Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To be angry at my BF's response to the current issues around abortion?

134 replies

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
Sugarpiehoney · 30/06/2022 17:25

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 16:08

This isn't about free speech, this is about a man saying to a woman that another man has a right to hold an opinion that has potentially devastating consequences long term to women.

Sorry, but that's nonsense. Men are also entitled to their opinions. His opinion does not have any consequences for women other than perhaps some mild annoyance.

This

WinterMusings · 30/06/2022 14:55

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:44

Not at all, in fact you've just described how he can often be. I have no issue with other people having a differing opinion. My issue is when those people are given a platform of power and then have the ability to instigate change that infringes on another persons human rights.

Frankly, I think you're angry about several things. What the MP said, that he's in a position to say it with a platform, that your bellend BF didn't object to what the MP said, that he's an argumentative dickhead that doesn't have your back.

your many subsequent posts explain why you felt the way you did, so I stand by my original reply to your original post, but in general I'd question why you are with Captain Bellend??

OchreDandelion · 29/06/2022 18:56

malificent7 · 29/06/2022 17:37

Free speech should be preserved...absolutely. do you have to agree with him? Absolutely not. Are you compatible? Dosn't sound like it.

The compatibility thing is the crux of it for me. Regardless of what some MP does or does not say, this kind of issue is something that partners need to agree on for a harmonious life.

wellhelloitsme · 29/06/2022 18:55

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:49

I will also add that he has said before that every man looks at women when they are out and automatically things of all the sexual things he could do to them and in his view that's normal it's just that not all men act upon it, but that drinking can change that. This was when discussing Sarah Everard.

Why are you with such an utter cunt who would say that let alone in relation to a woman who was murdered?

Shade17 · 29/06/2022 18:46

He needs to LTB!

Greencushion6 · 29/06/2022 18:16

Well, I'd say that your opinion "does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights" (your own words). So should you not be allowed to express that opinion?

Ogwen · 29/06/2022 17:53

I agree with your BF on the free speech issue, but for him to receive your text and respond talking about free speech was spectacularly missing the point. You weren’t, I presume, sending it to him looking for a debate about freedom of speech, but for a bit of empathy about how it feels to know that people in positions of power in this country hold those views. Thank goodness they do have the freedom to express them, so we all know where we stand. Doesn’t mean we aren’t wounded when we hear them.

He likes to talk about alot of women's issues from a very argumentative point of view. He loves a good debate about it and we often end up clashing.

Sounds exhausting. I’d hate to be put on the defensive like that, on issues that have such personal and significant meaning to me, in my own home, by someone who is supposed to have my back.

Honestly, I’d LTB. And accept he’ll never understand why.

BiscuitLover3678 · 29/06/2022 17:43

I will say that even though I agree with you, I have also learned to see this from the other point of view. We really are talking about two bodies and yes you are talking about putting a fetus’s life before a woman or girl’s life (and a real baby when it comes to the last few months of pregnancy - whether you like it or not, it really is a real baby). Yes some people will see that baby, male or female, as more important than the woman who carries it. It might not be right in our eyes or nice or ok but they can have that opinion.

Onlinemum22 · 29/06/2022 17:42

The donkey told the tiger, “The grass is blue.”

The tiger replied, “No, the grass is green.”

The discussion became heated, and the two decided to submit the issue to arbitration, so they approached the lion.

As they approached the lion on his throne, the donkey started screaming: ′′Your Highness, isn’t it true that the grass is blue?”

The lion replied: “If you believe it is true, the grass is blue.”

The donkey rushed forward and continued: ′′The tiger disagrees with me, contradicts me and annoys me. Please punish him.”

The king then declared: ′′The tiger will be punished with 3 days of silence.”

The donkey jumped with joy and went on his way, content and repeating ′′The grass is blue, the grass is blue…”

The tiger asked the lion, “Your Majesty, why have you punished me, after all, the grass is green?”

The lion replied, ′′You’ve known and seen the grass is green.”

The tiger asked, ′′So why do you punish me?”

The lion replied, “That has nothing to do with the question of whether the grass is blue or green. The punishment is because it is degrading for a brave, intelligent creature like you to waste time arguing with an ass, and on top of that, you came and bothered me with that question just to validate something you already knew was true!”

Moral of the story?
Never waste time on discussions that make no sense. There are people who, for all the evidence presented to them, do not have the ability to understand.

BiscuitLover3678 · 29/06/2022 17:40

Do you think it’s because deep down he doesn’t see it as big a deal as you?

would he react like that to things about men?

it sounds like the way he is saying it feels a bit condescending and almost telling you off for being annoyed. He just needs to say “yeah it’s shit I’m sorry” but it’s like he can’t just do that for you, so I get your frustration.

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 17:37

thebeesknees123 · 29/06/2022 17:32

There should be a law against bigotry - especially in Parliament

It's bigotry to say that those who disagree with you shouldn't have rights. You'd be arrested under your own law @thebeesknees123

malificent7 · 29/06/2022 17:37

Free speech should be preserved...absolutely. do you have to agree with him? Absolutely not. Are you compatible? Dosn't sound like it.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 17:34

Bigots should be robustly challenged in public so that the weaknesses in their arguments can be laid bare for all to see.

thebeesknees123 · 29/06/2022 17:32

There should be a law against bigotry - especially in Parliament

CourtneeLuv · 29/06/2022 17:30

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 17:05

I think, all in all, we need a bit of restriction

So your idea of restriction is not, say, banning pornography, or putting age limits on internet access, or even amending hate speech laws, or anything else that most people would find reasonable enough to debate. Your idea of restriction is that "not everyone should have an automatic right to free speech" and presumably you think that the people who don't have that right are the ones who don't agree with you, @thebeesknees123?

That's pretty much most of MN in a nutshell though, isn't it.

CourtneeLuv · 29/06/2022 17:28

ConfusedatAmerica · 29/06/2022 14:06

I've been with my partner for just around 2 years. I've always struggled with his strong opinions and attitude to some things that I am deeply passionate about. Mainly my stance around women's issues, sexism and the way that men treat women.

I messaged him today sharing a video of a Tory MP in the House of Commons stating that women should NOT have an absolute right to bodily autonomy, and that this should be a point for political debate. His response was as follows :

'I can't be too upset with that MP, he has a right to an opinion and he was discussing it in the right fashion in the right arena - I don't agree with him, but I can't be angry at him because his belief is different to mine.'

I told him that his response was upsetting to me because if the MP had been discussing something that took away his bodily autonomy I would be angry on his behalf, especially with something as fundamental as bearing children.

He responded saying that 'All it is is in opinion and that the MP's opinion has no influence on the current state of affairs.' He then went on to say 'Are you angry at the Pope for every time he speaks? His opinion has much greater influence, and the Pope has been spouting antiabortion and homophobic statements for generations - point your anger towards people with much power. Not towards people with much power, not towards insignificant back benchers whose ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist.'

I responded and said that actually yes, I am angry at the Pope for his stance and that he should also not use his platform of power to state what he does. I also stated that Trump ended up in power through the backing of small minded individuals exactly like this MP.

It's not the first time we have disagreed on these sorts of issues. He has an attitude that regardless of experience everyone should be able to voice whatever opinion they feel (including himself and yes he can have some very polarising opinions), my attitude is that if your opinion does harm to another faction or undermines or wishes to take away another persons human rights then no you should not be entitled to share that opinion and that as a society we have a duty of care to ensure that these individuals are stopped.

AIBU here?

Ooohh the irony.

I agree with him btw. Everyone is entitled to their opinion, whatever it is.

Luxa · 29/06/2022 17:25

'ideals don't meld with the zeitgeist'

How pretentious is that?

BatshitBanshee · 29/06/2022 17:15

Christ just dump him. He sounds like an arsehole and thick as shit all at the same time.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 17:12

I absolutely no not agree that all opinions should be respected. Complete bollocks.

fionaapple · 29/06/2022 17:11

Hate when people say all opinions should be respected and then the opinions in question are misogyny, homophobia, and racism.

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 17:07

skinhappy · 29/06/2022 16:56

This.

It's sheer ignorance. And an entirely unwarranted confidence in the idea that their own opinions will somehow be protected.

beastlyslumber · 29/06/2022 17:05

I think, all in all, we need a bit of restriction

So your idea of restriction is not, say, banning pornography, or putting age limits on internet access, or even amending hate speech laws, or anything else that most people would find reasonable enough to debate. Your idea of restriction is that "not everyone should have an automatic right to free speech" and presumably you think that the people who don't have that right are the ones who don't agree with you, @thebeesknees123?

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 17:04

I think you might mean we don't have a ratified right to free speech but that doesn't mean we cannot exercise our freedom to say disagreeable and uncomfortable things until it butts heads with unlawful/hate/libellous speech.

FourTeaFallOut · 29/06/2022 17:00

Of course we have free speech. We can say whatever we like so long as the thing we are saying isn't an illegal thing to say. It's not illegal to say that you don't agree with a woman's right to abortion.

BigFatLiar · 29/06/2022 16:59

the MP is giving his opinion on the law in the US

Those poor colonials bet they're regretting that tea party now. Leave them on their own and this is how they behave!

Swipe left for the next trending thread