Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be absolutely gutted the school have received a complaint about this race?

205 replies

WinTakenAway · 29/06/2022 20:43

Sports day last week.

It was the first one since Covid, and was so well run.

Every child had to do everything but they were all awarded a house point for taking part, 2 points for a 1st place only.

My DD came last in all but one race. The race she won was her against 1 other child in her class whose in a wheelchair.

This is the race they’ve received a complaint about.

According to the parent complaining it was unfair!

It wasn’t the parent of the child in the wheelchair who complained as the parent was heard praising the HT for including him in everything.

My DDs had the win taken off her, as the complaint was upheld by the governors. Even though the boy himself wasn’t bothered (he’d won 2 races himself).

DD needed that win, she hates school, is dyslexic and dyspraxic so struggles with even the basics. She needed that win to go into school with confidence and have something to boast about (trust me she’s the type of child that needs to be able to talk about her achievements as she’s always complaining and comparing herself).

It’s a mixed class of Y1 and 2s, so the other child was at most 7. And neither of the DC involved cared, as I said the boy had already won 2 races, my DD just needed a little boost.

Why can’t people just leave alone and let the teachers make a decision that’s best for the class?

OP posts:
Augend23 · 29/06/2022 21:43

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/06/2022 21:23

Why are folk assuming the child in the wheelchair is less able to cover a set distance in a straight line than a non-wheelchair user?

Assuming hard ground/track and not grass, when I used a manual chair I could absolutely beat my partner in a 100yard sprint and I have heart failure!

I know manual chair users who would almost certainly beat most folk in this thread, because their disability is spinal or specific to their legs and their upper body strength is phenomenal.

This is what's confusing me - the boy had won races already so competing doesn't seem obviously unfair to me?!

My understanding was that wheelchair users don't compete in running races because actually it can be faster in a wheelchair - same with the springy prosthetic legs?

XelaM · 29/06/2022 21:42

Oscar Pistorius always competed against able-bodied kids in school and fought to compete against able-bodied athletes in adulthood (obviously not condoning his crime). I think it's a shame that the boy in the wheelchair can't also be treated the same as other kids.

Idilliedanddallied · 29/06/2022 21:41

I don’t think it was unfair.

There is sports day and only one child who uses a wheelchair. You could either deal with it by

a) not having a sports day
b) having a sports day without any running races
c) somehow get enough wheelchairs so everyone races in them
d) not allow the child in a wheelchair to take part in running races because he can’t run
e) allow the child in the wheelchair to take part in whatever he wants to the best of his ability.

The last option is the least othering, especially since the child clearly has enough skill in his chair to be in a with a chance of winning.

BobbinHood · 29/06/2022 21:40

The school shouldn’t have even mentioned this to your DD. A bit of grovelling and assurances it wouldn’t happen again or something (although what’s the alternative - the child using a wheelchair just isn’t allowed to compete at all?) should have sufficed.

SnowyLamb · 29/06/2022 21:40

Ahh were parent governors present at the event?

They still shouldn't get involved, they're supposed to be strategic not operational, but I wonder if that's where the complaint came from?

Lowcarbfest · 29/06/2022 21:40

Hard to believe that parents actually complain about which child wins a race at a school sports day. It's not the Olympics, ffs.

DelosParks · 29/06/2022 21:40

The whole thing is crazy.

The two person race.

Someone complaining about a six year olds sports day.

The school listening to the complaint ever mind upholding it.

Madness.

Kanaloa · 29/06/2022 21:38

I hate sports days anyway. They’re just torture for non-athletic kids and it wouldn’t fly AT ALL in any other subject. Imagine making every child stand up and perform poetry from memory or do quick mental maths. It just wouldn’t fly and would be so unfair but for some reason sports day is okay.

In this case it’s a tricky one. Would I have set up a child in a wheelchair versus a running child? Probably not. But I also wouldn’t have removed a medal from a child after the fact, I would just try to smooth it over and regroup for the following year. It’s a whole messy situation overall.

Lowcarbfest · 29/06/2022 21:38

I cannot believe that a child in year 1/2 has had their win taken off them! That would never happen in any school I’ve ever worked in. Nor would the governors get involved in who won races at sports day

This.

Morph22010 · 29/06/2022 21:37

Dyspraxia effects coordination and movement so your daughter is at a massive disadvantage but where were the complaints about every race she came last in being unfair, it’s exactly the same thing but just because it’s a hidden disability people don’t see, I’d put a complaint in or at least formally bring to schools attention in writing

Mrssophie · 29/06/2022 21:35

Crikey, I was at my sons sports day on Monday and have been to my daughters previously, I honestly couldn't tell you who won what. It was mainly all done in small teams and they certainly didn't announce any winners. Aren't sports day only suppose to be a bit of fun.

EveryFlightBeginsWithAFall · 29/06/2022 21:35

That's ridiculous , we have a couple of children in my youngest dcs year who use wheelchairs and another dc who needed the support of 2 teachers to participate in the running race

None of them won a race but their parents (and the dc) all seemed happy with the taking part.

I have a dc with dispraxia and asd, he was a bit sad that he came last in all the races. I can imagine how upset he would have been if they decided to take a win off him . People will complain about anything 🙄

LyndaSnellsSniff · 29/06/2022 21:34

I'm doubtful of governors involvement in this. All schools have a complaints process and getting the chair of govs involved is the last straw for after all other avenues have been explored. It's essentially an operational matter which the head would deal with.

I think someone is spinning you a yarn.

Misstes · 29/06/2022 21:34

What did they achieve by taking their point away? The school is at fault for making it a two way race! Surely they could have found more runners? As a mum with a child with extra needs I would be mad they put my kid in that position. Two kids with extra needs against each other alone. Shocking.

nothingfound · 29/06/2022 21:31

WinTakenAway · 29/06/2022 21:17

@nothingfound I'm only going off what I was told by school I have no ideas how or when Governors meet, sorry

Either the school have mishandled this, or you were lied to. Formal complaints must go to the head first, they usually meet the complainant but also respond in writing. The governor stage is after HT process is complete and involves a panel meeting, not a regular meeting. It’s physically impossible to set that up, meet and notify of outcome within a week.

PrivateHall · 29/06/2022 21:28

To those saying the dc in a wheelchair shouldn't have had to compete against someone not in a wheel chair..... so should he just be left out of sports day all together then? He won races against other dc, are you ok with him being allowed into those races because he won, but its not ok in this other race because he didn't win? I don't know what the solution is here, but I really don't think its to leave this DC out of races. However taking the win off this dd is one of the weirdest things I have heard of a school do.

MolkosTeenageAngst · 29/06/2022 21:28

Why were there only 2 children running in the race? Seems very odd to have only two children in a race and even stranger when one is a wheelchair user and the other running on foot. Was there a logical reason as to why it was only the two of them racing?

Scottishgirl85 · 29/06/2022 21:27

A very odd race to have held, but how utterly ridiculous to take the award away. Why should a child be punishment for adult stupidity? They should have taken a lesson learned from it, but not removed your daughter's award. I would definitely complain back!

caringcarer · 29/06/2022 21:26

My DS went to a Special Primary school and had some children racing in wheelchairs with ta's pushing them running and they started part way down lane about a third of way so only had to go shorter way. A boy running won, second was a child in wheelchair and third as child running. Maybe something your child's school could consider in future.

twocatsandtwokids · 29/06/2022 21:25

Taking a race win away from a small child is awful, whatever the circumstances 😡

SnowyLamb · 29/06/2022 21:25

I can't believe anyone cares about the result of an infant sports day. Enough to complain? Enough for the governors to take action on a complaint received from someone who's child wasn't even involved? Enough to change the result after the event?

How did they communicate the change?

Plusba race between only two children, one of whom is in a wheelchair? I agree with PP why does that give DD a "boost"? I think someone needs to fund her another way to get that.

The whole thing is bizarre. I can't really see the complaint even being investigated if it came from someone not involved and definitely not by governors in that timescale.

BlackeyedSusan · 29/06/2022 21:23

Dd came last in every race in 6 years of sports day at primary. The other year was too wet to run it. Occasionally she got a third sticker when they only put three kids in the race. A couple of teachers managed to engineer that.

WiddlinDiddlin · 29/06/2022 21:23

Why are folk assuming the child in the wheelchair is less able to cover a set distance in a straight line than a non-wheelchair user?

Assuming hard ground/track and not grass, when I used a manual chair I could absolutely beat my partner in a 100yard sprint and I have heart failure!

I know manual chair users who would almost certainly beat most folk in this thread, because their disability is spinal or specific to their legs and their upper body strength is phenomenal.

Watzzap · 29/06/2022 21:23

Just read one of your updates. The boy won a race when he was being propelled by his mum! How come that isn’t unfair?

FabFitFifties · 29/06/2022 21:20

I've never heard anything so ridiculous (OK I have, but this is high in the list). I would certainly complain. Taking a win off a year 2 child, with dyspraxia, defies belief. Please put your own complaint together and force them to see how ridiculous this is.