Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

Sick of the push for Scottish independence

421 replies

ThisKiltIsMadeForWalking · 28/06/2022 11:37

I keep seeing on the news that Nicola Sturgeon is pushing for another referendum and I just don’t get it. If she doesn’t get the answer she wants this time can she push for another in a few years? I just find it disgusting that half the country are struggling badly for things like food/electricity/petrol and she wants to spend millions pushing for something that she wants, that the majority voted against a few years ago? Am I missing something?

OP posts:
antelopevalley · 28/06/2022 14:26

MN is very anti-Scottish Independence, and very anti-SNP and Nicola Sturgeon. Any excuse to bash either one of these is relished.

I think Scottish independence is inevitable.

Villagewaspbyke · 28/06/2022 14:25

Sorry @CapMarvel Greens and Alba and SNP got over 50%

Bobbins36 · 28/06/2022 14:24

FrecklesMalone · 28/06/2022 11:39

Things have changed quite significantly under the Johnson administration. He is slowly destroying much of the economy and rights we have. If I was Scottish I would now vote for independence was previously I wouldn't have.

You are aware of the even greater economic damage this would do to ordinary Scots on top of the current situation? Just because she’s anti Tory doesn’t make Nicola Sturgeon right about separatism. Do you know how toxic 2014 was for Scotland? You want to inflict that again?
the SNP have shafted Scotland through sheer incompetence for 15years, it’s a shithole compared to what it was and they take zero responsibility. Bunch of nationalist wankers.

Fairisleflora · 28/06/2022 14:23

Indy supporter group (twitter @ nowScotlandnow released the most disgracefully racist video yesterday on Twitter to the adoration of its followers. Need we say more?

Villagewaspbyke · 28/06/2022 14:22

CapMarvel · 28/06/2022 14:17

This is not difficult. The SNP are in government on the basis of the election results, ergo they have a mandate. It's seats that count when it comes to driving the agenda of government, not % vote.

The percentage of the vote with the greens (an independence supporting party) was more than 50% anyway.

Changedmynamefor · 28/06/2022 14:21

Apologies, 84.59%

Changedmynamefor · 28/06/2022 14:20

@CulturePigeon for info, voter turnout at the referendum was 85.59%. By comparison it was 63% at the last Scottish Parliament election (highest ever turnout).

Villagewaspbyke · 28/06/2022 14:19

CulturePigeon · 28/06/2022 14:03

Not Scottish, but have several Scottish friends who've experienced nasty bullying over the independence issue. My personal wish is that Scotland stays part of the Union, but I do get the fact that Brexit has changed the game somewhat.

Although I would be sorry to see Scotland separate, I respect a nation's right to self-determination - I'm just concerned at the way the SNP and some of their supporters behave. And I get depressed at the anti-English feeling which some of them promote. Wanting Scottish independence doesn't have to involve near-racist (yes, I know it's not actually racism - but such virulent nationalism that comes pretty close) attitudes to English people. I don't know how the Scottish govt justifies their policy, for eg, of allowing free university education to everyone (including overseas students) except the English! Imagine if it was the other way around. I blame that idiot Australian bloke - Mel Gibson, that's the one -and his inaccurate film, Braveheart.

Also - I think that only 60% of Scots voted in the last IndyRef, and around 50% of those were for independence. Therefore the total pro-independence is something like 30% of the total population.

Scotland doesn’t give free education to everyone except the English. That’s absolutely untrue. Overseas students have always paid large fees and pay more than the English (who I believe pay the same fees as for English universities). There was previously a reciprocal agreement with EU countries on university fees but that was due to EU regulations so may not last.

My dds were born in England and have strong English accents (also they are mixed race). They have never experienced racism for being English in Scotland.

Of course people are racist in Scotland like everywhere. But I do not believe that there is a particular issue with racism with independence supporters or the SNP. I have certainly never seen any sign of that.

CapMarvel · 28/06/2022 14:17

Andouillette · 28/06/2022 14:13

Go on then, prove I'm wrong. Electoral Commission says 63/129 seats and 44.1% of the vote. No mandate.

This is not difficult. The SNP are in government on the basis of the election results, ergo they have a mandate. It's seats that count when it comes to driving the agenda of government, not % vote.

Fairisleflora · 28/06/2022 14:17

You said English view Scot’s as parasites. I don’t know any English (lived there many years of my life, lots of friends from every corner of the UK) who have ever expressed any such view of Scot’s - ever. They don’t even think about such things. You’ve said you think Scot’s are viewed as parasites a number of times, and I just don’t think it’s true at all.

greywinds · 28/06/2022 14:16

I feel voting for any big over promised change is like the fleabag hair scene, if you want to change your life, change YOUR life. Waving any kind of flag is a temporary feel good consumption.

ProfessorFusspot · 28/06/2022 14:15

YABU in principle; self-determination isn't an event, it's an ongoing social contract and a right that cannot be given up. There are no official or legal limits on the number of successive referendums in the Scotland Act of any other relevant legislation. "Once in a generation" was a comment/observation/prediction from Alex Salmond, said in the context of urging people to vote in case they never had another chance. It was never a binding promise or a policy statement. The Good Friday Agreement has a built-in limit for an Irish Reunification poll, which cannot take place any less that 7 years after the previous one. Why should Scotland have less flexibility?

As for the current government at WM - yes, they'll eventually be replaced, but the larger issue for Scotland is the growing perception/realisation that they can never influence the outcome of a UK national election. Even if every person eligible to vote in Scotland had gone to the polls in December 2019 and voted (for example) Labour, the Conservatives would still have won an outright majority of seats in the HoC and therefore the first right to form a government.

YANBU to think it's a waste of time at the moment. Polling shows the appetite has not increased significantly despite the assumed game-changer of hard Brexit. And the issues that weren't addressed at the last referendum still haven't been addressed, despite a majority at Holyrood in November 2017 authorising the Scottish government to seek a Section 30 "when the shape of Brexit is clear". And now a new set of issues arise because of the UK having left the European SIngle Market and the Scottish government pledging to rejoin the EU (which is out of their remit to promise and therefore needs a concrete backup strategy).

Andouillette · 28/06/2022 14:13

CapMarvel · 28/06/2022 13:52

Utter nonsense.

Go on then, prove I'm wrong. Electoral Commission says 63/129 seats and 44.1% of the vote. No mandate.

Fairisleflora · 28/06/2022 14:11

Its exactly likeBrexit. There are a lot of people living in extreme poverty (yes vote is highest in areas of poverty, lowest in areas of affluence) who would vote for independence as they don’t think their lives could get much worse - and have no understanding of the economic and trading conditions which would indeed make their lives so much worse. And politicians who are happy to tell these people any sort of lies to get their vote.

Villagewaspbyke · 28/06/2022 14:09

Fairisleflora · 28/06/2022 13:39

There are only two regions of the UK that earn more in taxes than they spend - London and the South East of England. Scotland gets part of that excess money as it is part of the UK, same as Wales, N Ireland, NE of England etc get their share too. It’s how the UK works, sharing out the excessive money earned by London. Scotland is no more thought of as a parasite than any of these other areas of the UK. So please, get the chip off your shoulder.

Is that to me? In fact that’s true in recent years but previously Scotland was a net contributor to the uk. The fact you think this is some sort of permanent situation is an issue.

in any event it’s often said that Scotland needs to be subsidized by England even on this thread. And even your quote above would seem to indicate you think it too.

on the other hand what evidence is there I have a “chip on my shoulder” (other than again the old racist stereotypes of chippy Scots)?

CulturePigeon · 28/06/2022 14:03

Not Scottish, but have several Scottish friends who've experienced nasty bullying over the independence issue. My personal wish is that Scotland stays part of the Union, but I do get the fact that Brexit has changed the game somewhat.

Although I would be sorry to see Scotland separate, I respect a nation's right to self-determination - I'm just concerned at the way the SNP and some of their supporters behave. And I get depressed at the anti-English feeling which some of them promote. Wanting Scottish independence doesn't have to involve near-racist (yes, I know it's not actually racism - but such virulent nationalism that comes pretty close) attitudes to English people. I don't know how the Scottish govt justifies their policy, for eg, of allowing free university education to everyone (including overseas students) except the English! Imagine if it was the other way around. I blame that idiot Australian bloke - Mel Gibson, that's the one -and his inaccurate film, Braveheart.

Also - I think that only 60% of Scots voted in the last IndyRef, and around 50% of those were for independence. Therefore the total pro-independence is something like 30% of the total population.

Geneviev · 28/06/2022 14:02

I actually agree with that. I don’t think IndyRef2 will actually happen.

Abouttoblow · 28/06/2022 14:01

As a ex-member of the SNP, Nicola Sturgeon has absolutely no intention of another referendum. Absolutely none. She has her next job lined up and will continue to "dangle the carrot" while she kills time till she goes.

Babdoc · 28/06/2022 14:00

The SNP do not have a mandate for a referendum. Only 34% of Scots actually vote SNP, but they keep getting seats purely because the unionist vote is split between Labour, Conservative and Lib Dem parties.
The majority of SNP supporters don’t want a referendum for at least 5 years either, according to innumerable polls. Yet Sturgeon ploughs on regardless, to try and distract from her abysmal record in office.
And even Sturgeon recently admitted that Scotland would be financially worse off if independent- without the UK subsidy from the Barnett formula, adrift outside both the EU and UK, with a 25% deficit that would preclude EU membership for decades, and a hard border with their largest trading partner. And if they continued to use the pound Sterling with no agreement, they would have zero influence on interest rates or currency valuation. The whole thing is an idiot’s pipe dream, appealing only to the economically illiterate. There would be a massive exodus south of higer rate taxpayers, capital investment and businesses.

Fairisleflora · 28/06/2022 14:00

The SNP should go back on their promise of a referendum for the obvious reason that they have no legal means of providing one.

Geneviev · 28/06/2022 13:57

Still too many unknowns and unanswered questions for me to consider voting Yes.

Even further put off by the Brexit shitshow. I think many people will be put off voting Yes at such a time of turmoil and hardship.

Even my die-hard Yes voting in-laws are pissed off about the timing.

Villagewaspbyke · 28/06/2022 13:56

Sweetpeasaremadeforbees · 28/06/2022 13:30

I think Scotland has as much right to take back control as the UK/ England.

As an English person living in England I agree with that. But I didn't realise the push for another Ref in Scotland was such a prominent thing in Scottish life. Surely focussing on the cost of living crisis etc. should be the SNP's priority.

Why should that be their only priority (it is one of them as far as I can understand). They were elected promising to hold another independence referendum. Why should they go back on that?

CapMarvel · 28/06/2022 13:52

Andouillette · 28/06/2022 13:35

Bullshit. They needed the Greens to form a majority and they and the Greens between them received less than 50% of the combined vote. No mandate.

Utter nonsense.

Weegiewtf · 28/06/2022 13:50

Do I live in a different country and watch a different media?
I don’t see relentless pushes for Indyref from pro-independence politicians and I don’t hear about it on tv in the papers that often either. I see a lot of Tories talk about it endlessly though.

I’m not an SNP voter and I don’t like Nicola Sturgeon but I have the maturity not to make ridiculous insults or call her names because I don’t like her politics. I do lose respect for anyones argument when they call her things like wee nippy or put her and her colleagues down as people.

That said I am very pro-independence. It’s not really for my future but it is for my kids and grandkids. They cannot be subjected to a lifetime of Westminster Tory rule and all the negative shit associate with brexit and the rise of fascism down south.

Once we have independence then we can vote for someone we’d like to govern an independent Scotland. That won’t be Nicola Sturgeon or the SNP.

xILikeJamx · 28/06/2022 13:48

I voted No last time but would vote Yes in a heartbeat now. In fundamental terms I'm an airy fairy liberal and believe that we're all equal as humans, should be removing borders and there should be no wealth or poverty. These things are more likely outside of the UK in its current state.

The reasons I previously voted No have been shat on from a great height by the people who campaigned for BT.