Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Very overweight. what would you do?

58 replies

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:00

Hello.

im currently with slimming world, have been going for 4 weeks and have lost 7.5 pounds so far which I’m really pleased with.

However, I do have an eating disorder and I do feel that weighing every week might be not the best thing for me mentally. I now know the diet well enough to continue doing this alone (without counting syns, but just making healthier choices).

I would also like to implement a sustainable exercise program. The idea would be to not focus on the weight loss, but by how I feel, my body feeling healthier and my clothes getting smaller. My only obstacle is myself, I know I’m very lazy and I also have 2 children so by the time they are in bed I’m very tired.

I’m currently 17 stone and a size 18 and I would like to get back into a size 10. I am built like a fridge so I’ve never been slender but a size 10-12 had always looked nice on me.

My main goal I think now needs to be to work on the self hatred and self loathing, not in the number in the scale. I think if I feel happy and confident in myself then I will naturally just make better choices and I won’t binge and purge on junk food.

Any advice would be very much appreciated.

Thankyou

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
emmie847 · 29/06/2022 00:02

This has really helped me

www.theproteinworks.com/diet-meal-replacement-extreme

vandertable · 28/06/2022 23:59

Firstly, and above all else, well done! That's a fantastic start. 2lb a week is a healthy and sustainable rate, and to do that for four weeks is amazing! Try not to get overly focused on the week by week numbers, but in my experience the discipline of a weekly weigh-in can be a great help in avoiding the self-sabotage that often scuppers weight-loss attempts, which is probably why the main companies tend to work that way.

You can do it on your own though, of course you can. If you do then my advice would be to make sure that you keep the focus on day-by-day meal planning even if you drop the weekly weigh-in, as it's the idle unplanned snacking that leads to the "oh today's a write-off so I may as well eat what I like" that leads to the "this week's a write-off, let's have a takeaway"...etc. The way you avoid the binge is to plan each day so that you know exactly where your next meal is coming from.

Good luck whichever route you take! Another four weeks and you'll be at a stone. Then to two by Halloween, maybe even three by Christmas. You can do it! You're not lazy, far from it - you're bringing up two kids while working yourself, it's bloody hard work. So is this, but you can get there if you make sure you focus on whatever strategy you decide to follow.

zoemum2006 · 28/06/2022 22:20

I do Slimming World online and weigh myself at home (but you don't have to weigh yourself).

I think the SW plan is really good as it's basically encouraging you to eat whole foods and monitor your processed food intake.

I'd definitely stick with a formal plan for at least 3 months.

Bluebottlejuice · 28/06/2022 21:37

At the end of the day, its up to you what you decide to do.

Here's my experience FWIW. I'm currently on SW. I've attempted to lose weight for a few years on various diets with limited success. I have come to realise that my problem is daily weighing. I would get discouraged if I did not lose a large amount of weight quite literally overnight. Daily fluctuations would determine my whole mood for the entire day. If I didn't see the progress I wanted, then I would binge because WTF was the point?!

I realised a few months ago that I had to just stick to a plan regardless of how much weight I lost. I chose SW because it is mainly just healthy eating. (Don't listen to the MN naysayers who will spout muller lights, mountains of pasta and mug shots at you!). It's just cooking from scratch with a third of your plate being veg. I do it now and just eat what I want on plan each day regardless of what the scales may say. I had to really work hard on not weighing myself. I weigh in once a week at class still, but that's it. I don't lose every week, but I stick to plan every week. And the overall trend is downwards. I am not losing weight as fast as I would like TBH. And that is my next mental barrier to overcome. But I just keep pushing through, one day on plan at a time.

I've pretty much had to focus on teaching myself to eat healthier instead of focusing on eating to lose weight.

Spinfit · 28/06/2022 21:22

If your BMI is 35 or over, your GP can refer you to your local weight loss centre and you can be seen by a trained dietician. They help patients learn about mindful eating but also flag ED such as binge eating or emotional eating which in the long term need to be addressed. There are so many different kinds of diets these days but the weight is unlikely to stay off unless you can deal with the underlying ED. I personally think that regular weight checks can make people obsessive about their weight loss and I always tell patients it's not just the number but how you feel in yourself as well

Fullofhotcrossbuns · 28/06/2022 21:15

Labdo · 28/06/2022 18:17

I was thinking about maybe going to boots instead once a month I stead of paying £6 a week at slimming world. I have free use of a gym, just no confidence to go. I’d like to lose a stone or two myself first at home I think before I could face going to the gym. Low carb is very much not good for me or a very low calorie diet. I like the slimming world plan and I will stick to it I just think the weekly weighing isn’t helpful for me.

You will only get encouragement at the gym not ridicule

i recommend fasting as well a 9-5 eating window and nothing but water during the fasting period

Labdo · 28/06/2022 20:47

Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 28/06/2022 20:41

Could you talk to the leader of your SW group? I have done that too and find going to and staying in group is vial for me. But understand about the weighing. I would bet they have encountered this before and have a way of helping with it.

I think I might have to. Currently not able to stay at group as I have a class that I go to straight after but that finishes in 3 weeks so then I can start staying again. But now my baby is mobile it’s a bit of a nightmare tbh! My evenings are also now taken up by baby and his awful sleep regression he’s going through. I usually could put him down and then get in my exercise bike for a while but atm I’m just stuck holding him all evening (but hey at least I’m not snacking!)

OP posts:
Wheresmywoolyjumpers · 28/06/2022 20:41

Could you talk to the leader of your SW group? I have done that too and find going to and staying in group is vial for me. But understand about the weighing. I would bet they have encountered this before and have a way of helping with it.

Labdo · 28/06/2022 20:38

I’ve applied for counselling but because I’m currently under perinatal care they won’t see me yet. Hopefully getting discharged soon though. As of next month I’m back to working 12 hour shifts 3 days a week so I’ll be eating less and moving more naturally anyway. With my husband shift pattern I don’t really get any chance to go to the gym but I’m going to try and fit some in where I can!

OP posts:
YouCahnts · 28/06/2022 20:29

BackToTheTop · 28/06/2022 19:55

I think by turning up and weighing yourself means you hold yourself accountable. It's so easy to pick up bad habits without realising it. If you're not tracking progress you won't know if it's working. Plus if you do have a bad week, you know you have and you can then put it behind you and start afresh that day.

I remember coming home from holiday and knowing I'd put a lot of weight on. I followed sw diet but didn't weigh for 2 months (I knew the program as I'd done it previously). I felt great in myself, but when I did eventually weigh myself I'd only lost 2lbs. I was devastated and it took me 2 years to start properly dieting again

I agree with this. You need accountability - look how well you've done so far. Once a month at Boots isn't going to cut it at the outset. Before you know it it will be every 2 months and you'll be back to where you were. This is where you need to be getting into the swing of it.

I would also recommend counselling too.

RoundaboutRacer · 28/06/2022 20:14

SW was the same as any other diet for me. Just put it all back on again and more.

The notion of "free foods" isn't a healthy way to eat. Nor is all the processed food and "fat free"/"sugar free" chemicals that go with SW.

Intermittent fasting and low carb changed my life. Lost 6 stone and have kept it off for a year.

With SW it would be back on and more by now.

Labdo · 28/06/2022 20:12

Spritelite · 28/06/2022 20:05

I’ve no advice because I’m in the exact same boat myself (did seeing all the skinny minnies dresses for the recent heatwave make you feel crap too?) but do you mind me asking what height you are?

Feel free not to disclose, I’m just being nosey because I’m a bigger size than you but weigh 13st 5lb. I’m 5’4” and literally all my fat’s in my belly, my Mum says I look like Gru off despicable me😂 xx

Im 5ft7. I am naturally heavy too which doesn’t help. When I was a size 8-10 I was still 13stone. I’m very wide, I have big shoulders, wrists, bones etc. I don’t look fat per se, just biiiig. I think my body wants to be 6ft 4!

OP posts:
Hankunamatata · 28/06/2022 20:12

With the gym I talked myself into going and giving myself permission to do 20mins on cross trainer oe bike then leave. I did this 4 times a week then when felt better I stuck to 30mins on cross trainer or bike.

It didn't feel so bad and it was easy to fit 30 mins in and didnt feel daunting. I still go back to 30mins only if iv had a bad week or not felt I had enough time.

Sunshine10012 · 28/06/2022 20:07

having 2 children should be the reason why you can’t be lazy. Take them to the park after school, play spots with them, go for walks etc.
the busier you are the less chance you’ll get to eat.
Slimming world is a great start but long term it’s not the healthiest plan out there but it will help you to budge a good few stone. The rest has to come from you and if you’re not happy with weigh in, then ask your consultant to keep the results from you.

Spritelite · 28/06/2022 20:05

I’ve no advice because I’m in the exact same boat myself (did seeing all the skinny minnies dresses for the recent heatwave make you feel crap too?) but do you mind me asking what height you are?

Feel free not to disclose, I’m just being nosey because I’m a bigger size than you but weigh 13st 5lb. I’m 5’4” and literally all my fat’s in my belly, my Mum says I look like Gru off despicable me😂 xx

OldTinHat · 28/06/2022 19:57

If you're in England, the NHS run a 12 week weight loss course for free. I can't recommend it enough. Started May 5th at 16st9 and am now 14st13. Am 5'7.

Easy, healthy and no fads. They educate you properly about food.

Contact your GP or Google it.

Good luck OP!

BackToTheTop · 28/06/2022 19:55

I think by turning up and weighing yourself means you hold yourself accountable. It's so easy to pick up bad habits without realising it. If you're not tracking progress you won't know if it's working. Plus if you do have a bad week, you know you have and you can then put it behind you and start afresh that day.

I remember coming home from holiday and knowing I'd put a lot of weight on. I followed sw diet but didn't weigh for 2 months (I knew the program as I'd done it previously). I felt great in myself, but when I did eventually weigh myself I'd only lost 2lbs. I was devastated and it took me 2 years to start properly dieting again

7eleven · 28/06/2022 19:51

I’m trying to lose weight as well. Contrary to what we used to think, Noom recommends that you weight every day, to lose the fear of the scales.

AvocadoPlant · 28/06/2022 19:47

Hi Op, please reach out to your SW consultant, nobody wants you to feel bad, but the plan is helping you and going to the meetings, even if you don’t get told your weight, will help you accept that losing weight, a lot of weight, is a journey, and will feel better if you have supportive company around you.
There will be slip ups and bad weeks, that’s life. Accepting that and not letting it stop you is so much easier when you see others dealing with exactly that situation-you tgen have positive examples to model your behaviour and mindset on.

scoopoftheday · 28/06/2022 19:39

I used to do sw, I helped out on the desk.

There were people who came to the group each week, paid their money and took a seat without weighing in as they liked the support of group but only wanted to weigh monthly. Would that sound like something you'd like to do?

When I left the group I gained a lot of weight as I'd no weigh ins or nobody to hold me accountable. But I joined a gym and downloaded my fitness pal. Made sure I got my steps in and stuck to the calories and the weight fell off again.

Tbh (please don't take this the wrong way) someone that's 17 stone could have lost 7lb in one week easily at my group (water weight at the beginning but even after that they could average 4/5lb per week) so are you sure you're doing it right? (You say you're not counting syns)

I wish you every success in your weightloss journey and hope you get to where you want to be.

Thunderrr · 28/06/2022 19:35

I'd get counselling and find a physical activity that I enjoy and set the time to do it regularly.

Curlyhairedbrummie · 28/06/2022 19:35

Hi op! I'm in a similar position to you and I've learnt that long term change does not come from a place of self hatred. Working on your mental health comes first in my opinion. Waiting to loose weight before doing a, b and c is soul destroying. I try to focus on non scale victories such as loosing inches, a dress size and increasing daily amount of water, fruit and veg etc. If weekly weights are triggering for you then don't do them. Have you every had counselling for your eating disorder?

thriftyhen · 28/06/2022 19:32

www.bbc.co.uk/programmes/m0017tcz

Try listening to this podcast on the BBC. It's about UPF (Ultra Processed Foods). It might help you.

ILikeHotWaterBottles · 28/06/2022 19:26

I know you've got two kids so probably not possible, but can you go to a gym? I'm trying to lose weight and get fitter and noticing a massive difference with going to the gym. But it is costly and with kids not very good for time so maybe not suitable.

I haven't cut out food types either, I'm still eating carbs etc. I have cut out snacking though, that's helped a lot. I used to snack far too much, now if I want something, I'll have one and that's it, no more. It's too easy for me to eat a ton of chocolate 😂

SmellyWellyWoo · 28/06/2022 19:23

You won't count syns? You mean very high calorie food? You're going to eat very high calorie food without counting or measuring in anyway? That doesn't sound like a good plan to be hornet.