Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Detention/request off school

80 replies

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/06/2022 13:31

DC has been given detention for incomplete homework. Was large A3 sheet with 15 question and answer boxes. Left 1 empty. Homework was set last Friday, due in Monday and after school Friday, he had 1 hour after school before leaving to go on cub camp till Sunday.

Anyway, he did the detention (30 mins) Monday and has another detention tonight (30 mins) as he didn't finish the last box as they wouldn't allow it in class or detention. I agree, he could have found time.

Today I've received a phone call from his head of year, requesting that for his best interests, that he is withdrawn from all of his outside school activities as they are hindering his school work and as he is going into year 10, incomplete homework is unacceptable.

I've refused and the school have said they will allow me time to reconsider and withdraw before they take it further as matter of concern. Not sure how they will take it further?

For reference, this is his 3rd detention in 3 years for incomplete homework, including 1 where homework wasnt handed in as he was off school with covid.

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 29/06/2022 13:41

The school is being absurd. Regardless of homework issues (and frankly, if your son has only ever failed three times in three years to finish his homework and one of those times was from illness and another was missing out a single question from a sheet of 15, he really does not have any significant issue with homework at all) it's none of their business what he does when he's not all school. His head of year is an idiot.

AbreathofFrenchair · 29/06/2022 13:41

Sorry, he is a young leader for Cubs and this was their end of year camp. He is an Explorer himself and has been on more camps than I can remember but this is the only one where he didnt complete the homework.

First one was he didnt realise the questions were on the other side of the worksheet as he had glued it into his book (within the first two weeks of year 7) and the second as I said, was he completed the worksheet and was off with covid when the sheet was due to be handed in. School said he should have been proactive in getting the sheet to school as he wouldn't be able to avoid handing in reports late at work.

The school itself doesn't have any after school clubs other than homework clubs and they are looking to make this so all pupils have to attend 2 per week and they seem to be against extra curricular activities until sixth form.

OP posts:
ilovesooty · 29/06/2022 13:40

They're being ridiculous. Very heavy handed.

Minfilia · 29/06/2022 13:37

Batshit.

He is entitled to have hobbies. All that because he missed one question on his homework after being away for the entire weekend?

Just wow.

AndSoFinally · 29/06/2022 13:35

Missing the point but why is he still in cubs in year 9?

I wouldn't withdraw him in these circumstances, but would keep an eye on his time commitments during year 10/11