Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my BF's response to the current issues around abortion?

134 replies

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 16:19

Recent posters have not seen your update.

FOJN · 29/06/2022 16:17

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

The MP in question was elected to represent his constituents in the place where our laws are made. I think you are being very unreasonable. There is nothing your partner has said which is untrue. You seem hurt that he's not as angry about it as you. The MP's comments don't challenge his right to bodily autonomy so it doesn't feel personal to him. Men are free to talk about abortion and I'm free to ignore their opinions.

I am a strong advocate for a woman's right to chose and for free speech. I think it's highly undesirable to create a list of things which are unsayable in parliament, a healthy democracy depends on open, honest and robust debate.

I might prefer it if that Tory MP STFU but that's not how democracy works.

EmmaH2022 · 29/06/2022 16:17

Pumperthepumper · 29/06/2022 16:01

I’m absolutely delighted that MPs can stand up and share views like Danny Kruger has. It means there’s no way to hide them and means they’re less likely to be voted in.

But the conversation about Sarah Everard is horrible, and he sounds like a dickhead because of that.

Agree

And free speech means OP BF said what he said about men and violence, effectively issuing a warning, and free will means OP could heed that warning.

doesn't sound like OP wants to, which is her choice. I think it's handy when men say that stuff - you know to run away. Fast.

SmileyPiuPiu · 29/06/2022 16:15

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:49

I will also add that he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal it's just that not all men act upon it, but that drinking can change that. This was when discussing Sarah Everard.

He can't speak for every man but he is telling you who he is. I'd run for the hills!

BigFatLiar · 29/06/2022 16:13

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:08

This isn't about free speech, this is about a man saying to a woman that another man has a right to hold an opinion that has potentially devastating consequences long term to women.

Sorry, but that's nonsense. Men are also entitled to their opinions. His opinion does not have any consequences for women other than perhaps some mild annoyance.

I'm not controlling but my partner is only entitled to express opinions I agree with. Isn't that the MN way?

skinhappy · 29/06/2022 16:12

my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped

I think your opinion is downright dangerous and utterly naive. You are fondly imagining that whoever the powers that be are that decide which individuals are not allowed to speak and which views are not allowed to be expressed, will always agree with you and your opinion. What if the powers that be decide that it is not allowed to talk about the right of women to choose as that harms unborn humans?

It is the absolute bedrock of democratic civilisation that different views and opinions are able to circulate and debate.

You are completely unreasonable. You are also unreasonable as you are clearly one of those people who loves to stridently express their opinion and then gets in a huff if the other person does not agree with you. If you don't like being disagreed with then keep your opinions to yourself.

YABVVU

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:08

This isn't about free speech, this is about a man saying to a woman that another man has a right to hold an opinion that has potentially devastating consequences long term to women.

Sorry, but that's nonsense. Men are also entitled to their opinions. His opinion does not have any consequences for women other than perhaps some mild annoyance.

butterflied · 29/06/2022 16:04

JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:39

Everything is a philosophical issue for men, while for women it is lived experience.

This is so on point that it hurts.

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/06/2022 16:03

But everyone is entitled to their opinion

Who gets the final decision on what opinion is acceptable and what opinion should be cancelled?

I'd rather live in a world where I can share my opinions than have them cancelled by someone because they dont agree.

If he has such strong opinions and polarising views, maybe you should consider whether you want to spend however long with someone whose views don't appear to align with yours?

Life is difficult enough without battling with loved ones over differing opinions

BigFatLiar · 29/06/2022 16:03

JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 14:34

This.

It's easy to blame 'the patriarchy' but remember it was 'the patriarchy' that gave the original ruling and this ruling was diverse in race and gender. No doubt the black and female members were channelling their inner old white man.

I suspect this ruling was more based on politics but not being American I'm not so aware.

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:03

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:46

Actually no, I think what bothers me is that he is 'unbothered' by the MP's opinion. It's so meaningless to him that he can't even be bothered to be mad about it.

Why do you need him to be mad about it? I heard what the MP said and I don't agree, but I'm not angry about it either. As your boyfriend says, the MP's opinion doesn't affect abortion provision in the states or here. We have a pretty good set of laws around abortion in the UK and nothing he says makes any difference to that. So yeah, I can't get worked up about it either. I think you're unreasonable to demand that your boyfriend gets angry about the things you get angry about.

roarfeckingroarr · 29/06/2022 16:01

I am fiercely pro choice but I agree with him on this - there's nothing wrong with someone stating their own opinion in a polite fashion, especially in a debating chamber!

Pumperthepumper · 29/06/2022 16:01

I’m absolutely delighted that MPs can stand up and share views like Danny Kruger has. It means there’s no way to hide them and means they’re less likely to be voted in.

But the conversation about Sarah Everard is horrible, and he sounds like a dickhead because of that.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:01

This whole thread gives a great insight into how patriarchy creeps into women's brains like a toxic mould. This isn't about free speech, this is about a man saying to a woman that another man has a right to hold an opinion that has potentially devastating consequences long term to women.

If the MP had stood up and said 'I don't believe black people have a right to bodily autonomy' would anyone make the free speech argument?

If a female MP stood up and said 'In light of the way men keep on murdering women I think we should debate whether men should be allowed out alone at night' would men tolerate that for one single second?? Of course they fucking wouldn't. Because men's rights, even when what they're committing is actual factual murder are never up for debate.

WAKE UP.

Meraas · 29/06/2022 16:00

Op, you realise your boyfriend is creepy right?

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 15:56

@Aquamarine1029 well that's your opinion, you're entitled to it. We have been compatible in many ways, the way he can express his opinions is often not one of them. He can very overbearing and will go on long rants to ensure his opinion is heard. I often just walk away at this point but now looking back at this conversation I can now see clearly that it is this statement that bothered me the most 'I can't be angry at him, because his belief is different to mine.' I fundamentally disagree with that, you are entitled to be angry, just as much as the MP is therefore entitled to that opinion. You can't have it both ways.

OP posts:
SmileyPiuPiu · 29/06/2022 15:54

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 15:14

@SmileyPiuPiu he gets more heated in person.

Omg then I'd stop seeing him. He sounds like a right dick.

balalake · 29/06/2022 15:52

You do not seem compatible, should this relationship continue?

MintyGreenDreams · 29/06/2022 15:52

He sounds rapey af sorry

Aquamarine1029 · 29/06/2022 15:45

I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion.

You very much have an issue, at least be honest about it.

You are very unreasonable to have invested two years with someone who you are clearly not compatible with. Hard work all the way around.

JustFrustrated · 29/06/2022 15:39

I agree with your partner. (Weirdly he said similar to DH)

I loathe what the MP said, but we have a right to freedom of speech, and whilst I may not like what's said I'll defend the right to say it to the end of times.

There is a difference between freedom of speech and freedom from consequences before anyone points out racist/sexist/inciting hate.

I do worry that these small murmurings may gain traction, however there was an attempt to pass a bill regarding changes to our abortion laws not that long since, and that was overwhelmingly shouted down.

We live in a democratic society, so we have to tolerate hearing things we don't like. Challenging, properly, where possible.

Write to your MP to express your distaste in what was said for example.

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 15:35

@Mangogogogo no actually we had a disagreement about it then.

OP posts:
RedWingBoots · 29/06/2022 15:33

picklemewalnuts · 29/06/2022 15:16

Your still missing the point. He has a nasty attitude to women. That's all you need to know. You can't change that. You might persuade him to hide his nasty attitude a bit when you're looking- might- but it won't change the nasty attitude.

OP please re-read this.

Myself and PP have pointed this out to you by highlighting what he says all men think about women.

His stance on people having different opinions isn't wrong. His stance on what other men think is wrong. His attitude to women is horrid.

Do not have a child with this man.

Mangogogogo · 29/06/2022 15:30

So you were okay with him discussing a murdered woman like that but not okay when he said the mp what a right to share his opinion?
bizarre

IRunbecauseILikeCake · 29/06/2022 15:29

Your problem isn't him agreeing to free speech.
Your problem is that he's an absolute creep.