Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To ask DH to pay half the mortgage after split?

91 replies

Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 10:13

We’re splitting, he wants to stay on the mortgage (house isn’t selling so taken off market and agreed me and DC will stay in it) however, he only wants to pay child maintenance (bare minimum/legal requirement) because it states CM includes ‘costs of housing’. He thinks I’m being unreasonable for asking for half the mortgage payments while he’s still owning half and CM and that he will struggle to live on his wage (we will both struggle either way) when he moves out.

3 very young DC (1 of them a baby still on the breast, 1 a toddler and 1 just started school) I will be working around his hours just over minimum wage in social care to cover my costs.

OP posts:
Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 15:10

Not half my housing costs, half of the mortgage we both share.

OP posts:
hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 15:06

Well no, you are not being reasonable then.

You are unlikely to get a mortgage based on your current circumstances.

You currently benefit from having the joint mortgage you already have and you want him to pay half your housing costs as well as his own.

He should sell the house and get a new mortgage on his own and start to build up his own assets.

hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 15:02

You should be able to demonstrate very clearly that the relationship is over for UC purposes from what you have said. Your divorce papers, letter from your women's aid support worker about the DA, your agreements from CAB.

It is possible you would be far better off financially if you moved out of the property, as UC takes your rent into account. Although if there is a lot of capital in the property, you may not be eligible for UC once the house has sold as you can live off the assets.

Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 15:02

Let’s just get this straight.. nowhere in my post did I ask.. “is he legally obliged?”, I’m NOT asking for legal advice, I’m asking if it’s a reasonable enough request for him to pay half of our mortgage as he’s requesting to stay on to own it, but move out, that’s it.

Your opinions are then made or advice then given, but to tell me to stop asking for legal advice when it’s not what I’m doing in the first place is genuinely bizarre.

OP posts:
UggyPow · 29/06/2022 15:01

My friend is currently getting divorced & they are using mediator to try to sort finances - would this be an option?

britneyisfree · 29/06/2022 14:53

I believe you can claim UC while he's there we long as you're clear you've split and don't cook for one another/ do each other's laundry etc.

Good luck.

hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 14:44

You have been given poor advice. You are entitled to universal credit while living together if you have ended the relationship.

Do you still have a joint bank account? Remove your name from it.

You will then be entitled to legal aid.

You can move out of the property and rent somewhere else and do not have to remain in the property.

There are also no costs to an occupation order which would decide temporarily who pays the mortgage.

Get legal aid and get the judge to agree lowering the selling price.

Sandinmyknickers · 29/06/2022 14:42

Yabu for taking legal advice from MN AIBU. You clearly have access to the Internet where there are many more helpful resources!!!

Reallyreallyborednow · 29/06/2022 14:42

I have 3 very young DC with him and I was asking if I’m being unreasonable to ask for him to pay half of a mortgage he will be profiting on in the years to come (when he finally agrees to sell)

you’ll be profiting on it as well. If he isn’t contributing to the mortgage can you look at getting it valued now and ringfence any increase in equity.

have you looked at extending the mortgage term or asking for interest only? Obviously long run it will leave you both with less equity but will make it affordable until your kids are older and you can start supporting yourself.

GlitteryGreen · 29/06/2022 14:38

ComtesseDeSpair · 29/06/2022 10:51

If he can’t afford to move out and pay half the mortgage then the house has to be sold, and you remain living together until it does.

Agree with this. I don't think many people would be able to pay 50% of a mortgage for a place they're not living in, plus CM, plus housing costs for themselves.

I'd think the house needs to be sold.

MooseBeTimeForSnow · 29/06/2022 14:31

No one has a crystal ball. What happens if, when you do come to sell, the house value has dropped? No one knows how the housing market will go.

Is he the sort of spiteful bastard that would quit his job?

And any agreement you make has to be approved by the Court otherwise it’s not legally binding.

FishcakesWithTooMuchCoriander · 29/06/2022 14:30

If he has money and you don’t, but you need a solicitor to advise you properly on a fair division of assets in the divorce, then he should be paying for you to have a solicitor. The costs associated with that can be considered as part of the settlement. He can bear the costs of drafting the order, but you need legal advice to go into mediation with and to agree the final order (that’s the cheaper option for you).

It’s not a ‘middle class luxury’. You have a shared home (potentially pensions and other assets), shared children to provide for, and different earning potentials - you do need proper advice about a consent order. Unless you are splitting up and have no assets at all, you need advice.

You don’t necessarily need a child arrangements order or anything like that - you can have an informal arrangement there. If you and your H can be reasonable and agree something based on legal advice, it need not cost too much. He can bear the more significant costs, and your upfront costs by the sounds of it.

Anothernosebleed · 29/06/2022 14:22

He should continue paying half the mortgage, but then you should pay rent to him for half market value - which is probably far more than the mortgage.

Fuuuuuckit · 29/06/2022 14:18

You are still missing the point.

Yes solicitors cost, and you will most likely need to fund some advice and representation at some point. But access as much free EXPERIENCED AND PROFESSIONAL advice as you can on the likes of wikivorce before paying out, this will give you a clearer expectation of what is likely to happen rather than what dozens of mn users who've never been in your situation think should happen

Your house will sell for the right price.
If her refuses to sell, a court can force him to.
He won't (well, vanishingly unlikely to) be expected to house you in the former marital home AND pay his own rent AND pay cms.
You WILL be expected to maximise your income (including claiming benefits, single person council tax reduction etc); you will be expected to use appropriate childcare if available.

Stop taking legal advice from mumsnet AIBU.

InChocolateWeTrust · 29/06/2022 14:13

If he can’t afford to move out and pay half the mortgage then the house has to be sold, and you remain living together until it does.

This

TiddleyWink · 29/06/2022 14:08

I totally get that a solicitor may not be affordable OP. Your opening post sounded like things were going to get pretty confrontational but if you’ve managed to sort other issues then that’s something.

He can’t just refuse to sell, you can force him if it comes to that.

cottagegardenflower · 29/06/2022 13:52

Someone can't afford to pay half a mortgage plus rehouse/rent themselves. It's unreasonable. You need to agree to buy him out/sell up/or he buys you out. CM is totally separate and doesn't include this type of mortgage arrangement. However if he pays enough to cover half the mortgage plus living costs for the kids, I would say that's a good deal.

MargotMoon · 29/06/2022 13:51

Please don't take legal advice off random people on MN. You may be entitled to legal aid if there has been DV. Ring the CLA helpline and they will do an assessment and tell you how to access free legal advice

Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 13:49

Obviously he won’t move out until we’ve sorted what’s going on with the house and he’s found a suitable home.. catch 22 isn’t it

OP posts:
Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 13:48

Thank you. I’ve spoke to WA, they was helpful to a point, he’s emotionally DA, however actually good with boundaries. They’ve gave me links to certain solicitors (this was yesterday) however as HE earns over a certain amount I can’t obtain legal aid (what a great loophole 😅) until I’m on universal credit which I can’t obtain until he moves out 😑helpful.

OP posts:
JustLyra · 29/06/2022 13:41

put up with however many more years of DA

Speak to Women’s Aid.

If you stay in the house that is jointly owned you need sound legal advice to stop him just entering the home as he pleases.

Be careful he doesn’t trap you there - can’t leave because you can’t claim housing benefit, can’t stay without him abusing you more.

Women’s aid will help you without costing a fortune.

Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 13:40

@IncompleteSenten Yes, I’ve put this to him (similar to the mesher order pp have mentioned) he said he needs to have a think about it (fair enough), I’m hoping that getting an agreement in writing will be the best option all round and I’ll just take premium bank shifts from work (evenings/nights/weekends) to make up the shortfall.

OP posts:
IncompleteSenten · 29/06/2022 13:34

What about saying to him that if he doesn't want to contribute to the mortgage then you get a contract drawn up that states he gets half of £x (£x being the amount of equity there is in the house as of the date of the agreement) but no more than that when the house is eventually sold.
So he gains nothing from you paying the mortgage after the date he stopped contributing to the mortgage?

Inthefirepit · 29/06/2022 13:33

Im not missing any points, im simply saying advice costs, 30 minutes of free legal advice isn’t what you get (I’ve been through similar from a previous relationship)- it’s 10 minutes of what they offer as a service, 10 minutes them listening to the issue, 5 minutes saying they can help then that last 5 minutes trying to book you in and charge for the actual advice and that’s when you can finally get a solicitor to call you back.

I think regardless of whether it is reasonable here what I’m taking from everyone’s opinions is; either go to solicitor to potentially get half or accept I’m not going to get half as I can’t get legal respresentation.

OP posts:
Sirzy · 29/06/2022 13:28

But your missing what people are saying in as much as If you don’t get it sorted now it will become more of a problem and likely much more expensive to sort because of the complexity.

expecting him to pay half the mortgage isn’t realistic. Not long term. If you can’t sort out a sale amicably then you need to get proper advice.