckleBeanstalk - I tested negative for the gene, yes, and it was an unspeakable relief as I already had young DC when we found out the disease was in my family.

My dad was barely existing towards the end. I honestly can't understand why people who weren't dying his death would fight so hard to keep him alive.

HoneysuckleBeanstalk · 30/06/2022 12:32

@BeautyGoesToBenidorm I read this thread, thinking I don't agree with euthanasia or assisted dying. But then you hit the nail on the head. A disease like Huntington's, which robs you of everything. How can I disagree?

It sounds like you haven't inherited the gene? That must be such a relief for you.

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 12:27

I would NOT exclude mental illness from euthanasia
That would be stigmatizing and dismissive of how serious a psychiatric illness can be.
Stop with this false belief that suicidal people all need a bit of love and help and support to get back on track.
Many do sure,
But for many it's not a "mental health issue" it's a full on Psychiatric illness and they can be as severe crippling de-humanising and awful as the worst physical illness.

MRex · 30/06/2022 12:25

Euthanasia should be legal as personal decision between a person and their doctors. No doctor should be involved in the decision who stands to benefit financially directly or indirectly through them, their family or their friends inheriting as a beneficiary of the person being euthanised.

ThreeLocusts · 30/06/2022 12:25

OP I don't think you get how different abortion and euthanasia are.

The whole point, the reason why the 'abortion is murder' line is bollocks, is that abortion doesn't kill an actual human being. It destroys a potential one. Nothing follows from that in respect to euthanasia, which concerns fully formed humans.

BeautyGoesToBenidorm · 30/06/2022 12:21

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 12:07

I am pro euthanasia because I strongly believe it is in fact pro life and not pro death (I'm absolutely not a pro-lifer in terms of how the definition is used politically).

Many years ago when I was a new ambulance technician in my early 20s I went to a young lad, the same age as me who had attempted suicide and survived by pure luck not a lack of effort. He had Huntington's disease, he had grown up seeing various male members of his family die horrible, drawn out, young deaths and when he was diagnosed he started drinking heavily and then this escalated to suicide attempts, I can only assume he ultimately succeeded.

I sometimes wonder if he had had the option of euthanasia and therefore been able to dictate the point in his disease progression that he didn't want to be alive any longer, whether he would have been able to live an enjoy his 20s and 30s, rather than throwing the time he did have away.

God this is heartbreaking. My dad died of Huntington's, and had I inherited it, I certainly would've contemplated ending my life whilst I still had capacity. Anything rather than die that terrible death.

An old professor of mine at uni also had Huntington's. Very few people knew, most assumed he was just an alcoholic, which he also was - he drank to "mask" the physical symptoms of HD. He'd rather people believed he was a drunk. The drink killed him before HD did, but it was hardly a better, more dignified way to go. Assisted suicide would've been a far kinder option had it been available to him.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 12:07

I am pro euthanasia because I strongly believe it is in fact pro life and not pro death (I'm absolutely not a pro-lifer in terms of how the definition is used politically).

Many years ago when I was a new ambulance technician in my early 20s I went to a young lad, the same age as me who had attempted suicide and survived by pure luck not a lack of effort. He had Huntington's disease, he had grown up seeing various male members of his family die horrible, drawn out, young deaths and when he was diagnosed he started drinking heavily and then this escalated to suicide attempts, I can only assume he ultimately succeeded.

I sometimes wonder if he had had the option of euthanasia and therefore been able to dictate the point in his disease progression that he didn't want to be alive any longer, whether he would have been able to live an enjoy his 20s and 30s, rather than throwing the time he did have away.

ChinBristles · 30/06/2022 12:04

Mind you, atm it's fucking impossible to even get a Dr's appt. And CERTAINLY impossible to get at any of the goodies like opiates or sleeping tablets. Can you imagine the paperwork involved in assisted dying? So most of us will die on the waiting list for it.

Personally, I wish I had become a vet or a pharmacist and I could sort the damn issue out myself.

Onlyforcake · 30/06/2022 11:55

I'm pro choice and pro euthanasia. Either you believe people have bodily autonomy or you'll be on Krugers team (to me).

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 11:54

My friends mum is a doctor (mostly retired but went back to icu for the first COVID wave), has recently attended a course in the UK covering assisted dying, she thinks it will be legalised within the next 5 years.

daisyjgrey · 30/06/2022 11:51

Abortion should be legal and easily accessible to those who want it.

Euthanasia should be legal and easily accessible to those who want it.

My family was impacted by suicide, and I don't think that should come with the narrative it often does. In some circumstances it's entirely understandable and the saddest part is that the person felt that it was their only option.

I don't agree with life at any cost.

FOJN · 30/06/2022 11:50

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Who is we?

Sounds like you think women need to campaign on every issue you consider to be related by principle just so they can avoid being accused of intellectual inconsistency.

I think the thread shows you most of us are very consistent but we're more concerned with protecting what we have right now so please stop being goady, it doesn't make you look as clever as you think it does.

ILoveAllRainbowsx · 30/06/2022 11:49

CounsellorTroi · 30/06/2022 11:26

Here’s an article from the Guardian at the time of Gill Pharaoh’s death.

www.itv.com/news/2015-08-03/gill-paraoh-healthy-nurse-75-ends-life-at-swiss-suicide-clinic-because-she-did-not-want-to-become-hobbling-old-lady

if you accept the argument that old people are “a burden on society” it’s not a huge leap to applying that to other people such as disabled, homeless etc people.

@CounsellorTroi

No, I do not think you can extrapolate like that. I think most people would agree that it depends on age, not disability or homelessness.

But, when I am in my 80s and taking up a bed and and precious resources then I am a burden to society because we do not have an endless point of money. That is a fact. I would much rather that young people were given the resources.

I will have had my life by the time I am 80. It is now the turn of younger people and I don't want them to have to pay for me.

OhmygodDont · 30/06/2022 11:42

With the worry about some who would want it no longer being seen as able to consent surely a living will or such made with a doctor could be used. personally if I didn’t know who I was and who my children where I wouldn’t want to be kept alive. That is something pretty easy to test and write that a person wishes to end their life upon such a time that they no longer recognise their close loved ones, that they no longer wish to be kept alive if in a vegetive stage. Even if it’s something that has to be signed and checked year on year.

Alot more people are alive right now than would be if they had safe legal dignified ways to end their life. Although I guess life insurance payouts could be an issue?

ChinBristles · 30/06/2022 11:37

I've become a member of Dignity in Dying Scotland off the back of this thread. Signed up to a small monthly direct debit. Sadly you can't gift aid it as "what we're campaigning for is illegal so we cannot be a registered charity"

ChinBristles · 30/06/2022 11:31

Thanks, I've signed that petition

CounsellorTroi · 30/06/2022 11:26

Here’s an article from the Guardian at the time of Gill Pharaoh’s death.

www.itv.com/news/2015-08-03/gill-paraoh-healthy-nurse-75-ends-life-at-swiss-suicide-clinic-because-she-did-not-want-to-become-hobbling-old-lady

if you accept the argument that old people are “a burden on society” it’s not a huge leap to applying that to other people such as disabled, homeless etc people.