Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question for the pro-life members of MN

654 replies

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 16:28

The biggest argument always boils down to “taking a life away, acting like God”.

So - how does IVF sit with you? Are you anti it, because it is “acting like God”. Are you for it because acting like God to create a life is somehow fine whereas taking one away is not?

Do you understand that many IVF pregnancies are high risk and may ultimately require medical management aka abortions?

I’m firmly pro science and think access to both abortions and IVF is a wonderful thing, for avoidance of doubt.

One never sees protests outside fertility clinics and I wondered why.

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 29/06/2022 20:09

@ReneBumsWombats Ah, OK, that sounds very definite. I can't say, in my case, whether the benefit to my grandmother would have outweighed the value of other lives lived. It was certainly hell for her for quite a few years, though her life improved and she came to love my mother. I appreciate that's not at all the case for everyone.

ReneBumsWombats · 29/06/2022 19:43

Even so, do you feel the benefits to your grandmother would have been worth none of you existing?

Yes. But even if I didn't, it was her womb and her life and not for some non-existent potential future person to make the decision.

gnilliwdog · 29/06/2022 19:36

@ReneBumsWombats Yes, I don't want to go back to the days when our grandmothers threw themselves down the stairs. Even so, do you feel the benefits to your grandmother would have been worth none of you existing? My mother achieved a lot fighting for racial justice, I have worked hard to help young homeless people and others in poverty. I think my children will touch others lives and make a contribution as well.

hepatocyte · 29/06/2022 19:32

I also posted a couple of pages ago that women need to be supported in accessing services early on, so they can make an informed choice

hepatocyte · 29/06/2022 19:31

ancientgran · 29/06/2022 15:41

Of course we need all that but it doesn't change the fact that some women state that having an abortion was a traumatic experience for them. Obviously it isn't for everyone but everyone has a right to their own experience. We can't shut women down if their experience isn't what we want to hear.

I was agreeing with you @ancientgran

Why would I highlight the things needed to reduce abortion and help women continue a pregnancy, if I thought it was never associated with trauma..?

ReneBumsWombats · 29/06/2022 19:25

gnilliwdog · 29/06/2022 19:18

I generally think access to safe abortion causes less harm than no access. Still, had it been available, neither my mother, I or my children would be here. Perhaps it's irrelevant to the pro choice argument, but I don't think our lives have been to those we have met. As a philosophical point, who can say whose life is better not lived?

I wouldn't be here either if abortion had been available to my grandmother. Nor my siblings, nor my father.

It doesn't matter. It's irrelevant to the reasons why women need to have access to safe abortion.

gnilliwdog · 29/06/2022 19:18

I generally think access to safe abortion causes less harm than no access. Still, had it been available, neither my mother, I or my children would be here. Perhaps it's irrelevant to the pro choice argument, but I don't think our lives have been to those we have met. As a philosophical point, who can say whose life is better not lived?

Comedycook · 29/06/2022 17:49

I am pro life but not on the ground an embryo in conscious or even has any right to life. I just personally wouldn't have an abortion barring any health complications for me or the baby or rape

You sound pro choice to me.

FunDragon · 29/06/2022 17:34

I’ve never met a pro-lifer who wasn’t a ginormous hypocrite in one way or another. And that’s because it’s really about misogyny, not preserving life.

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 17:29

Bloody autocorrect. This analogy

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 17:28

Nope. This analogous only vaguely works if you agree that life begins at conception, which is where the contention lies.

ClocksGoingBackwards · 29/06/2022 17:10

LynneBenfield · 28/06/2022 18:15

Abortion isn’t against the law though @ClocksGoingBackwards . Never heard of The Abortion Act (1967)?

Nor is putting a dog to sleep when it’s the right thing to do, but we still acknowledge that it’s taking a life.

I believe that us women should have the right to abortion like I said, but we do need to own it and accept what it is.

Carpy88999 · 29/06/2022 16:48

Comedycook · 29/06/2022 16:15

I'm pro choice but I find the whole discussion fascinating from a philosophical point of view.

I'm an atheist and generally all about science but the one thing I can't square in my head is where our consciousness comes from? So, I'm me. Right. Now, if I'd been aborted, would my consciousness just not exist? Would my consciousness end up in another human being?

Not a view I express irl, but I'm against fertility treatments...one reason is overpopulation. The other reason is I just cannot fathom how consciousness would work if we make human beings in an artificial way....not sure if that makes sense.

consciousness as far as I can understand it comes from the brain alone. Say for saying so i suffered a horrific brain injury although I may be still be alive I would cease to be me.

If you were aborted you would have no brain to experience consciousness with. I am pro life but not on the ground an embryo in conscious or even has any right to life. I just personally wouldn't have an abortion barring any health complications for me or the baby or rape or something but anyway it shouldn't be up to me or anyone what someone else can do with their own body/health.

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 16:22

Ah I see, thanks for clarifying @hangonsnoopy

hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 16:18

Sorry, Lynn, not disagreeing with you, just quoting the general debate you were participating in.

I am more saying 'God has made it possible through science' doesn't answer any ethical questions, even in terms of creation, or believers would be agreeing to cloning for the purposes of creating new life.

hepatocyte · 29/06/2022 16:16

deedledeedledum · 29/06/2022 15:49

Because it is highly irregular to do what your friend did. IVF is very expensive and has a low success rate. The general process is to do everything to improve outcomes which means fertilising several embryos not just one and thus generally results in the destruction of embryos at some point. Not sure why this is confusing to you.

I don't think it can be true.

Blastocysts often have low viability and so it would be completely unethical for a clinic to implant one that is unlikely to be successful, rather than destroying it.

I agree that maybe clinics can choose to fertilise an egg one by one and see viability that way before implanting, but the idea of "embryo sparing" IVF is nonsensical.

Comedycook · 29/06/2022 16:15

I'm pro choice but I find the whole discussion fascinating from a philosophical point of view.

I'm an atheist and generally all about science but the one thing I can't square in my head is where our consciousness comes from? So, I'm me. Right. Now, if I'd been aborted, would my consciousness just not exist? Would my consciousness end up in another human being?

Not a view I express irl, but I'm against fertility treatments...one reason is overpopulation. The other reason is I just cannot fathom how consciousness would work if we make human beings in an artificial way....not sure if that makes sense.

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 16:13

hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 16:07

The fact that a technology exists doesn't mean we should use it, whether you are basing that on God or secular morality.

We have an international ban on using advancements in cloning on humans for moral reasons.

Abortion is a tool. It isn't pro-science to use it in every possible imaginable scenario. Different people have different moral stances on where it is right to use it, with the vast majority falling somewhere in the middle, which is why that is where our law is.

? @hangonsnoopy. I think we are talking at cross purposes. I wasn’t arguing against medical ethics. I was merely asking why that particular poster considered one procedure to be a god given technological advancement and (presumably) the other is not? I get the religious connotations of creation vs destruction but the poster discussed purely in terms of ‘technology to allow’, so I’m confused how that circle is squared.

BigFatLiar · 29/06/2022 16:08

I think the reality is principles and morals are often put to one side when they become inconvenient

hangonsnoopy · 29/06/2022 16:07

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 15:58

@deedledeedledum , @Toddlerteaplease is a paediatric nurse, so very probably. Apparently there are embryo sparing types of IVF (frozen or donated).

If ‘God created the technology to allow IVF to happen’ why didn’t he also ‘create the technology to allow abortions to happen’ ? Why is one technological advancement God’s will and another Man’s?

The fact that a technology exists doesn't mean we should use it, whether you are basing that on God or secular morality.

We have an international ban on using advancements in cloning on humans for moral reasons.

Abortion is a tool. It isn't pro-science to use it in every possible imaginable scenario. Different people have different moral stances on where it is right to use it, with the vast majority falling somewhere in the middle, which is why that is where our law is.

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 16:00

PetraBP · 29/06/2022 15:55

Although I’m not against abortion altogether, I do feel that a late term foetus has more of a right to life than an adult child abuser.

Rather than calling me a troll, if you disagree, explain to me why you think I’m wrong.

What the heck? Where did this ginormous, ridiculous and irrelevant straw man come from?

Late stage foetuses vs child abusers?

Jog on. That’s a reach and half. Watch you don’t strain yourself.

restedbutexhausted · 29/06/2022 15:59

PetraBP · 29/06/2022 15:55

Although I’m not against abortion altogether, I do feel that a late term foetus has more of a right to life than an adult child abuser.

Rather than calling me a troll, if you disagree, explain to me why you think I’m wrong.

I don't understand the purpose of comparing a late term foetus to a child abuser Confused

LynneBenfield · 29/06/2022 15:58

@deedledeedledum , @Toddlerteaplease is a paediatric nurse, so very probably. Apparently there are embryo sparing types of IVF (frozen or donated).

If ‘God created the technology to allow IVF to happen’ why didn’t he also ‘create the technology to allow abortions to happen’ ? Why is one technological advancement God’s will and another Man’s?

PetraBP · 29/06/2022 15:55

Although I’m not against abortion altogether, I do feel that a late term foetus has more of a right to life than an adult child abuser.

Rather than calling me a troll, if you disagree, explain to me why you think I’m wrong.

deedledeedledum · 29/06/2022 15:49

PurpleDaisies · 28/06/2022 16:57

My friend had ivf where they only fertilised one egg at a time so there would be no spare embryos.

IVF and abortion are different things so I don’t know why you’re trying to link them.

Because it is highly irregular to do what your friend did. IVF is very expensive and has a low success rate. The general process is to do everything to improve outcomes which means fertilising several embryos not just one and thus generally results in the destruction of embryos at some point. Not sure why this is confusing to you.