Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To feel hurt at DH decision

93 replies

Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 07:02

Trying to condense this as best I can. My dh and I have one child who has a genetic disease which causes severe learning and mobility disabilities but is not life limiting. We had always said we wanted two children and after diagnosis when it was discussed we agreed we didn't want to change our plans. We were tested and found I have a balanced translocation which caused the genetic condition. Two weeks ago we had an appointment with a genetic counsellor to discuss our options. I didn't want to risk a natural pregnancy so we discussed referral for ivf to screen. It wasn't straightforward but felt the right choice. Then that evening dh told me he doesn't want to have anymore children. I was shocked and wasn't sobbing tears started streaming almost instantly and he snapped at me to not cry. I asked why and he said it was a big decision and he couldn't be expected to make it quickly. I said I thought we'd already made it - we'd kept all the baby and toddler stuff and we'd spoken about options and said we both thought ivf before the appointment. He said it had never been discussed and how could I not think it was a big decision. I do but I thought we were on the same page. The whole thing felt very harsh. Thinking back when I got emotional at the appointment he didn't put his arm round me or anything so I suppose I hadn't picked up on how he was feeling.
I feel really hurt and like my life has been spun 360 all of a sudden. I'm in my mid 30s so there's obviously a time imperative with these things and the hospital also has to make an application to do the genetic screening which can take several months. I don't feel I can or should be trying to convince him. It's hard to explain but I love my child more than anything and if it happened that we never had another that would have been fine but something about this is hurting me so much. I also have 2 friends whose partners pushed back on having kids for years then left and had new partners and babies in a relatively short space of time and I can't help wondering if that might happen here. My head is a bit of a mess.

OP posts:
JanisMoplin · 29/06/2022 18:54

Am on your DH's side and I would do the same.

Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 18:51

No ofc not but it sparked a worry in me.

OP posts:
Johnnysgirl · 29/06/2022 18:39

I've seen friends give up on the dream of a much wanted child for their partners who have then walked out and within a short space of time had a baby with a new partner. One within a year of their separation!
The thing is; you can't stop someone doing that. None of those people could have forced their partners to choose them to have a baby with.
We only have free will wrt our own behaviour, not anyone else's.

Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 18:34

Just to clarify - our options were conceive naturally (with high chance of pregnancy loss) and either screen at around 12 weeks or at birth, Ivf with pre implementation genetic testing or no more children.

We both agree that we wouldn't want to risk either miscarriage or passing on a genetic condition so the first wouldn't be an option. So it was between no more children or attempting ivf with screening.

OP posts:
Ciaocatnip · 29/06/2022 18:21

Thanks for all the replies. I think I've got my head on a little straighter now. He has apologised to me for being insensitive and said he wants to talk about it. We've agreed to give it a bit of breathing space I think it's a bit too raw still atm and will lead to me getting teary and him stonewalling.

My personal opinion is that one partner can vetoe having a child but it should be discussed properly. There was some massive rewriting of history and gaslighting going on with dh pretending this was all out of the blue which has hurt me a lot.

This part is a me issue - I've seen friends give up on the dream of a much wanted child for their partners who have then walked out and within a short space of time had a baby with a new partner. One within a year of their separation! That's nothing against my dh but I think it's planted a "men can be shits" seed in my brain and when he started to lie about the conversations we'd had that seed started to root.

With regards having a 2nd when the 1st is disabled. I think it's a very personal decision down the disability/support network/future health concerns etc. It's certainly not an easy decision to make. I cared for my Mum so I recognise I have a skewed view on caring. Really it's just been a continuation for me as she passed a month before dc was born. It's hard to predict future care support (or what support will even be available with how things are in the UK!). Some adults with dc condition are at home with full time family care some live in supported accommodation. It's really impossible to judge how that will play out which ofc makes future planning hard as well.

I have got a therapist that I have been seeing on and off for a few years so I've scheduled an appointment to have a debrief!

Sorry this is long and thanks again!

OP posts:
hattie43 · 29/06/2022 18:11

As awful as it sounds I wouldn't be surprised if he maybe considering his options to have a healthy child with someone else at some point .

I absolutely wouldn't risk having a second disabled child so can understand his reticence.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 18:10

I only want one child myself. Me and my husband can discuss it and discuss it until we are blue in the face but it won’t change anything because I know my own mind as does OP’s husband

and as others have said you can’t compromise on this - you either have a baby or you don’t. One will ‘win’

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 18:08

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:35

it’s one partner giving in to what the other wants in order to keep the peace and maintain the relationship

I don't think so tho obviously it entirely depends on the quality of the relationship.

It has to ultimately be what both people are happy with, after discussion.

It's not 'giving in'.

As I say, I know many couples who have had exactly this discussion. Sometimes they will go ahead & try for another, sometimes not. To me, it's about respect for one another.

@EarringsandLipstick

but it is giving in!

ops husband has clearly stated that he doesn’t want a second child

They can have a discussion (I.e., OP can try and talk him round and persuade him) and if he agrees then he is giving in. Of course he is. He won’t be happy about because he has already stated that he doesn’t want another child, really what can a discussion do? What can op say in that discussion to make him change his kid besides ‘I’m leaving you if you don’t get me pregnant’?

If the boot was on the foot it and it was a man pressuring a woman would be describe described as coercive and rightly so

Babdoc · 29/06/2022 18:01

I used to be clinical lead for special
needs anaesthesia in my hospital, and it was depressing how many men walked out on their wives when the hard reality of raising a disabled child sank in.
OP, I am more concerned by his cold attitude, than his decision on a second child. I suspect he is withdrawing from you and the marriage, and wants out. A second child would be an added tie and complication in terms of maintenance and contact.

I hope I am wrong in your particular case, but I have seen this so often - the man starting another family elsewhere while the mother struggles as single parent to a challenging special needs child. You need a serious and honest discussion with your DH about what is really going on here.

mathanxiety · 29/06/2022 17:50

Your H is trying to blame you for pushing him into something he never once told you he didn't want.

You are not a mind reader and it is dishonest and cowardly of him to accuse you of doing something he never agreed to.

Call him out on his completely unreasonable expectation that you should have read his mind. He needs to grow up and use his words - directly, honestly, and with kindness.

Fenella123 · 29/06/2022 17:48

Bloody men.
Am I imagining it, or is there an unhappily Darwinian pattern where a couple have a disabled child and then the man sidles out of the relationship to go spread his seed elsewhere and raise the younger kids he then fathers?

I get it OP, it's about the communication/ lack of, not so much the decision itself.

MimiSunshine · 29/06/2022 17:38

It’s of course within his right to change his mind but what many PP seem to be missing is the issue that he says they’ve never discussed it up to now.

how does he think they got to the stage of having IVF appointments without any discussion?
he’s rewriting history to suit and ease his feelings of guilt about changing his mind and rather than face the upset that doing so will bring, he has gone on the defensive and wants to position himself as being rushed into a decision.

OP ask him why he’s claiming no discussion and what has happened to change his mind? And yes to telling him
hell be the one to get the snip.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:38

Or he might have just changed his mind, which he is absolutely entitled to do.

Sure.

But he's not entitled to announce it to her coldly, after having the appointment / counselling & with no discussion or appreciation of her feelings.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:37

He doesn't want one. They could debate it and exchange views, but if he doesn't change his mind....?

No I agree with this. If there is no way that discussion leads to a shared decision, then it's hard, and I agree, it's not possible to have another child.

In this case, it's more complicated due to the DH's change in approach, lack of communication & that their first child is disabled.

I was speaking generally but yes, you're right if there is no shared agreement after discussion.

Aquamarine1029 · 29/06/2022 17:36

KangarooKenny · 29/06/2022 07:37

He’s a coward and a shit to let it get this far without speaking up.

Or he might have just changed his mind, which he is absolutely entitled to do.

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/06/2022 17:35

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:32

@ChateauxNeufDePoop

It's not 'utter nonsense' nor is it 'forcing' someone.

Please read my posts properly.

It's about a respectful discussion leading to an agreed course of action. This might not be the starting point for one person but they may agree.

Most couples I know have had some version of this discussion.

There's no need to rubbish someone's opinion, without even reading my post properly, because you disagree.

He doesn't want one. They could debate it and exchange views, but if he doesn't change his mind....?

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:35

it’s one partner giving in to what the other wants in order to keep the peace and maintain the relationship

I don't think so tho obviously it entirely depends on the quality of the relationship.

It has to ultimately be what both people are happy with, after discussion.

It's not 'giving in'.

As I say, I know many couples who have had exactly this discussion. Sometimes they will go ahead & try for another, sometimes not. To me, it's about respect for one another.

Johnnysgirl · 29/06/2022 17:34

KangarooKenny · 29/06/2022 07:37

He’s a coward and a shit to let it get this far without speaking up.

Of course he isn't, don't talk nonsense.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:33

JellyBellyNelly · 29/06/2022 17:30

Finally, I sense from what you have written that you have an underlying worry that there is a more fundamental problem with your marriage and you are worried that the reason your DH does not want to commit to a second child is BC he is no longer fully invested in your relationship. If that is the case, then you need to discuss this openly with him (better to know what you are facing and find out how he feels) and maybe counselling could be helpful?

I think this poster is spot on in what she says and if I was the Op I’d be really scared right now. What an awful situation to be in.

I agree with this too, sadly.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 17:32

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:30

@LuckySantangelo35

I think you can. Certainly, couples I know have.

As I said, sometimes it's been the case that one wanted another child, the other didn't. They talk about it, listen to each other & make a decision one way or the other.

The compromise is that one person may be agreeing to a course of action that they weren't initially keen on, but following a respectful discussion, are happy.

(I'm aware the OP's situation is more complex than this but just answering your point on compromise)

@EarringsandLipstick

it’s not a compromise though is it

it’s one partner giving in to what the other wants in order to keep the peace and maintain the relationship

in this instance that ‘compromise’ would be OP’s husband agreeing to have a kid he doesn’t want in order to keep his partner happy

it’s completely unfair on either a male or female partner

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:32

@ChateauxNeufDePoop

It's not 'utter nonsense' nor is it 'forcing' someone.

Please read my posts properly.

It's about a respectful discussion leading to an agreed course of action. This might not be the starting point for one person but they may agree.

Most couples I know have had some version of this discussion.

There's no need to rubbish someone's opinion, without even reading my post properly, because you disagree.

JellyBellyNelly · 29/06/2022 17:30

Finally, I sense from what you have written that you have an underlying worry that there is a more fundamental problem with your marriage and you are worried that the reason your DH does not want to commit to a second child is BC he is no longer fully invested in your relationship. If that is the case, then you need to discuss this openly with him (better to know what you are facing and find out how he feels) and maybe counselling could be helpful?

I think this poster is spot on in what she says and if I was the Op I’d be really scared right now. What an awful situation to be in.

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:30

@LuckySantangelo35

I think you can. Certainly, couples I know have.

As I said, sometimes it's been the case that one wanted another child, the other didn't. They talk about it, listen to each other & make a decision one way or the other.

The compromise is that one person may be agreeing to a course of action that they weren't initially keen on, but following a respectful discussion, are happy.

(I'm aware the OP's situation is more complex than this but just answering your point on compromise)

ChateauxNeufDePoop · 29/06/2022 17:29

EarringsandLipstick · 29/06/2022 17:19

anyone in a relationship is entitled to say they don't want any/any more children and that's fine

I completely disagree with this.

As always, though, context matters. Ideally, the conversation about having DC takes place before getting married / being long-term committed. If one person definitely doesn't want kids, that's a clear decision for the other to make.

Of course, no one can really predict that they won't change their mind, want fewer or more DC than they might have first said. That can happen.

What I disagree with is the notion someone can baldly state it, and that's it - no discussion, no consideration of how the other person (that you love!) feels. One party cannot pressurise another to have a child of course, but stating 'no' with no openness to hearing your partner's perspective is not reasonable nor how relationships should work.

I know plenty of couples who have had to discuss having a 3rd or 4th baby. One wants it, other less sure. I know cases where couples have gone ahead, even with one more keen than the other, and where they haven't, with one more disappointed than the other

In OP's case, it's even more difficult, given the disabilities their DC has, and all the ramifications of caring for them & having another DC. It's hard for both, but even more reason for a proper discussion, done respectfully.

Utter nonsense. Sorry, if someone doesn't want to have a baby of course they don't have to have one. Taking the emotiveness of this specific thread out of it, there's no middle ground or compromise. If someone doesn't want one that's an unfortunate circumstance but there's no forcing someone into something this big.

LuckySantangelo35 · 29/06/2022 17:28

notquiteruralbliss · 29/06/2022 17:20

I would be exploring other options to have a 2nd child that didn't involve my DH.

@notquiteruralbliss

would you really ?

you’d really fuck over your husband and existing child for some hypothetical baby which may never come into fruition

@Ciaocatnip Op life must be really hard for you. Use what time you do get left over from work, caring for your child etc and invest it in yourself - going for a walk or a night out or the gym or getting your nails done or whatever. If you have a second child you won’t have time for any of that for a long while. You deserve some time for yourself!