Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Abortion is fine but euthanasia isn't??

209 replies

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

OP posts:
EmilyBolton · 02/07/2022 13:36

I agree it should be legalised. BUT…the issue is safeguarding and that by and large is why it has failed to get through parliament as a bill. No one knows how to make a fool proof fail safe to ensure only those that really need to die as such, are allowed to persue it
ifnitnis legalised, many people believe, and I agree, that old people will feel too much of a burden and if their quality of life is poor will simply want to “get it over and done with “. But this is really about old people being isolated, under valued, and negated- and society really should be addressing that . There are concerns that children will put gently nudges and not so gentle coercion on their elderly and ill parents to reduce care home fees etc.

pin an ideal world everyone who has made a decison to end their life should appear before a judge or independent body to hear the pro and cons and ensure no coercion is involved. But that will be prohibitively expensive and time consuming and complex. that would make it the preserve of individuals with extremely complex and difficult physical illnesses - which is probably the right shout

i think it is very dangerous to just allow people to take their lives when they want- coercion, temporary periods of depression or self harm ideation will result in a loss of life that is just plain wrong.

EmilyBolton · 02/07/2022 13:28

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

Suicide in the same bucket? You have to be kidding! That is one of the strongest arguments against euthanasia, that people with mental health conditions will have easier access for suicide
people who loose the will to live, or more probably become fixated with ideas of self harm are extremely ill. This is not normal. In almost all cases with correct treatment they can be helped beyond this self harm ideation. For many people it is as a result of a mental health crisis that is short lived. Sure, there may be other crisises later, but in between this person does not want to actively kill themselves.
jeez, so many people feel like this for temporary periods in their lives. I had a bout of this both during PND and then menopause. What would have happened if I’d been allowed to kill myself with a 8 week baby depending on me? What would have happened if I’d driven into the walls/trees on my way home from work for weeks when I was at my lowest a few years back with menopause symptoms. I self harmed and the lot. It was a temporary state of mind. Thank god I was not legally allowed to act on it, and if I had tried anything people would have stopped me. My ex has schizoaffective disorder. Only a few times before he was diagnosed did he express thoughts of self harm. He has been on meds for 14 years- it simply doesn’t happen now. Sure, meds are shit, his quality of life not fantastic..but he still feels his life is worth living,

it is very different having self harm ideation as a result of mental illness vs having a physical terminal illness that you will be dying of imminently. We don’t put animals down cos they’re miserable- we do it becuase they are dying or won’t survive treatment needed and are inacute physical pain.

Iamnotamermaid · 02/07/2022 13:26

It is not about abortion or euthanasia and although I truly believe both should be legalised, (abortion is tolerated in the UK, do not believe it is 100% legal for all situations) I believe even more in individual choice.

If a woman chooses to have an abortion, she should be able to have access to one in a medically safe environment, without going through pickets lines and endless justification. Same with euthanasia, it is the right of the individual to decide on the quality of life they wish to have and end of life choices when faced with terminal illness.

Newmumatlast · 02/07/2022 13:19

Mommabear20 · 30/06/2022 08:05

With all the discussion on abortion at the moment, and the clear view from the majority is people that they're a good thing, AIBU to wonder why we still don't allow for legal euthanasia of terminally ill people in this country (England)?

My personal view on abortion is that is a terrible practise that makes me terrible sad to think about and a resource I would never use, BUT that it should be legal for woman whose views differ to mine, to allow them to make their own decisions about their bodies and lives.

It baffles me then, to think that while we are fighting for woman's rights on this subject, that we aren't also fighting for the rights of every person who is or will suffer terribly as a result of terminal illnesses, not to mention the trauma for their families who have to watch them deteriorate in health knowing that it's only going to get worse and often times won't get to be there with them at the end.

Would you be in agreement to make euthanasia legal?

Yes. I think we should have autonomy over our own bodies including whether or not we stay alive.

PollenHigh · 02/07/2022 13:17

Providing there are strict safeguards in place, euthanasia should be legal.

BigFatLiar · 02/07/2022 13:07

Reading mumsnet sometimes makes me believe that euthanasia should be compulsory for some.

cottagegardenflower · 02/07/2022 13:02

Of course it should be allowed in very restricted and carefully regulated circumstances

maddening · 02/07/2022 12:24

I think both are fine and should be legal with the appropriate controls in place.

Lalosalamanca · 02/07/2022 12:11

Op, I share your thoughts on abortion and euthanasia. You are brave to come on here and share them, was refreshing for me to read.@Mommabear20

iloveeverykindofcat · 02/07/2022 12:07

I will be taking myself off to Dignitas asap
It's not that easy - average cost is around 11K for a UK traveller. I'm banking on euthanasia being legal in the UK by the time I get to the age when the women in my family get major dementia. If not, I'll have to make my own plans when I get the diagnosis, with a time limit - which is bad, because it means I might get less quality time out of my life than I otherwise would have, and have to be incredibly careful not to incriminate anyone else. But I won't die like my grandmother did. Absolutely not. Even if I have to cut my life short to avoid it.

BooksAndHooks · 02/07/2022 11:58

Absolutely. Because as a society we make death such a taboo the focus is currently on quantity of life and the quality is completely dismissed. I don’t fear death at all, I fear being kept alive in a state I wouldn’t want to be.

Having seen elder relatives being aggressively treated for many medical conditions with great suffering to keep them going into their late 90s it isn’t something I respect or would want for myself.

NeverDropYourMooncup · 02/07/2022 11:51

WindowsSmindows · 30/06/2022 08:21

But why then do we act as though suicide is still always awful/ dreadful/ tragic and to be avoided.

Suicide is seen as preventable with any number of charities set up to prevent it and to raise awareness and it's very common that people blaming mental health services.
Why?
Why not just say " ok well his life was pretty miserable he euthanized himself" some times I've heard of a suicide I might think "yeah well they had addiction issues, a shitty life poor personality, medical problems psychiatric problems etc etc I wouldn't want that life, off you pop.
Why is it treated so differently by us all, by the media, by communities?
Just the shock of it?
Is that the only difference between it and eothanasia?

Op I don't know, I think abortion, euthanasia and suicide are all aspects of the same issue-
Either life really really matters in all it's forms?

Or it doesn't matter
so crack on with ending your own life or life within your own body, with no blame no limits no moral questioning.

That could mean that people who would recover wouldn't be helped. After all, it's what they want, let them get on with it - and it would save the NHS and other organisations a lot of money.

Saving money and shrugging one's shoulders 'Oh, well, your choice' would be the worst possible outcome for a huge number of unwell people who could recover, their families, loved ones and society. And it would give the message to other people with depression that nobody cares/they should also end their lives and stop beating about the bush with it. Which would also filter down to children.

RedToothBrush · 02/07/2022 11:34

I think the debate should not start with euthanasia tbh.

In terms of dignity in death, we could do a lot if we had more of a debate about simply being more honest and upfront about quality of life and prolonged medical intervention.

I think we have a tendency to consider medical intervention in all circumstances as the right course of action. I don't think we have enough of a conversation about being brave enough to say this isn't going to get better and instead having better palliative care.

'Having more time' isn't necessarily a good thing for everyone if they have lost dignity.

It troubles me that we so often start the conversation about this topic with euthanasia, rather than the a wider topic about dignity in death.

I know this thread OP is about comparing abortion to euthanasia, but that for me doesn't work precisely because its not a good comparison.

Woman have abortions to save their lives or to perserve their health. They have them to ensure the economic survival of others. They have them to escape abusive relationships. They have them because the baby is incompatible with life.

Notably we talk about ways to prevent unwanted pregnancies as part of the topic.

Why do people want euthanasia? This is a fundamental question for me. Especially if we aren't having the conversation about why is it needed rather than better palliative care pathways and better understanding of when to discontinue medical care to prolong life at all costs, particularly invasive medical care.

The conversation about euthanasia always must include cost and benefits to others...

LuaDipa · 02/07/2022 11:11

EekThreek · 30/06/2022 08:20

Absolutely euthanasia should be legal. My Nan (with Alzheimer's) was bedridden for the last 7 weeks of her life after an operation to drain a bleed on her brain following a fall. She didn't know where she was, and every day would repeatedly say "I just want to go home. I don't want to do this anymore". We wouldn't have made an animal wake up every day to that, there was no quality of life. It was cruel.

Not to mention the expense for the NHS. Morphine, adjustable bed, inflatable mattress, carers 4x a day, daily visits from doctors and nurses from the palliative care team. Just to prolong her misery.

Noone should be forced to go through that, we should be able to choose euthanasia.

While I’m very sorry your Nan went through this, this is exactly why I have concerns about euthanasia. She was in no position at this stage to make the decision for herself, any decision would have come from her family. It’s impossible to know what she would gave wanted as she couldn’t tell you. Had she been diagnosed with Alzheimer’s and then taken the decision while she still had her faculties then it’s her choice.

I’ve seen my own grandparent go through this so I’m honestly not unsympathetic, in fact I’ve told my dh that if I was to be diagnosed with Alzheimer’s in the future I will be taking myself off to Dignitas asap so they don’t have to see me like that. But this isn’t a decision that I would feel comfortable taking on behalf of someone else.

SinisterBumFacedCat · 02/07/2022 11:02

I think euthanasia could be regulated if it is something you decide in advance when you have full capacity. Apply for a license which is renewed every year at a GPs surgery alone, until you start to decline. You could specify at what point you would want to be euthanised, eg. when you are unable to communicate or swallow or when you no longer recognise family rather than currently having to whisk yourself off to Switzerland while you are still physically capable of the journey (some would argue this is too early in a progressive degenerative illness). The choice would be there but you would have to show a long term commitment to it.

Ponoka7 · 01/07/2022 06:35

I don't see how euthanasia would be properly regulated, as many think it would once the Tory's remove the human rights act. Couple that with the immediate DNR placed on people who had learning difficulties during Covid, I don't see how we'd guarantee protection for disabled people. I listened to the parents of a young woman who had down syndrome and Covid and had little intervention, so died. She was 26, doing voluntary work, going dancing, doing gymnastics etc. They were one of many relatives of young disabled people who did feel bitterness that doctors were fighting to keep 70+ year olds alive and not their relatives in their 20's.
It took Craig Phillips going on Big Brother to get legalisation changed around transplants for people who have downs syndrome.
I do believe in people leaving a living will stating that they don't want forced feeding etc if they develop certain conditions. I've watched a friend go through aggressive MS and relatives through dementia. I respected and agreed with my Mother's DNR. I'm just unsure about giving direct powers to doctors.

Re the death sentence, very few people who kill children get convicted of murder. Those who would get the death sentence aren't the people who the public think shouldn't exist.

ohfook · 01/07/2022 05:59

I am in favour of both abortion and euthanasia if that's any help?

Most people I know are in favour of both. I think the general feeling is people deserve at least the same amount of dignity and consideration that we give our dogs!

iloveeverykindofcat · 01/07/2022 05:37

@absolutenightmare That must have been terrible for you and I'm sorry you had to go through it. I see precisely how it made you more sure euthanasia should be legal - in the story I told earlier, the difference is of course that our old vet, being a vet who owned his own practice, had precisely the means and knowledge to die in his own bed at the time of his choosing, which he did.

absolutenightmare · 30/06/2022 19:57

I am pro-choice although wouldn't personally have an abortion under most circumstances (this is easy for me to say though as an infertile woman), I still will defend the right for women to make the choice for themselves.

I am also pro-euthanasia, but with strict regulation.

I would not however say euthanasia is in any way comparable to suicide. My dad died by suicide last year. His was perhaps a 'rational suicide' although still ultimately rooted in mental health difficulties. But it has utterly destroyed me. The shock of that phone call, the fact I did not get the chance to say goodbye, that he died alone hanging from a bannister staring at a wall (which is far more brutal than assisted dying at Dignitas), the fact I will never get the image of his dead distorted face at the funeral home out of my head and that is all I can see now when I think about him. The only saving grace is I wasn't the one to find him. Grief from suicide is like no other form of grief, although I have learned to live with it I will never get over it. It has made me more sure that euthanasia should be legal and respected.

Lwren · 30/06/2022 19:08

A fetus is a potential life, not a life.
As someone who's had a medical abortion, you're lucky you've never had to make the choice between a termination of a pregancy or your own life.

Euthanasia allows for abuse to people not sound of mind. The guidelines need to be airtight.

The world of elderly finical abuse is a scary place and Euthanasia could really truly allow many people to be euthanized without the capacity to say if that is what they want.
I belive dying with dignity and Euthanasia is a terrific thing if people don't use it for nefarious reasons, however people are scum when it comes to money, so I'm on the fence for that reason.

feellikeanalien · 30/06/2022 18:11

I agree with euthanasia in principle. What concerns me greatly is society's attitude to the elderly.

I would not be confident that it would not be used to get rid of those "burdensome" old people who are using NHS resources.

It is not so much the greedy relative scenario but the perception that the elderly are a drain on the health service that would make me uncomfortable.

It's a very emotive issue and whilst I do believe that anyone should have the right to end their own life if they want to, the selfish nature of much of our society makes me uneasy about introducing euthanasia.

PushkaMcgee · 30/06/2022 17:50

Apologies @pointythings I highlighted the wrong poster

pointythings · 30/06/2022 17:19

@iloveeverykindofcat in terms of mental ill health one would think a person's medical records would go a long way towards evidencing that the person's suffering was prolonged, unbearable and unlikely to be resolved. And of course at the point of taking the decision and the point where the death actually happens, there must be capacity, which can be assessed. It's not that difficult, it just has to be set out meticulously and adhered to.

@PushkaMcgee it was LookingGlassMilk who was going on about 'the slippery slope' and saying euthanasia shouldn't be legalised, not me.

PushkaMcgee · 30/06/2022 17:14

pointythings · 30/06/2022 15:48

@LookingGlassMilk the Netherlands is one of those countries where euthanasia is legal on mental health grounds. And it is not as simple as rocking up at A&E feeling suicidal and being handed some suicide pills - that is a groteque misrepresentation of how the system works. And it does work. In the (rare) cases where euthanasia has been granted on mental health grounds, the people involved had been suffering without relief for decades. How long do you think we should torture people for before we let them die? Because that is what you are advocating.

No system can be 100% perfect - but in the UK the system is 100% imperfect with no end to suffering allowed for human beings.

I, personally, don't think the two (pro-life and pro-euthanasia) can be compared.

My Uncle lived in the Netherlands and had a euthanasia injection last year. As LookingGlassMilk says, it was very tightly regulated. He met with many doctors and physicians who discussed everything with him and his mental health was looked at closely, he was asked the morning of his injection if he was still sure. He had the injection at his own home, in his own bed with his partner by his side.

It was heartbreaking knowing exactly the date and time that he would die but it was the right thing to do, he had no quality of life, his partner was his permanent carer, his life was deteriorating every day, he had lived a long, healthy life and in his mid 90s was depressed, unable to walk properly and just slept or picked at food. He made the decision after a lot of discussion not only with the health professionals but also his partner and, sad though it was, it was the best thing to do.

I am wholeheartedly in support of the same thing being available here. Having seen friends whose parents have spent years with dementia, just wasting away to nothing, a shell of a person with no movement or recognition of what is going on I think, like we do with our pets, euthanisia, under the correct procedures (as in The Netherlands) should definitely be made legal.

iloveeverykindofcat · 30/06/2022 17:09

I think if you believe that mental illness is illness, it follows that some will be fully treatable, and the person will make a full recovery, some will be treatable to a reasonable or good quality of life, and some will not be treatable, and the person has no realistic prospect of relief from suffering. Exactly how you'd administer this system though is probably the most difficult question surrounding euthanasia.