Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To draw your attention to this U.K. abortion law court case?

274 replies

Wouldloveanother · 29/06/2022 20:29

Evening ladies
in light of Roe v Wade, it seems more important than ever that we are vigilant about abortion rights here in Britain.
there is an upcoming case at the Court of Appeal which seeks to repeal section 1(1)(d) of the Abortion Act 1967. Which permits later terminations for fetal abnormalities.
the hearing is on 13th July (next month).
very few posters seemed to be aware of it, so thought I would open it here for anyone who wishes to discuss.
thanks

OP posts:
pointythings · 30/06/2022 15:58

Pearl S Buck can do one. It is up to the woman, and only the woman, to decide whether or not she is willing and able to dedicate her life to a child with DS. People romanticise DS so much, but it occurs on a spectrum. The incidence of very young onset dementia in people with DS sits at well above 60%. Having seen two parents succumb to dementia I would not wish that on anyone - not on the person themselves, not on the parents who care for them. Nobody gets to take that decision but the woman who is pregnant with that child. The law must not change.

crossstitchingnana · 30/06/2022 15:20

Perhaps I phrased my post insensitively. What I meant was, yes hypothetically, I don't think I could terminate once past 24 weeks. Yes, I have two children thankfully healthy.

I understand right to choose but to me it feels so wrong to abort past the time when a baby could live outside the womb. I hope abortions past 24 weeks are done humanely is all I will say.

JustLyra · 30/06/2022 15:05

crossstitchingnana · 30/06/2022 14:19

IMO abortion after 24 weeks (when life is viable) is wrong. I would carry a baby with no possible chance of life, outside the womb, to term.

That’s good that you feel that way. Your choice shouldn’t take away the choice of other women who wouldn’t want to do that, or couldn’t cope with that.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 14:58

crossstitchingnana · 30/06/2022 14:19

IMO abortion after 24 weeks (when life is viable) is wrong. I would carry a baby with no possible chance of life, outside the womb, to term.

Out of interest, have you had any babies or ever been pregnant? Or cared for a disabled child or adult in any capacity?

Maybebabyno2 · 30/06/2022 14:57

SmileyPiuPiu · 29/06/2022 22:20

What is the difference between terminating a pregnancy at 39 weeks and killing a baby that has been born with a disability at one week old? this is what I am having difficulty with too. However I'm not the one having to make that choice so I'd like the parents to decide if they are ok with that or not.

I agree, however if the baby has a condition not compatible with life. I cannot see how it is less cruel to slowly watch it die for a couple of hours rather than just terminating in the womb without pain or suffering.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 14:49

Olivestone · 30/06/2022 09:08

An injection the foetus will feel along with the resulting cardiac arrest. I'm not saying this is any worse than if the baby is born and dies but it's not pain free.

Cardiac arrest is not painful. And an injection is considered only mildly painful. Being born is probably far more painful

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 14:35

@Tiag An injection is not considered painful enough to need anaesthesia. That's why anaesthesia isn't given to foetuses being terminated. Babies are given vitamin k injections as soon as they are born, no anaesthesia there either. They do scream so it does hurt but it's quick and not that bad. Anyway there's no doubt that surgery for cleft lip or club foot is painful so it's odd that you are so concerned about the pain caused by one injection to a foetus.

ApplesandBunions · 30/06/2022 14:34

It's always very easy to make these kinds of decisions when it's purely hypothetical.

Reallyreallyborednow · 30/06/2022 14:31

IMO abortion after 24 weeks (when life is viable) is wrong. I would carry a baby with no possible chance of life, outside the womb, to term

and if doing that threatened your own life? Or your ability to have any further children?

the only circumstance I would do this in, would be if the baby’s organs could be donated- for example anencephaly. If the child has no chance of life, i would rather it died peaceful and warm in utero, surrounded by all it has ever known, than be dragged into this world of pain to be stuck with needles and poked and prodded until it expired.

aldilemonade · 30/06/2022 14:30

@crossstitchingnana
Well aren't you amazing.
Whilst back in the real world some of us have had to make agonising decisions about whether to continue the pregnancy or not.
Some people will never get it so i don't even know why i comment on these posts because it just makes me angry about how perfect some people are and those of us who have made these difficult decisions are made out to be heartless monsters.

EddieHowesBlackandWhiteArmy · 30/06/2022 14:20

@crossstitchingnana cool, you do you. Don’t take my choice away from me though.

crossstitchingnana · 30/06/2022 14:19

IMO abortion after 24 weeks (when life is viable) is wrong. I would carry a baby with no possible chance of life, outside the womb, to term.

ApplesandBunions · 30/06/2022 14:13

And if the mother really feels she cannot cope with a child with DS then there is always the option to surrender the child to foster care and adoption.

Yes, we famously do a fantastic job for looked after children in this country and there's a huge surplus of prospective parents willing and able to take on children with significant extra needs. No fucking problemo, all solved with an airy wave of the hand.

SnackSizeRaisin · 30/06/2022 13:58

Demigo · 30/06/2022 07:18

@SnackSizeRaisin www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pmc/articles/PMC3740159/

Brian Skotko who led the study is pretty much THE leading academic on DS. He’s a paediatrician researching out of Harvard.

Why would only a tiny minority of people with DS be able to complete a survey?? These days people with DS have access to education so the majority can read and write.

They sent the survey to 5000 people and only 284 responded. That's a tiny proportion. It's likely to have been extremely biased towards the upper end of the ability range.

Slothtoes · 30/06/2022 13:27

Tiag not once have I said a post 24 week fetus does not have the capacity to feel pain. I am pro-science and anti-scaremongering so that’s why I posted about anaesthesia in your ‘death row’ assertions that the fetus feels pain.

EddieHowesBlackandWhiteArmy · 30/06/2022 13:21

For me a known disability would not necessarily have to be incompatible with life for me not to want to continue a pregnancy. That’s because I know what I would and would not want to cope with, I get that when you have a baby there are unknowns and you can’t guarantee a healthy child with no issues but for issues I do have the capacity to know about it should be my choice about whether I’m willing to accept that because it is MY life that will be most impacted by a disabled child.

How many marriages break down when a disabled child is brought into the mix. Of those I reckon a high percentage end with the mother being left metaphorically holding the baby while the father gets to pick and choose how much of the hard work they take on if any at all.

Fuck anyone who wants to take that choice away from me.

Slothtoes · 30/06/2022 12:51

Conditions don’t have to be immediately or inevitably fatal, to be desperately impactful on the quality and length of the life of the affected baby if they were born, and that same severity of course is also going to hugely impact on the woman, couple, wider family, the baby’s other siblings in different ways, according to the resources they have available.

motogirl · 30/06/2022 12:16

This is specifically about what counts as an abnormality to exceed the 24 week limit. Read Sally Phillips information on this. This is not the same as a condition that is not compatible with life. 24 weeks is a good limit as it's where early delivery becomes possible (just)

Tiag · 30/06/2022 12:12

This reply has been deleted

Message deleted by MNHQ. Here's a link to our Talk Guidelines.

aldilemonade · 30/06/2022 11:36

From Tommy's website

To draw your attention to this U.K. abortion law court case?
To draw your attention to this U.K. abortion law court case?
Talkingabouttea · 30/06/2022 11:11

@JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon it sounds like the initial diagnosis was cleft lip and palate. Cleft palates is actually quite difficult to see on the scans, cleft lip is much easier.

But it sounds like other abnormalities were observed as the pregnancy progressed that lead to the conclusion it wasn’t viable, which is a higher risk if a cleft is identified, but very much not the most likely outcome.

An isolated cleft lip and palate with no other issues identified is very much compatible with life.

So really the cleft issue is a way to get through the legislation. A ‘code’ to put on a form.

I don’t think her doctors/she should have had to justify it in that way. And the other end I feel like it contributes to stigma/fear of cleft diagnoses.

Livpool · 30/06/2022 11:00

PetraBP · 30/06/2022 09:08

OK, fine, for those who use the term “forced birthers” and favour abortion on demand for any reason up to term, if we reach the point where a healthy foetus is past the point where it could survive outside the womb, and we have a woman exercising her right to end the pregnancy, why not save the baby? Why does it have to die?

Are you going to look after all of these babies then?!

JesusMaryAndJosephAndTheWeeDon · 30/06/2022 10:47

Jott · 29/06/2022 22:30

There are various co-morbid conditions associated with cleft palate and cleft lip and the severity of the cleft can vary enormously. A friend of mine has a child with a cleft palate, as a baby she had difficulty feeding, had frequent ear infections, and over the course of a few years had multiple surgeries to repair it. At the age of 8 she still has difficulty chewing/swallowing, her speech is not clear, and she still gets frequent ear infections which have caused permanent damage to her hearing. It is becoming apparent that she has issues with her development and is not progressing as expected so is undergoing testing to determine why, genetic abnormalities have been suggested although nothing pinpointed as yet.

Down Syndrome is another condition which can vary enormously from individual to individual, it also has its own co-morbidities and complications including heart problems, dementia, a higher risk of leukaemia, GI problems, spinal problems, immune system issues, and so on.

The reasons for a TOP are between the woman and her medical team and it is the woman's choice whether she continues with the pregnancy or not.

The person I know who had a late TOP for medical reasons had a diagnosis of cleft palate. They watched and had further tests as the pregnancy progressed. She took the heartbreaking decision to abort when it became apparent that if her baby survived to term and was delivered safely he would have a short life in pain requiring significant medical intervention. He had zero chance of a "normal" life.

This was her last chance to have a baby, she had lost a child before and had an older girl. This baby was desparately wanted and his loss was a tragedy. The family and others like them should not have been forced to prolong their suffering or to put the mother's life at risk.

We must protect the rights of women in these tragic circumstances.

NCforgoodreason · 30/06/2022 10:36

*we do NOT have the resources that should say!

NCforgoodreason · 30/06/2022 10:35

I believe it should be down to the woman.

She's the one who has to bring up the baby, who has to give her life for the baby.

All this take away womens rights, force them to have children is ludicrous. As a planet we are extremely overpopulated, our life span has increased dramatically in most countries, we do have the resources to continually reproduce humans. We already have seen huge rise in costs, and food shortages....

Why the fuck are they doing this to us? And why as women are we not taking the streets?