Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my BF's response to the current issues around abortion?

134 replies

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

OP posts:
WinterMusings · 29/06/2022 14:59

AlternateFri · 29/06/2022 14:40

You need to find out what your boyfriend's opinions are about this, and decide whether to dump him based on that.

He's been very annoying so far but not stated his position on women's right to choose. If he's in any way anti- Goodbye!

Try READING what's been written instead of making up your own version.

He SAID he disagreed with the MP!! But defended his right to speak his opinion

@ConfusedatAmerica bloody hell. Are you against free speech for everyone or just people you don't agree with?!

your partner agrees with you about womens rughts to abortion, he simply thinks other people are entitled to give their opinion.

I could understand your anger if your partner agreed with the MP, but he doesn't.

LetitiaLeghorn · 29/06/2022 14:59

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

But you're talking about elective representatives that make law. That's their purpose. How else can they make laws unless they discuss and express opinions? Most laws affect human rights or behaviour. We elect MPs to instigate change. The different political parties believe different things but we don't ban parties that don't align with one political view. There will be women who agree with the MP, should their views not have representation?

jeaux90 · 29/06/2022 14:56

I believe in free speech.

I disagree with the MP.

I think people are allowed a platform however much I disagree with them. As long as they are prepared to debate. It's this no debate bollocks I hate.

I'm a radfem so have a very high bar for men in my life. You have to work out whether your boyfriend meets yours.

SpiderVersed · 29/06/2022 14:56

he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal

^ This was the cue to leave him, OP.

Eatingchips · 29/06/2022 14:54

I think I’d be annoyed if my DH didn’t consider someone with the views expressed by that politician as completely anathema to his own values and disagree ferverently with what he was hearing. It would bug me if my DH didn’t hold similar views to me on issues that were extremely important to me such as abortion. I want a partner with whom I share values.

Personally though I have no problem with politicians expressing their views in parliament, I’ll shout at the radio/TV when I hear them but I don’t think they need to stop speaking just because I don’t like what they are saying. Personally I rank abortion rights close to or at the same level as free speech rights, your DP seems to rank free speech ahead of abortion but he still values both by the sounds of it.

I’m Irish, debate on abortion was a permaculture here until the last referendum we had, what I have found abhorrent is the #nodebate women have experienced and are continuing to experience around transgender ideology.

Throckmorton · 29/06/2022 14:54

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:49

I will also add that he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal it's just that not all men act upon it, but that drinking can change that. This was when discussing Sarah Everard.

That is properly sleazy and disgusting. I could not be with someone who did that, and who thought it was normal

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 14:53

Wired = wield

ZaraSizeMedium · 29/06/2022 14:53

if your opinion does harm… then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion

Who decides what constitutes “does harm”?

Throckmorton · 29/06/2022 14:52

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

The chap is an MP. He was literally elected by the people to do exactly what he's doing, ie state on a platform of power his opinions on things that impact other people. I don't agree with him at all, but he's doing what he was elected to do.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 14:52

But being able to speak and say dislikeable and unpopular things which people find offensive is exactly the kind of democracy we need if we are to mount a useful defense of women's rights while being departed by both the left and right of politics.

I'm about as pro choice as you get but I have no truck with silencing the opposition. It's much worse when those who weird power legislate by stealth so that women's rights are lost through the back door - looking at you. NHS.

Mumoblue · 29/06/2022 14:50

@ConfusedatAmerica
Okay never mind just saw your last post. Throw the whole man out.

Mumoblue · 29/06/2022 14:49

Personally I think if you don’t think your partner would fight for your rights, why are you with them?

Too many women are finding out because of this decision that a lot of men in their life are just not particularly bothered about their right to bodily autonomy.

(My ex used to do this “they’re just stating their opinions” shit about his racist and sexist family
members. Yes, I respect everyone’s right to an opinion, but I don’t have to for a second respect their actual opinion. I have my own right to say it’s dogshit).

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:49

I will also add that he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal it's just that not all men act upon it, but that drinking can change that. This was when discussing Sarah Everard.

OP posts:
MintJulia · 29/06/2022 14:49

Everyone is entitled to their opinion. Thankfully we don't have mind control yet.

Hopefully that mp will be deselected for his views because they don't represent the views of his electorate but at least he was being honest.

Likewise your bf. At least he is honest about his views, now you can choose whether to leave him or not.

picklemewalnuts · 29/06/2022 14:48

I would agree it's a matter for debate. #nodebate doesn't win hearts and minds,

We need people to agree 'I trust women, as soon as possible, as late as necessary' is the right approach, not inform them no other view is tolerated.

Debate in a civilised arena demonstrates the strength of an argument, and shouldn't be feared.

EmmaH2022 · 29/06/2022 14:46

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:42

This is my exact issue. He likes to talk about alot of women's issues from a very argumentative point of view. He loves a good debate about it and we often end up clashing.

I don't engage with that kind of "enjoys a row" type.

but in my free speech POV, I'm baffled by people who do engage.

are you happy with him?

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:46

Actually no, I think what bothers me is that he is 'unbothered' by the MP's opinion. It's so meaningless to him that he can't even be bothered to be mad about it.

OP posts:
Cir · 29/06/2022 14:45

JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:39

Everything is a philosophical issue for men, while for women it is lived experience.

^I agree with this so hard.

But I would also add that everything is philosophical for men until it happens to a girl or woman close to them. Then it becomes real and important. Almost like women they're not related/close to are just abstract, nebulous concepts.

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

OP posts:
ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:42

This is my exact issue. He likes to talk about alot of women's issues from a very argumentative point of view. He loves a good debate about it and we often end up clashing.

OP posts:
LetitiaLeghorn · 29/06/2022 14:42

I don't know what he's done wrong. He expressed an opinion in a respectful and thoughtful way. People are entitled to have different thoughts and beliefs from others. Be careful of shutting down freedom to express opinions because one day they'll be shutting down you.

Circumferences · 29/06/2022 14:41

He did say "I disagree with him" so there's that..

AlternateFri · 29/06/2022 14:40

You need to find out what your boyfriend's opinions are about this, and decide whether to dump him based on that.

He's been very annoying so far but not stated his position on women's right to choose. If he's in any way anti- Goodbye!

JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:39

Everything is a philosophical issue for men, while for women it is lived experience.

MissBPotter · 29/06/2022 14:39

You seem to be against freedom of speech. While I disagree with what that MP seemed to be saying, he does have a right to say that. You seem to be of the ‘it offends me therefore shut up’ brigade, which I fundamentally disagree with.