Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my BF's response to the current issues around abortion?

134 replies

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:39

On rereading @nothingfound you are right, but I do think men are not as passionate about certain issues as are women. Because they are not affected. Many women I know in London are discussing Zara Aleena's murder on a busy road. DH and DS haven't even noticed her murder. They didn't comment much on Sarah Everard's or Sabina Nessa's deaths either. Whereas DD immediately went " I need to avoid that area."

steff13 · 29/06/2022 14:37

You're upset that he thinks people are entitled to their own opinions?

nothingfound · 29/06/2022 14:36

I expected to agree with you until I read your post. You're being unreasonable. He doesn't agree with the MP, he is maintaining the MP's right to express his opinions. He is also defending the Pope's right to express his. To reply to an earlier poster - that isn't being complicit. To be complicit he'd have to aid the MP in promoting his views. He doesn't even agree with him.

Throckmorton · 29/06/2022 14:36

Stopped from what though - having and expressing an opinion? I think the MP is absolutely wrong and people need to stand up and say this, but he also has the right to say what he thinks. We can't stop people saying things just because we don't like that they say

JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:34

RaspberryChouxBuns · 29/06/2022 14:23

Stop press! Men complicit in patriarchy!

This.

amicissimma · 29/06/2022 14:33

“Think for yourselves, and allow others the privilege to do so, too.” as Voltaire is thought to have said.

You will never agree with everybody all the time, but taking away the right to free speech is very dangerous. You may need it to defend your interests one day.

Better to allow free speech and put up a robust argument against the expressed premise. Personally I don't think 'I'm angry. I'm upset.' is a very compelling argument against any view, any more than calling people names for holding a different view is.

But you may not agree with me ...

Fizzgigg · 29/06/2022 14:32

He's right to an extent. I mean I'm incredibly passionate about these things too but actually getting angry at every idiot who I disagree with doesn't always serve me well or help me do anything constructive.

Any idiot can say things but if that's how this MP feels I'd rather know about it so people can vote him out. Give him all the rope ...

I don't believe in cancelling people for bad thoughts or opinions. Take action and do something to be the change but there's no point being angry about other people's stupid opinions.
If your BF agreed with him then yeah, be annoyed. But I can't fathom being this annoyed by your BF thinking that other people have a right to different opinions than yours.
Il

RaspberryChouxBuns · 29/06/2022 14:23

Stop press! Men complicit in patriarchy!

SweatyChamoisPad · 29/06/2022 14:12

I sent mine a link to the Guardian story as soon as Roe was repealed and he responded with a comment about how the Guardian never mentions things closer to home like Poland, N. Ireland and Malta, completely missing the enormity of what had just happened. This is an educated man with two teenaged daughters. The “whoosh” that went over his head probably parted his hair. Some men just don’t get it.

I pointed out that the Graun had covered the lack of availability in other countries extensively over the past couple of years and….that was the end of the text conversation.