Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very overweight. what would you do?

58 replies

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:00

Hello.

im currently with slimming world, have been going for 4 weeks and have lost 7.5 pounds so far which I’m really pleased with.

However, I do have an eating disorder and I do feel that weighing every week might be not the best thing for me mentally. I now know the diet well enough to continue doing this alone (without counting syns, but just making healthier choices).

I would also like to implement a sustainable exercise program. The idea would be to not focus on the weight loss, but by how I feel, my body feeling healthier and my clothes getting smaller. My only obstacle is myself, I know I’m very lazy and I also have 2 children so by the time they are in bed I’m very tired.

I’m currently 17 stone and a size 18 and I would like to get back into a size 10. I am built like a fridge so I’ve never been slender but a size 10-12 had always looked nice on me.

My main goal I think now needs to be to work on the self hatred and self loathing, not in the number in the scale. I think if I feel happy and confident in myself then I will naturally just make better choices and I won’t binge and purge on junk food.

Any advice would be very much appreciated.

Thankyou

OP posts:
smoothceiling · 28/06/2022 19:18

You ask what I would do and I will tell you but you are under no obligation to do the same!

3 years ago I discovered a book called Delay don't Deny, I found out about it on Mumsnet. I read the reviews on Amazon and then I listened to it on Audible. It literally changed my life. I was obese, I probably was close to type II diabetes. Anyway it worked for me!

Audible says it's something like a 4 hr read but actually about 2 hrs are the author reading out the scientific study references. I listened on a long car journey. Then I listened again with my mum and she started it too. We liked the author's voice reading it to us and it seemed less of an effort than to read the book ourselves!

Totally up to you whether you read or listen but it will explain why people put on weight again after slimming world, weight watchers etc. it all made perfect sense to me, the first week was hard but then it was fine as you get what they term appetite correction.

Good luck with whatever you choose to do!!

Labdo · 28/06/2022 19:14

Thankyou so much for all your lovely advise. I’m going to try and build myself a plan and think a bit more about slimming world. I’m dreading weighing tomorrow as I’ve had a really bad week.

OP posts:
Ohsugarhoneyicetea · 28/06/2022 19:03

Ive lost a stone in a month using Saxenda, its been quite amazing, I have a very small appetite now so its been quite easy. I think the only way to loose weight is low calories, whether you do that by low carb, low fat or intermittent fasting, its all the same - lower calories. I'm basically doing the fast 800 with Saxenda making it painless. I'll do it for 2 months to get where I want to be and then I can manage the maintenance on my own. Exercise I do for health, but I don't find it helps me loose weight as it makes me hungry!

schmalex · 28/06/2022 18:59

If binge eating is behind your weight gain, I would try and tackle that behaviour without worrying too much about the weight loss (which will follow). I found the Stop Binge Eating podcast by Kirsten Sarfde really helpful but if you can afford therapy that would be good too.

Mariposista · 28/06/2022 18:53

Well done you for your initial weight loss - keep it up!
The good thing about SW is the community aspect, having people to egg you on and stop you giving up. Especially if, as you say, you can get lazy. At SW you are accountable to the rest of your group and you want each other to do well. Could you go for the camaraderie but ask not to be weighed in front of everyone, but more subtly and perhaps the instructor writes it down instead of saying it to the whole class?
Keep going OP for a healthier future you for yourself and your family!

MoominFeatures · 28/06/2022 18:49

First, amazingly well done for taking back the control, OP.

Unless I have the wrong end of the stick I’m wondering whether some of the PPs May have missed some of the nuanced cues in your posts.

If you have the self-motivation, going to Boots monthly might not be a bad shout - at least initially while you kickstart your process. I recognise that group settings (or therapy), whilst immensely helpful for many looking for support with weight loss (or EDs) may not be for everyone - there is no one size fits all. Perhaps do consider some counselling (maybe CBT) if you haven’t already, though - Beat are an incredibly amazing source of info and will be able to point you in the right direction if you’d like that, so they might not be a bad first port of call.

Also, if you can try to take the plunge and get to the gym (though I absolutely hear and can understand your comments about wanting to wait), the confidence you may find you get from seeing small, and then incrementally bigger, successes in a structured programme pulled together by a supportive gym (and they 100% exist!) would hopefully spur you on and can also serve as positive influence as far as your eating goes - the whole process can be a real mind-set changer. It’ll be hard taking that leap of faith, no doubt, but what’s the worst that can happen? If you sign up for a short term trial to start with, just don’t join fully if you don’t think you’re ready or just don’t like it!

bruce43mydog · 28/06/2022 18:39

Hello Labdo, well done on loseing the 7.5lbs you have lost so far. I have been 17 stone and got down to 9st 8lbs in a year. I did this by going on long walks with my dog every night, and doing cardio exercise for 1 hour a day every day. I really didnt like exercise at all in the begining but i started seeing the results on the scales every month. i could get up the stairs without getting out of breath my back, hips and knees didnt pain me. i would weight myself at the end of every month and i lost 7-11lbs consistently. i plateaued on the 8th month and then lost again 7-11lbs consistently for the following 4 months.
i was naturally lazy, but i would make myself exercise daily. put your favorite songs on or podcast, walk, jog or run, to get your body moving. You will feel the benifits straight away. find healthy food that you like and drink plenty of water.
Dont cheat on your healty eating plan, because you wont see the results every month. i did have 3 slip up myself in the year i had a toffee crisp one day and a fizzy drink another time and some crisps another time. I always got straight back on my heathy eating and exercise plan.
Treat yourself to shower/bath with your favorite shower gel. You need to look after your physical and mental health you will feel a lot better more or less straight away.
Also look up on youtube, lose it like lauren or louise's journey. They both youtubers that lost weight. i youtube weight loss inspiration stories to inspire me. Theres is a lot of hours in the day, find a time that suits you. i used to go for a run between 5pm and 6pm. it might be that you prefere mornings, or afternoons or late evening, find a time and stick with it. You can do it. Good luck xX

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:33

Bluebottlejuice · 28/06/2022 18:32

Are you the poster who is BF, going to slimming world and calorie counting as well. It sounds familiar?

I’m am doing all those things but not the same poster! Must be 2 of us.

OP posts:
toastofthetown · 28/06/2022 18:32

If you like Slimming World and that way of eating is working for you, then there's no reason you couldn't keep it up without going to the sessions. Mumsnet are very against Slimming World another low fat diets in favour of low carb diets, however the DIETFITS study found that over twelve months there was no significant difference in weight change between a healthy low-fat diet vs a healthy low-carbohydrate diet.

If I wanted to improve my health the two changes I would make would be reduce ultra-processed food (UPF) and aim to eat 30 different plants each week. There's some interesting research being done on UPFs; the podcast A Thorough Examination is very interesting listening. The 30 plants a week comes from a study finding that people who eat thirty different plants each week have a more diverse gut microbiome, which we are learning more anymore about how important that is. It sounds a lot, but grains, fruit, vegetables, herbs, spices, nuts seeds, beans, pulses all count.

Bluebottlejuice · 28/06/2022 18:32

Are you the poster who is BF, going to slimming world and calorie counting as well. It sounds familiar?

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:29

JuneJubilee · 28/06/2022 18:24

Could you take a month off going to meetings, don't weigh until the end of the month (at Boots) & see how well you're able to stick to SW on your own & see how you do without the weekly meetings?

if it doesn't work out well, go back.

I’m going to see if I can take a break and reset myself a bit.

OP posts:
Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:29

No my mental health comes first, always. I would be incapable of doing anything at all otherwise.

OP posts:
JuneJubilee · 28/06/2022 18:24

Could you take a month off going to meetings, don't weigh until the end of the month (at Boots) & see how well you're able to stick to SW on your own & see how you do without the weekly meetings?

if it doesn't work out well, go back.

Ohthatsexciting · 28/06/2022 18:23

I am all for addressing mental health op

But in this instance - I think physical health has to take precedent

And i suspect mh will naturally improve

Ohthatsexciting · 28/06/2022 18:21

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:17

I was thinking about maybe going to boots instead once a month I stead of paying £6 a week at slimming world. I have free use of a gym, just no confidence to go. I’d like to lose a stone or two myself first at home I think before I could face going to the gym. Low carb is very much not good for me or a very low calorie diet. I like the slimming world plan and I will stick to it I just think the weekly weighing isn’t helpful for me.

Op

no brainer

you like slimming world and it’s clearly working!!

please do not abandon a mere month after starting

Whydotheyallhaverubbishwheels · 28/06/2022 18:21

I'm super overweight and have recently starting playing netball, it's a back to netball programme so very basic rules. I think the secret is to do exercise you enjoy. Swimming/ Zumba/ classes. Also you can get lots of free online workouts like Joe wicks on YouTube. He does 20 minute ones for people getting back into exercise. I think also building it up slowly and into a routine so it becomes second nature. It makes me feel so good to be exercising again!

Stellaris22 · 28/06/2022 18:20

OP don’t feel like your weight is a limiting factor to join the gym, it absolutely isn’t. Start slowly with a plan, get a PT if you can for advice.

The plan is essential so you don’t feel lost, people are there to exercise and staff will be there to help. The benefits for mental health are absolutely worth it.

Carpy88999 · 28/06/2022 18:19

Ditch slimming world, ditch the scales, take measurement of your waist and arms etc and take photos periodically. Start by just walking more try and get more steps in each week.

You don't have to eliminate anything at all and it's not sustainable or enjoyable even trying. Just treat calories like a bank account, Doughnuts are expensive so if you have one you may have less to spend less at dinner.

Stellaris22 · 28/06/2022 18:18

How would you feel about increasing exercise? Is there a type of exercise you enjoy? It doesn’t have to be endless cardio, mixing it up with strength training makes it exciting.

Personally I would ditch SW and focus on health instead of a number on a scale if that would work better.

Losing weight is done through diet, but you need to be in a good place mentally for that to work. Getting a gym membership and a PT will give you something to focus on. Some weeks I know my diet hasn’t been great, but knowing I’m still progressing health wise with exercise means I don’t beat myself up about it.

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:17

I was thinking about maybe going to boots instead once a month I stead of paying £6 a week at slimming world. I have free use of a gym, just no confidence to go. I’d like to lose a stone or two myself first at home I think before I could face going to the gym. Low carb is very much not good for me or a very low calorie diet. I like the slimming world plan and I will stick to it I just think the weekly weighing isn’t helpful for me.

OP posts:
Hont1986 · 28/06/2022 18:14

If you are very overweight, then it is going to take a long time to see and feel actual progress. Will you be able to keep up the discipline for five or six months even if you aren't seeing any results? That was my experience of big weight loss, at least. It will be really helpful for you to get to a point where you can use a scale so that can see actual progress, even if that isn't reflected in your dress size in the short term. Maybe that will mean some therapy.

Aquamarine1029 · 28/06/2022 18:14

Ohthatsexciting · 28/06/2022 18:02

Personally I think the immediate and goal needs to be weight loss. I would go so far as to say it is fairly critical.

when you have lost a couple of stone - I reckon that a) your mental health will have naturally improved without you even trying and b) you will find fundamentals be less at risk to very serious health implications

I agree with all of this. I also think if you could manage your weight and eating habits alone, you never would have gotten up to 17 stone. I think a program with support and structure is what you need.

Losing weight will help your mental health considerably.

Allicando · 28/06/2022 18:13

I listened to the podcast which has helped me enormously with binge eating, it made so much sense and described me perfectly. I wasnt hugely overweight but had a cycle of self hatred that perpetuated itself for over 20 years. I hated my relationship with food and in turn my body.

Brain over binge

I do not weigh myself anymore as I find it becomes an obsession with the scales. I have increased my running to 4-5 times per week consistently (have run for the past 16 years or so but half arsed). I sometimes mix it up with a Body Coach 15 minute HIIT session at home via YouTube. My relationship with food is so much better, not perfect but much better and I have definitely lost weight and feel the self hatred easing - it is very freeing.

Twizbe · 28/06/2022 18:11

I found Noom really good for changing to a healthy lifestyle. The weight loss has been an added bonus really.

The whole thing is aimed at exploring psychological triggers and long term health

actiongirl1978 · 28/06/2022 18:10

Agree with pps. Stick with what's working for now. For a few months at least.

Really build on those habits and then focus on the 'healthy long term lifestyle' stuff.