Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

That alcoholism can be cured in certain people?

246 replies

teenagehurtbag · 29/06/2022 18:58

I'm a 30 year old woman. Have drank since I was around 12, it was always problematic for me since my first sip. I had never been able to say no, if I had one drink then I needed 100 more, my personality and behaviour would change completely. I binged most weekends from the age of 14 to 24.

At age 24 my binges turned daily, I would drink at a minimum 1.5 bottles every single night come rain or shine. I would promise myself every morning that I wouldn't drink that night but I always ended up doing it anyways. I functioned find from 24 - 27. Was able to keep being a mum and go to work/university and keep on top of everything and whilst everyone knew I liked a wine, no one knew the extent.

Summer 2019 when I was 27 my drinking got to an unmanageable level. I would drink from the time I woke up to the time I went to bed. I would sleep in between and get up and drink more as soon as I woke. My daughter (5 at the time) had to go and live with her dad. All I cared about was alcohol. I was so ill, lost so much weight.

In September 2019 I got help, started counselling. In October 2019 I stopped drinking for 6 months. I really really enjoyed this break from alcohol. It changed everything for me. I got my daughter back in the December 2019.

I started drinking again in March 2020 when lockdown hit. It was a conscious decision and I set myself rules. No drinking when my daughter was with me/coming home, no drinking 2 nights in a row and no drinking in the day.

At first I thought I was doomed as the fact I had to set those rules were enough of a concern. However, 2 years later and I have stuck to each of my rules, have managed to graduate uni, start my masters in September. I can actually drink like a normal person now. For instance the other day I went out with my friends and had two cocktails and went home and didn't drink for the rest of the day.

So many people say drinking in moderation isn't possible and at first I'd of agreed, but two years on and alcohol has about the same grip on me as a McDonalds Big Mac burger

Maybe I wasn't a true alcoholic. Maybe I was drinking to mask depression etc. but every professional I met with during that time claimed I was an alcoholic and on the fast track to lolling myself.

AIBU to think some people can be cured?

OP posts:
savethatkitty · 30/06/2022 04:14

You are kidding yourself. You are STILL an alcoholic, even if you think you are in control.

romdowa · 30/06/2022 04:06

I wonder how honest op is being here , with us and herself. I'd bet you are drinking far more than you'll even admit to yourself , never mind admitting it here. In my experience alcoholics are liars and they lie most to themselves. It's just a pity you can't put your daughter before the drink , especially when you know how bad it can get but no doubt you tell yourself that it was never that bad .

Adelesky · 30/06/2022 03:27

Did the same OP, 9 years in - no more than 2 drinks every 2 weeks. It can be done.
people here know nothing

BritInAus · 30/06/2022 03:25

I didn't need to read even half of your posts OP to know you're not out of the woods.

regardless of the units your 'rules' let you drink currently, your arrogance, delusion, entitlement and sheer idiocy shine through.

I so hope your little daughter has other good adults in her life and that she's getting professional support. God knows she must need it.

nowaydudde · 30/06/2022 03:23

DONT DO IT. Your mind is playing tricks telling you you will be fine but the reality is you will be on a slippy slope back to drinking.

I was like this about smoking, I'd do all the hard work. I once stopped for couple of years and told myself I would just smoke socially you can guess what happened.

You and alcohol are not compatible you need to stay away. Is there a support group locally you could join.

longcoffeebreak · 30/06/2022 03:19

I'm 21 years sober and i can't help think why would you chance it unless alcohol was so important to you it was worth risking everything for?

UniversalAunt · 30/06/2022 02:44

a else underlying. The point I got sober was also the point I started anti depressants. However, I've had to up them recently and still no changes in alcohol consumption.’

Have I got this right - you stopped drinking then started anti-depressant medication? Was the prescribing doctor aware of your drinking behaviours up to that point?

Then after a while on anti-depressants, you started to drink again?
You have been drinking routinely while taking anti-depressants, & recently your doctor has increased your medication to help you cope better with everyday life?
Have I got that right?

Is your doctor aware that you are drinking (in any amount) while taking the medication? Have you explicitly told them how much you are drinking?
I would be surprised if you have told your doctor what you are doing.

Some people might be surprised that you are taking prescribed medication as treatment for depression yet are self- medications with the depressant that is alcohol. I am not surprised.

BTW your daughter knows that you drink.
You may not drink alcohol in front of her, but she clocks how responsive you are to her, your absences in thought & deeds, & the smell of alcohol on your breath/in your sweat. She’s too young to articulate it explicitly but she knows & adapts to accommodate your drinking.

Your judgement is clouded by your self-deluding sentiment & refusal to take hard stock of your situation. You have choice in this situation.

DifficultBloodyWoman · 30/06/2022 01:47

There is a fair bit of misinformation on this thread.

Let’s start with the efficacy of AA. The big book claims about 50% will get and stay sober. 25% will relapse and then achieve sobriety later. 25% will always struggle. I don’t know how those figures were reached.

I do know that the studies have shown that AA (even with its flaws) is the most effective method to achieve sobriety, if that is what you want (OP, it doesn’t sound like what you want). The Cochrane Review backs this up - AA Cochrane Review - Stanford

OP, I think the big book actually addresses those alcoholics who decide they can control their drinking and start drinking again. Of course, initially it is drinking in moderation. But what will happen the shit hits the fan as it almost always does in life? Life goes up and down and my fear is that if you have turned to alcohol in the past, it is incredibly easy to fall back into that.

You have rules about your drinking now and your daughter never sees you drink. That is good. But how is it different from being a secret drinker? (Secret drinking is a red flag in alcoholism).

I am genuinely interested in your answer and open to that discussion you mentioned earlier.

alltoomuchrightnow · 30/06/2022 01:35

My schoolfriend lost her kids from her drinking
Her daughter... the same thing
My friend became sober and died a few months later
Because abstinence does not cure
Her liver was not cured
She was in her 40s

Oceanus · 30/06/2022 01:33

Maybe your nickname means something? teenagehurtbag...

milkyaqua · 30/06/2022 01:26

teenagehurtbag · 29/06/2022 19:58

I think personally that there was something else underlying. The point I got sober was also the point I started anti depressants. However, I've had to up them recently and still no changes in alcohol consumption.

There is always something else underlying.

You are kidding yourself/in denial.

The fact that you would drink like this, and then kid yourself it is just fine to start again with "controlled drinking" only goes to show what an alcoholic you are, not how "cured" you are.

Nat6999 · 30/06/2022 01:17

I watched my late dp go from the lovely gentle happy person I met to someone I didn't recognise. In the space of 6 months he went from someone who only drank when he went to the pub or maybe a few cans & a bottle of wine on a Friday night to someone who went in the fridge for a can as soon as he woke up & drank 15 cans a day. 9 months before he died he broke his distal humerus in a drunken arm wrestling match, it just snapped. I woke up to missed calls & when I rang him he begged me to get to the hospital, when I got there he was sat crying with his arm in plaster from shoulder to wrist. They wanted to operate to pin & plate it but he refused as it meant staying in overnight & because he needed a drink. He chose to be in such agony that he was on morphine instead of missing one night's drinking, he overdosed three times & I'm convinced that was when he damaged his liver so badly he was dead 9 months later. If you saw someone die of alcoholism you would never drink again, his liver failed, he was yellow, looked pregnant & looked like a famine victim. The day he passed away his lungs filled with blood & his loved ones had to sit & watch him drown in his own blood, he wasn't sedated & knew everything that was happening to him. He left his parents childless, his children without a dad, me without my partner & my son without the person who ran around with him, played video games, Nerf gun battles & helped him with his school work. I know everyone thinks of alcoholics as a waste of space but under all that he was a good person, kind, loving & caring, but the drink stole all that.

alltoomuchrightnow · 30/06/2022 00:19

Controlling drinks does not cure alcoholism, that's impossible , even if you never get drunk again

Yazo · 29/06/2022 23:38

Personally I think the rules and control are a bad sign, mostly because I think you can drink quite a lot and stick to them, but most of all because you always know the next day you'll have a drink. It's not worth it, I do know what you mean as a good friend is a recovered alcoholic but better to be safe than sorry. I'd quit you don't need it

Oceanus · 29/06/2022 23:34

Sb in my family has turned to drinking recently. Even when they're not drunk they're still very aggressive (but unable to see that) and they weren't like that before, I think it's because of the withdrawl but I'm no expert, I look at it as the before and the after.
I've said over and over again you have to stop and they seem unable to realise they've been drinking too much. They think I'm exagerating and trying to pick a fight because I'm a b*tch. Every single day they drink either wine or beer, or both! It's almost always a bloody bottle, never just one glass. It's always 3 beers, never just 1. Common sense has gone out the window, though it's desperately needed because there's a kid in the mix.
You are just as deluded as my relative. The fact you've posted here, though, tells me you're one step ahead in that deep deep down you know you have a problem and you've been dwelling on it but at the same time you're also looking for that last bit of validation so you can keep on drinking some more without feeling guilty enough to want to stop.
OP, get help before you end up driving with sb else in the car and it goes bloody wrong. You have a problem. The way you've laid out your story so nicely tells me you've been giving this a great deal of thought, so you know you've got a problem, you know and I just want to say I agree with you, you do have a problem.

LovinglifeAF · 29/06/2022 23:26

Joyfultoes · 29/06/2022 20:53

There’s a lot of ‘experts’ on the disease of alcoholism on this thread…

If you had been addicted to cocaine or heroin would you view moderating as a success?

”I only take cocaine like normal people”

well yes actually. I know Of one very close friend that had a coke problem and now takes it very very rarely if someone else has it on them

Right. So your hearsay sample of one makes you more of an expert than those of us who have had addiction issues ourselves.

i don’t profess to be an expert on anything but I am (was?) addicted to alcohol and have learned a lot since I faced my demons.

Southwestten · 29/06/2022 23:17

orbitalcrisis
@Fairislefandango AA has one of the highest failure rates of any alcohol addiction programme, abstinence is not the only route. Finding the root cause of the issue and treating that is usually the best place to start, after that you will know whether completely abstaining from alcohol in the future is necessary

Since AA keeps no records or statistics I don’t know how it’s known what its success or failure rates are.
Re finding the root cause - my father, uncle and brother were alcoholics and they blamed all sorts of things for why they drank. However, apparently knowing what made them drink (it was always someone or something else’s fault) didn’t stop them drinking.

Mumoftwoinprimary · 29/06/2022 23:08

teenagehurtbag · 29/06/2022 19:56

Thank you! I think yes, my goal would eventually be no alcohol at all purely due to the way it makes me feel the next day. But unlike 3 years ago, it's not something k focus on too much. I'm much more concerned with days out with my daughter and dogs (also a privilege I wouldn't have had if I were still drinking out of control).

So you can’t stop at the moment although you would like to?

It’s great that you are no longer unable to care for your daughter as a result - but it still feels like a problem if you want to stop and can’t?

TonTonMacoute · 29/06/2022 23:07

teenagehurtbag · 29/06/2022 19:25

I was hoping for a healthy, interesting debate rather than a pile on to be honest.

No, you were hoping that people would support your theory that you are 'cured', so you could carry on.

Many of us are older and have been around the block too many times not to be a bit more realistic.

You say life is good atm, but it's when you hit a bump in the road that it can all go sideways. Please be very careful.

featheryfancy · 29/06/2022 23:04

@AlienatedChildGrown what a powerful post

alltoomuchrightnow · 29/06/2022 22:59

AA does not get to the root cause , I agree with that. Although I never attended AA but certainly asked a lot of questions in Al Anon and we did have speakers come in from AA. I was told not needed (to get to root cause) as it's a spiritual disease. My asking of q's was never welcomed really,,,just brushed away.
However , the support and friendship of Al Anon certainly saved MY life. They made it about me and not my ex. They said I'd get better and he'd drink himself to death. They were right. Can't say I'm entirely better because of the ptsd but, I got on with life and they helped me with feeling suicidal. I did post about them on here at the time as they did confuse me. But I'll always thank them...
Nine years on I'm still full of q's though about why Al Anon work as they do!

Ladywiddio · 29/06/2022 22:58

I am an Alcoholic,once an Alcoholic always an Alcoholic.I have been sober over 19years.

Lots of people who are called Alcoholics aren’t at all,they can stop drinking and find another hobby.Perhaps you are one of those?

The fact that you are even debating all this suggests to me you are far from a normal drinker,normal drinkers don’t give their drinking a second thought.

I have known lots of Alcoholics drink again and control their drinking,sometimes for years,but eventually it gets worse and they end up drinking more than ever.

I am in AA,we say Alcoholism is cunning,baffling and powerful.It is also patient.

You made the decision to drink again,you accept the consequences.

alltoomuchrightnow · 29/06/2022 22:54

Most of the alcoholics linked to my Al Anon group never attended AA, not a single meeting nor followed the programme. Like my ex, they refused. They said they'd rather be dead. He totally mocked me as I went to Al Anon only after we split. And yes he died

Caminante · 29/06/2022 22:51

orbitalcrisis · 29/06/2022 22:49

@Fairislefandango AA has one of the highest failure rates of any alcohol addiction programme, abstinence is not the only route. Finding the root cause of the issue and treating that is usually the best place to start, after that you will know whether completely abstaining from alcohol in the future is necessary.

Do you have any stats and/or links to back that up?

orbitalcrisis · 29/06/2022 22:49

@Fairislefandango AA has one of the highest failure rates of any alcohol addiction programme, abstinence is not the only route. Finding the root cause of the issue and treating that is usually the best place to start, after that you will know whether completely abstaining from alcohol in the future is necessary.