Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Managers should give us older workers a bit of respect!

114 replies

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 15:21

This is just a rant really. The options are to put up with it or move on. I've been doing my job (not with the same company) for 37 years. I've been a manager but now cruising along looking forward to retiring in a few years. I'm very happy not being a manager & just being that steady reliable person that every dept needs. However, this young girl has been promoted to a manager within the dept, but she's not my line manager. She is studying towards the same qualification I attained 30 years ago. I really think the "power" has gone to her head! She receives a lot of support from my very experienced line manager, which is a good thing of course. However, she seems to have taken the view that she should be micro managing me as well as her other reportees. My own manager does not micro manage me, I do not need it! I know my job inside out, I keep up with technology. There are no new, improved processes she's bringing to the table, she's not teaching me anything new, but seems to think she can tell me what to do to all of a sudden! I'm all for bringing the youngsters on, she's same age as my daughter, but remember youngsters, us oldies who have kept up with the times still have our faculties, do not need micromanaging & therefore deserve a bit more respect than that, we're not office juniors!
How can I manoeuvre her away from me without sounding like a jealous old woman who's had her day in the workplace. Ignoring her seems childish, but I'm.not going to be micromanaged by someone who has so much less experience, not even attained the qualification yet & does not know anything more about my.job than I do either! Otoh I don't want to be a manager either

OP posts:
ThePants999 · 28/06/2022 17:54

You need to manage your manager. People new to management take some time to really understand that people are different and need to be managed differently.

AchatAVendre · 28/06/2022 17:51

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 17:41

@10HailMarys yes I am cruising along to retirement and have no interest in professional development. Been there & bought the t shirt. I have no dependants, no mortgage or rent, I do not need to develop in the workplace. The younger generation have a long hard slog in front of them with the housing and cost of living crises and they should be the ones pushing ahead & being given the chances if they want them. I've done my time, had my chances. I therefore do not have an issue in being managed by someone younger. When you get to my age its inevitable that is going to happen. I do not think my posts give the impression that I'm stuck in the past & behind the times. I have kept up to date with my industry & technology & new processes. I am, however, that steady, reliable worker who does a very good job, as has been clarified in my appraisal, who will go the extra mile to make sure deadlines are met. I am never off sick, still have my good memory. I'm not a dinosaur who has not kept up with the times, so I would like to feel that trust & respect from a manager that I can get on with the job without being micro managed & bossed around as if I were a child.

tbh you are giving the impression that you are quite hard to work with and can't teamwork. But then I tend to disbelieve people who tell me how good they are, rather than letting their actions speak for them. Obviously difficult online but do you go around telling people how great you are at your job constantly when you're in work? And you do sound as though you have it in for this young girl quite a bit!

rookiemere · 28/06/2022 17:48

You could just start replying "Bless your heart" in a sympathetic tone to everything she says.

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 17:41

@10HailMarys yes I am cruising along to retirement and have no interest in professional development. Been there & bought the t shirt. I have no dependants, no mortgage or rent, I do not need to develop in the workplace. The younger generation have a long hard slog in front of them with the housing and cost of living crises and they should be the ones pushing ahead & being given the chances if they want them. I've done my time, had my chances. I therefore do not have an issue in being managed by someone younger. When you get to my age its inevitable that is going to happen. I do not think my posts give the impression that I'm stuck in the past & behind the times. I have kept up to date with my industry & technology & new processes. I am, however, that steady, reliable worker who does a very good job, as has been clarified in my appraisal, who will go the extra mile to make sure deadlines are met. I am never off sick, still have my good memory. I'm not a dinosaur who has not kept up with the times, so I would like to feel that trust & respect from a manager that I can get on with the job without being micro managed & bossed around as if I were a child.

OP posts:
YourLittleSecret · 28/06/2022 17:35

I doubt it's to do with age. She has been given a job as a "manager" and has yet to learn that some staff need more input and scrutiny than others.
I have been in both situations.
I suggest a gentle word with her about delegation and management styles.

suckingonchillidogs · 28/06/2022 17:34

It's not as if OP has actually called her a young girl to her face though is it

littlefireseverywhere · 28/06/2022 17:31

I know w we just you mean, I had a new manager 2 years ago & have now trained her well. She no longer micromanages me.

Staffy1 · 28/06/2022 17:24

I think it needs saying, pretty much as you have in your OP, that you’ve been qualified in what she’s training for for the last 30 years and don’t need micro-managing.

Stressedout65 · 28/06/2022 17:23

OK, hands up, I uses the incorrect terminology when referring to the manager in question. I am very good at my job. There have been no performance issues on my part. This has been confirmed in an appraisal with the relevant director. They released another member of staff last year as they were too slow & I was worth two of them in terms of work rate & performance; and this manager is aware of my positive appraisal. It is probably down to her inexperience & wanting to make her mark. I could raise the issue but I do not want to make myself look like the stereotypical older worker who thinks she rules the roost. I remember a few of those from my early days in the 1980's and I am most certainly not one of those. Neither do I mean that older workers should automatically command respect at all. What I do mean is that if an older worker is good at their job and has a lot of experience under their belts, moves with the times, then the younger
manager should respect that experience & trust that older member of staff to do the job properly, without micro managing. This manager knows my capabilities and that I do a good job so I don't see why she suddenly needs to do this. I've said nothing so far, I just tell her it's taken care of & ignore any attempts to boss me around. Maybe she is on line to become my manager, I don't know; but if she is to become my line manager then I should be able to feel that trust in me that I get from my current line manager - who happens to be as young as one of my adult children. We work well together because he trusts me to do the job quickley & to a high standard. He therefore gets a lot of respect from me and I will go the extra mile when we are exceptionally busy. Respect is a two way thing. It is also not my job to tell this new manager how to manage or guide her with my supposed "people skills" gained from my time many years ago as a manager, as someone suggested further up the thread. Now that would really be overstepping boundaries don't you think!

OP posts:
10HailMarys · 28/06/2022 17:18

Age doesn't automatically command respect. Why should it?

I'm in my mid-40s and have been working for about 25 years now. I would never in a million years talk about a younger colleague the way you're talking about yours and I would never assume that just because I'm older than some of my colleagues, I should somehow be treated differently to them.

You sound really complacent and stuck in your ways. As you said yourself, basically just cruising along to retirement and not really interested in professional development. Maybe that's why your new colleague has been asked to get involved a bit more - she's probably a lot more enthusiastic and open to improvement than you are, whereas you just assume you know it all.

You say she gets support from your line manager - are your manager and her manager the same person, then? Or is your manager just mentoring her while she's managed by someone different? Either way, if you do feel she's genuinely overstepping the mark and 'managing' you when you are on the same level as her, have a chat with your line manager about that and where you stand. But certainly don't bring the age/experience thing into it because you'll sound ridiculous and entitled. Just ask for clarification on reporting lines.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 17:06

ilovesooty · 28/06/2022 16:50

I'm an anti ageism poster and I agree with you. It doesn't just go one way.

Thanks ilovesooty. Agree it goes both ways.

Butitsnotfunnyisititsserious · 28/06/2022 17:06

You get respect if you give it. I've found at times when someone has been there years, they can be inflexible with change. If cv there's a real issue, mention it to your manager.

Mememene · 28/06/2022 17:03

I used to be in senior management, now I'm tootling along and know I could do my managers job with my eyes closed. Like you OP I don't want it, the days of stressing my head off are long gone, my mortgage is paid and I can afford to bob along.

I respect my boss, she respects me. I think you maybe should refer back to some of the communication techniques that you learned as a manager all those years go. Meet her where she is and put your view point across. I really think that if you were as brlliant as you say you were then these techniques should be old hat to you.

"I appreciate what your saying however,.......bang in what you need to change........ but thanks for your perspective" Otherwise known as the shit sandwich technique. Putting the negative between two positives.

or has has been said say "great point, I'll mention it to my manager", there are so many more.

If you can't communicate with her, or if she fails to listen only then would I refer it to your manager.

PansyPetunia · 28/06/2022 16:59

Butchyrestingface · 28/06/2022 16:56

You're certainly been the author of a few interesting threads recently, @Stressedout65 . One would almost think you are bored. Grin

hmmm so true.....but not bored enough to come back to clarify or answer questions...

balalake · 28/06/2022 16:57

Very disappointed to read someone referring to a woman over school leaving age as a 'young girl'. I thought we'd moved on from that in the 1980s.

EthicalNonMahogany · 28/06/2022 16:56

I like the post that says you can engage with her and ask her how she could feel more comfortable delegating. Ok she's not your line manager but she may have a role that impacts the whole team - leadership isn't just about line management.

If you're so wise and experienced you'll know that you have to work with people. The way to stop someone doing something annoying at work is not to grey rock them or be dumbly insolent or ignore and hope it all goes away... that's gonna make her feel more insecure.

Ask her for a coffee, ask her how she's finding the role. Ask her if there are any aims she has for the department and any changes she's thinking about. Ask her how you can help her and what she'd like you to do. Listen in a non judgemental way. You have peace and wisdom and a good angle on the problems she's running into for the first time. You might learn something too.

She may not be very good but you need to honour her ambition and desire to do well in her job and if she feels you are an ally you will not only look more mature and less petty you'll have an easier life.

Butchyrestingface · 28/06/2022 16:56

You're certainly been the author of a few interesting threads recently, @Stressedout65 . One would almost think you are bored. Grin

Randomness12 · 28/06/2022 16:54

She may have less experience but she’s been promoted and now outranks you whether you like it or not. If any manager asks a member of my team to do something, I expect it to be done regardless of reporting lines.

Respect is earned, not given based on age and this goes both ways.

Frankly, you sound like a patronising know-it-all. You may have kept up to date, but it might be time to move on. The reliable pair of hands is great, but there is a fine line between that and becoming a pain who has to be worked around for the rest of the team/department.

gwenneh · 28/06/2022 16:52

How can I manoeuvre her away from me without sounding like a jealous old woman who's had her day in the workplace.

You don't "manoeuver" anything. You bring the situation immediately to your own line manager's attention like a grown adult and address the problem head on, promptly. If she doesn't have the authority to tell you what to do, then a direct and clear meeting will resolve that immediately and you can go back to casting your way to retirement.

ilovesooty · 28/06/2022 16:50

Meraas · 28/06/2022 16:36

Calling an adult woman a 'young girl' is ageist.

Where are the anti-ageist posters who rise up when they hear terms like boomer?

I'm an anti ageism poster and I agree with you. It doesn't just go one way.

Squareflair · 28/06/2022 16:48

Everyone at work deserves to be treated with respect, the issue is the micro managing by the sound of it, her age is irrelevant as is yours- I recognise your attitude in lots of people I have worked with and its not pleasant. Address the management style if you feel it impacts your negatively, if she puts forward new ideas etc then give professional feedback surely ie we have tried that before and it didn't work, or it probably won't work because of x reason. I've found lots push back for the sake of it to try and prove a point about how amazing they are as they've been there years. Not always the case.

SmileyPiuPiu · 28/06/2022 16:47

If you do have a meeting with your manager leave age out of it or you'll (rightfully) be disciplined.

TeapotTitties · 28/06/2022 16:45

How can I manoeuvre her away from me without sounding like a jealous old woman who's had her day in the workplace.

Well (and hear me out cos this is just an idea) you could stop patronising the fuck out of her.

Stop calling her a 'young girl' when she clearly isn't and cut the sexist phrases like 'oldies'.

If you want to continue to be the dependable head down sort of worker that has far less responsibility than most managers, you'll have to get used to being managed by younger people.

LookItsMeAgain · 28/06/2022 16:44

Firstly - irrespective of the ages of the people involved here, respect is earned, not automatic.

Next, as this trainee manager is not your direct manager, if they ask you to do anything, refer them to your manager. Something like this might work:
Trainee Manager (TM) - Hi @Stressedout65 , I need you to do X, Y and Z as I noticed that they weren't done properly.
StressedOut - I think you should run that one by my manager TM, I'm only doing what they asked me to do.
TM - Ok then. I'll check with them and get back to you.

They then go off to check with your manager and get told that you're doing fine and you don't have to do X, Y or Z or your manager will approach you to ask you to do X, Y and Z as requested. The latter though is a request coming from your manager not TM (just to clarify).

PupInAPram · 28/06/2022 16:43

Honestly I would just completely ignore her. What's she going to do about it?

Swipe left for the next trending thread