Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my BF's response to the current issues around abortion?

134 replies

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

OP posts:
skinhappy · 29/06/2022 16:56

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 16:31

It amazes me how quickly mnetters would do away with free speech as soon as it provides a platform for uncomfortable and disagreeable opinions without any regard for the cascade of unintended consequences that dissolves any robust democratic function.

This.

thebeesknees123 · 29/06/2022 16:56

We don't actually have free speech in the UK- only America. Freedom is a relative term anyhow as it's easily contradicted by other laws such as not inciting hatred.

There are no absolutes. With absolute freedom, we have anarchy. I think, all in all, we need a bit of restriction

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:54

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:26

Do you genuinely believe that the opinions of MPs have no consequences? Have you heard of Brexit?

Brexit happened because of a referendum, not because of a back bench MP spouting off. So it's not really a useful comparator.

In this particular case, the MP is giving his opinion on the law in the US - so, no, doesn't affect people in the UK. In the UK we have very sensible laws on abortion and there's no push to change those laws.

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:50

thebeesknees123 · 29/06/2022 16:25

I don't think people have an automatic right to free speech either. Some people's views are very questionable and best kept to themselves.

In light of your update re Sarah Everard, he gives me the ick. I can imagine he likes playing Devil's Advocate except he's not playing, only pretending to

Which people shouldn't have an automatic right to free speech? People you disagree with?

Do you think you should have an automatic right to free speech? What if you say things someone else finds questionable?

hotcoldnotsold · 29/06/2022 16:45

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:43

Brexit is absolutely not a bad example @BigFatLiar as it illustrates a situation in which a harmful political opinion is introduced by MPs (the EU is bad and controlling, Britain is better off alone) it's amplified and advertised (through lies and fear) and then there's a vote, leading to people choosing something that is just bad for the country, in the belief that it's the right thing to do.

Brexit wasn't one rogue MP's opinion, it was positioned by the PM with support from a majority of MPs. This is not what's happening here. If BJ or anyone in his cabinet had the same opinion only then would this be comparable to Brexit.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:43

Brexit is absolutely not a bad example @BigFatLiar as it illustrates a situation in which a harmful political opinion is introduced by MPs (the EU is bad and controlling, Britain is better off alone) it's amplified and advertised (through lies and fear) and then there's a vote, leading to people choosing something that is just bad for the country, in the belief that it's the right thing to do.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:40

Jedsnewstar · 29/06/2022 16:37

If this MP said there should be a law brought in that child abuse is made legal would your partner be so eager to defend his right to his opinion?

People only seem to defend people like this when the issue doesn’t effect them.

Spot on. They also like to defend people who imply that women's rights are temporary and up for debate, as though that isn't an absolutely abhorrent position to take. If the same position was taken over the rights of men....well it just wouldn't happen would it? Men aren't subject to the whims of the law, they are entitled to their rights.

Pyewhacket · 29/06/2022 16:39

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 16:31

It amazes me how quickly mnetters would do away with free speech as soon as it provides a platform for uncomfortable and disagreeable opinions without any regard for the cascade of unintended consequences that dissolves any robust democratic function.

Totally agree with this.

BigFatLiar · 29/06/2022 16:38

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:26

Do you genuinely believe that the opinions of MPs have no consequences? Have you heard of Brexit?

Brexit is a bad example as it was put to the country and the country voted not just the MPs.

It might have been interesting to see what the result would have been if the Americans had put this to a referendum.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 16:38

Acceptable? No.

Of course it's not fucking acceptable. And I don't think it's acceptable to suggest women's bodies belong to the state.

But where speech isn't legislated against (for example, inciting hatred - which I'm almost certain your example would fall under) then robust debate is the only way that we challenge shitty opinions and don't just sweep them under the carpet.

hotcoldnotsold · 29/06/2022 16:38

Also don't forget that bodily autonomy for all sexes is a highly debated thing as currently we don't have the right to kill ourselves or euthanise others even if they want it. So I don't agree with the politician but bodily autonomy has always been contentious.

Jedsnewstar · 29/06/2022 16:37

If this MP said there should be a law brought in that child abuse is made legal would your partner be so eager to defend his right to his opinion?

People only seem to defend people like this when the issue doesn’t effect them.

SherbertLemonDrop · 29/06/2022 16:35

Yabvu your partner is allowed an opinion.

hotcoldnotsold · 29/06/2022 16:32

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:46

Actually no, I think what bothers me is that he is 'unbothered' by the MP's opinion. It's so meaningless to him that he can't even be bothered to be mad about it.

I'm unbothered by the MPs opinion. Because it is just that, an opinion. If he was impacting current legislation then I would care - he isn't.

I can either get mad at every twat with an opinion different to mine or do something practical to change the power dynamic in society. I do this this by mentoring young women to get into highly paid jobs of the future where they will be able to influence things. I also do this by working voluntarily with charities in the developing world to promote condom usage which will give them some health protection against draconian abortion laws. I do all this in my free time. It's a lot better use of my time than just getting angry at people I can't influence or change.

But I also believe in free speech and the right to express an opinion.

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:32

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 16:31

It amazes me how quickly mnetters would do away with free speech as soon as it provides a platform for uncomfortable and disagreeable opinions without any regard for the cascade of unintended consequences that dissolves any robust democratic function.

This is a genuine question: if the same MP had stood up and said 'I don't think black people should have the same rights as white people' would that be equally acceptable?

OchreDandelion · 29/06/2022 16:32

Honestly? This would be a deal breaker for me. There are some values that I feel have to be aligned and this would be one of them.

FWIW, my DH and teen DS were appalled and concerned about the US news.

TheWayoftheLeaf · 29/06/2022 16:32

He will never ever be impacted by these opinions. So that's why he doesn't care and just sees it as an 'opinion'.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 16:31

It amazes me how quickly mnetters would do away with free speech as soon as it provides a platform for uncomfortable and disagreeable opinions without any regard for the cascade of unintended consequences that dissolves any robust democratic function.

WindowsSmindows · 29/06/2022 16:29

Actually need not totally incorrect when he says that about how men think
There's a"classic" forensic text called "bad men do what good men dream" which endorses what he's saying.

Here's the question- you've been in a relationship with him for 2 years- you know him- do you like him? Love him? Agree that he is entitled to slightly different opinions to you? See him as separate entity to you, one that you cannot control?
Do you enjoy the relationship? Share common interests? Like each other's family values? Have plans for the future?

TheDailyCarbunkle · 29/06/2022 16:26

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:08

This isn't about free speech, this is about a man saying to a woman that another man has a right to hold an opinion that has potentially devastating consequences long term to women.

Sorry, but that's nonsense. Men are also entitled to their opinions. His opinion does not have any consequences for women other than perhaps some mild annoyance.

Do you genuinely believe that the opinions of MPs have no consequences? Have you heard of Brexit?

Carlycat · 29/06/2022 16:25

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:49

I will also add that he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal it's just that not all men act upon it, but that drinking can change that. This was when discussing Sarah Everard.

This is disgusting 🤢

thebeesknees123 · 29/06/2022 16:25

I don't think people have an automatic right to free speech either. Some people's views are very questionable and best kept to themselves.

In light of your update re Sarah Everard, he gives me the ick. I can imagine he likes playing Devil's Advocate except he's not playing, only pretending to

Carlycat · 29/06/2022 16:25

jeaux90 · 29/06/2022 14:56

I believe in free speech.

I disagree with the MP.

I think people are allowed a platform however much I disagree with them. As long as they are prepared to debate. It's this no debate bollocks I hate.

I'm a radfem so have a very high bar for men in my life. You have to work out whether your boyfriend meets yours.

This.
He sounds like a real Prince 🚩

TheOrigRights · 29/06/2022 16:21

The MP was voted in by democratic process.
He is not breaking any laws by voicing his opinion.

YABU.

DingleyDel · 29/06/2022 16:20

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

Mmm, the problem with this is that people are entitled to be anti abortion because it comes under religious beliefs and that is protected in our society.

For instance, doctors and nurses who object abortion are allowed to opt out of treatment on women who have had abortions because their religious beliefs are protected. It never occurred to me until I was denied treatment in the U.K. for a medical abortion that went wrong (granted my life wasn’t in immediate danger but I had had sepsis during Labour only 7 months prior, which I believe put me at greater risk and my bloods were showing signs of possible infection. Plus I was kept in hospital 2 nights away from my breastfed baby). To me this is absolutely despicable and absolutely should not be allowed for a gyne dept in a country where abortion is legal but I’m not sure how we protect the right to religious beliefs from spilling over into public life. It’s certainly worrying and I would never believe the right to abortion is 100% safe in the U.K. especially given some of our MPs!