Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question for the pro-life members of MN

654 replies

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 16:28

The biggest argument always boils down to “taking a life away, acting like God”.

So - how does IVF sit with you? Are you anti it, because it is “acting like God”. Are you for it because acting like God to create a life is somehow fine whereas taking one away is not?

Do you understand that many IVF pregnancies are high risk and may ultimately require medical management aka abortions?

I’m firmly pro science and think access to both abortions and IVF is a wonderful thing, for avoidance of doubt.

One never sees protests outside fertility clinics and I wondered why.

OP posts:
CandyLeBonBon · 02/07/2022 17:02

Xenia · 02/07/2022 15:05

Cupid I am not sure it is the moral position to accept an abortion at any stage. Any of the positions on the thread could be the correct moral position. I am not sure there are moral absolutes on this topic. Eg the Romans thought it was fine if you did not want a baby to leave it out on a hillside up to one year old as it was in a sense the mother's property. Is doing that at 40 weeks and 1 hour worse than killing it at 41 weeks whilst still in the womb?

Because that doesn't happen in legal abortion. That's why.

foliageeverywhere · 02/07/2022 15:59

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/07/2022 15:51

It most definitely is misogyny - pure and simple

Yup

And god knows how you're supposed to you were raped, and therefore are allowed an abortion, in a scenario where you weren't violently attacked by a stranger.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/07/2022 15:51

Miffee · 02/07/2022 15:18

I was thinking of starting a thread for people who were pro life but will try and ask in this one instead.

Prolifers who believe all abortion is wrong make sense to me. I disagree but I get it. You think it's a baby from conception or "heartbeats" or whatever and you are against killing what you perceive as a baby. Fair enough.

What bugs me is "pro lifers"who believe in abortion for rape or incest but nothing else. How the fuck is that anything other than misogyny? How can you justify that position other than punishing women for having sex?

It most definitely is misogyny - pure and simple

Miffee · 02/07/2022 15:18

I was thinking of starting a thread for people who were pro life but will try and ask in this one instead.

Prolifers who believe all abortion is wrong make sense to me. I disagree but I get it. You think it's a baby from conception or "heartbeats" or whatever and you are against killing what you perceive as a baby. Fair enough.

What bugs me is "pro lifers"who believe in abortion for rape or incest but nothing else. How the fuck is that anything other than misogyny? How can you justify that position other than punishing women for having sex?

Xenia · 02/07/2022 15:05

Cupid I am not sure it is the moral position to accept an abortion at any stage. Any of the positions on the thread could be the correct moral position. I am not sure there are moral absolutes on this topic. Eg the Romans thought it was fine if you did not want a baby to leave it out on a hillside up to one year old as it was in a sense the mother's property. Is doing that at 40 weeks and 1 hour worse than killing it at 41 weeks whilst still in the womb?

psydrive · 02/07/2022 15:04

There is no evidence tht loosening the abortion laws in the UK would lead to the government forcing people to have abortions based or race. That's ridiculous and quite sinister for you to suggest that.

foliageeverywhere · 02/07/2022 14:39

psydrive · 02/07/2022 13:34

So you think if women are allowed to decide whether they have abortions that will lead to women being forced to have abortions? That's a stratospheric leap right there.

It's a common trope - fortunately we have a wealth of data demonstrating that in countries with the most restrictive policies, they have the highest rates of abortion, maternal & foetal death, and very later term terminations.

Dancingwithhyenas · 02/07/2022 14:35

SexyLittleNosferatu · 02/07/2022 13:47

I do not support the right of a woman to abort a foetus ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON. Do you?

Yes I do.

Why are you so keen to force women to birth babies they don't want? How do you propose to make them want the child once it's born?

My experience is that most people think a healthy baby in third trimester should be protected. If the woman doesn’t want the baby she can then give it up for adoption.

It’s vanishingly rare for women to not know they are pregnant before this point and for many of us ethnically the balance of rights tips once the (healthy, I’m not talking about terminations for medical reasons) babies reach viability. That is the current law in the UK. It’s not somehow an extreme pro life position to support the law.

foliageeverywhere · 02/07/2022 14:35

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 12:34

@CupidStunt22 I applaud your honesty. But how would you prevent such legislation being abused? At the moment doctors carry out abortions on certain grounds. If law was changed to state any grounds, what would stop a government deciding it didn't want any more children from a certain group? I can see the law would try to state it should be the woman's choice only, but in practice I think it could open the gate to ethnic cleansing and the depopulation of certain groups.

Another strawman argument.

Forced sterilisation and abortion of specific populations already occurs, relaxing restrictions isn't going going to somehow increase this problem.

If this is something are genuinely passionate about, consider joining Amnesty and Redress, who will explain the many ways you can contribute (arguing against women's reproductive rights is not one).

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 14:03

@psydrive women are allowed abortions in the UK. I am arguing that this provision is sufficient and we do not need to change the law to any time, any reason. And also, of you want to change the law to any time, any reason you need to have seriously considered all ramifications.

SexyLittleNosferatu · 02/07/2022 13:47

I do not support the right of a woman to abort a foetus ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON. Do you?

Yes I do.

Why are you so keen to force women to birth babies they don't want? How do you propose to make them want the child once it's born?

psydrive · 02/07/2022 13:34

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 11:28

@LuckySantangelo35 do you care about starving children? If you won't adopt them all you have no right to an opinion. Do you care about girls trafficked into prostitution, or fgm? No, you have not rescued them all so you have no right to an opinion. Do you support free contraception globally for women? No, you have not paid for every woman to have a choice so you can't have an opinion.

So you think if women are allowed to decide whether they have abortions that will lead to women being forced to have abortions? That's a stratospheric leap right there.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/07/2022 12:55

CupidStunt22 · 02/07/2022 11:54

I do not support the right of a woman to abort a foetus ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON. Do you?

I do. It's the only logical position to hold. It's the only morally acceptable one.

@gnilliwdog

so do I.

and l will never change my mind on it

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 12:34

@CupidStunt22 I applaud your honesty. But how would you prevent such legislation being abused? At the moment doctors carry out abortions on certain grounds. If law was changed to state any grounds, what would stop a government deciding it didn't want any more children from a certain group? I can see the law would try to state it should be the woman's choice only, but in practice I think it could open the gate to ethnic cleansing and the depopulation of certain groups.

CupidStunt22 · 02/07/2022 11:54

I do not support the right of a woman to abort a foetus ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON. Do you?

I do. It's the only logical position to hold. It's the only morally acceptable one.

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 11:53

@LuckySantangelo35 I am not a forced birther. I believe in giving women ample opportunity to seek a termination, but there should be grounds and limits. I agree with @PetraBP and @Xenia that the UK provision is sufficient and there is no need to change the law. And thank you for your question to pro lifers @SemperIdem . It's made me rather red in the face but given me clarity on various positions. Good to discuss.

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 11:28

@LuckySantangelo35 do you care about starving children? If you won't adopt them all you have no right to an opinion. Do you care about girls trafficked into prostitution, or fgm? No, you have not rescued them all so you have no right to an opinion. Do you support free contraception globally for women? No, you have not paid for every woman to have a choice so you can't have an opinion.

PetraBP · 02/07/2022 11:10

Xenia · 02/07/2022 09:03

I take a pragmatic view of English abortion law - it is such a difficult subject we are better off just leaving it as it is a a reasonable compromise. If a baby can now live out of the womb a bit earlier than the original law expected then it is not so many weeks it is worth the can of worms of changing the law. If most down's and other babies are aborted early not late on we can still keep the late abortion right for disabilities even if it is not often used as it is so hard to get changes on this through parliament.

As i said earlier on the threat most of those who are anti abortion are also not keen on IVF either (eg the Roman Catholics - 1.3bn but as someone rightly said back to me about not all 1.3bn believe the same views as their church of course and the same would go to muslims too - 1.9bn. I don't know the view of the C of E but it probably lets people decide themselves rather than saying abortion is wrong).

Not that it will matter to most people here, but the view of the C of E is that abortion is permissible where continuing the pregnancy puts the mother’s life is at risk or the foetus has a grave disability that is incompatible with life outside the womb.

In other words, the C of E would condone abortion where a baby would not have long to live if it was born.

LuckySantangelo35 · 02/07/2022 09:40

@gnilliwdog

“Of course I can't adopt every unwanted child in the UK.”

well there you go then!

Care so much about the unborn, when they’re here….it’s ‘no chance, soz mother get on with it, you’re on your own !’

That’s one of the (many) problems with you forced birthers

Xenia · 02/07/2022 09:03

I take a pragmatic view of English abortion law - it is such a difficult subject we are better off just leaving it as it is a a reasonable compromise. If a baby can now live out of the womb a bit earlier than the original law expected then it is not so many weeks it is worth the can of worms of changing the law. If most down's and other babies are aborted early not late on we can still keep the late abortion right for disabilities even if it is not often used as it is so hard to get changes on this through parliament.

As i said earlier on the threat most of those who are anti abortion are also not keen on IVF either (eg the Roman Catholics - 1.3bn but as someone rightly said back to me about not all 1.3bn believe the same views as their church of course and the same would go to muslims too - 1.9bn. I don't know the view of the C of E but it probably lets people decide themselves rather than saying abortion is wrong).

Gogster · 02/07/2022 08:57

Lovetogarden2022 · 28/06/2022 16:36

I know a few people who are 'pro life' and they are staunchly anti IVF.

That's generally because the unneeded/unused embryos are destroyed.

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 00:41

JustLyra · 02/07/2022 00:11

If a woman has not decided to abort by 24 weeks she should take responsibility for creating a life

and those that don’t get the information by then? As several of us have pointed out.

My DDs condition wasn’t spotted, confirmed and explained until several weeks beyond that point. Is that just tough shit for people in that position?

No, that is a terrible situation, but in this country the law allows you to make a decision. I support that and I am so sorry for what you must have been through. I do not support the right of a woman to abort a foetus ANY TIME FOR ANY REASON. Do you?

SemperIdem · 02/07/2022 00:38

I’ll accept your hidden thanks for starting the thread, to encourage discussion, as someone who doesn’t share your views @PetraBP

OP posts:
gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 00:37

PetraBP · 02/07/2022 00:22

Well for all those who argue that abortion should be permitted at any stage and for any reason, as someone who disagrees with you, I’m just very glad that the law of the UK, and just about every other European country disagrees with you too.

You say that the feelings of the mother trump the life of the foetus, even after 24 weeks. I disagree, and the law disagrees with you too.

The life of the foetus does not trump
the life of the mother if the mother’s life or health are at risk, but that is a different scenario.

Like it or not, your absolute right to choose does not exist, legally or morally.

To tell others that they aren’t even entitled to an opinion on this, when the law, the biology and the majority moderate opinion are against you smacks of breathtaking arrogance.

I respect your right to a different opinion even if I disagree with it. The “no debate”
culture is dangerous and I’m very glad that by allowing a diversity of opinion on here, Mumsnet is not condoning it.

Well said, I'm with you.

gnilliwdog · 02/07/2022 00:34

Looking at gov statistics it states that in 2021 'there were 214,256 abortions for women resident in England and Wales, the highest number since the Abortion Act was introduced.' 'The age standardised abortion rate is 18.6 per thousand women, the highest rate since the Abortion Act was introduced.' There have been a number of measures to ease restrictions which may account for the steep rise - the Human Fertilisation and Embryology Act, which removed restrictions to late abortions in cases of risk to life, foetal abnormality, or grave physical and mental injury to the woman. The Abortion Act also stated that abortions carried out under the terms of the Act were not offences under the Infant Life Preservation Act 1929. Mifepristone was introduced in Britain in 1991, and in 2019 women were allowed to take both pills at home. There is no indication of more late term abortions, the number remains very low, but late term abortions require serious medical concerns that are not temporary. As far as I can tell all abortions in the UK are on medical grounds, concerning physical or mental health, so there is no information on abortion on non medical grounds. On demand abortion has never been on offer here.

Swipe left for the next trending thread