Please or to access all these features

AIBU?

Share your dilemmas and get honest opinions from other Mumsnetters.

To want the HMRC child maintenance calculator to apply to the whole salary?

39 replies

Bobsmyaunty · 28/06/2022 11:14

From my understanding, the calculator only applies itself to the first £130k of earnings, and anything above is not included.

I am in the process of divorce and agreeing future child maintenance and spousal maintenance. I'm working (part time) so the spousal maintenance isn't particularly high and am tasked with working towards becoming self-sufficient over time, which is fine, I would like to be anyway. I was high earner before having kids and whilst (10 years later) I am now starting at the (very bloody) bottom and am a very low earner, I can take that knock in the teeth because I am confident I can turn this around.

HOWEVER, on principle, it seems bonkers that Ex-DH only pays child-maintenance on the first bit of his salary. And, I am posing this question universally. Who came up with this incredibly biased system? You could have people earning £500k (which is NOT my Ex-DH btw), and rolling it in, only sharing a small proportion to the main carer.

Whilst we are not destitute, I have to watch the bottom line very carefully, whilst Ex-DH does big ticket items like Harry Potter world or Legoland etc. I'm not sure even sure it's great for the kids to have a discrepancy like this - it will definitely put them off taking time out of their careers (and maybe that's a big fat plus to this situation!)

My question is: AIBU to ask for the HMRC child maintenance calculator to be applied to his whole salary?

OP posts:
New posts on this thread. Refresh page
youlightupmyday · 30/06/2022 10:50

I get spousal maintenance and kids also get all school.fees paid by their father and got 50% of assets. We did detailed budgets, Form Es and went before a judge. I did prove that I had already cut expenditure massively. Had moved to smaller home and finished a post grad and got a job. All of which was taken into consideration. It was not an affordability case. It was kids needs and our needs based.

DomPerignon12 · 30/06/2022 08:31

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/06/2022 21:53

I also think payments should take into account a childs costs prior to the split. For example if you have 2 kids under 3 in nursery, that can be £2k a month to £4k a month in London. If the kids are in private school that's a considerable expense. It seems harsh to have to dramatically change the kids lifestyle or the residents parents chances of working a job with normal hours, because the money resident parent can pay and has been paying but suddenly goes down to the legal minimum because they can

The resident parent will have been paying for a single household, with a PT parent as childcare.
Now they’ll be paying for two, with added childcare on top.

CMS should be more but the kids aren’t entitled to the same lifestyle.

Btw OP DOES get spousal maintainence. Not sure why nobody else has noticed but she says so in the OP

bg21 · 29/06/2022 20:48

spousal payments ??? don't just don't 🤦‍♀️

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 29/06/2022 20:40

warofthemonstertrucks · 29/06/2022 10:02

If you live in the south east and you inherited a large mortgage in your divorce-then you are probably spending a fair bit of that on the mortgage, bills and food for the two children-and if you didn't work because that was the agreement you made with with your then husband because he was the higher earner and you stayed home with the kids, then your 1700 is all that you have coming in. Yep you need to sell your house, but given that you've just got divorced or are in the process of it, and you are probably trying to keep things stable for you and your kids, plus you might struggle to get a mortgage on your own, that might not be the best option the rental market being as it is. Rent for a three bed house around where I live for example is about 1300-1400 a month.

I get that it's complaining from a position of Privilege and lots of people are far worse off, but the change in lifestyle doesn't just happen overnight-and the kids shouldn't suffer because their Dad no longer wants to part with his cash for them IMO.

Unfortunately though. Each parent now has their household to run individually and its shit for the kids but OP cannot expect things to remain the same surely. If you agree to be a SAHM... well that was the risk you choose to take!

SweetChild0mine · 29/06/2022 20:21

Deary me… it sounds like you have enough to raise your kids but want to be able to do what dad does. He probably works hard enough for the wage.
if you are genuinely struggling, apply for universal credit as they have can calculate how much you have and make up the difference to the calculated amount needed to raise a child.
while dad has the kids, let dad do his thing and take them where he wishes. You do the same in your care but please don’t use your kids as an income and to keep a hold on dad becsuse kids aren’t daft and they’ll realise soon enough

warofthemonstertrucks · 29/06/2022 10:02

If you live in the south east and you inherited a large mortgage in your divorce-then you are probably spending a fair bit of that on the mortgage, bills and food for the two children-and if you didn't work because that was the agreement you made with with your then husband because he was the higher earner and you stayed home with the kids, then your 1700 is all that you have coming in. Yep you need to sell your house, but given that you've just got divorced or are in the process of it, and you are probably trying to keep things stable for you and your kids, plus you might struggle to get a mortgage on your own, that might not be the best option the rental market being as it is. Rent for a three bed house around where I live for example is about 1300-1400 a month.

I get that it's complaining from a position of Privilege and lots of people are far worse off, but the change in lifestyle doesn't just happen overnight-and the kids shouldn't suffer because their Dad no longer wants to part with his cash for them IMO.

Getoff · 28/06/2022 23:02

I wonder what does £1700 a month goes on? I literally can't think how I would spend that much. (School fees don't count.)

IfIhearmumagaintoday · 28/06/2022 22:17

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:18

So based off 2 kids child maintenance would be around 1700 a month that is my whole months salary to look after 3 ppl no child needs such a high amount then its also only meant to cover 50% so include your 1700 thats 3400 for 2 kids a month

Let's be fair there's a lot of shit men who don't pay for their kids and there's a lot of gold digging mums too.

I think CMS should not be giving any mother obscene high figures like you have quoted for the mum to spend, a percent yes but not the figures you have quoted. It should go into a trust fund unless you have private school fees to pay for. What exactly are you doing with £1700 a month???

motogirl · 28/06/2022 22:08

On higher incomes spousal maintenance is usually payable, that's not part of the calculator

DrinkFeckArseBrick · 28/06/2022 21:53

I also think payments should take into account a childs costs prior to the split. For example if you have 2 kids under 3 in nursery, that can be £2k a month to £4k a month in London. If the kids are in private school that's a considerable expense. It seems harsh to have to dramatically change the kids lifestyle or the residents parents chances of working a job with normal hours, because the money resident parent can pay and has been paying but suddenly goes down to the legal minimum because they can

rghltifndn · 28/06/2022 15:14

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:58

@ChocolateHippo if anything the minimum payment amount needs increased from the £7 per week to at least £50 and tough shit if they are on benefits children need food and clothes my own dad was a waste of space that never paid for his kids but capping it is the right move other wise the op would not have instentive to go back to work and stand on her own to feet I also think paying your ex dh dw is crap just because they took time of work when income was high enough for a nanny ect

I completely agree.

My ex-h refuses to work or claim benefits (lives off an allowance from his family) so according to the CMS he doesn’t have to pay maintenance as he has no official income.

Because obviously he is living on fresh air so the kids have to also. 🤷🏽‍♀️

It’s a very unfair system to be honest.

ChocolateHippo · 28/06/2022 15:08

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:58

@ChocolateHippo if anything the minimum payment amount needs increased from the £7 per week to at least £50 and tough shit if they are on benefits children need food and clothes my own dad was a waste of space that never paid for his kids but capping it is the right move other wise the op would not have instentive to go back to work and stand on her own to feet I also think paying your ex dh dw is crap just because they took time of work when income was high enough for a nanny ect

I agree - all children have a minimum level of basic needs, regardless of the NRP's income. And this should be met by the NRP or paid by the government and taken off the NRP's state pension.

But while the system totally ignores the needs of children at the lower end, I don't see why it should suddenly focus on them to allow the NRP to reduce their payments at the higher end. It's a fairly small percentage of income, after all, and even if a 'windfall' to the RP is hardly going to leave the NRP penniless.

Crikeyalmighty · 28/06/2022 15:07

I think OP what the real issue is here is that you need higher spousal maintenance for a few years , not higher child maintanance (which is meant to be for the child's needs) that's presuming he is due to pay around £1700 a month based on £130k. If it's far less because he is declaring income as far less then that needs to be gone into to. The other adjective is what assets if any are you getting, house equity, pension shares etc? Because this may well be a fair bit of money too- and it does sound like he was the main earner for quite a long time. With regards to him having more money to do the nice add ons- you need to explain to your children that he has more spare money than you do- because you took time out to look after them- once they are old enough they will understand. Life's not always fair I'm afraid - it doesn't always work out at 50/50 on income- although it usually does on assets.

youlightupmyday · 28/06/2022 15:00

My ex earns over that and I think the assumption is that you negotiate with lawyer and/ or go to court. We did both and I got more. Judge ignored CMS in our circumstances but was still fair

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:58

@ChocolateHippo if anything the minimum payment amount needs increased from the £7 per week to at least £50 and tough shit if they are on benefits children need food and clothes my own dad was a waste of space that never paid for his kids but capping it is the right move other wise the op would not have instentive to go back to work and stand on her own to feet I also think paying your ex dh dw is crap just because they took time of work when income was high enough for a nanny ect

warofthemonstertrucks · 28/06/2022 14:52

Agreed op. Also see bonuses which don't come in to the calculation.

Guardup · 28/06/2022 14:43

I would think that as they are the one working (presumably high stress/long hours for that kind of salary), they wouldn’t want to pay % of their earnings to an ex partner. I would think that % of £130k maintenance would be a reasonable sum, plus I would also assume the marriage would have been asset rich and the resident parent come out with a larger % of the marriage asset pool.
I appreciate I am adding in a lot of assumptions, but surely not capping it incentivises the high earner to give up their job?
I would also assume stops ex partners making a career out of being married to a high earner?

I just don’t know. When you leave a marriage I do think you shouldn’t have the responsibility of the other adult in that marriage, they should stand on their own two feet so perhaps capping £130k is enough to financially support your children without having an adult dependent on you too.

Best of luck to you in becoming self sufficient x

QueenCoconut · 28/06/2022 14:39

I think you are at risk of trying to ‘keep up’ with your ex and creating unnecessary stress for yourself, chasing his standard of living. The reality is that he is the higher earner and will (most likely) always be able to provide the children with different things/ standards and opportunities.

At what point do you stop and accept that what you provide for them is good enough? Just a thought.

ChocolateHippo · 28/06/2022 14:31

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:18

So based off 2 kids child maintenance would be around 1700 a month that is my whole months salary to look after 3 ppl no child needs such a high amount then its also only meant to cover 50% so include your 1700 thats 3400 for 2 kids a month

No, no child 'needs' such a high amount, but nowhere else does the maintenance amount take account of the child's needs so why do so here? According to the child maintenance calculator, some children only 'need' £5 per week.

DomPerignon12 · 28/06/2022 14:29

Splitting up creates a division OP. Nothing to do with how much £££ you get in maintenance.
The RP usually gets the raw end of the deal, and too many NRP pay as little as they can get away with.
But each parent can choose to spend on different things. Each parent might also remarry - things will become even more confusing.

You can never keep the life they had

ChocolateHippo · 28/06/2022 14:28

Can't you apply to the court for a top up or even a lump sum payment in cases where the NRP is earning more than the maximum amount?

Tbh, the whole system is a bit crazy because it bears no relationship to what is necessary to 'maintain' a child. Instead, it's a pure income calculation (and a relatively low percentage of NRP income at that). I can't get too exercised about high earners having to pay a fairly low proportion of their income, even if much more than is reasonably required to feed and clothe a child to a basic standard, when at the other end you have RPs receiving £40 per month or less as the NRP's contribution to their children. The system is broken anyway, so it may as well at least be consistent.

Bubblesandsqueak1 · 28/06/2022 14:18

So based off 2 kids child maintenance would be around 1700 a month that is my whole months salary to look after 3 ppl no child needs such a high amount then its also only meant to cover 50% so include your 1700 thats 3400 for 2 kids a month

vivainsomnia · 28/06/2022 14:17

I think it's the principle I'm interested in too - as in, why?
Because after a certain point, it's not child maintenance any longer but indeed spousal maintenance. There is so much you can spend on the kids each month.

Once you separate, children accept that things are not going to be exactly the same at mum and dad and that can be on either side.

Ultimately, unless your ex threaten you if you did stop work it is a decision you've made because it suited you. If you were on 6iyr way to be a very high earner, it should take long to get back there.

According to you, if a dad was left with huge debts and after maintenance couldn't even offer his kids to go on any holiday whilst they went abroad three times with their mum, it would be acceptable to pay half his maintenance so he could use the rest to take his kids away too. Would that be reasonable?

satelliteheart · 28/06/2022 14:16

Would your ex be open to a discussion over more maintenance? A relative sorted out a private arrangement with her high earning ex to pay based on his whole income

LetitiaLeghorn · 28/06/2022 14:07

If he earns higher than 130,000, won't you be taking him to court for all his assets to be checked over and shared, including his pensions? It's not like you're just going to stick some numbers into an online calculator and shrug your shoulders at the outcome.
I also don't think that parents will ever have comparable parenting. They will have different time available, different styles, make different financial choices. However, that doesn't mean that the children's upbringing won't be equally as good with both parents. Just different.

Swipe left for the next trending thread