Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Managers should give us older workers a bit of respect!

114 replies

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 15:21

This is just a rant really. The options are to put up with it or move on. I've been doing my job (not with the same company) for 37 years. I've been a manager but now cruising along looking forward to retiring in a few years. I'm very happy not being a manager & just being that steady reliable person that every dept needs. However, this young girl has been promoted to a manager within the dept, but she's not my line manager. She is studying towards the same qualification I attained 30 years ago. I really think the "power" has gone to her head! She receives a lot of support from my very experienced line manager, which is a good thing of course. However, she seems to have taken the view that she should be micro managing me as well as her other reportees. My own manager does not micro manage me, I do not need it! I know my job inside out, I keep up with technology. There are no new, improved processes she's bringing to the table, she's not teaching me anything new, but seems to think she can tell me what to do to all of a sudden! I'm all for bringing the youngsters on, she's same age as my daughter, but remember youngsters, us oldies who have kept up with the times still have our faculties, do not need micromanaging & therefore deserve a bit more respect than that, we're not office juniors!
How can I manoeuvre her away from me without sounding like a jealous old woman who's had her day in the workplace. Ignoring her seems childish, but I'm.not going to be micromanaged by someone who has so much less experience, not even attained the qualification yet & does not know anything more about my.job than I do either! Otoh I don't want to be a manager either

OP posts:
RaspberryParfait · 28/06/2022 16:03

I’d ask for a meeting with your line manager and her, and explain how you feel and that it’s causing you stress in the workplace. Also asking outright if she has issues with your output that is causing her to be on your back all the time. If not, kindly ask her to leave you alone to get on with your job!

I’d get it on record so if it continues and you feel the need to raise it with HR as a bullying grievance you have proof it’s been raised with your line manager.

girlmom21 · 28/06/2022 16:00

Why don't you try and help her with your experience and knowledge then? Encourage and support her to advance in her career - rather than dragging her down for trying her best in a role you didn't want.

TimBoothseyes · 28/06/2022 16:00

Although your post is a bit , shall we say, "off" I understand it is a rant and people tend to use wording that they would not normally do so otherwise. I also totally get the sentiment behind the rant. When someone has being doing a job for a long time it is infuriating when somebody else (who is less experienced), decides that they know better and are not prepared to listen. By all means voice your ideas, but if somebody with more years under their belt tells you that a), it's already been tried and b), it didn't work then listen to them. Yes former "training manager" I AM looking at you.

SharpLily · 28/06/2022 16:00

Do office juniors not also deserve respect, then?

Are you actually doing your job as well as you think? I work with a number of much older, very experienced people with an attitude similar to your own. Not a problem on my shift but our manager is pulling her hair out because she regularly receives complaints from clients about these same older people, who are also making a number of mistakes due to being forgetful, for example. However they're so convinced of their own experience and professionalism that they refuse to listen to her. Ask yourself if there may be a reason your colleague feels the need to micromanage you.

MajorCarolDanvers · 28/06/2022 15:59

Perhaps this adult woman is picking up on your appalling ageism and doesn't think you are worthy of respect.

Perhaps you should see if HR can book you on a course to deal with your prejudices

Justcallmebebes · 28/06/2022 15:59

I totally get you too OP and I don't think your post comes across as in the slightest bit disrespectful.

Can you speak to your line manager?

FOTB · 28/06/2022 15:58

Mahanii · 28/06/2022 15:54

I've been micromanaged. You have to grey rock, smile and nod, pretend you are listening while actually thinking about what you'd like for tea, anything to stay sane and civil.

Micromanaging usually means one of two things:

  1. The manager is new to managing people. In which case, they'll micromanage everyone, not just one person. The OP doesn't mention anyone else complaining.

  2. The person being micromanaged is not performing to expectations, and the manager is trying to get more out of them before things move to a performance improvement plan and possible dismissal. The OP has admitted to cruising along in their job and counting down to retirement.

I would agree that 1) is terrible, and I'm not keen on managers who haven't learned how to manage people.

If you're the subject of 2), you've brought it on yourself. I hate micromanaging people, and as such, I really hate having to manage underperformers in this way. It's just as unpleasant an experience for the manager.

Marvellousmadness · 28/06/2022 15:54

*is

Marvellousmadness · 28/06/2022 15:54

Yabu . What's her age got to do with it
Also she us a woman. Not a girl

Mahanii · 28/06/2022 15:54

I've been micromanaged. You have to grey rock, smile and nod, pretend you are listening while actually thinking about what you'd like for tea, anything to stay sane and civil.

KatherineJaneway · 28/06/2022 15:52

Sounds like she hasn't got the balance right with delegation and team working. Why not have a gentle talk with her and help her see that. Agree ways of working between you.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 15:48

You should be able to put in a coffee with her and explain to her that you have a lot of experience and don't require the micro managing.

Why do you not feel able to do that?

FOTB · 28/06/2022 15:47

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 15:21

This is just a rant really. The options are to put up with it or move on. I've been doing my job (not with the same company) for 37 years. I've been a manager but now cruising along looking forward to retiring in a few years. I'm very happy not being a manager & just being that steady reliable person that every dept needs. However, this young girl has been promoted to a manager within the dept, but she's not my line manager. She is studying towards the same qualification I attained 30 years ago. I really think the "power" has gone to her head! She receives a lot of support from my very experienced line manager, which is a good thing of course. However, she seems to have taken the view that she should be micro managing me as well as her other reportees. My own manager does not micro manage me, I do not need it! I know my job inside out, I keep up with technology. There are no new, improved processes she's bringing to the table, she's not teaching me anything new, but seems to think she can tell me what to do to all of a sudden! I'm all for bringing the youngsters on, she's same age as my daughter, but remember youngsters, us oldies who have kept up with the times still have our faculties, do not need micromanaging & therefore deserve a bit more respect than that, we're not office juniors!
How can I manoeuvre her away from me without sounding like a jealous old woman who's had her day in the workplace. Ignoring her seems childish, but I'm.not going to be micromanaged by someone who has so much less experience, not even attained the qualification yet & does not know anything more about my.job than I do either! Otoh I don't want to be a manager either

By your own admission, you're "cruising along", so not working particularly hard. Definitely not putting in any extra effort.

You've described the manager as a "young girl" and said you "deserve respect" because you're one of the "oldies". This is ridiculous. You're making this an age issue, which it's not, so you're currently discriminating against the manager on the basis of age, which is illegal.

I've managed plenty of people who are younger than me and older than me - for me, age is irrelevant. It's about how much experience they have, and how hard they work. You might have more experience than this manager, but given you don't seem to be putting in any extra effort, has it occurred to you that she's trying to give you more support to help get more out of you? Why should she assume you don't want to achieve more purely because you're "retiring in a few years"? She's treating you like any other worker.

By the sounds of it - and this is entirely based on your side of the story - she's being respectful by ignoring your age, and you're being disrespectful by making a big deal of her age.

PansyPetunia · 28/06/2022 15:45

This younger person is ALSO devoid of respect it seems...

comealongponds · 28/06/2022 15:44

YABU

you sound really patronising about her just because of her age. Older does not equal better or more deserving of respect than anyone else.

PansyPetunia · 28/06/2022 15:43

Wonder how this shiny new manager would handle a grievance procedure, or how would she react to the word 'bullying' being associated with her management style?

Weirdwonders · 28/06/2022 15:43

YANBU. I couldn’t be bothered with finding the headspace to deal with that either when I’m trying to get on with my work, but you’ve referred to her as a ‘girl’ now so according to Mumsnet law you’re irredeemable. Speak to your Manager about it and ask for clarification of who you should report to. Or if she asks you to do something different ask if she’s cleared it with your manager.

5128gap · 28/06/2022 15:42

You need to take age out of this as it's irrelevant. Your respective ages don't make either of you better or worse at your jobs, or more or less deserving of respect.
Your problem is that you have a colleague who is behaving arrogantly and over stepping her role in relation to you. This would look exactly the same if she was your own age, so tackle it as if she were.
Firstly with a conversation with her about instances where she behaved inappropriately with examples and a request to stop. Secondly if necessary with your line manager.
In neither conversation should you bring age into it (unless you have evidence she has been ageist of course) or you will just blur the issue. And also risk accusations of ageism against you if you use terms like 'these youngsters'.

partyface · 28/06/2022 15:41

Oh I get it completely, could have written this myself OP, sincere sympathies from me. It's the rudeness that annoys me most, the apparent inability to say please and thank you. And that the company apparently thinks that's okay. One day I won't be able to help myself and I'll say 'what's the magic word'?

PansyPetunia · 28/06/2022 15:41

Ragwort · 28/06/2022 15:37

Smile and nod.

This! I'm in a similiar situation with people breezing in from other branches thinking they are here to 'save us' or ' show us how it's done in other stores'

Er, no

But it's amusing watching them tie themselves up in knots vying for top dog place

TheGrumpiest · 28/06/2022 15:38

If you're "cruising along" waiting for retirement, it might not really be worth getting too worked up about this? I was in a similar situation just after I came back from maternity leave. Someone who had joined while I was off decided to start micro managing me on my return. I didn't need it, had a lot more experience and qualifications than her, but didn't have the energy to fight it off. I just used to nod and smile and carry on in my own merry way knowing I was out of there. She wasn't my direct line manager so I wasn't worried about a reference.

She used to give me lists of tasks to do Grin I used to tick them off with smiley faces and give the list back to her (without actually doing all the tasks...). If I couldn't be bothered with something complex because I'd been up half the night I would say it was really too tricky for me and needed a management eye "over to you ms clipboards".

Probably not a professional or constructive approach but I was beyond caring and it kept me sane.

Work it to your advantage somehow? Good luck!

Ragwort · 28/06/2022 15:37

Smile and nod.

Spohn · 28/06/2022 15:36

The obvious answer is to tell your manager that Z seems to be checking a lot of small details about your role, is there anything you need to know? Is there a reason you require this extra supervision?

Do not mention anyone’s ages, it’s irrelevant, you seem heavily obsessed focused on it and it comes across dreadfully.

Talkingtopigeons · 28/06/2022 15:34

People who micromanage are usually anxious about delegating and whether things will be done because they're responsible if it's not - which is a very typical thing for a new manager to be. As others have said perhaps you could use your experience of people managing to give some constructive feedback instead of assuming that she's trying to wind you up?

DashboardConfessional · 28/06/2022 15:34

I'm pretty sure she can tell you think of her as a "girl" which isn't going to help you.

If she tries to steer you off-task and give you things to do, I would just pleasantly reply that you're doing X for your line manager at the moment.

Swipe left for the next trending thread