Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question for the pro-life members of MN

654 replies

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 16:28

The biggest argument always boils down to “taking a life away, acting like God”.

So - how does IVF sit with you? Are you anti it, because it is “acting like God”. Are you for it because acting like God to create a life is somehow fine whereas taking one away is not?

Do you understand that many IVF pregnancies are high risk and may ultimately require medical management aka abortions?

I’m firmly pro science and think access to both abortions and IVF is a wonderful thing, for avoidance of doubt.

One never sees protests outside fertility clinics and I wondered why.

OP posts:
stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 19:30

Apologies to cartoon mum.
Got my wires crossed.
Sorry.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/06/2022 19:28

ancientgran · 28/06/2022 19:18

I thought it was the next of kin who had to give permission not the "corpse."

I think it depends on where you are.

However, that's beside the point. It's a thought experiment. If you believe people should have to opt in, or at least not opt out, of an organ donation register, then it's hard to argue why a dead person's wishes for their body are more important than a living woman's.

hangonsnoopy · 28/06/2022 19:25

Hangongran, abortion not miscarriage. I corrected it straight away in the post underneath.

Thescentoftheocean · 28/06/2022 19:24

@Songoftheseas for the following reasons:

  1. IVF involves some unused (for want of a better word) foetuses
  2. It goes against God’s will
  3. Infertile people often seek to adopt and being anti abortion means in theory there are more babies available.
These aren’t my personal views but I’m surprised it can’t be seen how most people who are anti abortion will also be against IVF.
Lesserspottedmama · 28/06/2022 19:22

Also, not all pro-lifers are religious. I’m not, nor are my numerous friends who share my views.

Lesserspottedmama · 28/06/2022 19:20

LadyAnnabelsTapestries · 28/06/2022 16:42

Don't agree with abortion.
Don't agree with IVF where embryos are held in stasis and sometimes destroyed or used for science either.
Don't agree with surrogacy.
Don't agree with sperm donation.

I think I'm consistent in respecting the value as opposed to the disposability of human life.

But I did not always think that way. I've come to it gradually over time.

This. 100%.

Metabigot · 28/06/2022 19:19

doadeer · 28/06/2022 16:41

Those I know who struggle to accept abortion on Christian grounds would say that every life is sacred and a miracle.

Usually until its born

Pumperthepumper · 28/06/2022 19:19

Cartoonmom · 28/06/2022 19:15

Thank you, @Pumperthepumper . Just to be clear, my post about abortion not being a political issue was in reference to separation of church and state. If more religous people in America understood that doctrine, we would not be in the place we are today.

Yes, that’s how I understood your post and I agree.

Songoftheseas · 28/06/2022 19:19

Thescentoftheocean · 28/06/2022 16:44

Believe me, plenty of pro life people are anti IVF. The two things go hand in hand when you think about it.

How exactly do they go hand in hand? IVF helps to create new life, abortion terminates it.

I had IVF to conceive my DD and am pro life (also pro choice in certain circumstances). I am also an atheist.

LynneBenfield · 28/06/2022 19:18

Cartoonmom · 28/06/2022 19:15

Thank you, @Pumperthepumper . Just to be clear, my post about abortion not being a political issue was in reference to separation of church and state. If more religous people in America understood that doctrine, we would not be in the place we are today.

That was what I took from that post, @Cartoonmom. If more people who held pro-life beliefs understood that they could apply them to themselves and their own situations but not impose them on others, that it would be a great improvement.

ancientgran · 28/06/2022 19:18

ReneBumsWombats · 28/06/2022 19:05

It would be interesting to know how many pro lifers believe that organs should not be harvested unless the person gave permission before their death.

If you think a corpse deserves more bodily autonomy than a woman...

I thought it was the next of kin who had to give permission not the "corpse."

ancientgran · 28/06/2022 19:16

hangonsnoopy · 28/06/2022 19:12

Ectopic pregnancy, septic uterus and retained miscarriage don't fall under the Catholic church's teachings against miscarriage.

I don't really understand what you mean, does the Catholic teach anything against miscarriages?

LynneBenfield · 28/06/2022 19:15

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 18:31

what is the expression 'benefits babies'?

I have never heard that before.

My guess is that you are discriminating and being hateful to people (and their familes on benefits).

I don't know if you are in the U.K. but we are in the middle of an economic crisis and the number of people having to rely on food banks and benefits is massive and growing.

What exactly do you mean by a 'benefit baby'?

I have reported your post as this expression is hateful and discriminatory.

@stayingpositiveifpossible (today, 18:31)

Cartoonmom · 28/06/2022 19:15

Thank you, @Pumperthepumper . Just to be clear, my post about abortion not being a political issue was in reference to separation of church and state. If more religous people in America understood that doctrine, we would not be in the place we are today.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 19:15

Still here. Re read the thread.

hangonsnoopy · 28/06/2022 19:12

Against abortion, I mean.

hangonsnoopy · 28/06/2022 19:12

ancientgran · 28/06/2022 18:57

That is very dismissive. I'm well past the age of justifying IVF because it affects me but I have no issue justifying it. If you are a person of faith it is straightforward to believe God gave us the ability to do it just like heart transplants or chemotherapy and I see it as something positive.

I imagine prolife supporters have a spectrum of beliefs and most would follow the doctrine of having an abortion to save the life of the mother. I don't imagine many people would believe the woman should die and inevitably it would result in the death of the baby in those cases although I am old enough to remember when more people did believe that.

Ectopic pregnancy, septic uterus and retained miscarriage don't fall under the Catholic church's teachings against miscarriage.

LynneBenfield · 28/06/2022 19:11

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 18:50

Meaning Cartoonmum is trolling.

Fairly clear if not crystal that some despicable right wing twats will be seeking to voice themselves on this forum.

'Benefit babies' is the pits.

Mods?

I think you are getting confused. @Cartoonmom didn’t use the term “benefits babies”, @QOD did (and you replied to her).

I’m not sure what you think @Cartoonmom has said that’s so awful? Calm down and read back @stayingpositiveifpossible

Pumperthepumper · 28/06/2022 19:09

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 19:08

'Benefits babies' ? and I quote.

That wasn’t Cartoon mum. It was QOD.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 19:08

And I'm not 'upset'.

Lucid. Aware and clear.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 19:08

Cartoonmom · 28/06/2022 19:04

@stayingpositiveifpossible - oh my, I've never been called right wing or a troll before in my life. Fwiw, I'm a Bernie Sanders supporter. I spent an hour this morning writing to my Senators demanding they do more to ensure federal access to abortion.

Not sure what I said to make you so upset?

'Benefits babies' ? and I quote.

Tandora · 28/06/2022 19:08

SarahProblem · 28/06/2022 17:41

YABU only for using the phrase pro-life. Don't let them get away with that euphemism.

This. It’s forced pregnancy and birth. It’s about controlling and enslaving women. Has nothing to do with IVF.
.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/06/2022 19:05

It would be interesting to know how many pro lifers believe that organs should not be harvested unless the person gave permission before their death.

If you think a corpse deserves more bodily autonomy than a woman...

ancientgran · 28/06/2022 19:04

Herbyhippo · 28/06/2022 18:43

I’m presuming that viagra is banned in these states, surely the inability to get an erection is Gods will?

Viagra isn't normally used to end a life so nothing like the equivalent.

Cartoonmom · 28/06/2022 19:04

@stayingpositiveifpossible - oh my, I've never been called right wing or a troll before in my life. Fwiw, I'm a Bernie Sanders supporter. I spent an hour this morning writing to my Senators demanding they do more to ensure federal access to abortion.

Not sure what I said to make you so upset?