Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abortion is fine but euthanasia isn't??

209 replies

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

OP posts:
SinisterBumFacedCat · 30/06/2022 16:38

It really annoys me that people bring a financial element into the argument against euthanasia and presume everyone’s families are trying to kill them off for their money. Families who have often cared for the relatives for years and sacrificed everything. There is always this blanket presumption of greed as a motivator. We are talking about a persons right to choose themselves, and that their families respect that choice when the time comes. As it is there is no choice. For anyone.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 16:37

@EgonSpengler2020 - thank you for taking the time to explain all that. That is a lot to take in for a non medically trained person. I will re-read it, because it's interesting and important. I wonder though, as bad as it sounds, if that is why full explanation is not attempted 'in the moment', if that makes sense? As much as in a perfect world there should be the time and resources to allow everyone to understand the in's and out's every time, a significant majority of stressed upset tired relatives just wouldn't get it faced with all that info.

Re: the actual patient - i don't know if my mother would have listened for that long! I can imagine her saying '' .... oh god enough. Just don't bring me back if i start to peg out ok?!''

When you get to snatch what you know is only going to be a 2/3/4/5 min chat with a doctor on a hospital ward these days you ask the basics as clearly as poss. and want pretty concise answers in return in order to get through more than one thing.

On a lighter note ''I blame the media, casualty and also Keifer Sutherland in particular'' made me actually chuckle. What is it he's done specifically? 🤔😆

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 15:54

@Laiste I'm glad your mother is doing well and enjoying life.

However your post highlights the widespread lack of understanding around death and dying and end of life care.

This is in no way a critism of you, but a critism of british society which still sees talking about death as a massive taboo, the health system that doesn't afford the time for proper discusions, and to a lesser extent individual health practioners who can become complacent about the significance and impact of what they are saying and therefore how much is being taken in and understood.
Your mother won't have had a DNR, as the correct term is 'Do not attempt Cardio Pulmonary Resusitation' (DNACPR), DNR or do not resusitate is bad terminology as in medicine we use the term to resusitate to cover far more than CPR, including for example fluid resusitation in shocked (hyopvolemic, anaphlaxis, hypothermic) patients. The 'Resusitation' Room in A&E is a busy place often full completely of patients who are concious throughout their stay. In order to stop this level of care an order not to treat would be required. These do exist in the form of a 'Treatment escalation plan' (TEP), and are an important documement in achieving a dignified death, but are DNACPR is literally just that, it does not mean do not treat only to not perform CPR. Also Doctors and certain HCPs (Paramedics) can make the decision to stop or not start CPR based on the obvious futility of CPR in relation to the patients condition, and in the best interest of the patient, regardless of whether or not DNACPR has been completed.

Also, many people misunderstand what CPR and defibrillation is and what it's indications and limitations are. Performing CPR on someone in cardiac arrest secondary to sepsis will almost certainly be futile, and defibrillation will not be indicated as they will go into a pulseless electrical activity (PEA) where the electrical signals in the heart still continue but no blood circulates, and from that they will progress into flat line (Asystole) both of which are non-shockable rhythms. Withholding CPR in the situations is abosolutely the right thing to do, and is a way of giving the patient dignity in their very final moments.
I blame the media, casualty and also Keifer Sutherland in particular, for the mis-representation of CPR and and defibrillation, and a public health campaign of what it actual is and can do is much needed.

I think even without the legalistion of euthanasia (which I passionately agree with) that a long overdue public education campaign on death and dying, and lasting power of attorny etc is needed to encourage families to have evidence based, open conversations and enable them to feel empowered to state their wishes. This would help many more people achieve a better death, without needing euthanasia. But Euthanasia is desperately needed to improve the quality of life and death in patients who are unfortunate enough to develop a neurodegenarative disease.

pointythings · 30/06/2022 15:48

@LookingGlassMilk the Netherlands is one of those countries where euthanasia is legal on mental health grounds. And it is not as simple as rocking up at A&E feeling suicidal and being handed some suicide pills - that is a groteque misrepresentation of how the system works. And it does work. In the (rare) cases where euthanasia has been granted on mental health grounds, the people involved had been suffering without relief for decades. How long do you think we should torture people for before we let them die? Because that is what you are advocating.

No system can be 100% perfect - but in the UK the system is 100% imperfect with no end to suffering allowed for human beings.

LookingGlassMilk · 30/06/2022 15:19

I am pro choice, not because I think abortion is a good thing, but that I think it is necessary.

I'm against euthanasia. I do really feel for people who are suffering with terminal illnesses, but I think that legalising euthanasia will cause more harm than good overall.
It will definitely be abused. There are massive financial gains to be made, not just by family members who stand to inherit, but it will also save the NHS massive amounts of money. So if they introduce it with strict rules, these will gradually get challenged and chipped away at.

There will be so much pressure put on people not just from family members, but also from the health service and society as a whole. You can see from some of the replies here that there is already a perception that the morally right thing to do is to prevent yourself from becoming a 'burden'. There is a whiff of 'useless eaters' off it.

In some countries, euthanasia is allowed on mental health grounds. As someone who has had to repeatedly present at A&E with a suicidal family member, this absolutely terrifies me. Said family member has now recovered and is glad that he didn't end his life.
If assisted dying was legal for mental health issues, you would have to hide mentally ill family members from the health services instead of seeking help for them.

Canada only introduced assisted dying in 2015 with strict rules. Five years later they removed the requirement for the condition to be terminal and now they are looking to introduce it for mental health conditions.

www.spectator.co.uk/article/why-is-canada-euthanising-the-poor-

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 15:16

@Suzi888

When someone is dying of cancer,no amount of pressuring relatives can convince a doctor of anything.
The medic's will see they are at the ends.

The medic's can ask

And I agree,I want to legally make that choice now.
That doesn't mean it would automatically happen but I'd like to legally say now especially in the case of dementia, when I don't recognise my family and can't self care...

End me !! Please!!

Beachmummy23 · 30/06/2022 15:15

You have a very narrow minded view on abortion. I have had 11 miscarriages and have had to use abortion medication numerous times when the pregnancy wouldn't come away alone. You never know whether you will have to use it. These were pregnancies I desperately wanted

PaperTyger · 30/06/2022 15:14

We are an uncivilised and barbaric society whilst we continue to make terminally ill people hold on until their bodies collapse.its in humane.

It's wicked.

We are also uncivilised whilst we continue to control women's birth experience.
Women should be offered a range of options including ELC at birth.

Suzi888 · 30/06/2022 14:56

RaspberryChouxBuns · 30/06/2022 08:27

I want to see euthanasia legalised.

Me too.

The only issue is greedy family members encouraging elderly parents/relatives to take the option when they aren’t ready. Why can’t we make these decisions when we are fairly young, sound of mind etc. I’m in my forties, why can’t I make the decision now that if I have dementia or cancer when I’m older that I don’t want to suffer. If I don’t know who I am, where I am, if I’m in pain if I can’t swallow, can’t move and won’t recover then I want it to end peacefully.

Hibiscrubber · 30/06/2022 14:51

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

Maybe because suicide isn't painless or dignified?

When my Dad stuck a hosepipe in his car exhaust and gassed himself to death, it wouldn't have been the pleasant, just going to sleep death that people think it is. And maybe the police, ambulance and dog walker who found him, wouldn't have the memory of finding him in that state.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 30/06/2022 14:44

Marvellousmadness · 30/06/2022 14:39

"My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use"

How ignorant
What if you have an ectopic pregnancy that could end up killing you. Or a mental health issue that forcee you to take medicine that would cause the baby to die etc. Of course you would terminate. Plus 928383 more reasons.

Exactly. The ignorance around abortion really does show lately.
Abortion is a necessity. Late term abortions are only done for medical need, and I support women having the choice at any time in her pregnancy.
I also think euthanasia should be legal. I do agree it should be tightly regulated, the Netherlands have a good policy around it.

AgathaAllAlong · 30/06/2022 14:43

Why does abortion make you feel 'terrible sad'?

Yeah I think assisted suicide should be legal.

Marvellousmadness · 30/06/2022 14:39

"My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use"

How ignorant
What if you have an ectopic pregnancy that could end up killing you. Or a mental health issue that forcee you to take medicine that would cause the baby to die etc. Of course you would terminate. Plus 928383 more reasons.

PetraBP · 30/06/2022 14:38

I hasten to add I don’t think biological males should be permitted to vote in Parliamentary votes on abortion either as it isn’t an issue that can or does affect them in any way.

PetraBP · 30/06/2022 14:36

To help settle these issues, I think we should have referendums on the following:

  • Abortion (absolute right to choose v time limits) with only biological females allowed to vote.
  • Euthanasia.
  • Capital punishment .
Mangogogogo · 30/06/2022 14:14

A little blob of barely developed cells is so, soooo different to an actual living, breathing human.

i would like to see euthanasia legalised too but this isn’t the argument to have

TheGoogleMum · 30/06/2022 14:03

Yep legalise it but legalise only in certain circumstances to avoid it being abused

Laiste · 30/06/2022 14:01

@ManateeFair - Well, to be fair lots of people are fighting for voluntary euthanasia to be made legal in this country.

The reason people are particularly vocal about abortion rights at the moment is because it is an existing right that is being taken away, which is a backward step in women’s rights.

Yes; imagine existing euthanasia rights being removed in certain countries now. Imagine racial equality rights being removed now. How backwards all this is!

I'm stunned that my life has spanned the 70s, 80s, 90s and the noughties i'm seeing women's rights in a developed country REMOVED in the 2020s 😰

I'm hoping this will be remembered as a scary backwards temporary blip.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 30/06/2022 13:58

I agree and I am glad you are recognising the similarities in the my body my choice point of view.

i believe it is a person’s absolute right to end their own life if terminal illness makes it unbearable to continue at any point and there should be safe ways to do this.

I have been personally effected by suicide and it is completely different and leaves trauma and unending questions and guilt for everyone left behind.

I face the prospect of genetic disease from both parents so I am having a ringside view of a long protracted death and I am not prepared to inflict this on myself or my family due to other peoples squeamishness surrounding death.

if it makes you uncomfortable please support charities that fund research into cures and treatments for the world’s worst ways to die and stop voting in political parties that cut social care budgets.

Regularsizedrudy · 30/06/2022 13:45

False equivalence is a logical fallacy in which an equivalence is drawn between two subjects based on flawed or false reasoning. This fallacy is categorized as a fallacy of inconsistency. Colloquially, a false equivalence is often called "comparing apples and oranges."

ManateeFair · 30/06/2022 13:43

Well, to be fair lots of people are fighting for voluntary euthanasia to be made legal in this country.

The reason people are particularly vocal about abortion rights at the moment is because it is an existing right that is being taken away, which is a backward step in women’s rights. Whenever euthanasia is debated in Parliament or becomes a manifesto issue, or there is a criminal case against someone who assisted a suicide, you will definitely see a lot of discussion about it in the media and so on.

Personally I think abortion and voluntary euthanasia should both absolutely be legal.

I don’t actually think they are in any way comparable acts though. Euthanasia is about terminating the life of a consenting adult. Abortion is about stopping a life from starting in the first place - and it actually saves the lives of many women and girls.

Laiste · 30/06/2022 13:42

@EgonSpengler2020 Flowers A brave man.

When my mother (84) was in hospital with complications arising from an awful Campylobacter bacteria infection the docs took me to one side and told me she'd signed a DNR (no resuscitation) as she'd said that basically after 6 weeks in hospital struggling with this thing and fading fast she'd had enough and if the time comes then the time comes!

It was a hard thing to hear, but i respected her wishes of course.

The time never came. She pulled through. This was all about 2 years ago now. But she says she feels as if every day is borrowed time now. in a good way.

Luxa · 30/06/2022 13:35

Yes euthanasia and abortion should both be legal and available.

Both should be a free choice.

EgonSpengler2020 · 30/06/2022 13:03

There are also lots of choices and plans we can already put in place legally that most people are unaware of to potentially hasten our passing.

I have an advanced directive with a range of parameters and scenarios, whereby i would lack capacity and/or the ability to communicate, where I have stipulated in advanced the withdrawal/omission of certain medical treatments/procedures. Eg. If I ever develop dementia, once I've reached the point of no longer having mental capacity (for a sustain, specified period of time, rather than temporary) then they are not to give me antibiotics at all, that way I will succumb to infection much earlier on than many elderly people do.

My Dad had an aggressive brain tumour and in the end he declined a second course of antibiotics for a chest infection and due to his general poor state by this point he died from sepsis within 3 days of his decision.

ItsSnowJokes · 30/06/2022 12:59

Euthanasia should be legal. We treat humans appallingly when it comes to terminal illness etc....... animals would be put down, but we let humans linger on and suffer etc.... for no reason what so ever.

YABVU about both subjects.