Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Friends are all more successful than me. "Failed teacher"

94 replies

Flotraidroberts · 28/06/2022 22:57

Hello;
I'm 28 and I class myself as a "failed" teacher.
I live in Chester and jobs are far too competitive. I've been trying to get a permanent teaching job for 3 years but can't. I've had long terms during this time but sometimes the school won't do the induction due to being too busy and if I don't get it done by the end of 2023, I become an ECT.

I don't mind supply, like Ive said, I have good feedback from schools, I've had long-term PPA covers but I just can't get the job. A school I was in a few weeks ago said they had over 90 applicants for a job!! And that seems the norm around here.

I'm currently on a long-term now doing PPA and have been in the school nearly half this academic year but the school haven't got the time to do the induction. It's stressing me out.

Anyway, my stress has increased tonight as my friend who finished her PGCE this year has just got a permanent teaching job and I feel happy for her but at the same time useless in myself.
Boyfriend is now questioning me about whether teaching jobs around here are actually hard to get or whether it's just me.

I feel just sad. I'm applying for a job tonight but I feel like motivation is going. I have had interviews and sometimes get to the final 2/3 but I just never get the job.

All my other friends have great careers and some are established teachers; It's got to the point where I am avoiding meeting up to save the questioning about how supply is going.
I can't move as I have a mortgage here in Chester;
I'm feeling absolutely lost at the moment. Surely at 28 I should be more established now?

OP posts:
jeanne16 · 29/06/2022 07:47

Primary school teaching is very over subscribed. Are your friends perhaps doing secondary teaching, where there are shortages in certain subjects, though not all.

ladydoris · 29/06/2022 07:41

Then means as soon as you have finished your paper. Not august.

ladydoris · 29/06/2022 07:40

When you start you have to move were people don't want to move, it's the rule, even if it's for one full year. Or two. Do you have family that you can stay with elsewhere in England ? It's has already been stated, but if I don't say it out loud I will be bemoaned for it. There.
Finish your dissertation. For good. Get it fully approved and wait for D day. Then look for a NQT job in a wider perimeter like crazy. Take pride in yourself. Your "friends" looking down on you is not helping for your self esteem. You need to boost yourself to get were you want to. You've got this. All the best op.

MassiveSalad22 · 29/06/2022 07:35

People with mortgages move all the time, I don’t get that argument. Is your partner’s job truly tied to where you’re living now? Can’t you both move to an area where you’d both have a commute, to make it fair?

dottiedodah · 29/06/2022 07:24

It always amazes me how so many people seem to think its "easy" to get a good job in teaching or otherwise!You are most certainly not a "failed Teacher! You are just starting out and presumably have a degree as well .Your BF is being unfair here.Chester is a nice MC town I think so will be a lot of competition for jobs .What about a commute to Liverpool? Would that be doable .Lots more jobs there I would think .Perhaps to gain some experience and then move back in a couple of years .There will be tutoring jobs for 11 plus exams ,help generally with children weak in certain subjects .You will get there Nil despradum as they say!

Longmoorlane · 29/06/2022 07:23

The whole point is that she can’t find a post though, @ladydoris !

However, while I wouldn’t phrase it as harshly as the one above I do think you have to look at moving, if only during the week for now.

Russell19 · 29/06/2022 07:23

Now is the time to be applying as an NQT because that's what head teachers will be expecting at this time of the year due to notice deadline passing. Apply for everything within a 15/20 mile radius. I am in Cheshire (about half an hour from you) and I have seen loads of jobs come up over the last month and I have got one myself.

MuddlerInLaw · 29/06/2022 07:22

TBH I think it’s ridiculous to be so tied down by mortgage and partner that you can’t move elsewhere at 28.

You want a permanent teaching job - they are apparently available in other places.

You’re young. Widen your horizons.

MrsSpoon78 · 29/06/2022 07:21

I'd commute for a long way foe a year. Up to 90 mins.

Also...you could look into porting your mortgage to move to a different area?

ladydoris · 29/06/2022 07:20

Longmoorlane · 29/06/2022 07:08

Did you read any of her post?

Yes I did. All of this is mind game while she has to focus on finishing. It will clear up. She is a good teacher. she is almost finished , it's a way to second guess herself. The pride of finishing will help also for any interview phase further down the line. This is my opinion. Let the friend gloss over their short term success. Focus on you. I need not advise on the job market, there were plenty of very positive advice there.

resuwen · 29/06/2022 07:19

Have you thought about paying for some interview coaching?

Igmum · 29/06/2022 07:13

Sending hugs, this sounds grim for you Flowers. If it helps, different areas have always had different labour markets for teachers. My mum was a primary school teacher (would have been 94 this year) and it was well-known then that you could never get your first job in Wales because it was waaaayyy too competitive so you travelled away then returned once you had a few years under your belt. Sounds like that might still be the case! I agree with other posters, head over to Warrington or some parts of South Manchester- definitely commutable from where you are. Make sure you get fully qualified. (Obviously speak to your current head first and emphasise how important this is - get the union involved if necessary.)

No, you're absolutely not a failure. You are still getting jobs in an incredibly tight labour market and it sounds like you are good at what you do and want to continue with it.

Good luck 🤞

HTruffle · 29/06/2022 07:13

Would you open up more options if you speak / learn to speak Welsh, being so near the border. Also there are excellent rail links to north wales, Manchester, Liverpool, could you look at schools further afield but near a station?

Lisbeth50 · 29/06/2022 07:12

Whoops! Look at it as getting a lot of varied experience. And you are not a failure. You have a degree and QTS and you are working in the area for which you trained which is actually very successful.

Lisbeth50 · 29/06/2022 07:10

I spent several years doing supply then had several temporary contracts, some of which were part-time, before finding a permanent job. I think I was 30 at that point. I stayed 15 years in that job and have been in another permanent job for the past 5 so you have loads of time.

Look at it à

Longmoorlane · 29/06/2022 07:08

ladydoris · 29/06/2022 07:00

Finish your NQT ASAP. Problem solved.

Did you read any of her post?

Somerandomshittyname · 29/06/2022 07:06

Hi,
Have you tried looking a little further afield? Try Wirral, Liverpool or even North Wales. I live on the Wirral but had to commute to Liverpool last year for my NQT. I was offered 0.5 teaching 0.5 cover on the Wirral last year, took it, and have just been made full time in the same school. It will happen for you, I’m sure x

Bowbridge · 29/06/2022 07:05

My neice qualified last year as a primary school teacher in your area and only managed to get part-time position (3 days). She later picked up another 1.5 days in another school. It is not the same as a full-time permanent position, but she is happy getting experience in two settings and hoping a full-time position comes up. Maybe look out for maternity covers.

I teach in the south. We get lots of applicants for teaching positions and very few for support roles.

Have you thought about alternative provisions (Octavia House, Red Balloon type places) in your area or speech and language units?

ladydoris · 29/06/2022 07:00

Finish your NQT ASAP. Problem solved.

NellesVilla · 29/06/2022 06:53

You have most certainly not failed.

You have your own home at 28 which is incredible (I am older and single in the south and a long way off homeownership as are friends of mine.

And I agree re tutoring. I did this up
until covid hit and really enjoyed most aspects. I had some great kids (mainly bright boys who simply found English dull), and would highly recommend doing this as you can hybrid it out- some hours f-2-f and the others, wfh.

parrotonmyshoulder · 29/06/2022 06:51

Read some Brené Brown - maybe ‘The Atlas of the Heart’ would be good as there are good sections on jealousy and envy. Sounds like you’re more worried about what others think than how you actually feel about it yourself.

Loads of great advice above for getting NQT finished. Supply can be really stressful and many established teachers wouldn’t want to do it, so it’s great that you can manage it so well. Tutoring is a good option. Do you really, really want a school based teaching job?

HappyHappyHermit · 29/06/2022 06:43

Teaching job interviews are horrendous and really old fashioned in style. They expect the world for a job that pays, what around 26k?! You aren't failing as you are getting into schools, I think schools sadly miss out on a more varied teaching staff because they only want those who really come across as super confident at interview. Keep going as you are and gaining more experience and you will find your place. Maybe ditch the partner though as he doesn't sound supportive at all.

Longmoorlane · 29/06/2022 06:42

People mean well, but setting up a business as a private tutor is really not simple. Many parents who can afford it will want to see someone who has a long history of successfully teaching, and a lot of parents can’t afford it. At the moment, it’ll be one of the first things to go.

This has been an issue since I started teaching: there are always a few people who don’t get jobs, either too fussy or just genuinely unlucky, and end up on the supply circuit.

I don’t think you’re a failed teacher but I do think you could do with considering something to break the chain as it were. And this might involve living elsewhere in the week and coming home weekends.

bjjgirl · 29/06/2022 06:42

How far are you willing to commute?

Look rurally- up to Northwich / Warrington / crewe- the schools just can't get the teachers there

BenCoopersSupportWren · 29/06/2022 06:39

MrDaddybear · 28/06/2022 23:43

Was she doing the dance with no pants with the headteacher?

Because that is of course the only way a young woman could get a job…she couldn’t possibly have the teaching skills the school was looking for 🙄

Swipe left for the next trending thread