Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt at DH decision

93 replies

Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 07:02

Trying to condense this as best I can. My dh and I have one child who has a genetic disease which causes severe learning and mobility disabilities but is not life limiting. We had always said we wanted two children and after diagnosis when it was discussed we agreed we didn't want to change our plans. We were tested and found I have a balanced translocation which caused the genetic condition. Two weeks ago we had an appointment with a genetic counsellor to discuss our options. I didn't want to risk a natural pregnancy so we discussed referral for ivf to screen. It wasn't straightforward but felt the right choice. Then that evening dh told me he doesn't want to have anymore children. I was shocked and wasn't sobbing tears started streaming almost instantly and he snapped at me to not cry. I asked why and he said it was a big decision and he couldn't be expected to make it quickly. I said I thought we'd already made it - we'd kept all the baby and toddler stuff and we'd spoken about options and said we both thought ivf before the appointment. He said it had never been discussed and how could I not think it was a big decision. I do but I thought we were on the same page. The whole thing felt very harsh. Thinking back when I got emotional at the appointment he didn't put his arm round me or anything so I suppose I hadn't picked up on how he was feeling.
I feel really hurt and like my life has been spun 360 all of a sudden. I'm in my mid 30s so there's obviously a time imperative with these things and the hospital also has to make an application to do the genetic screening which can take several months. I don't feel I can or should be trying to convince him. It's hard to explain but I love my child more than anything and if it happened that we never had another that would have been fine but something about this is hurting me so much. I also have 2 friends whose partners pushed back on having kids for years then left and had new partners and babies in a relatively short space of time and I can't help wondering if that might happen here. My head is a bit of a mess.

OP posts:
LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 17:24

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:21

Really? You think somebody should be forced to have a baby? Because that's the only way around one person not wanting to have children without them "trumping" the other.

Not forced.

But both people openly listening, discussing & hearing what the other thinks.

And yes, that might lead to a compromise, but obviously one both are happy with. It's what's happened in many families I know of.

@EarringsandLipstick

thing is though when it comes to having a baby you can’t really compromise can you?

You either have a baby or you don’t

theres no halfway, meet me in the middle option

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 17:23

MotherOfCrocodiles · 29/06/2022 16:47

That sounds so hard.

I just don't agree with the accepted mn wisdom that the one who doesn't want children "trumps" the other.

Life is not a card game where you bang down your trump card and the other person shuts up. You are already tied together by the child you have, neither can just walk away, so I just don't agree that he can change his mind on dc2 without obligation.

@MotherOfCrocodiles

you are wrong

of course he can

just as Op could change her mind if it was her not wanting a second child

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:21

Really? You think somebody should be forced to have a baby? Because that's the only way around one person not wanting to have children without them "trumping" the other.

Not forced.

But both people openly listening, discussing & hearing what the other thinks.

And yes, that might lead to a compromise, but obviously one both are happy with. It's what's happened in many families I know of.

notquiteruralbliss · 29/06/2022 17:20

I would be exploring other options to have a 2nd child that didn't involve my DH.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:19

anyone in a relationship is entitled to say they don't want any/any more children and that's fine

I completely disagree with this.

As always, though, context matters. Ideally, the conversation about having DC takes place before getting married / being long-term committed. If one person definitely doesn't want kids, that's a clear decision for the other to make.

Of course, no one can really predict that they won't change their mind, want fewer or more DC than they might have first said. That can happen.

What I disagree with is the notion someone can baldly state it, and that's it - no discussion, no consideration of how the other person (that you love!) feels. One party cannot pressurise another to have a child of course, but stating 'no' with no openness to hearing your partner's perspective is not reasonable nor how relationships should work.

I know plenty of couples who have had to discuss having a 3rd or 4th baby. One wants it, other less sure. I know cases where couples have gone ahead, even with one more keen than the other, and where they haven't, with one more disappointed than the other

In OP's case, it's even more difficult, given the disabilities their DC has, and all the ramifications of caring for them & having another DC. It's hard for both, but even more reason for a proper discussion, done respectfully.

HoneysuckleBeanstalk · 29/06/2022 17:08

I feel for you both but ultimately he might just find the prospect of IVF, and all that entails and another child too much.

Vikinga · 29/06/2022 17:07

I think it is a hard situation and it seems like your DH is blaming you.

Also, would you be able to care for your second child properly? And what if they had another disability?

One of my friend's youngest is severely autistic. He needs 24/7 care. Sleeps very little. They are an amazing and loving family but it is very tough.

KrisAkabusi · 29/06/2022 17:00

MotherOfCrocodiles · 29/06/2022 16:47

That sounds so hard.

I just don't agree with the accepted mn wisdom that the one who doesn't want children "trumps" the other.

Life is not a card game where you bang down your trump card and the other person shuts up. You are already tied together by the child you have, neither can just walk away, so I just don't agree that he can change his mind on dc2 without obligation.

Really? You think somebody should be forced to have a baby? Because that's the only way around one person not wanting to have children without them "trumping" the other.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/06/2022 16:59

MotherOfCrocodiles · 29/06/2022 16:47

That sounds so hard.

I just don't agree with the accepted mn wisdom that the one who doesn't want children "trumps" the other.

Life is not a card game where you bang down your trump card and the other person shuts up. You are already tied together by the child you have, neither can just walk away, so I just don't agree that he can change his mind on dc2 without obligation.

Sorry but that makes no sense and in this case there obviously is a trump card which can be played by either sex. What if a couple decided to have 2 and then one decided they want 4/5/6?

Also, why have a chid with someone who doesn't want it?

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/06/2022 16:56

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 09:53

I agree with this & disagree with many of the other posters.

Of course, no-one can be forced to have a child. But in this situation there was an understanding that they would have 2 DC.

The situation is very hard from several perspectives.

I can absolutely understand OP's shock & distress. It is unacceptable for her DH to state they aren't having a other child.

He needs to talk & listen & the decision should be mutual insofar as possible.

It is unacceptable for her DH to state they aren't having a other child.

Sorry, as upsetting as this situation is, he's well within his rights to say it. He may change his mind certainly, but anyone in a relationship is entitled to say they don't want any/any more children and that's fine. As per PP though, he should be looking at the snip.

MotherOfCrocodiles · 29/06/2022 16:47

That sounds so hard.

I just don't agree with the accepted mn wisdom that the one who doesn't want children "trumps" the other.

Life is not a card game where you bang down your trump card and the other person shuts up. You are already tied together by the child you have, neither can just walk away, so I just don't agree that he can change his mind on dc2 without obligation.

Darktimes35 · 29/06/2022 16:18

I can understand why you’re upset. Maybe when you talked about another child it was more abstract and then your DH is at the appointment it hits home. I have two children with disabilities. I was pregnant with our third when we became aware our middle child had a disability. The youngest has the same disability (autism) but it’s much more severe and comes with a learning disability as well. I go through stages of grief and anger and sadness. I imagine your husband might feel the same. Our life is very difficult and we decided against any more children as we’re aware our older son has a lot on his shoulders with two disabled siblings.

Sooperdooper19 · 29/06/2022 15:51

CharlotteRose90 · Today 15:14
I think your husbands done the right thing. It’s hard bringing up a disabled child. Plus if you have another child that doesn’t have disabilities it’s equally hard on that child growing up. I know because I’ve been there. They don’t get as much focus or energy on them . It’s all on the sick child and not fair on them at all.

Totally agree with this. Have a friend who was the 2nd child, she couldn’t wait to leave home (and subsequently ended up marrying a right twat very young) and now her parents are aging, she is being pressured to take on caring duties for her very disabled sibling.

Appreciate not everyone knows their 1st child has severe disabilities before conceiving a 2nd, however, to do it knowingly is in my opinion, is unfair.

CharlotteRose90 · 29/06/2022 15:14

I think your husbands done the right thing. It’s hard bringing up a disabled child. Plus if you have another child that doesn’t have disabilities it’s equally hard on that child growing up. I know because I’ve been there. They don’t get as much focus or energy on them . It’s all on the sick child and not fair on them at All.

Hankunamatata · 29/06/2022 12:19

I think you both need separate counselling then couples counselling. There is lots to work through emotionally. Sounds like dh thinks the IVF is too much on top of everything else.

ImAvingOops · 29/06/2022 12:18

Do you think your husband might be worried about a younger child not getting enough attention due to the needs of the older one. Or being put in a position as an adult of having to take on caring responsibility?
You really need to get to the bottom of what specifically he is worrying about.
At the moment there is a big disconnect between you - he is denying conversations that you definitely remember having and he seems quite cold towards you. So now isn't the right time. I think you need some professional intervention, ideally from a relationship counselling service that has experience with families facing your particular circumstances.

Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 12:05

To answer some questions dc is 3 and will need lifelong care. We are in a support group with other families and there is a lot of variation in how people with the condition develop so a lot of unknowns. Most families have more than 1 child but I'd say the majority the youngest child is the one who is disabled so it's a little different. We've definitely discussed it and I thought fairly in depth about pros and cons and effects on dc and potential future sc. We'd discussed ivf before the appointment. It is a difficult decision to have another child when one is already disabled. I'm still feeling very sad and am trying to keep this to myself. Thank you all for your input x

OP posts:
Mally100 · 29/06/2022 09:55

This is heartbreaking for you and I really understand where you are coming from. Your dh seems to have his own unfair but valid reasons. However his reaction isn't caring or sensitive to the situation. I also think something happened after the session you had. Would you both consider a counsellor to discuss this with? To communicate this final decision and what are the alternatives, what changed and what does this mean for your future.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 09:53

Comtesse · 29/06/2022 09:27

i would say he has an on obligation to keep talking. He may not change his mind but I don’t see why he can just stop the debate either, certainly not at this stage when it’s all very new. It sounds very hard Flowers

I agree with this & disagree with many of the other posters.

Of course, no-one can be forced to have a child. But in this situation there was an understanding that they would have 2 DC.

The situation is very hard from several perspectives.

I can absolutely understand OP's shock & distress. It is unacceptable for her DH to state they aren't having a other child.

He needs to talk & listen & the decision should be mutual insofar as possible.

PollyPatella8 · 29/06/2022 09:49

Although he is entitled to change his mind, your DH is being very unreasonable in the way he is communicating (,or not communicating) with you op. If it is such a big decision then surely he needs to respect that by discussing it reasonably and at length with you. This should be a joint decision, and it is really immature and unkind of him to dismiss your opinions and feelings about this out of hand. He should at least be prepared to treat this issue with seriousness and sympathy, not shut down and tell you off for crying .

However it is clear from what you have written that you will probably get further with him by suppressing your emotions over this and presenting a logical and rational argument as to why a second child is a good idea, or why taking that leap of faith is something you strongly want to do. Do you know any families who have DC with the same condition op? Did any of them go on to have more DC? If so, it might be worth introducing them to your DH.

Finally, I sense from what you have written that you have an underlying worry that there is a more fundamental problem with your marriage and you are worried that the reason your DH does not want to commit to a second child is BC he is no longer fully invested in your relationship. If that is the case, then you need to discuss this openly with him (better to know what you are facing and find out how he feels) and maybe counselling could be helpful?

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 29/06/2022 09:31

I do think it's fair enough for him not to want more kids though in your circumstances. It sounds like the needs of your current child will be enormous and lifelong (maybe even longer than your life). Is it fair to knowingly have another child upon whom a lot of this burden will necessarily fall as you and your husband get older? Is it fair to your current child to deliberately split your attention when their needs will be so great?

Brefugee · 29/06/2022 09:31

it's hard for you, OP, but as others said, it's a two yesses situation. And also it could be that what you think of as discussing it, and what he thinks of as discussing it are two different things. It could be that the IVF meeting was his final straw.

He seems cold, but maybe he feels that your tears are a kind of blackmail? No idea but i feel very badly for you wanting this so much and realising it's not going to happen.

MaybeIWillFuckOffThen · 29/06/2022 09:28

It's his sudden coldness towards you on the back of your diagnosis that bothers me. Is he one of those people who always thinks everything has to be somebody's 'fault'?

Comtesse · 29/06/2022 09:27

i would say he has an on obligation to keep talking. He may not change his mind but I don’t see why he can just stop the debate either, certainly not at this stage when it’s all very new. It sounds very hard Flowers

aNCforjune · 29/06/2022 09:27

WhatsWithAllTheCarrots · 29/06/2022 09:22

Well, yes he's perfectly within his rights to decide he doesn't want another child, but you are definitely not being unreasonable here - I'm just going to echo what you said back to you:

You guys had discussed it before having children, discussed it AGAIN after DC was diagnosed and agreed plans aren't changed, put clothes aside, made an appointment with a genetic counsellor to discuss your options for pregnancy, and within that appointment discussed being referred for IVF.

Throughout all this, your DH hasn't indicated once that he might not be on board with having a second child - he waited until after you had discussed the IVF referral to voice those feelings. So OF COURSE you are blindsided, and OF COURSE you are upset. He has no right to tell you not to cry. I notice he also said it had never been discussed - but you felt it had been discussed? And I mean, it had been discussed to the point that you both ended up in a genetic counselling appointment looking at pregnancy options, so...!!

I also notice he said it was a big decision and he couldn't be expected to make it quickly. Does that then mean that he might still want a second child, but just needs to take some time to think it through? Did he indicate what was putting him off or worrying him about the idea of having two?

It sounds to me like the two of you need to try to sit down and talk through your feelings about this so that you can better understand one another's viewpoints. Maybe agree to each other that to begin with you can each have your say, without interruption, and that the other person needs to just listen.

Best of luck x

Agree with all of this