Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to make the will fair

116 replies

Xanthe68 · 29/06/2022 00:14

A friend has asked for my advice-

A woman marries, she and her husband have two children, they work hard and are lucky and end up with a flat in London (approx £1.5m), a house in the country (similar) and investments of about £2m.

After a long happy marriage the husband dies. The woman inherits his share. 10 years later the woman begins a relationship with another woman- they live together and and they are very happy together for 5 years (and ongoing).

The woman wants to write her will. What should she do? All her wealth comes from the period of her marriage (both partners contributed) and was thought of as the children’s inheritance. But she’s worried about her new partner who doesn’t have much (not lazy- has worked hard all her life in a low paying profession).

WWYD? FWIW the children are very happy about their mum’s new relationship and it’s probable that the late husband would have been as well (based on how he was in life). Would you leave everything to the kids or something to the new partner? (Unmarried).

OP posts:
ShandaLear · 29/06/2022 04:00

£3m to the kids, £1/2m to the partner. I think that’s generous to the partner as they’ve only been together 5 years.

Nahnanananahna · 29/06/2022 03:57

My mum's in this situation (not such big amounts but she is disproportionately wealthy compared to her partner).

First step is your friends needs to speak to her partner and her DC. My mother's DP wouldn't want to stay in the house because she wouldn't be able to afford to run it plus she sees it as my mother's house. My mum has also discussed extensively with me and DB to check we're ok with it/ won't vindictively evict her DP one day after she dies (I tell her to spend it enjoying life but leaving an inheritance is very important to my mother!).

What my mother has ended up on is a lump sum to her DP, basically enough that her partner will be ok (DP has a lot less money) - can afford to buy a little flat (what partner has said she wants) and to top up state pension. Rest split between me and DB.

I do think 5 years is a short relationship in this context though. Remind your friend that she can always increase the amount given in the will later (eg in 10 years time).

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 03:51

Your kids are your kids.

This is a relationship, and a pretty new one at that.

Kids come first, always.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 03:50

£1m to a partner you have been with only 5 years? That's crazy.

Snog · 29/06/2022 03:47

£4M to kids and £1M to partner
Partner is then well looked after and kids have £2M each which is nothing to moan about.

expat101 · 29/06/2022 03:31

Life interest for spouse to remain in the house with spouse liable for upkeep and costs unless she commences a defacto or married relationship, then the life interest terminates.

House can be sold unless children want to keep it. Proceeds as follows:

100% of Fathers share of house and assets to go to their children.

Mother's portion of assets pre 2nd relationship goes to the children allowing for inflation increases.

Whatever interest/growth occured on cash assets after Mother established her 2nd relationship to be divided by Spouse and Children equally.

MrsDrSpencerReid · 29/06/2022 03:09

When my grandfather died he left everything 50/50 to my dad and aunt, with their step mum being allowed to live rent free in the house until she passed, then they were free to sell.

She was responsible for electricity, water etc and my dad and aunt paid for any maintenance.

Their mum passed when I was little, and he was married to step mum for 20+ years.

Everyone was happy with the arrangement.

Mellowyellow222 · 29/06/2022 03:05

Misstes · 29/06/2022 00:27

Husband share all to kids. Her share split 3 ways.

I like this. Seems fair, if it leaves the new partner enough to have a home and live comfortably.

Appleblum · 29/06/2022 02:46

I wouldn't leave a lifetime interest. They are very wishy washy and ties down the new partner to the children when they could want nothing to do with each other. I would leave a lump sump instead.

50% (late husband's share) directly to the children, and the new partner gets maybe 10 to 20% of the remaining half (wife's share).

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 02:06

It's a five year relationship? Then even less to the new partner.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 02:04

Everything accumulated pre-marriage, or post marriage from those marital assets going up in value divided between the children.

Any assets accumulated post-divorce unrelated to the existing assets divided as she sees fit (probably equally split) between kids and new partner.

caringcarer · 29/06/2022 01:50

50 percent husband's half split between kids and sit wife's share into 30 percent new wife and 70 percent between children. On basis relationship only 5 years long. If 20 years then leave wife more.

perimenofertility · 29/06/2022 01:50

First I would leave a life residential interest for the partner in one of the properties, whichever one they consider their home, with agreement that the property goes to the two children upon the partners death.

The other property would then be added to the estate value, and from that total I would leave 1/3 to DC1, 1/3 to DC2, 1/3 to partner.

So each child gets a financial inheritance plus eventually the remaining home to split, and the partner also gets financial inheritance (theirs to do what they like with in life and after death) and use of their home for life.

PurpleMarie · 29/06/2022 01:47

It's clear that none of you have had a second partner that you love just as much as the first. I stand by 50% to partner, 50% split between kids (clearly state's two kids)

Coyoacan · 29/06/2022 01:21

A friend of mine was the new love interest in a similar situation. When her partner died she was left a life interest in the property, reverting to the children on her death.

Walkingalot · 29/06/2022 01:12

They are just 'partners' at this stage, anything could happen. First off, she should discuss this with her children. I wouldn't leave property, as when the partner eventually dies, some total random (not sure if she has kids) would get it and that seems massively unjust to your friend's children. I wouldn't even state that she could continue to live in the house. Maybe a lump sum, maximum would be proportionate to 1/3 of 50% of any savings, which were joint with her DH. Anything more and I'd think her late DH would turn in his grave, however happy he would be that she's found a new love.

toooldtocarewhoknows · 29/06/2022 01:09

I would take into account the assets the husband and wife had when he died.

The value of these assets today.

Leave the husbands 50% of the value of these assets to the children as his inheritance to them.

Divide the remaining (mothers portion) between the three of them.

She will get approx 16.5% of the original assets and all of the assets they acquired as a couple after they got together.

£825K plus recently acquired assets is a decent amount. Minus inheritance tax if they are not married. So approx £610K

If this would provide a home for her to live in then I'd end it there.

If there isn't enough to provide a home for her you might want to look into a life interest on one of the properties so she has a home. The portion that is willed to the children is given once she has died.

Alternatively look into purchasing another home for around £800k and give this to her in its entirety. Then leave all other legacy assets to the children.

TamSamLam · 29/06/2022 01:07

I don't actually think it's fair to leave the house to the kids with the wife having a right to live there.

Give them a legally straightforward will, an ability to move on with their lives once you're gone. Given there's enough money to go around I wouldn't be making them wait around for potentially decades because you put a house in trust so the wife could live there. Either give a house or don't, don't make it complicated.

SkeletonFight · 29/06/2022 01:04

There is no way I would be giving a huge % to the new partner. 5 years ? Most of the money should go to the children. I think the best thing would be a sum of money for partner to buy a small place to live in. Life time interests are a PITA.

Alwayspaintyournails · 29/06/2022 00:58

If 5 million I would split it as;
kids £1.875 each (1/2 dads plus 1/4 mums)
partner £1.25 (1/2 of her share)

BEAM123 · 29/06/2022 00:56

Late husband's share straight to the kids.

Your friends share mainly to kids with a cash gift to her gf and a lifetime interest in a property so she has somewhere secure to live, and then after her death it securely passes back to the kids.

This is because if a property is left directly to new gf (rather than as a lifetime interest) she could then leave it to someone else and it passes out of the family.

Also make any adjustments that may be necessary. For instance if gf has given up any work to support your friend's business then her pension would have suffered etc so she should be compensated accordingly

BreadInCaptivity · 29/06/2022 00:48

HeddaGarbled · 29/06/2022 00:31

Three and a half million? No one’s going to be deprived whatever the split!

One million each to children and partner, half mill to charity. Or any other division. Anyone who complains gets disinherited for being a prat.

It's actually circa £5m with the investments.

Given the wealth was the product of a joint relationship I think the majority should go to the children of that marriage.

That said, your friend can protect her new partner by stating in her will that she can live in (but not own) one of the houses until her death, upon which it can be sold to the benefit of her children.

I'd also consider how much money the partner would need to maintain the property and provide a fund to do so (along with an obligation to keep the property in good repair - there's no point in letting someone live in a house they can't afford to maintain and thus devaluing it).

Finally I'd make a no strings attached cash gift to the partner of £250k in respect of their relationship.

Upshot is she should respect the origins of the money whilst ensuring her new partner would not be homeless or struggling.

In this will, the partner would also have the choice having received £250k and walking away from living in/maintaining any property your friend "gifted to live in" at any point if their circumstances changed.

She may also wish to consider a clause as to what would happen if her partner met someone else. Would she still be comfortable with a "gift to live in" under those circumstances?

If no, then that needs to be clear that a "new" relationship can't be maintained in that property (but can be tricky to prove in reality) or offer a further sum of say £100k to move out and rescind her rights to live their until her death.

shropshire11 · 29/06/2022 00:47

All the husband’s “half” to the kids, equally split. Half the wife’s “half” to her partner, the other half equally split between the kids.

HarvestFly · 29/06/2022 00:43

Most of the estate to the children with a token amount to the new partner.
On the basis the mother and partner are obviously not young and the partner has supported herself up until they met. If the plan for 40 years had been to leave it all to the children why would she change that now?

WGACA · 29/06/2022 00:41

Misstes · 29/06/2022 00:27

Husband share all to kids. Her share split 3 ways.

This seems very fair to me.

Swipe left for the next trending thread