Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Another DC’s paying board one.

62 replies

Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 12:48

This isn’t about me but my Dsis.
AIBU to tell her that she should still make her dc’s pay board on a regular basis, even though her dd’s spend most of the week at their boyfriend’s houses?

Sis thinks she’s probably being unfair to now expect board, but she’s a single working parent, and as you know, all bills have shot up drastically.
Her dd’s stay at home occasionally, but will pop in and out, have showers, use the electric and eat the food when they want.

I’m trying to make her see that her dd’s rooms are available to them whenever they want to stay at home, and Sis could let those rooms out to lodgers if it came to it, so can anyone help me persuade her that she needs to get her adult kids to pay up! .… they’re both 20 and 21, at Uni, but work part time.

They were both originally paying £50 a week board all in, Sis tells me.

OP posts:
Comefromaway · 29/06/2022 11:27

I'd say £50 per week is ridiculously low if it includes all food and bills. My dd attended college in a different town and lodged with a landlady. Four years ago she was paying £130 per week.

Cloud16 · 29/06/2022 10:54

They'll have to stay at home longer if she charges them. They won't be able to save and move out, or go and do activities with the bf.

Floralnomad · 29/06/2022 10:46
  1. It’s none of your business
  2. £50 per week for uni students , even if they work is ridiculously high
  3. it’s none of your business .
puffyisgood · 29/06/2022 10:43

Terrible parenting [unless you really badly need the money, in which case things of course are totally different] to let your kids who are in FT education do unskilled work at the expense of their studies/take at student loans at 7% in order to pay you money.

Mally100 · 29/06/2022 10:42

Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 12:53

Maybe because she’s working a lot and she’s told me she’ll struggle with the extra bills. And I can’t see why she should pay for everything and her girls wander in and out and stay when they want to.

But then it's her problem? She is chosing to do this so she bears the struggle. I think its not your business at all.

shiningstar2 · 29/06/2022 10:34

I would prefer not to charge kids still studying if possible. However if that's difficult could she charge £25 a week instead of £50 if they are mainly at boyfriends? If she has 2 dds that would be £100 a month from each. £200 a month should be a good help. Maybe that would be a good compromise.

Butterfly9999 · 29/06/2022 10:24

bewilderedhedgehog · 28/06/2022 16:12

It is for every family to sort out but I imagine from the description that (a) her daughters don't have much money if they are at uni and (b) this is their family home. I am sure you have your sister's best interests at heart but I don't think you are reasonable to tell her what she should do, or try to persuade her. Did you have children who paid board in similar circumstances?

They’re at Uni and receive a student loan to help with living costs, and they also have a part time wage coming in, so I think they should be helping her. I know ultimately it’s her decision though.

OP posts:
bewilderedhedgehog · 28/06/2022 16:12

It is for every family to sort out but I imagine from the description that (a) her daughters don't have much money if they are at uni and (b) this is their family home. I am sure you have your sister's best interests at heart but I don't think you are reasonable to tell her what she should do, or try to persuade her. Did you have children who paid board in similar circumstances?

Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 14:41

BalloonsAndWhistles · 28/06/2022 13:49

I don’t think the OP has a ‘sister’. I reckon she’s asking for our opinion on whether to charge her own kids board…just saying.

Think what you like

OP posts:
Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 14:41

Comefromaway · 28/06/2022 13:48

A student living at home with parents earning under £25,000 per year will get £8,171 per year (22-23 figures)

A student living away from home in halls or private accommodation will get an extra £1,535 per year.

It costs a LOT more than £1,535 to live away in halls (usually between £5-7k rent alone) so the reasonable assumption is that a good proportion of that loan is meant for the student to pay their way at home.

And £50 a week only works out at a few k tops.

OP posts:
BalloonsAndWhistles · 28/06/2022 13:49

I don’t think the OP has a ‘sister’. I reckon she’s asking for our opinion on whether to charge her own kids board…just saying.

Comefromaway · 28/06/2022 13:48

A student living at home with parents earning under £25,000 per year will get £8,171 per year (22-23 figures)

A student living away from home in halls or private accommodation will get an extra £1,535 per year.

It costs a LOT more than £1,535 to live away in halls (usually between £5-7k rent alone) so the reasonable assumption is that a good proportion of that loan is meant for the student to pay their way at home.

Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 13:44

Testina · 28/06/2022 13:28

Don’t forget that there is a government assumption that on a certain income level, the parent is supposed to support the student - reduced maintenance loan. If the maintenance loan for them is reduced and she’s not giving them any money, you could argue they’re contributing by working part time and not taking any money from her!

I may be wrong but I think the gov give extra to the students classed as living at home, if their parents are on low incomes.

OP posts:
Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 13:42

LetitiaLeghorn · 28/06/2022 13:38

I wouldn't charge them term time while they're studying. If they get summer jobs, I'd definitely expect them to contribute.

My nieces both work around their studies, not just in the hols.

OP posts:
Bibbetybobbity · 28/06/2022 13:41

Good point @Testina …

LetitiaLeghorn · 28/06/2022 13:38

I wouldn't charge them term time while they're studying. If they get summer jobs, I'd definitely expect them to contribute.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 13:38

Suedomin · 28/06/2022 13:28

Surely it is up to your sister to decide whether she wants to charge them lodge. I have never charged my children rent as I have never viewed them as lodgers. But that was my decision. If someone wants to that is their decision and I wouldn't presume to question it.

I paid my mum whilst I was at uni, she never viewed me as a lodger, but as a member of the family contributing to the bills. I was happy to do it.

Just like when she moves in with me when she's older, she will likely contribute to bills but I won't view her as a lodger.

Butterfly9999 · 28/06/2022 13:35

Suedomin · 28/06/2022 13:28

Surely it is up to your sister to decide whether she wants to charge them lodge. I have never charged my children rent as I have never viewed them as lodgers. But that was my decision. If someone wants to that is their decision and I wouldn't presume to question it.

Just because some parents ask their dc’s to help pay their way, that doesn’t mean they view them as lodgers!

OP posts:
Suedomin · 28/06/2022 13:33

mereas. The OP says that both the daughters are at University.

Meraas · 28/06/2022 13:31

Oh they do go to Uni.

I think they should still contribute.

Suedomin · 28/06/2022 13:28

Surely it is up to your sister to decide whether she wants to charge them lodge. I have never charged my children rent as I have never viewed them as lodgers. But that was my decision. If someone wants to that is their decision and I wouldn't presume to question it.

Testina · 28/06/2022 13:28

Don’t forget that there is a government assumption that on a certain income level, the parent is supposed to support the student - reduced maintenance loan. If the maintenance loan for them is reduced and she’s not giving them any money, you could argue they’re contributing by working part time and not taking any money from her!

Testina · 28/06/2022 13:25

The time they spend at their boyfriends’ is a red herring. If anything, they’re saving her money. It sounds like although they’re both an uni, neither has moving out, so this is their home? In which case, it’s up to your sister to decide in principle does she want to charge board (reasonable) and then in practical terms - does she? You could be someone who in principle would prefer not to - but finances insist.

I think YANBU to ask if it’s reasonable for her to consider it, but YABU to ask for how to persuade her. Beak out!

Comefromaway · 28/06/2022 13:20

I assume they have tution fees to cover too -How much would you expect them to contribute?

Tuition fees are paid direct to the university and you only start to pay it back after graduation when you start earning over a certain amount.

Comefromaway · 28/06/2022 13:19

There is a big difference between a child at uni who only comes home in the holidays and one who lives at home full time. They get less maintenance loan than someone living away for uni but their loan still includes an amount for their share of the food/bills etc.