Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

A question for the pro-life members of MN

654 replies

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 16:28

The biggest argument always boils down to “taking a life away, acting like God”.

So - how does IVF sit with you? Are you anti it, because it is “acting like God”. Are you for it because acting like God to create a life is somehow fine whereas taking one away is not?

Do you understand that many IVF pregnancies are high risk and may ultimately require medical management aka abortions?

I’m firmly pro science and think access to both abortions and IVF is a wonderful thing, for avoidance of doubt.

One never sees protests outside fertility clinics and I wondered why.

OP posts:
OMG12 · 28/06/2022 21:13

There was a totally vile American politician on tv. The presenter asked whether he thought it was right a 12 year old who had been raped was forced to continue with her pregnancy (his state said abortion could be done up to a heartbeat, so about 8 weeks). His response was you would know you had been raped within the last 2 months. Totally ignoring the biology of the 8 weeks, trauma and number of reasons why a young child would not come forward. This man is sick, he gets his kicks out of child abuse but actively deepening the pain caused by the abuse. Anyone who thinks the rights of a few cells trumps the need to do everything possible to help that 12 year old rather than put her at severe risk of further life long mental and physical harm and even death is the lowest of the low. Child abuse is disgusting. If anyone was in any doubt what these people are up to and think it might be about protecting children needs to listen to this “man”. There is a special place in hell awaiting him

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 21:11

And no, it is not true mumsnet is only for people of higher income brackets.

In particular in respect of education and forward thinking that is NOT true at all.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 21:10

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 28/06/2022 20:32

Also quite nasty about people who have religious beliefs.

Mumsnet is not for religious people, non white people, people who are not struggling financially - you get so much hate and are dismissed of your experiences if you fall within these groups and offer an opinion.

The IVF / Infertility boards are the only sane boards. Oh and property.

Hope I don't get kicked off for saying this as as I need the IVF boards.

I don't agree with this statement.

Yes, mumsnetters can be brutal and straightforward in their opinions.

But one thing I have always respected them for is

if you REALLY, REALLY need help then someone is up 4 a.m if need be in the morning and will respond.

For all my trials and tribulations with this board I respect mumsnetters to the ends of the earth for that.

Many many people on here will help in dire circumstances and at the drop of a hat. I respect them for that.

CapMarvel · 28/06/2022 21:09

LifeExperience · 28/06/2022 19:45

I'm pro-life, anti IVF, anti surrogacy, and anti death penalty. Human life is a gift from God and should be protected to the greatest extent possible from natural conception until death.

Around 25,000 women die every year because they are desperate enough to undergo unsafe, illegal abortions.

All life is precious, apparently, apart from those women.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 21:00

and lie about it on the other hand.
Which you are doing currently.

You have just said you are 'delighted about judgement of Roe versus Wade'

You are JUDGING

Women.

NO DOUBT WHATSOEVER ABOUT THAT ONE

Please stop pretending you are doing anything else.

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 20:59

tictoc76 · 28/06/2022 20:33

How am i sitting on the fence? No fence at all but I am also not perfect so i cannot judge others.

Do you want me to say I disagree with both abortion and IVF and I sit in judgement over others? I disagree with both - very strongly!

So no problem with you saying you are 'not judging others'

but actually you ARE judging others. You say

you were 'delighted when Roe and Wade were overturned'.

You just SAID that.

That is not 'not judging others'

That is Making a judgement.

You don't want to judge.

Don't judge.

Don't feel anything one way or the other about Roe versus Wade.

With all due respect don't make a judgement on one hand and life about it on the other.

ReneBumsWombats · 28/06/2022 20:54

The consequences of an argument aren't the same thing as the argument itself.

What are you arguing for, if not the best possible consequences?

Ansjovis · 28/06/2022 20:51

If you're pro-life you (whether or not you want to call it this) believe in forced pregnancy and birth that you won't be around to see the consequences of. I've never met a pro-choice person who wouldn't defend the rights of a pro-lifer not to get an abortion that they don't want. One side is inherently more harmful to currently living women than the other. If you're pro life and you own this fact I believe it becomes easier to understand why you may be getting so much 'hate'.

OMG12 · 28/06/2022 20:50

What I find bizarre with all these Christian misogynistic idiots is that it’s quite clear they have never actually read the Bible. Eg Numbers 11 et seq clearly sets out how a priest is to carry out an abortion. It’s literally there in black and white! Of course it’s written in a completely misogynistic manner with the woman having no choice in the matter. So one can only assume that it’s the matter of giving women a choice in this that’s the issue

lightisnotwhite · 28/06/2022 20:50

I also think we as women we don’t want to lose what an amazing thing having a baby is. We should value “life” as the rare gift it is. I think it’s a danger being too matter of fact about abortion.
How many more women would keep their babies if money, housing and respect weren’t such an issue.
Clearly there will always be circumstances where a mother will decide it’s in everyone’s interest to terminate but it slightly worries me that we are getting a bit blasé about it.

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 20:45

@hangonsnoopy

I didn’t ask why some people are pro choice and others anti it. That has been rehashed time and time again. The difference between the religious and non-religious anti abortion argument is largely semantics.

I asked what pro life advocates stance on IVF was, I am interested in that perspective.

OP posts:
bbqhulahoop · 28/06/2022 20:38

LadyAnnabelsTapestries · 28/06/2022 16:42

Don't agree with abortion.
Don't agree with IVF where embryos are held in stasis and sometimes destroyed or used for science either.
Don't agree with surrogacy.
Don't agree with sperm donation.

I think I'm consistent in respecting the value as opposed to the disposability of human life.

But I did not always think that way. I've come to it gradually over time.

Genuinely not being goady, but would like to understand why the value of life doesn't extend to people who could die from giving birth, from living with the physical consequence of rape etc. why is the value of the woman not important?

And fwiw I am squeamish about abortion personally, but pro choice for women who need access to the service

hangonsnoopy · 28/06/2022 20:36

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 20:19

The argument is the same because of the end result @hangonsnoopy - less rights for women over their own bodies.

The consequences of an argument aren't the same thing as the argument itself.

I am not sure why you have started this thread if you don't want to understand why people have different beliefs from each other.

My understanding is that only a quarter of people who are anti abortion are also opposed to IVF, and part of that is because people are anti-abortion for different reasons.

SuziSecondLaw · 28/06/2022 20:34

Andthedebategoeson · 28/06/2022 20:23

I got pregnant by my violent and abusive ex, my rapist, when I was 19. That baby was adopted shortly after birth and has a good life with a family who loves them.

The baby isn't responsible for the actions of the parents.

So when you're spouting such hate about how a group of people disgust you, don't be surprised or enraged to hear that many of us feel the same about those with your view and choices.

The 'pro choicers' on mumsnet are much more vitriolic and hateful than any of the pro lifers I have seen post. It's rare you see a pro lifer on mumsnet calling people vile and disgusting and if they did it would be removed immediately.

Intolerant and aggressive is what lots of you are. Not too dissimilar to the idiots who harass people outside of abortion clinics.

You want to take away a woman's choice.

I would never, and could never give a baby I carried for 9 months and gave birth to up for adoption, I couldn't do it.

However, that does not mean I have the right to take away YOUR choice to do so.

Can you imagine if this latest decision was instead about adoption. So a bunch of people decided it was illegal for you to give the baby up for adoption. Would you think that was fair? Would you think those people were decent?

Do you really not see the difference?

Hornbostel · 28/06/2022 20:33

Stylishkidintheriot · 28/06/2022 20:26

just following on from @Andthedebategoeson I do find in the UK, in general conversation and on mumsnet that pro choicers are a lot more nasty about difference of opinion than pro lifers.

I've never been called a murderer by a pro- choicer.

tictoc76 · 28/06/2022 20:33

stayingpositiveifpossible · 28/06/2022 18:57

Heavens above, lets all sit on the fence shall we? Good luck with that one.

How am i sitting on the fence? No fence at all but I am also not perfect so i cannot judge others.

Do you want me to say I disagree with both abortion and IVF and I sit in judgement over others? I disagree with both - very strongly!

Pumperthepumper · 28/06/2022 20:33

Andthedebategoeson · 28/06/2022 20:23

I got pregnant by my violent and abusive ex, my rapist, when I was 19. That baby was adopted shortly after birth and has a good life with a family who loves them.

The baby isn't responsible for the actions of the parents.

So when you're spouting such hate about how a group of people disgust you, don't be surprised or enraged to hear that many of us feel the same about those with your view and choices.

The 'pro choicers' on mumsnet are much more vitriolic and hateful than any of the pro lifers I have seen post. It's rare you see a pro lifer on mumsnet calling people vile and disgusting and if they did it would be removed immediately.

Intolerant and aggressive is what lots of you are. Not too dissimilar to the idiots who harass people outside of abortion clinics.

This is pretty vitriolic. Loads of pro-lifers rock up to mumsnet and start using words like ‘murder’, you can’t have read many abortion threads.

CandyLeBonBon · 28/06/2022 20:32

"If you don't agree with abortion, what is your plan to support the women who will be forced to have children they didn't want? And how do you plan to support the children themselves?
*
Will you campaign for a law that ensures the fathers pay for the children they create? Will you ensure the women are financially compensated for the time they will have off work and the costs associated with pregnancy - clothing, food etc?
Will you ensure that adequate financial provision is made for these children? Will you find the money to invest in our broken maternity services? What about funding for all the new school places that will be needed?

Being anti abortion is totally your right as regards your own body. But if you seek to impose your views on other women, you must accept that a ban on abortion does not reduce pregnancies, it just results in more unwanted babies being born, a cost that should be carried by the whole of the society that has sought to control women's bodies.*"

^^ALL OF THIS

IVFPrayingForBioChild · 28/06/2022 20:32

Stylishkidintheriot · 28/06/2022 20:26

just following on from @Andthedebategoeson I do find in the UK, in general conversation and on mumsnet that pro choicers are a lot more nasty about difference of opinion than pro lifers.

Also quite nasty about people who have religious beliefs.

Mumsnet is not for religious people, non white people, people who are not struggling financially - you get so much hate and are dismissed of your experiences if you fall within these groups and offer an opinion.

The IVF / Infertility boards are the only sane boards. Oh and property.

Hope I don't get kicked off for saying this as as I need the IVF boards.

WoolyMammoth55 · 28/06/2022 20:29

Haven't RTFT but came on to say that when I had an abortion, over a decade ago, it was for what some would consider "social reasons" -

i.e. I was physically healthy, at 7 weeks the fetus seemed viable, etc.

However, I was in precarious temporary employment, had no family support, didn't own a home, had no financial security, and was in a new relationship. I was also in deep grief for the loss of my own mother.

If I'd been refused an abortion, since requiring it for only "social" reasons, I'd definitely have killed myself rather than continue that pregnancy. In fact that thought occurred to me often after I took the pregnancy test - that one way I could control this out-of-control situation would be to commit suicide...

I honestly can't imagine what it must be like right now for those women in the US, for whom healthcare is so expensive, where the cost of a delivering those unwanted babies can be $20K and upwards... The pure financial terror of it. And none of these (sickening misnomer) "pro-life" groups are offering to cover any of those costs for these forced pregnancies and deliveries...

The hypocrisy makes me nauseous, honestly. Anyone who truly thinks life is sacred HAS TO trust living women to make the right choice for their life. Anytime safe access to abortion is restricted, women will die because of it.

Stylishkidintheriot · 28/06/2022 20:26

just following on from @Andthedebategoeson I do find in the UK, in general conversation and on mumsnet that pro choicers are a lot more nasty about difference of opinion than pro lifers.

Andthedebategoeson · 28/06/2022 20:23

SuziSecondLaw · 28/06/2022 19:32

Pro lifers are vile, they disgust me.

I once got pregnant by my violent abusive ex.
Pro lifers would force me to be connected to my ex forever through a child I'd struggle to love. I'd probably have committed suicide by now.

Instead I am extremely lucky to be living in a country where abortion is legal. It was the best decision I ever made. I moved on, I fell in love, and I now have a very much loved and WANTED child.

I got pregnant by my violent and abusive ex, my rapist, when I was 19. That baby was adopted shortly after birth and has a good life with a family who loves them.

The baby isn't responsible for the actions of the parents.

So when you're spouting such hate about how a group of people disgust you, don't be surprised or enraged to hear that many of us feel the same about those with your view and choices.

The 'pro choicers' on mumsnet are much more vitriolic and hateful than any of the pro lifers I have seen post. It's rare you see a pro lifer on mumsnet calling people vile and disgusting and if they did it would be removed immediately.

Intolerant and aggressive is what lots of you are. Not too dissimilar to the idiots who harass people outside of abortion clinics.

ItWasPeculiarButBearable · 28/06/2022 20:20

They often are outside IVF clinics, without realising it. When I was having IVF in Edinburgh they were protesting on the main road at the junction to the hospital which leads to all the women’s services.

It was horrible on a number of levels, most of which I’d struggle to articulate. Arseholes.

SemperIdem · 28/06/2022 20:19

The argument is the same because of the end result @hangonsnoopy - less rights for women over their own bodies.

OP posts:
aloneandlost · 28/06/2022 20:18

LadyAnnabelsTapestries · 28/06/2022 16:42

Don't agree with abortion.
Don't agree with IVF where embryos are held in stasis and sometimes destroyed or used for science either.
Don't agree with surrogacy.
Don't agree with sperm donation.

I think I'm consistent in respecting the value as opposed to the disposability of human life.

But I did not always think that way. I've come to it gradually over time.

And I suspect you wouldn’t want to prevent someone else accessing an abortion, you would just prefer they didn’t get one?

Swipe left for the next trending thread