Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

How to make the will fair

116 replies

Xanthe68 · 29/06/2022 00:14

A friend has asked for my advice-

A woman marries, she and her husband have two children, they work hard and are lucky and end up with a flat in London (approx £1.5m), a house in the country (similar) and investments of about £2m.

After a long happy marriage the husband dies. The woman inherits his share. 10 years later the woman begins a relationship with another woman- they live together and and they are very happy together for 5 years (and ongoing).

The woman wants to write her will. What should she do? All her wealth comes from the period of her marriage (both partners contributed) and was thought of as the children’s inheritance. But she’s worried about her new partner who doesn’t have much (not lazy- has worked hard all her life in a low paying profession).

WWYD? FWIW the children are very happy about their mum’s new relationship and it’s probable that the late husband would have been as well (based on how he was in life). Would you leave everything to the kids or something to the new partner? (Unmarried).

OP posts:
GoodThinkingMax · 29/06/2022 10:51

It’s quite a high value estate so the expense of a trust is worth it @Xanthe68

Your friend should set up a trust in her will for her children. Her partner - if they’re still together - should have her life use of the INCOME but not the CAPITAL of your friend’s estate.

It really doesn’t matter than if your friend’s partner remarries etc. The estate is left in trust to the children, with the partner/widow with a life right to the income, but not the capital (properties, stocks etc). With strong trustees who will stop her liquidating assets.

It’s the way things have been arranged in my family for several generations.

riesenrad · 29/06/2022 10:48

I'd leave everything to the kids with £500K to the partner so she can buy herself somewhere to live (and depending on area and size of property) have a bit to live on or blow on a new car/holiday etc.

Even better, buy a property now and give it to the partner. As long as you survive 7 years there's no IHT; and then leave everything else to the kids.

Harridan1981 · 29/06/2022 10:41

I would take it that half belonged to dad, and half to mum. So when both parents have past, kids should have all of dad's and half of mum's so she can leave something to partner.

So I would do 75% split between the kids, and 25% to the partner.

Xanthe68 · 29/06/2022 10:39

Thank you to everyone who has commented on this thread- I've shared it with my friend. She is going to get legal advice but has been asking around for advice from friends to try to get a handle on what's a fair way to proceed. Everyone gets on very well so she's also planning to tell her children and partner what she's proposing so that people know what to expect and can speak up if they're worried.

OP posts:
theemmadilemma · 29/06/2022 10:36

Yeah the kindest, generous thing would be a life interest. Less generous a specific period in a property. But they would need to provide enough to maintain said properly somehow too, in order that the children recieve it in good nick.

Whatsonmymindgrapes · 29/06/2022 10:34

All to the kids.

GCRich · 29/06/2022 10:29

I think I'd be minded to try to buy a fairly nice buy to let flat as an investment, using cash, in a location the partner would be happy to live, and then leave the partner the buy to let flat, the right to live in the central london flat for 2-3 years after death, and some cash (£20k, £50k, much more?!!?!?!)

If the partner didn't want this then it would appear likely that the partner can be left enough cash to buy a reasonably nice home, but maybe not as nice as the £1.5 central london flat.

balalake · 29/06/2022 10:24

Something to the new partner.

missdemeanors · 29/06/2022 10:02

@PurpleMarie the OP says the dh died after a long and happy marriage, and that it was 10 years later that the woman met her new partner who she has been with 5 years.

This is not about whether she loves her new partner 'just as much.' It's about having a will which reflects the fact that she has two children from her marriage, that her late dh contributed as much to their wealth as she did (and also that up until 5 years ago her now partner was obviously supporting herself or in a previous relationship from which she may have assets.)

The logical way is that her late DH's half goes to the children. Her half is then split 3 ways.

Your suggestion of 50% to the current partner means they get more than each of her children.

thefirstfortyeight · 29/06/2022 09:59

Having had a family member left a lifetime interest I wouldn't ever go anywhere near one - sounded great in writing was hell in reality.

Taking all the emotional aspect out - it tied together two lots of people with nothing in common for years.

harriethoyle · 29/06/2022 09:54

Misstes · 29/06/2022 00:27

Husband share all to kids. Her share split 3 ways.

Yes this feels fair - akin to a stepparent will.

genie10 · 29/06/2022 09:51

Defineitely take financial advice. However, I think she should leave everything to her own children. Does the new partner have family? If so, why should her family (strangers to the friend and late husband) inherit money from her? Is the partner too old to begin planning for her retirement herself? Leaving life time interests is messy and problematic too. Her children should come first.

SkeletonFight · 29/06/2022 09:41

PurpleMarie · 29/06/2022 01:47

It's clear that none of you have had a second partner that you love just as much as the first. I stand by 50% to partner, 50% split between kids (clearly state's two kids)

No that is not true. My now H has a lifetime interest in the property but he has his own children and own assets. I have agreed I will not take anything from him and vice versa. I love him more than my first. My divorce assets are for my children.

creamwitheverything · 29/06/2022 09:19

My mums will is really simple OP. She decided to split it 4 ways equally between me and my brother and her 2 grandchildren, Thats it no debate for anyone! I am the executor as I am the oldest (??) I sort all assets and the funeral then everything is done.,no arguments,not that there would be as we are all close and a happy,get on well kind of family,Everyone was told by mum what was what and she brokered no discussion which was fine. Wouldnt work for some families but it works fine for us. Should be fairly straight forward when the time comes to sort it out.

TheTeenageYears · 29/06/2022 08:53

@HollowTalk Yes probably. Presumably the DC are adults with their own lives. DF chose not to split his share of the estate on his death with no guarantee the money would end up with them. Many DC end up with nothing eventually due to second relationships/marriage/step DC. It's not unreasonable for someone with a new partner to split her share equally between DC and newer partner. The DC still end up with the lions share of the estate.

wildseas · 29/06/2022 06:20

I agree with a pp that you need to seek professional advice. most people on this thread are splitting the full value of the estate but without inheritance tax planning it won’t be anywhere near that value.

What I would do is firstly consider what I should do now. I think that would look something like seperating out half of the estate including one of the properties and either gifting that to the children (slowly over some years to minimise tax) or using it to create a family trust with them as beneficiaries or a combination of the two. What I chose would probably depend on if they were independently wealthy, how much help they had already had, if there were grandchildren (or likely to be).

I would then make a will which looked like a fair split of the remaining assets - 3 ways potentially- with thought as to what would happen to the remaining property. With a view that this might change over time if I married my partner or split up with them etc.

Penners99 · 29/06/2022 06:07

As I believe in reincarnation, I would leave it all to myself.

HollowTalk · 29/06/2022 05:54

TheTeenageYears · 29/06/2022 05:49

Husbands share split equally between DC, Wife's share split equally between DC & partner with a right to remain living in one of the properties for life.

So you would leave just as much to a relatively new partner that you would to your own children?

TheTeenageYears · 29/06/2022 05:49

Husbands share split equally between DC, Wife's share split equally between DC & partner with a right to remain living in one of the properties for life.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 04:53

Smart play if the mother is not unwell would indeed be to transfer as much as possible to the children now. Including house titles etc. Do tell your friend to speak to a fonancial adviser asap!

Inheritance tax is only really paid by those who do not trust their kids, or do not really care about their family's future. It's completely avoidable.

oldageprancer · 29/06/2022 04:50

It's a big estate. Get financial advice first so it's more tax efficient. Possibly gift some now to the kids.
Again for the will, get legal advice. Otherwise it could be challenged.
I'd go for all to kids, partner has life interest which stops after over a year cohabitation with a new partner or moving house, plus pension (assume she has one to give? maybe not?) and life insurance payout.

yepmetooo · 29/06/2022 04:42

Leave a specified amount to dp and everything else to kids. Or one house to dp and rest to kids.

BirdWatch · 29/06/2022 04:17

I would leave it to the children, but let the spouse live on the house your friend shares with her, until death or remarriage, whichever comes first. That was what my mother and stepfather had in their wills. They divorced, he died, but totally unexpectedly, he left her money in his new will.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 04:04

This is a person who is just in a relationship with her. Compared to her children!! She has also only been with them for what, less than 2000 days! I mean, honestly. A decent partner would not expect someone to give them anywhere near that qt the expense of their own kids after such a tiny amount of time together.

TheGirlOnTheDragon · 29/06/2022 04:01

ShandaLear · 29/06/2022 04:00

£3m to the kids, £1/2m to the partner. I think that’s generous to the partner as they’ve only been together 5 years.

It's not just generous, it's insane.

Swipe left for the next trending thread